Matthew Skinner

Evaluation of drug-induced QT interval prolongation in animal and human studies: a literature review of concordance

Evaluating whether a new medication prolongs QT intervals is a critical safety activity that is conducted in a sensitive animal model during non‐clinical drug development. The importance of QT liability detection has been reinforced by non‐clinical [International Conference on Harmonization (ICH) S7B] and clinical (ICH E14) regulatory guidance from the International Conference on Harmonization. A key challenge for the cardiovascular safety community is to understand how the finding from a non‐clinical in vivou2005QT assay in animals predicts the outcomes of a clinical QT evaluation in humans. The Health and Environmental Sciences Institute Pro‐Arrhythmia Working Group performed a literature search (1960–2011) to identify both human and non‐rodent animal studies that assessed QT signal concordance between species and identified drugs that prolonged or did not prolong the QT interval. The main finding was the excellent agreement between QT results in humans and non‐rodent animals. Ninety‐one percent (21 of 23) of drugs that prolonged the QT interval in humans also did so in animals, and 88% (15 of 17) of drugs that did not prolong the QT interval in humans had no effect on animals. This suggests that QT interval data derived from relevant non‐rodent models has a 90% chance of predicting QT findings in humans. Disagreement can occur, but in the limited cases of QT discordance we identified, there appeared to be plausible explanations for the underlying disconnect between the human and non‐rodent animal QT outcomes.

The role of the anaesthetised guinea-pig in the preclinical cardiac safety evaluation of drug candidate compounds

Despite rigorous preclinical and clinical safety evaluation, adverse cardiac effects remain a leading cause of drug attrition and post-approval drug withdrawal. A number of cardiovascular screens exist within preclinical development. These screens do not, however, provide a thorough cardiac liability profile and, in many cases, are not preventing the progression of high risk compounds. We evaluated the suitability of the anaesthetised guinea-pig for the assessment of drug-induced changes in cardiovascular parameters. Sodium pentobarbitone anaesthetised male guinea-pigs received three 15 minute intravenous infusions of ascending doses of amoxicillin, atenolol, clonidine, dobutamine, dofetilide, flecainide, isoprenaline, levosimendan, milrinone, moxifloxacin, nifedipine, paracetamol, verapamil or vehicle, followed by a 30 minute washout. Dose levels were targeted to cover clinical exposure and above, with plasma samples obtained to evaluate effect/exposure relationships. Arterial blood pressure, heart rate, contractility function (left ventricular dP/dt(max) and QA interval) and lead II electrocardiogram were recorded throughout. In general, the expected reference compound induced effects on haemodynamic, contractility and electrocardiographic parameters were detected confirming that all three endpoints can be measured accurately and simultaneously in one small animal. Plasma exposures obtained were within, or close to the expected clinical range of therapeutic plasma levels. Concentration-effect curves were produced which allowed a more complete understanding of the margins for effects at different plasma exposures. This single in vivo screen provides a significant amount of information pertaining to the cardiovascular risk of drug candidates, ultimately strengthening strategies addressing cardiovascular-mediated compound attrition and drug withdrawal.

Optimising conditions for studying the acute effects of drugs on indices of cardiac contractility and on haemodynamics in anaesthetized guinea pigs.

INTRODUCTIONnDetecting adverse effects of drugs on cardiac contractility is becoming a priority in pre-clinical safety pharmacology. The aim of this work was to optimise conditions and explore the potential of using the anaesthetized guinea pig as an in vivo model.nnnMETHODSnGuinea pigs were anaesthetized with Hypnorm/Hypnovel, isoflurane, pentobarbital or fentanyl/pentobarbital. The electrocardiogram (ECG), heart rate, arterial blood pressure and indices of cardiac contractility were recorded. In further experiments in fentanyl/pentobarbital anaesthetized guinea pigs the influence of bilateral versus unilateral carotid artery occlusion on haemodynamic responses was investigated and the effects of inotropic drugs on left ventricular (LV) dP/dt(max) and the QA interval were determined.nnnRESULTSnPentobarbital, given alone or after fentanyl, provided suitable anaesthesia for these experiments. Bilateral carotid artery occlusion did not alter heart rate or arterial blood pressure responses to isoprenaline or angiotensin II. Isoprenaline and ouabain increased LVdP/dt(max) and decreased the QA interval whereas verapamil had opposite effects and strong inverse correlations between LVdP/dt(max) and the QA interval were found.nnnDISCUSSIONnConditions can be optimised to allow the pentobarbital-anaesthetized guinea pig to be used for simultaneous measurement of the effects of drugs on the ECG, haemodynamics and indices of cardiac contractility. The use of this small animal model in early pre-clinical safety pharmacology should contribute to improvements in detecting unwanted actions on the heart during the drug development process.

Effects of group housing on ECG assessment in conscious cynomolgus monkeys

INTRODUCTIONnAssessing the cardiovascular safety of new chemical or biological entities is important during pre-clinical development. Electrocardiogram (ECG) assessments in non-human primate (NHP) toxicology studies are often made using non-invasive telemetry systems. We investigated whether ECG recording was feasible during group housing of NHPs, rather than the usual single housed arrangement, and whether it would impact the data collected or affect the ability to detect drug-induced changes in QTc interval.nnnMETHODSnFollowing a period of acclimatisation to jackets, cynomolgus monkeys (3 males and 3 females) were housed in same sex groups of 3. Female monkeys were administered 4 doses of vehicle while male monkeys were administered vehicle, 15, 45, and 135mg/kg moxifloxacin. Each dose was administered on a separate dosing day. The same dosing protocol was repeated with the animals singly housed and the results from the two phases were compared including assessment of statistical power.nnnRESULTSnHeart rate (HR) was significantly lower, and PR and QT intervals were significantly higher, at multiple time points when the animals were group housed compared with the singly housed phase. QRS duration and QTc interval were less affected. Moxifloxacin increased QT and QTc intervals but had no consistent effect on HR, QRS duration or PR interval under group housed or singly housed conditions. Power analysis suggested that group housing did not adversely affect the magnitude of detectable changes of ECG parameters. In general, detection of slightly smaller changes was achieved under conditions of group housing.nnnDISCUSSIONnThe current study shows group housing to be technically possible during non-invasive ECG recording, resulting in lower resting heart rates and small improvements in sensitivity of detection of drug-induced effects. Given the psychological benefits of group housing for NHPs, it is a refinement that should be considered when conducting ECG assessments in NHP toxicology studies.

Can non‐clinical repolarization assays predict the results of clinical thorough QT studies? Results from a research consortium

Translation of non‐clinical markers of delayed ventricular repolarization to clinical prolongation of the QT interval corrected for heart rate (QTc) (a biomarker for torsades de pointes proarrhythmia) remains an issue in drug discovery and regulatory evaluations. We retrospectively analysed 150 drug applications in a US Food and Drug Administration database to determine the utility of established non‐clinical in vitro IKr current human ether‐à‐go‐go‐related gene (hERG), action potential duration (APD) and in vivo (QTc) repolarization assays to detect and predict clinical QTc prolongation.

An Analysis of the Relationship Between Preclinical and Clinical QT Interval-Related Data

There has been significant focus on drug-induced QT interval prolongation caused by block of the human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG)-encoded potassium channel. Regulatory guidance has been implemented to assess QT interval prolongation risk: preclinical guidance requires a candidate drugs potency as a hERG channel blocker to be defined and also its effect on QT interval in a non-rodent species; clinical guidance requires a Thorough QT Study during development, although some QT prolonging compounds are identified earlier via a Phase I study. Clinical, heart rate-corrected QT interval (QTc) data on 24 compounds (13 positives; 11 negatives) were compared with their effect on dog QTc and the concentration of compound causing 50% inhibition (IC50) of hERG current. Concordance was assessed by calculating sensitivity and specificity across a range of decision thresholds, thus yielding receiver operating characteristic curves of sensitivity versus (1-specificity). The area under the curve of ROC curves (for which 0.5 and 1 indicate chance and perfect concordance, respectively) was used to summarize concordance. Three aspects of preclinical data were compared with the clinical outcome (receiver operating characteristic area under the curve values shown in brackets): absolute hERG IC50 (0.78); safety margin between hERG IC50 and clinical peak free plasma exposure (0.80); safety margin between QTc effects in dogs and clinical peak free plasma exposure (0.81). Positive and negative predictive values of absolute hERG IC50 indicated that from an early drug discovery perspective, low potency compounds can be progressed on the basis of a low risk of causing a QTc increase.

Detecting drug-induced changes in ECG parameters using jacketed telemetry: Effect of different data reduction techniques.

INTRODUCTIONnContinuous cardiovascular data is routinely collected during preclinical safety assessment of new medicines. This generates large datasets, which must be summarised to analyse and interpret drug effects. We assessed four methods of data reduction of continuous electrocardiogram (ECG) data and examined the impact on the statistical power of the assay.nnnMETHODSnContinuous ECG data were collected from a validation study in 6 cynomolgus monkeys using jacketed telemetry. Animals received either vehicle or vehicle followed by ascending doses of moxifloxacin each on a different dosing day. Recordings made for 25h on each dosing day were reduced to discrete time-points using: 1-min average snapshots, 15-min average snapshots, large duration averages (0.5-4h) or super-intervals (3.5-9h averages).nnnRESULTSnThere was no difference in the ability to detect moxifloxacin-induced QTc prolongation between the 1- and 15-min snapshots and the large duration averages data reduction methods (minimum detectable change in QTca of 20, 17 and 18ms, respectively at 80% power). The super-intervals method detected slightly smaller changes in QTc (15ms), but did not detect a statistically significant increase in QTc after the lowest dose of moxifloxacin, in contrast to the other methods. There were fewer statistically significant differences between dosing days in animals given vehicle when the large duration averages and super-interval reduction techniques were used.nnnDISCUSSIONnThere is no marked difference in the power of detection of drug-induced ECG changes in cynomolgus monkeys when using either small duration average or large duration average data reduction techniques. Use of larger duration averages or super-intervals may facilitate data interpretation by reducing the incidence of spurious significant differences that occur by chance between dosing days.

Functional Assessments in Nonhuman Primate Toxicology Studies to Support Drug Development

Abstract Clinical and nonclinical safety liabilities remain a major cause of drug attrition; many of the toxicities are functional in nature and/or in origin and can manifest after single-dose or chronic administration. In recent years there has been a growing use of nonhuman primates in safety assessment testing for new chemical or biological entities as well as novel modalities. Drivers of this are scientific, technological, regulatory (e.g., ICH S6, S7, S9), ethical, societal, and economic. Functional measurements (i.e., behavioral, physiological, and biochemical measurements of function) can be incorporated into repeat-dose toxicity studies either routinely or on an ad hoc basis. There are inherent challenges in achieving this: the availability of suitable technical and scientific expertise at the test facility; unsuitable laboratory conditions; use of simultaneous (as opposed to staggered) dosing; requirement for toxicokinetic sampling; unsuitability of certain techniques (e.g., use of anesthesia, surgical implantation, food restriction); equipment available in close proximity; and the sensitivity of the methods to detect small, clinically relevant changes. Nonetheless, “fit-for-purpose” data can still be acquired without requiring additional animals. Examples include assessment of cardiovascular (e.g., electrocardiography, arterial blood pressure, cardiac function); nervous system (e.g., behavior, general activity, body temperature); respiratory; gastrointestinal; renal; and hepatic functions. This is entirely achievable if functional measurements are relatively unobtrusive, both with respect to the animals and to the toxicology study itself. Careful pharmacological validation of any methods used, and establishing their detection sensitivity, is vital to ensure the credibility of generated data.