Maurice Stokes

Audit of complete axillary dissection in early breast cancer

The role of complete axillary dissection (CAD) in the management of breast cancer is controversial and largely unresolved. Acceptance of the results of trials incorporating CAD assumes that the axillary dissection is truly complete. To address this point, and also to define quality control criteria for this operation within our unit, we audited 100 consecutive axillary dissections as follows: the primary surgeon performed what he/she felt to be a thorough CAD and submitted separately the contents of level I, II and III for pathological evaluation; a second surgeon then independently assessed the dissection and arbitrarily labelled any further excised tissue as level IV. Level IV nodes were retrieved in 38% of cases. Tumour involvement of level IV nodes was noted in 5% (2/38) of dissections where lymph nodes were retrieved, but in neither instance was pathological staging altered. There was a significant decrease in the incidence of level IV node retrieval from 47% (28/60) in the first 6 months of audit to 20% (8/40) subsequently. This novel approach to our continuing audit identified quality control criteria for this procedure in our unit and suggested that audit of this kind benefits training.

Digital mammography in a screening programme and its implications for pathology: a comparative study

Aims Most studies comparing full-field digital mammography (FFDM) with conventional screen-film mammography (SFM) have been radiology-based. The pathological implications of FFDM have received little attention in the literature, especially in the context of screening programmes. The primary objective of this retrospective study is to compare FFDM with SFM in a population-based screening programme with regard to a number of pathological parameters. Methods During the study period, 107 818 women underwent screening mammograms with almost equal numbers obtained with each technique (49.9% with SFM vs 50.1% with FFDM). We compared SFM with FFDM using the following parameters: recall rate, diagnostic core biopsy rate, cancer detection rates, B3 rate, B4 rate, preoperative diagnostic rate for malignancy, positive predictive values and tumour characteristics. Results The recall rate was significantly higher with FFDM (4.21% vs 3.52%, p<0.0001). The overall cancer detection rate of 7.2 per 1000 women screened with FFDM was also significantly higher than the rate of 6.2 per 1000 women screened with SFM (p=0.04). The B3 rate in the SFM group was 1.3 per 1000 women screened versus 2.5 per 1000 women screened in the FFDM group (p<0.001). The recall rate and cancer detection rates (overall, invasive and pure ductal carcinoma in situ) were all significantly higher with FFDM for lesions presenting as microcalcifications. Conclusions The higher cancer detection rate with FFDM in this study was due to improved detection of microcalcifications. However, this was achieved at the cost of a higher recall rate and a higher B3 rate, indicating that overtreatment may be problematic with digital mammography.

Nipple discharge and the efficacy of duct cytology in evaluating breast cancer risk

BACKGROUND Nipple discharge accounts for up to 5% of referrals to breast surgical services. With the vast majority of breast carcinomas originating in the ductal system, symptomatic dysfunction of this system often raises disproportionate clinical concern. The aim of this study is firstly, to evaluate the clinical importance of nipple discharge as an indicator of underlying malignancy and secondly, to assess the diagnostic application of duct cytology in patients presenting with nipple discharge. STUDY DESIGN We performed a retrospective analysis of all patients presenting with nipple discharge as their primary symptom to the symptomatic breast unit at a tertiary referral center over a 30-month period (n = 313). The Hospital Inpatient Enquiry (HIPE) System and BreastHealth database were used to identify our study cohort. Parameters evaluated included patient demographics, clinical presentation, clinical evaluation, radiological assessment and histological/cytological analysis. RESULTS Three-hundred and thirteen patients presented with nipple discharge as their primary complaint. Invasive breast carcinoma was diagnosed by Triple Assessment in 5% of patients. 24% of patients presenting with nipple discharge underwent nipple aspiration and cytological analysis. Duct cytology was diagnostic of the underlying breast carcinoma in 50% of triple assessment diagnosed carcinoma. Four risk factors were identified as having a significant association with breast carcinoma, these included (a) age >50 years (p < 0.0001), (b) bloody nipple discharge (p < 0.008), (c) presence of a breast lump (p < 0.0001) and (d) single duct discharge (p < 0.006). CONCLUSIONS Nipple discharge is a poor indicator of an underlying malignancy. Use of nipple aspiration and duct cytology for the assessment of nipple discharge is of limited diagnostic benefit. However, by utilizing the systematic, gold standard approach of Triple Assessment (clinical, radiological and cytological evaluation), the risk of underlying carcinoma can be accurately defined.

A season of football injuries.

All rugby and soccer players presenting to the Accident & Emergency department during the football season 1992-1993 (a total of 871) were prospectively studied to compare the injuries sustained in the two sports. The nature and site of injury, treatment required, age, fitness, experience and position of the player, situation giving rise to injury, and medical attention at the grounds were all analysed. The results show that rugby and soccer players had the same number of injuries, and while there were some differences in the nature of the injuries, there was no difference in overall severity. Rugby flankers and soccer goalkeepers are particularly at risk. Competitive matches produce more injuries than training sessions. Experience or fitness did not appear to be a factor and 45% of rugby injuries and 15% of soccer injuries were from school matches. Law changes (e.g. the rugby scrum and the use of gum-shields) have reduced some injuries, but other areas (e.g. jumping for the ball in soccer, rucks and mauls in rugby) also warrant consideration. There was one death, but no spinal cord injuries. Medical attention at the grounds was limited. Rugby injuries, therefore, do not appear to be more numerous or severe than soccer injuries. Law changes have been of benefit but they need to be enforced and perhaps more should be considered. Medical attention at sports grounds could be improved and Registers of injuries kept by the sporting bodies would be of benefit.

An imbalance in progenitor cell populations reflects tumour progression in breast cancer primary culture models

BackgroundMany factors influence breast cancer progression, including the ability of progenitor cells to sustain or increase net tumour cell numbers. Our aim was to define whether alterations in putative progenitor populations could predict clinicopathological factors of prognostic importance for cancer progression.MethodsPrimary cultures were established from human breast tumour and adjacent non-tumour tissue. Putative progenitor cell populations were isolated based on co-expression or concomitant absence of the epithelial and myoepithelial markers EPCAM and CALLA respectively.ResultsSignificant reductions in cellular senescence were observed in tumour versus non-tumour cultures, accompanied by a stepwise increase in proliferation:senescence ratios. A novel correlation between tumour aggressiveness and an imbalance of putative progenitor subpopulations was also observed. Specifically, an increased double-negative (DN) to double-positive (DP) ratio distinguished aggressive tumours of high grade, estrogen receptor-negativity or HER2-positivity. The DN:DP ratio was also higher in malignant MDA-MB-231 cells relative to non-tumourogenic MCF-10A cells. Ultrastructural analysis of the DN subpopulation in an invasive tumour culture revealed enrichment in lipofuscin bodies, markers of ageing or senescent cells.ConclusionsOur results suggest that an imbalance in tumour progenitor subpopulations imbalances the functional relationship between proliferation and senescence, creating a microenvironment favouring tumour progression.

Cowden Syndrome: Serendipitous Diagnosis in Patients with Significant Breast Disease. Case Series and Literature Review

Cowden syndrome (CS) is a multi‐system disease that carries an increased lifetime risk of developing certain cancers as well as benign neoplasms. The presence of features of CS in the general unaffected population results in difficulties in the recognition and diagnosis of this condition. Early diagnosis is essential to prevent the development of malignant neoplasms, yet despite the introduction of diagnostic criteria and risk calculators, accurate diagnosis remains a challenge. We identified three patients who presented to the symptomatic breast unit of a University Teaching Hospital over a period of 12 weeks who subsequently were diagnosed with CS. In this article, we discuss their clinical presentations as well as their path to diagnosis. The short timeframe between the presentations of these patients undoubtedly expedited their diagnosis. Upon application of internationally recognized diagnostic criteria, only two out of our three patients were accurately diagnosed. The risk of breast cancer in CS is comparable with that found in Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer Syndrome and while a protocol for breast screening in these patients exists in most centres, no such protocol exists for patients with CS in our institution. The recommended cancer surveillance programs for patients with CS have not been found to prolong survival, however. CS consists of a vast array of diseases that span the various specialties and the subsequent varied phenotypic presentation poses diagnostic difficulties for clinicians as emphasized in our series. Continued research is required to improve recognition and diagnosis and will hopefully result in the emergence of life prolonging strategies.

Removal of a sex toy under general anaesthesia using a bimanual-technique and Magill's forceps: A case report.

Highlights • A case of a 68-year-old male with large bowel obstruction due to the presence of a phallic object in the rectum is presented.• Removal of the phallic object was achieved using a pair of Magill’s forceps and bi-manual manipulation under general anaesthesia.• This case demonstrates the use of Magill’s forceps to aid removal of a foreign body in the rectum.• Laparotomy and open removal may, therefore, be rarely necessary.