Matthias B. Donelan

Laser Treatment of Traumatic Scars With an Emphasis on Ablative Fractional Laser Resurfacing: Consensus Report

IMPORTANCE Despite expert wound care and assiduous management with traditional therapy, poor cosmetic outcomes, restricted motion, and symptoms such as pain and itch are a pervasive problem of disfiguring and debilitating scars. The advent of ablative fractional photothermolysis within the past decade and its application to the treatment of traumatic scars represents a breakthrough in the restoration of function and cosmetic appearance for injured patients, but the procedure is not widely used. OBJECTIVE To provide a synthesis of our current clinical experience and available literature regarding the laser treatment of traumatic scars with an emphasis on fractional resurfacing. EVIDENCE REVIEW Eight independent, self-selected academic and military dermatology and plastic surgery physicians with extensive experience in the use of lasers for scar treatment assembled for a 2-day ad hoc meeting on January 19 and 20, 2012. Consensus was based largely on expert opinion, but relevant literature was cited where it exists. FINDINGS After consensus was appraised, we drafted the manuscript in sections during the course of several months. The draft was then circulated among all panel members for final review and comment. Our consensus is that laser treatment, particularly ablative fractional resurfacing, deserves a prominent role in future scar treatment paradigms, with the possible inclusion of early intervention for contracture avoidance and assistance with wound healing. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE Laser scar therapy, particularly fractional ablative laser resurfacing, represents a promising and vastly underused tool in the multidisciplinary treatment of traumatic scars. Changes to existing scar treatment paradigms should include extensive integration of fractional resurfacing and other combination therapies guided by future research.

Large-volume suction lipectomy: an analysis of 108 patients.

Suction lipectomy was initially advocated for the treatment of localized collections of fat and for the removal of less than 1500 ml of material. However, many patients wished to have multiple areas treated or had diffuse collections of fat. In such instances, the removal of over 1500 ml of material and circumferential lipectomy are necessary to provide optimal aesthetic results. However, when over 1500 ml of material is removed, anesthetic requirements, fluid replacement, and treatment of blood loss become important if the operation is to be performed safely. We have treated 108 patients who had over 1500 ml of material removed. Eight-eight percent of the patients were female; 12 percent were male. Using the body-mass index, 3 percent of patients were underweight, 70 percent were normal weight, and 27 percent were overweight. Fifty-five patients (51 percent) had 1500 to 2499 ml of material removed, 26 patients (24 percent) had 2500 to 3499 ml removed, 16 patients (15 percent) had 3500 to 4499 ml removed, and 11 patients (10 percent) had over 4500 ml removed. All patients were treated in the hospital; 44 percent were admitted after surgery. A total of 227 units of autologous and 2 units of homologous blood were transfused. As measured by a computerized monitor, the average amount of blood in the material removed from thighs was 30 percent; from abdomens, the blood loss was 45 percent. The aesthetic results were generally excellent. No complications were encountered. A few patients developed undesired sequelae, the most common of which was seroma formation, which occurred in 19 percent of those who had suction of abdominal-wall fat. We believe that large-volume suction lipectomy is safe and efficacious, provided attention is directed to such important aspects of patient care as anesthesia, fluid replacement, and blood loss.

Alternative complement pathway activation increases mortality in a model of burn injury in mice.

We have studied the role of the complement system in burn injury in an experimental model in mice. A 25% body surface area, full-thickness scald wound was produced in anesthetized animals. Massive activation of the alternative complement pathway, but not the classical pathway, was seen. This activation was associated with the generation of neutrophil aggregating activity in the plasma, neutrophil aggregates in the lungs, increased pulmonary vascular permeability, and increased lung edema formation. Decomplementation with cobra venom factor (CVF) or genetic C5 deficiency diminished these pathologic changes, and CVF pretreatment substantially reduced burn mortality in the first 24 h. Preliminary data show that human burn patients have a similar pattern of complement activation involving predominantly the alternative pathway, indicating the possible relevance of the murine model to human disease.

Preferential Activation and Depletion of the Alternative Complement Pathway by Burn Injury

Complement levels of eight adult burn patients (25% to 90% body surface area) were studied upon admission to a burn unit and sequentially for one week. Mean classical pathway titers (CH50) were 49% below the normal mean, while hemolytic C4 titers were reduced by 53% and C3 by 43%. However, the alternative pathway titer was reduced by more than 90%, suggesting preferential depletion of this pathway. This depletion was associated with sepsis, pneumonia, and “shock lung.” Alternative pathway deficiency was still present one week post-burn, and may contribute to the susceptibility of burn patients to bacterial sepsis.

Biology and Principles of Scar Management and Burn Reconstruction

Hypertrophic scarring is extremely common and is the source of most morbidity related to burns. The biology of hypertrophic healing is complex and poorly understood. Multiple host and injury factors contribute, but protracted healing of partial thickness injury is a common theme. Hypertrophic scarring and heterotopic ossification may share some basic causes involving marrow-derived cells. Several traditional clinical interventions exist to modify hypertrophic scar. All have limited efficacy. Laser interventions for scar modification show promise, but as yet do not provide a definitive solution. Their efficacy is only seen when used as part of a multimodality scar management program.

Pulsed Dye Laser Therapy and Z-Plasty for Facial Burn Scars : The Alternative to Excision

Hypertrophic scarring after partial thickness facial burns is common when epithelialization takes longer than 3 weeks. Well-healed areas continue to mature unfavorably, resulting in raised, erythematous, and contracted scars. Excisional treatment of such scars has morbidity and can create iatrogenic deformities. The flashlamp-pumped, pulsed dye laser (PDL) in combination with z-plasty can be used as a successful alternative to excision in patients with facial hypertrophic burn scars. Fifty-seven patients with hypertrophic facial burn scars (mean age 12 years; range, 2–21 years) were treated with the PDL over the past 8 years. Thirty-four patients (60%) were also treated with z-plasties to relieve scar tension. There was one complication of postoperative blistering. Patients were divided into 3 groups based on time from burn to initial laser treatment. Group I (<1 year) had 11 patients and the laser diminished scar proliferation in these patients. Group II (1–4 years) included 24 patients and treatment resulted in reversal of hypertrophic scarring and elimination of erythema. Group III (>5 years) consisted of 22 patients. The PDL was effective in treating their stable and persistent erythema as long as 17 years after burn injury. No scars required excision in this cohort of 57 patients. The PDL should become an integral part of the management of facial burn scarring and will significantly decrease the need for excisional surgery.

Pulsed dye laser in burn scars: Current concepts and future directions

Hypertrophic scarring after partial-thickness burns is common, resulting in raised, erythematous, pruritic, and contracted scars. Treatment of hypertrophic scars, especially on the face, is challenging and has high failure rates. Excisional treatment has morbidity and can create iatrogenic deformities. After an extensive experience over 10 years with laser therapy for the treatment of difficult scars, the pulsed dye laser (PDL) has emerged as a successful alternative to excision in patients with hypertrophic burn scars. Multiple studies have shown its ability to decrease scar erythema and thickness while significantly decreasing pruritus and improving the cosmetic appearance of the scar. The history of laser therapy and the mechanism of action and results of the PDL in burn scars will be reviewed. The PDL should become an integral part of the management of burn scarring and will significantly decrease the need for excisional surgery.

Reconstruction of electrical burns of the oral commissure with a ventral tongue flap

Reconstruction of the oral commissure following electrical burn injury is a challenging problem. The commissure is a thin, delicate structure that is highly mobile and essential to normal facial appearance and expression. When there is full-thickness destruction of vermilion, mucosa, skin, and orbicularis muscle, the resulting contracture alters adjacent structures, displaces the commissure, and distorts facial animation. Utilizing a composite ventral tongue flap of mucosa and muscle in the reconstruction of the commissure permits effective release of scar contracture and replaces destroyed mucosa and muscle bulk. Remaining structures can be returned to their normal location, and the three-dimensional contours of the oral commissure can be better restored. The use of this flap in 21 patients has resulted in improved mobility, more normal facial expression, and more consistent results in the reconstruction of a wide range of commissure deformities.

Conchal Transposition Flap for Postburn Ear Deformities

Severe thermal injuries to the external ear often lead to extensive loss of peripheral structures such as helix and lobule but frequently spare the more central parts of the ear, even though they may be grossly deformed by scar contracture. The use of spared conchal structures as a transposition flap in combination with remodeling of the residual auricle and release of surrounding scar when indicated has been a useful technique in the reconstruction of a frequently occurring type of postburn ear deformity. Twenty-four ears have been reconstructed in 18 patients over the past 5 years using a conchal transposition flap. The residual concha with its overlying skin can be transposed superiorly, based on a very narrow pedicle in the area of the crus helicis. The raw central area remaining is then resurfaced with a split-thickness skin graft. This technique maximally utilizes the unique remaining auricular elements and can provide a satisfactory reconstruction in selected patients without resorting to more complex and extensive procedures. There have been no significant complications in this series, and patient acceptance of the results has been excellent.

Preoperative magnification angiography of donor and recipient sites for clinical free transfer of flaps or digits.

Based on the 14 free flap transfers we present with full survival, we recommend peroperative magnification angiography of both the recipient and donor sites. In our hands, this type of preoperative assessment seems to increase the margin of safety.