Maurice Corcos

Binge eating behaviours, depression and weight control strategies

The aim of this paper was to explore the relationships between depressive symptoms and weight control strategies in DSM-IV eating disordered patients with binge eating behaviours. We hypothesised that weight control strategies characterised by a loss of control, such as vomiting and purging, may be clinically associated with increased levels of depression. The study population consisted of 402 consecutive outpatients: 27 with binge eating/purging anorexia nervosa (AN-BN), 213 with purging bulimia nervosa (BN-P), 73 with non-purging bulimia nervosa (BN-NP), and 89 with binge eating disorder (BED). The severity of depression was measured using the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), and binge eating behaviours were investigated using the self-report scale for bulimic behaviours. In the sample as a whole, the severity of depression significantly correlated with the severity of binge eating behaviours, but no significant differences were found in the severity of depression by diagnostic sub-types. In order to avoid the confounding erasing effect of time, a smaller sample of patients with a short history of binge eating behaviours was further explored. Furthermore, because weight control strategies and the eating disorder diagnostic sub-types overlapped imperfectly, the patients were compared on the basis of presence or absence of strategies reflecting an active attempt to master the weight gain due to binge-ing behaviours. The patients adopting active control strategies (N=14) had significantly less severe depressive symptoms than those adopting non-active weight control strategies (N=39). Finally, the Authors discuss some hypotheses concerning the defensive role of weight control strategies and the impact of illness duration on the clinical expression of depression in eating disordered patients.

Understanding alexithymia within a psychoanalytical framework

The object of this paper is to provide a metapsychological definition of alexithymia as described in 1967 in terms of operational thinking and negative hallucination. This is a familiar and established concept in the fields of psychopathology, psychology, and of clinical and psychosomatic medicine. From a psychoanalytic and psychosomatic point of view, the term is conceptually close to P. Martys “operative thinking”, as described in 1963, even though we know they do not belong to the same epistemological field: on one hand Neuroscience, Psychiatry and the objectalization of the symptom at different levels, and on the other, as regards mechanical functioning, a psychoanalytic clinical approach within the dynamics of the relationship between transference and counter‐transference. The present authors consider that Freudian metapsychology, as now complexified by Andrè Green, allows for a metapsychological approach to alexithymia insofar as it relates to Martys operative thinking. Thus does Green’s conceptualization of the mother’s negative hallucination, of negative introjection, of a psychically ‘dead (and insecure) mother’, now provide us with the opportunity to describe, in metapsychological terms, the genesis of this particular mode of psychical functioning. Given the mother’s negative hallucination produces a host structure as a background to negativity that will fit future object representations, we will assume that in the case of & future operational or alexithymic &?, this negative hallucination will pathologically and defensively involve the endo‐psychic perception of affect.

Obsessive-compulsive symptoms as a correlate of severity in the clinical presentation of eating disorders: Measuring the effects of depression

Obsessive-compulsive symptoms have been related to severity in the clinical presentation of eating disorders, whereas the impact of depression on the correlations between their severity and the severity of eating disorders has not been investigated. This paper assesses the effects of depression in 42 adolescent patients who met DSM-IV criteria for anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa by using the Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS), the Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI) and the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). The results indicate that patients who show elevated obsessionality and compulsivity on the Y-BOCS display a significantly higher degree of disturbed attitudes and behaviours concerning eating than patients with limited obsessionality and compulsivity. However, when the effects of depression are considered, all the differences found disappear. Our study suggests that depression is more directly associated with the severity of eating disorders than obsessive-compulsive symptoms and that the intensity of obsessive-compulsive symptoms in eating disorders is influenced by the intensity of depression. The relations between obsessive-compulsive symptoms, depression and eating disorders are not known. Even so this study highlights the importance of assessing depression when using obsessive and compulsive symptoms as a correlate of severity in the clinical presentation of eating disorders.

Current developments in the practice of individual psychoanalytic psychodrama in France

The authors present the history of individual psychoanalytic psychodrama and its current developments as practised in France. They put forward the technique, objectives and rules, along with the indications, limits and risks that ensue from the specific nature of this therapeutic approach. Through its technical adjustments, individual psychoanalytic psychodrama provides a therapeutic option that is appropriate to the defences prevalent in many patients that cause classical psychotherapies to fail: massive inhibition, operative functioning far removed from affects or in false self mode; phobias, disavowal or splitting of the internal psychic life and emotions; prevalence of short discharge circuits in acted‐out behaviours and bodily or visceral complaints and expressions. Psychodrama utilizes these defences not in order to eliminate them but to ‘subvert’ them so that they can continue to carry out their protective role, in particular ensuring narcissistic continuity. At the same time, psychodrama relaxes these defences and facilitates a possible filtering through of the repressed material. Through the number of actors and the diffraction of transference that this allows, psychodrama provides a possibility of adjusting the potentially traumatic effect of the encounter with the object and the instigation of the transference in the regressive dimension induced by any psychotherapeutic process.

The Quality of Depressive Experience as a Prognostic Factor in Eating Disorders

There is overwhelming evidence that depression is one of the most common experiences of eating disorder patients (Herzog et al., 1992; Touchette et al., 2010). Individuals with anorexia or bulimia nervosa commonly display high levels of dysphoric affects, feelings of emptiness and ineffectiveness and emotions such as loneliness and desperation (Bruch 1973). Self-depreciating emotions associated with pathological eating behaviors may probably trigger depressive episodes (Nolen-Hoesema et al., 2007). However, several authors have suggested that eating behaviors themselves (whether starving, bingeing or purging) may serve as adaptive strategies to regulate negative emotions, such as those associated with identity and interpersonal disturbances, frequently seen in these patients (Heatherton et Baumeister, 1991). For these reasons, it seems worthwhile, in eating disorders, to look for depression not only in a categorical way but also in a dimensional way and to explore the subjective experience of depression of these patients. This is in line with recent conceptualizations on depression from different theoretical perspectives which converge towards the identification of two types of fundamental depressive experiences framed by personality development: the first one focused on concerns associated with disruption in relationships with others (with feelings of loss, abandonment and loneliness) and the second one centered on problems concerning identity (associated with low self-esteem, feelings of failure, culpability, lack of self-confidence) (Blatt and Zuroff 1992). According to Blatt (Blatt, 2004), maladaptive behaviors would emanate directly from an overemphasis and exaggeration of one of the two essential developmental lines of the personality: the Dependent/Anaclitic line, which concerns the establishment of satisfying interpersonal relationships, and the Selfcritical/Introjective line, which focuses on the achievement of a positive and cohesive sense of self (Blatt and Zuroff 1992). Blatt and colleagues have initially developed the Depressive Experience Questionnaire (DEQ) to assess these two dimensions which emerge as independent factors in analytic studies (Blatt et al., 1976). However, subsequent theoretical developments have suggested that different levels could be indentified, each following a developmental trajectory from immature to more mature forms of interpersonal relatedness and self-definition.