Matthijs J. M. Cluitmans

Noninvasive reconstruction of cardiac electrical activity: update on current methods, applications and challenges

Electrical activity at the level of the heart muscle can be noninvasively reconstructed from body-surface electrocardiograms (ECGs) and patient-specific torso-heart geometry. This modality, coined electrocardiographic imaging, could fill the gap between the noninvasive (low-resolution) 12-lead ECG and invasive (high-resolution) electrophysiology studies. Much progress has been made to establish electrocardiographic imaging, and clinical studies appear with increasing frequency. However, many assumptions and model choices are involved in its execution, and only limited validation has been performed. In this article, we will discuss the technical details, clinical applications and current limitations of commonly used methods in electrocardiographic imaging. It is important for clinicians to realise the influence of certain assumptions and model choices for correct and careful interpretation of the results. This, in combination with more extensive validation, will allow for exploitation of the full potential of noninvasive electrocardiographic imaging as a powerful clinical tool to expedite diagnosis, guide therapy and improve risk stratification.

Realistic training data improve noninvasive reconstruction of heart-surface potentials

The inverse problem of electrocardiography is to noninvasively reconstruct electrical heart activity from body-surface electrocardiograms. Solving this problem is beneficial to clinical practice. However, reconstructions cannot be obtained straightforwardly due to the ill-posed nature of this problem. Therefore, regularization schemes are necessary to arrive at realistic solutions. To date, no electrophysiological data have been used in reconstruction methods and regularization schemes. In this study, we used a training set of simulated heart-surface potentials to create a realistic basis for reconstructions of electrical cardiac activity. We tested this method in computer simulations and in one patient. The quality of reconstruction improved significantly after projection of the results of traditional regularization methods on this new basis, both in silico (p<;0.01) and in vivo (p<;0.05). Thus, we demonstrate that the novel concept of applying electrophysiological data might be useful to improve noninvasive reconstruction of electrical heart activity.

Physiology-based regularization of the electrocardiographic inverse problem

The inverse problem of electrocardiography aims at noninvasively reconstructing electrical activity of the heart from recorded body-surface electrocardiograms. A crucial step is regularization, which deals with ill-posedness of the problem by imposing constraints on the possible solutions. We developed a regularization method that includes electrophysiological input. Body-surface potentials are recorded and a computed tomography scan is performed to obtain the torso–heart geometry. Propagating waveforms originating from several positions at the heart are simulated and used to generate a set of basis vectors representing spatial distributions of potentials on the heart surface. The real heart-surface potentials are then reconstructed from the recorded body-surface potentials by finding a sparse representation in terms of this basis. This method, which we named ‘physiology-based regularization’ (PBR), was compared to traditional Tikhonov regularization and validated using in vivo recordings in dogs. PBR recovered details of heart-surface electrograms that were lost with traditional regularization, attained higher correlation coefficients and led to improved estimation of recovery times. The best results were obtained by including approximate knowledge about the beat origin in the PBR basis.

In-vivo evaluation of reduced-lead-systems in noninvasive reconstruction and localization of cardiac electrical activity

Noninvasive imaging of electrical activity of the heart has increasingly gained attention last decades. Heart-surface potentials are reconstructed from a torso-heart geometry and body-surface potentials recorded from tens to hundreds of body-surface electrodes. However, it remains an open question how many electrodes are needed to accurately reconstruct heart-surface potentials. In a canine model, we reconstructed epicardial electrograms and activation locations, investigating the use of a full-lead system, consisting of 169 well connected body-surface electrodes, and reduced-lead systems: using half or a third of the electrodes, or a minimalistic set of the default 12-lead ECG. Correlation coefficients indicate that the quality of the reconstructed electrograms remains stable to a third of the electrodes, and decreases with fewer electrodes. Similarly, the mismatch between the detected origin of a beat and known pacing location decreases when fewer body-surface electrodes are used. However, when only 9 or 10 electrodes are available for pacing localization, the median mismatch is 30mm, only marginally higher than when half of the electrodes are used, although with a significant error spread up to 65mm. These results indicate that for specific purposes (such as detecting the origin of an extrasystolic beat), a lower number of body-surface electrodes can provide noninvasive electrocardiographic imaging results that might still be useful for a clinical purpose.

Wavelet-sparsity based regularization over time in the inverse problem of electrocardiography

Noninvasive, detailed assessment of electrical cardiac activity at the level of the heart surface has the potential to revolutionize diagnostics and therapy of cardiac pathologies. Due to the requirement of noninvasiveness, body-surface potentials are measured and have to be projected back to the heart surface, yielding an ill-posed inverse problem. Ill-posedness ensures that there are non-unique solutions to this problem, resulting in a problem of choice. In the current paper, it is proposed to restrict this choice by requiring that the time series of reconstructed heart-surface potentials is sparse in the wavelet domain. A local search technique is introduced that pursues a sparse solution, using an orthogonal wavelet transform. Epicardial potentials reconstructed from this method are compared to those from existing methods, and validated with actual intracardiac recordings. The new technique improves the reconstructions in terms of smoothness and recovers physiologically meaningful details. Additionally, reconstruction of activation timing seems to be improved when pursuing sparsity of the reconstructed signals in the wavelet domain.

Wavelet-promoted sparsity for non-invasive reconstruction of electrical activity of the heart

AbstractWe investigated a novel sparsity-based regularization method in the wavelet domain of the inverse problem of electrocardiography that aims at preserving the spatiotemporal characteristics of heart-surface potentials. In three normal, anesthetized dogs, electrodes were implanted around the epicardium and body-surface electrodes were attached to the torso. Potential recordings were obtained simultaneously on the body surface and on the epicardium. A CT scan was used to digitize a homogeneous geometry which consisted of the body-surface electrodes and the epicardial surface. A novel multitask elastic-net-based method was introduced to regularize the ill-posed inverse problem. The method simultaneously pursues a sparse wavelet representation in time-frequency and exploits correlations in space. Performance was assessed in terms of quality of reconstructed epicardial potentials, estimated activation and recovery time, and estimated locations of pacing, and compared with performance of Tikhonov zeroth-order regularization. Results in the wavelet domain obtained higher sparsity than those in the time domain. Epicardial potentials were non-invasively reconstructed with higher accuracy than with Tikhonov zeroth-order regularization (p < 0.05), and recovery times were improved (p < 0.05). No significant improvement was found in terms of activation times and localization of origin of pacing. Next to improved estimation of recovery isochrones, which is important when assessing substrate for cardiac arrhythmias, this novel technique opens potentially powerful opportunities for clinical application, by allowing to choose wavelet bases that are optimized for specific clinical questions. Graphical AbstractThe inverse problem of electrocardiography is to reconstruct heart-surface potentials from recorded bodysurface electrocardiograms (ECGs) and a torso-heart geometry. However, it is ill-posed and solving it requires additional constraints for regularization. We introduce a regularization method that simultaneously pursues a sparse wavelet representation in time-frequency and exploits correlations in space. Our approach reconstructs epicardial (heart-surface) potentials with higher accuracy than common methods. It also improves the reconstruction of recovery isochrones, which is important when assessing substrate for cardiac arrhythmias. This novel technique opens potentially powerful opportunities for clinical application, by allowing to choose wavelet bases that are optimized for specific clinical questions.

Validation and Opportunities of Electrocardiographic Imaging: From Technical Achievements to Clinical Applications

Electrocardiographic imaging (ECGI) reconstructs the electrical activity of the heart from a dense array of body-surface electrocardiograms and a patient-specific heart-torso geometry. Depending on how it is formulated, ECGI allows the reconstruction of the activation and recovery sequence of the heart, the origin of premature beats or tachycardia, the anchors/hotspots of re-entrant arrhythmias and other electrophysiological quantities of interest. Importantly, these quantities are directly and non-invasively reconstructed in a digitized model of the patient’s three-dimensional heart, which has led to clinical interest in ECGI’s ability to personalize diagnosis and guide therapy. Despite considerable development over the last decades, validation of ECGI is challenging. Firstly, results depend considerably on implementation choices, which are necessary to deal with ECGI’s ill-posed character. Secondly, it is challenging to obtain (invasive) ground truth data of high quality. In this review, we discuss the current status of ECGI validation as well as the major challenges remaining for complete adoption of ECGI in clinical practice. Specifically, showing clinical benefit is essential for the adoption of ECGI. Such benefit may lie in patient outcome improvement, workflow improvement, or cost reduction. Future studies should focus on these aspects to achieve broad adoption of ECGI, but only after the technical challenges have been solved for that specific application/pathology. We propose ‘best’ practices for technical validation and highlight collaborative efforts recently organized in this field. Continued interaction between engineers, basic scientists, and physicians remains essential to find a hybrid between technical achievements, pathological mechanisms insights, and clinical benefit, to evolve this powerful technique toward a useful role in clinical practice.