Massimo Baroni

A common reference framework for analyzing/comparing proteins and ligands. Fingerprints for Ligands and Proteins (FLAP): theory and application.

A fast new algorithm (Fingerprints for Ligands And Proteins or FLAP) able to describe small molecules and protein structures using a common reference framework of four-point pharmacophore fingerprints and a molecular-cavity shape is described in detail. The procedure starts by using the GRID force field to calculate molecular interaction fields, which are then used to identify particular target locations where an energetic interaction with small molecular features would be very favorable. The target points thus calculated are then used by FLAP to build all possible four-point pharmacophores present in the given target site. A related approach can be applied to small molecules, using directly the GRID atom types to identify pharmacophoric features, and this complementary description of the target and ligand then leads to several novel applications. FLAP can be used for selectivity studies or similarity analyses in order to compare macromolecules without superposing them. Protein families can be compared and clustered into target classes, without bias from previous knowledge and without requiring protein superposition, alignment, or knowledge-based comparison. FLAP can be used effectively for ligand-based virtual screening and structure-based virtual screening, with the pharmacophore molecular recognition. Finally, the new method can calculate descriptors for chemometric analysis and can initiate a docking procedure. This paper presents the background to the new procedure and includes case studies illustrating several relevant applications of the new approach.

FLAP: GRID molecular interaction fields in virtual screening. validation using the DUD data set.

The performance of FLAP (Fingerprints for Ligands and Proteins) in virtual screening is assessed using a subset of the DUD (Directory of Useful Decoys) benchmarking data set containing 13 targets each with more than 15 different chemotype classes. A variety of ligand and receptor-based virtual screening approaches are examined, using combinations of individual templates 2D structures of known actives, a cocrystallized ligand, a receptor structure, or a cocrystallized ligand-biased receptor structure. We examine several data fusion approaches to combine the results of the individual virtual screens. In doing so, we show that excellent chemotype enrichment is achieved in both single target ligand-based and receptor-based approaches, of approximately 17-fold over random on average at a false positive rate of 1%. We also show that using as much starting knowledge as possible improves chemotype enrichment, and that data fusion using Pareto ranking is an effective method to do this giving up to 50% improvement in enrichment over the single methods. Finally we show that if inactivity or decoy data is incorporated, automatically training the scoring function in FLAP improves recovery still further, with almost 2-fold improvement over the enrichments shown by the single methods. The results clearly demonstrate the utility of FLAP for virtual screening when either a limited or wide range of prior knowledge is available.

High-throughput virtual screening of proteins using GRID molecular interaction fields.

A new computational algorithm for protein binding sites characterization and comparison has been developed, which uses a common reference framework of the projected ligand-space four-point pharmacophore fingerprints, includes cavity shape, and can be used with diverse proteins as no structural alignment is required. Protein binding sites are first described using GRID molecular interaction fields (GRID-MIFs), and the FLAP (fingerprints for ligands and proteins) method is then used to encode and compare this information. The discriminating power of the algorithm and its applicability for large-scale protein analysis was validated by analyzing various scenarios: clustering of kinase protein families in a relevant manner, predicting ligand activity across related targets, and protein-protein virtual screening. In all cases the results showed the effectiveness of the GRID-FLAP method and its potential use in applications such as identifying selectivity targets and tools/hits for new targets via the identification of other proteins with pharmacophorically similar binding sites.

GRID-Based Three-Dimensional Pharmacophores I: FLAPpharm, a Novel Approach for Pharmacophore Elucidation

Pharmacophore elucidation approaches are routinely used in drug discovery, primarily with the aim of determining the three-dimensional arrangement of common features shared by ligands interacting at the site of interest; these features can then be used to investigate the structure-activity relationship between the ligands and also to screen for other molecules possessing the relevant features. Here we present a novel approach based on GRID molecular interaction fields and the derivative method FLAP that has been previously described, which provides a common reference framework to compare both small molecule ligands and macromolecular protein targets. Unlike classical pharmacophore elucidation approaches that extract simplistic molecular features, determine those which are common across the data set, and use these features to align the structures, FLAPpharm first aligns the structures and subsequently extracts the common interacting features in terms of their molecular interaction fields, pseudofields, and atomic points, representing the common pharmacophore as a more comprehensive pharmacophoric pseudomolecule. The approach is applied to a number of data sets to investigate performance in terms of reproducing the X-ray crystallography-based alignment, in terms of its discriminatory ability when applied to virtual screening and also to illustrate its ability to explain alternative binding modes. In part two of this publication, a comprehensive benchmark data set for pharmacophore elucidation is presented and the performance of FLAPpharm discussed.

BioGPS: navigating biological space to predict polypharmacology, off-targeting, and selectivity.

The structural comparison of protein binding sites is increasingly important in drug design; identifying structurally similar sites can be useful for techniques such as drug repurposing, and also in a polypharmacological approach to deliberately affect multiple targets in a disease pathway, or to explain unwanted off‐target effects. Once similar sites are identified, identifying local differences can aid in the design of selectivity. Such an approach moves away from the classical “one target one drug” approach and toward a wider systems biology paradigm. Here, we report a semiautomated approach, called BioGPS, that is based on the software FLAP which combines GRID Molecular Interactions Fields (MIFs) and pharmacophoric fingerprints. BioGPS comprises the automatic preparation of protein structure data, identification of binding sites, and subsequent comparison by aligning the sites and directly comparing the MIFs. Chemometric approaches are included to reduce the complexity of the resulting data on large datasets, enabling focus on the most relevant information. Individual site similarities can be analyzed in terms of their Pharmacophoric Interaction Field (PIF) similarity, and importantly the differences in their PIFs can be extracted. Here we describe the BioGPS approach, and demonstrate its applicability to rationalize off‐target effects (ERα and SERCA), to classify protein families and explain polypharmacology (ABL1 kinase and NQO2), and to rationalize selectivity between subfamilies (MAP kinases p38α/ERK2 and PPARδ/PPARγ). The examples shown demonstrate a significant validation of the method and illustrate the effectiveness of the approach. Proteins 2015; 83:517–532.

Targeting the conformational transitions of MDM2 and MDMX: insights into dissimilarities and similarities of p53 recognition.

MDM2 and MDMX are oncogenic homologue proteins that regulate the activity and stability of p53, a tumor suppressor protein involved in more than 50% of human cancers. While the large body of experiments so far accumulated has validated MDM2 as a therapeutically important target for the development of anticancer drugs, it is only recently that MDMX has also become an attractive target for the treatment of tumor cells expressing wild type p53. The availability of structural information of the N-terminal domain of MDM2 in complex with p53-derived peptides and inhibitors, and the very recent disclosure of the crystal structure of the N-terminal domain of MDMX bound to a p53 peptide, offer an unprecedented opportunity to provide insight into the molecular basis of p53 recognition and the identification of discriminating features affecting the binding of the tumor suppressor protein at MDM2 and MDMX. By using coarse graining simulations, in this study we report the exploration of the conformational transitions featured in the pathway leading from the apo-MDM2 and apo-MDMX states to the p53-bound MDM2 and p53-bound MDMX states, respectively. The results have enabled us to identify a pool of diverse conformational states of the oncogenic proteins that affect the binding of p53 and the presence of conserved and non-conserved interactions along the conformational transition pathway that may be exploited in the design of selective and dual modulators of MDM2 and MDMX activity.

Exposition and reactivity optimization to predict sites of metabolism in chemicals

Chemical modifications of drugs induced by phase I biotransformations significantly affect their pharmacokinetic properties. Because the metabolites produced can themselves have a pharmacological effect and an intrinsic toxicity, medicinal chemists need to accurately predict the sites of metabolism (SoM) of drugs as early as possible. However, site of metabolism prediction is rarely accompanied by a prediction of the relative abundance of the various metabolites. Such a prediction would be a great help in the study of drug– drug interactions and in the process of reducing the toxicity of potential drug candidates. The aim of this paper is to present recent developments in the prediction of xenobiotic metabolism and to use concrete examples to explain the computational mechanism employed.

A Pipeline To Enhance Ligand Virtual Screening: Integrating Molecular Dynamics and Fingerprints for Ligand and Proteins

The importance of taking into account protein flexibility in drug design and virtual ligand screening (VS) has been widely debated in the literature, and molecular dynamics (MD) has been recognized as one of the most powerful tools for investigating intrinsic protein dynamics. Nevertheless, deciphering the amount of information hidden in MD simulations and recognizing a significant minimal set of states to be used in virtual screening experiments can be quite complicated. Here we present an integrated MD-FLAP (molecular dynamics-fingerprints for ligand and proteins) approach, comprising a pipeline of molecular dynamics, clustering and linear discriminant analysis, for enhancing accuracy and efficacy in VS campaigns. We first extracted a limited number of representative structures from tens of nanoseconds of MD trajectories by means of the k-medoids clustering algorithm as implemented in the BiKi Life Science Suite ( http://www.bikitech.com [accessed July 21, 2015]). Then, instead of applying arbitrary selection criteria, that is, RMSD, pharmacophore properties, or enrichment performances, we allowed the linear discriminant analysis algorithm implemented in FLAP ( http://www.moldiscovery.com [accessed July 21, 2015]) to automatically choose the best performing conformational states among medoids and X-ray structures. Retrospective virtual screenings confirmed that ensemble receptor protocols outperform single rigid receptor approaches, proved that computationally generated conformations comprise the same quantity/quality of information included in X-ray structures, and pointed to the MD-FLAP approach as a valuable tool for improving VS performances.

Flavin Monooxygenase Metabolism: Why Medicinal Chemists Should Matter

FMO enzymes (FMOs) play a key role in the processes of detoxification and/or bioactivation of specific pharmaceuticals and xenobiotics bearing nucleophilic centers. The N-oxide and S-oxide metabolites produced by FMOs are often active metabolites. The FMOs are more active than cytochromes in the brain and work in tandem with CYP3A4 in the liver. FMOs might reduce the risk of phospholipidosis of CAD-like drugs, although some FMOs metabolites seem to be neurotoxic and hepatotoxic. However, in silico methods for FMO metabolism prediction are not yet available. This paper reports, for the first time, a substrate-specificity and catalytic-activity model for FMO3, the most relevant isoform of the FMOs in humans. The application of this model to a series of compounds with unknown FMO metabolism is also reported. The model has also been very useful to design compounds with optimal clearance and in finding erroneous literature data, particularly cases in which substances have been reported to be FMO3 substrates when, in reality, the experimentally validated in silico model correctly predicts that they are not.

BioGPS descriptors for rational engineering of enzyme promiscuity and structure based bioinformatic analysis.

A new bioinformatic methodology was developed founded on the Unsupervised Pattern Cognition Analysis of GRID-based BioGPS descriptors (Global Positioning System in Biological Space). The procedure relies entirely on three-dimensional structure analysis of enzymes and does not stem from sequence or structure alignment. The BioGPS descriptors account for chemical, geometrical and physical-chemical features of enzymes and are able to describe comprehensively the active site of enzymes in terms of “pre-organized environment” able to stabilize the transition state of a given reaction. The efficiency of this new bioinformatic strategy was demonstrated by the consistent clustering of four different Ser hydrolases classes, which are characterized by the same active site organization but able to catalyze different reactions. The method was validated by considering, as a case study, the engineering of amidase activity into the scaffold of a lipase. The BioGPS tool predicted correctly the properties of lipase variants, as demonstrated by the projection of mutants inside the BioGPS “roadmap”.