Matthew D. Putnam

Treatment of distal radius fractures

The clinical practice guideline is based on a systematic review of published studies on the treatment of distal radius fractures in adults. None of the 29 recommendations made by the work group was graded as strong; most are graded as inconclusive or consensus; seven are graded as weak. The remaining five moderate-strength recommendations include surgical fixation, rather than cast fixation, for fractures with postreduction radial shortening >3 mm, dorsal tilt >10 degrees , or intra-articular displacement or step-off >2 mm; use of rigid immobilization rather than removable splints for nonsurgical treatment; making a postreduction true lateral radiograph of the carpus to assess dorsal radial ulnar joint alignment; beginning early wrist motion following stable fixation; and recommending adjuvant treatment with vitamin C to prevent disproportionate pain.

Sensibility deficiencies in the hands of children with spastic hemiplegia

We evaluated 40 children with spastic hemiplegia due to cerebral palsy for sensory function and relative limb size in the affected and unaffected upper extremities. Sensory function of each limb was evaluated with respect to stereognosis (12 objects), two-point discrimination, and proprioception. Four size measurements of each limb were made: arm and forearm circumference and forearm and forearm-hand length. This study showed that 97% of the spastic limbs had a stereognosis deficit, 90% had a two-point discrimination deficit, and 46% had a proprioception deficit. Thus sensory deficits are the rule rather than the exception in children with spastic hemiplegia. Those children with severe stereognosis deficits had significantly smaller limbs in all four measurement parameters than the children with mild or moderate stereognosis deficits. In the preoperative evaluation of children with spastic hemiplegia, severe size discrepancy is a physical examination tool that can be used as a predictor of severe sensory deficits. This information is helpful for the hand surgeon in establishing realistic surgical goals.

Design and biomechanics of a plate for the distal radius

A dorsal plate for the distal radius was designed to provide rigid fixation and thus allow early motion. It functions as a blade plate, lessening the role of metaphyseal screws, and providing internal neutralization rather than compression. The rigidity and strength of the plate were compared to the existing T-plate in an unstable, extra-articular fracture model in paired, fresh-cadaver, axially loaded radii. The dorsal plate construct was significantly stronger and more rigid than the T-plate construct. The failure mode was similar for both plate types; 8 of 10 constructs failed with plate bending and screw loosening, while the oldest specimen pair showed primary bone failure. Compared to the T-plate, the dorsal plate transmitted a greater single axial load from the articular surface to the shaft.

Limited open surgical approach for external fixation of distal radius fractures

In an effort to reduce treatment-related complications, a surgical procedure has been developed for the insertion and application of an external fixation device in the management of unstable fractures of the distal radius. Clinical experience with this device has demonstrated its effectiveness in reducing complications associated with pin insertion. The surgical technique is presented together with a case example. Results of laboratory tests corroborate our clinical experience and demonstrate the effectiveness of this technique in minimizing complications. Clinical results in 66 cases document the efficacy and safety of this technique.

Assessment of Technical Skills of Orthopaedic Surgery Residents Performing Open Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery

BACKGROUND Motor skills assessment is an important part of validating surgical competency. The need to test surgical skills competency has gained acceptance; however, assessment methods have not yet been defined or validated. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the reliability and validity of four testing measures for the integrated assessment of orthopaedic surgery residents with regard to their competence in performing carpal tunnel release. METHODS Twenty-eight orthopaedic residents representing six levels of surgical training were tested for competence in performing carpal tunnel release on cadaver specimens. Four measures were used to assess competency. First, a web-based knowledge test of surgical anatomy, surgical indications, surgical steps, operative report dictation, and surgical complications was administered. Second, residents participated in an Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills; each resident performed surgery on a cadaver specimen. All residents were evaluated independently by two board-certified orthopaedic surgeons with a subspecialty certificate in hand surgery with use of a detailed checklist score, a global rating scale, and a pass/fail assessment. The time for completion of the surgery was also recorded. Each assessment tool was correlated with the others as well as with the residents level of training. RESULTS Significant differences were found between year of training and knowledge test scores (F = 7.913, p < 0.001), year of training and detailed checklist scores (F = 5.734, p = 0.002), year of training and global rating scale (F = 2.835, p = 0.040), and year of training and percentage pass rate (F = 26.3, p < 0.001). No significant differences were found between year of training and time to completion of the carpal tunnel release (F = 2.482, p < 0.063). CONCLUSIONS The results of the present study suggest that both knowledge and cadaver testing discriminate between novice and accomplished residents. However, although failure of the knowledge test can predict failure on technical skills testing, the presence of knowledge does not necessarily ensure successful performance of technical skills, as cognitive testing and technical skills testing are separate domains.

Treatment of unstable distal radius fractures : methods and comparison of external distraction and ORIF versus external distraction-ORIF neutralization

Twenty-six closed unstable distal radius fractures were treated using a combination of internal fixation, external distraction (intraoperative), and, in some cases, up to 4 weeks of postoperative external fixation (neutralization). Intraoperative stability check determined the need for external neutralization. This combined technique allowed a comprehensive approach to even the most unstable fracture by merging the advantages of internal and external fixation. Up to 4 weeks of external fixation (neutralization) was not associated with the complications of external fixation usually reported.

Wrist Position Affects Loading of the Dorsal Scaphoid: Possible Effect on Extrinsic Scaphoid Blood Flow

Cadaver studies using radial artery injection techniques were used to study the vascular supply along the dorsal ridge of the scaphoid. These revealed an intraarticular membrane between the wrist capsule and the dorsal ridge of the scaphoid through which arteriolar vessels (25–100 μm internal diameter) passed. Biomechanical tests revealed that the extensor carpi radialis brevis may apply significant pressure to the dorsal ridge of the scaphoid when the wrist is flexed. The highest pressures occurred with the wrist flexed at 60° or 90° and in slight (15°) ulnar deviation. The authors suggest that these vascular and biomechanical factors may contribute to the aetiology for idiopathic osteonecrosis of the scaphoid.

Percutaneous Release of the A1 Pulley: A Cadaver Study

PURPOSE Percutaneous release of the A1 pulley has been used for treatment of trigger fingers with success. However, lack of direct visualization raises concerns about the completeness of the release and about potential injury to the tendons or neurovascular structures. The purpose of this study was to assess the efficacy and safety of percutaneous release of the A1 pulley in a cadaveric model using a commonly available instrument, a #15 scalpel blade. METHODS Fourteen fresh frozen cadaveric hands (54 fingers, thumbs excluded) were used. Landmarks were established for the A1 pulley based upon cutaneous features. Percutaneous release was performed using a #15 blade. The specimens were then dissected and examined for any tendon or neurovascular injury, and completeness of A1 pulley release was evaluated. RESULTS There were 39 (72%) complete releases of the A1 pulley with 14 partial and 1 missed (failed) release. There was a 22% incidence of release of the proximal edge of the A2 pulley. However, there was no case of release of more than 25% of the A2 pulley length, nor was bowstringing of flexor tendons seen in these specimens. Eleven digits showed longitudinal scoring of the flexor tendons and 3 had partial tendon lacerations. No neurovascular injuries were noted. CONCLUSIONS Percutaneous release of the A1 pulley using a #15 blade was associated with good efficacy and an acceptable margin of safety in this series. CLINICAL RELEVANCE Percutaneous release of trigger digits may assume a greater role in the treatment of patients with trigger finger because of cost containment pressures. The data from this study suggest that the technique used in this study is both safe and effective. With use of proper anatomical guidelines, risk to neurovascular structures is low, although longitudinal scoring of the tendon can occur.

Objective Structured Assessments of Technical Skills (OSATS) Does Not Assess the Quality of the Surgical Result Effectively

BackgroundPerformance assessment in skills training is ideally based on objective, reliable, and clinically relevant indicators of success. The Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skill (OSATS) is a reliable and valid tool that has been increasingly used in orthopaedic skills training. It uses a global rating approach to structure expert evaluation of technical skills with the experts working from a list of operative competencies that are each rated on a 5-point Likert scale anchored by behavioral descriptors. Given the observational nature of its scoring, the OSATS might not effectively assess the quality of surgical results.Questions/purposes(1) Does OSATS scoring in an intraarticular fracture reduction training exercise correlate with the quality of the reduction? (2) Does OSATS scoring in a cadaveric extraarticular fracture fixation exercise correlate with the mechanical integrity of the fixation?MethodsOrthopaedic residents at the University of Iowa (six postgraduate year [PGY]-1s) and at the University of Minnesota (seven PGY-1s and eight PGY-2s) undertook a skills training exercise that involved reducing a simulated intraarticular fracture under fluoroscopic guidance. Iowa residents participated three times during 1 month, and Minnesota residents participated twice with 1 month between their two sessions. A fellowship-trained orthopaedic traumatologist rated each performance using a modified OSATS scoring scheme. The quality of the articular reduction obtained was then directly measured. Regression analysis was performed between OSATS scores and two metrics of articular reduction quality: articular surface deviation and estimated contact stress. Another skills training exercise involved fixing a simulated distal radius fracture in a cadaveric specimen. Thirty residents, distributed across four PGY classes (PGY-2 and PGY-3, n = 8 each; PGY-4 and PGY-5, n = 7 each), simultaneously completed the exercise at individual stations. One of three faculty hand surgeons independently scored each performance using a validated OSATS scoring system. The mechanical integrity of each fixation construct was then assessed in a materials testing machine. Regression analysis was performed between OSATS scores and two metrics of fixation integrity: stiffness and failure load.ResultsIn the intraarticular fracture model, OSATS scores did not correlate with articular reduction quality (maximum surface deviations: R = 0.17, p = 0.25; maximum contact stress: R = 0.22, p = 0.13). Similarly in the cadaveric extraarticular fracture model, OSATS scores did not correlate with the integrity of the mechanical fixation (stiffness: R = 0.10, p = 0.60; failure load: R = 0.30, p = 0.10).ConclusionsOSATS scoring methods do not effectively assess the quality of the surgical result. Efforts must be made to incorporate assessment metrics that reflect the quality of the surgical result.Clinical RelevanceNew objective, reliable, and clinically relevant measures of the quality of the surgical result obtained by a trainee are urgently needed. For intraarticular fracture reduction and extraarticular fracture fixation, direct physical measurement of reduction quality and of mechanical integrity of fixation, respectively, meet this need.

Trapezium excision and suture suspensionplasty (TESS) for the treatment of thumb carpometacarpal arthritis.

Basilar thumb arthritis, or first carpometacarpal arthritis, is a common condition affecting older women and some men. It is estimated that as many as one third of postmenopausal woman are affected. Surgical treatment of this condition includes options ranging from arthrodesis to prosthetic arthroplasty. Intermediate options include complete or partial trapezial excision with or without interposition of a cushioning/stabilizing material (auto source, allo source, synthetic source). A multitude of methods appear to offer similar end results, although some methods definitely involve more surgical work and perhaps greater patient risk. Through retrospective evaluation of a cohort of patients who underwent suture suspensionplasty, we determined the postoperative effect on strength, motion, patient satisfaction, complications, and radiographic maintenance of the scaphoid-metacarpal distance. This review shows the method to be clinically effective and, by comparison with a more traditional ligament reconstruction trapezial interposition arthroplasty, the method does not require use of autograft or allograft tendon and has fewer surgical steps. Forty-four patients were included in this retrospective study. The results showed that 91% of patients were satisfied with the procedure. Pinch and grip strength remained the same preoperatively and postoperatively. A Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand patient-reported outcome instrument (DASH) scores averaged 30 at final follow-up. Three patients developed a late complication requiring further surgical intervention. In summary, this technique appears to be technically reproducible, requires no additional tendon material, and achieves objectively and subjectively similar results to other reported procedures used to manage first CMC Arthritis.