Michael A. McCartney

Dispersal barriers in tropical oceans and speciation in Atlantic and eastern Pacific sea urchins of the genus Echinometra

Echinometra is a pantropical sea urchin made famous through studies of phylogeny, speciation, and genetic structure of the Indo‐West Pacific (IWP) species. We sequenced 630 bp of the cytochrome oxidase I (COI) mitochondrial gene to provide comparable information on the eastern Pacific and Atlantic species, using divergence between those separated by closure of the Isthmus of Panama 3.1 million years ago (Ma) to estimate dates for cladogenic events. Most recently (1.27–1.62 Ma), the Atlantic species E. lucunter and E. viridis diverged from each other, at a time in the Pleistocene that sea levels fell and Caribbean coral speciation and extinction rates were high. An earlier split, assumed to have been coincident with the completion of the Isthmus of Panama, separated the eastern Pacific E. vanbrunti from the Atlantic common ancestor. Transisthmian COI divergence similar to that in the sea urchin genus Eucidaris supports this assumption. The most ancient split in Echinometra occurred between the IWP and the neotropical clades, due to cessation of larval exchange around South Africa or across the Eastern Pacific Barrier. Gene flow within species is generally high; however, there are restrictions to genetic exchange between E. lucunter populations from the Caribbean and those from the rest of the Atlantic. Correlation between cladogenic and vicariant events supports E. Mayr’s contention that marine species, despite their high dispersal potential, form by means of geographical separation. That sympatric, nonhybridizing E. lucunter and E. viridis were split so recently suggests, however, that perfection of reproductive barriers between marine species with large populations can occur in less than 1.6 million years (Myr).

Connectivity of Caribbean coral populations: complementary insights from empirical and modelled gene flow

Understanding patterns of connectivity among populations of marine organisms is essential for the development of realistic, spatially explicit models of population dynamics. Two approaches, empirical genetic patterns and oceanographic dispersal modelling, have been used to estimate levels of evolutionary connectivity among marine populations but rarely have their potentially complementary insights been combined. Here, a spatially realistic Lagrangian model of larval dispersal and a theoretical genetic model are integrated with the most extensive study of gene flow in a Caribbean marine organism. The 871 genets collected from 26 sites spread over the wider Caribbean subsampled 45.8% of the 1900 potential unique genets in the model. At a coarse scale, significant consensus between modelled estimates of genetic structure and empirical genetic data for populations of the reef‐building coral Montastraea annularis is observed. However, modelled and empirical data differ in their estimates of connectivity among northern Mesoamerican reefs indicating that processes other than dispersal may dominate here. Further, the geographic location and porosity of the previously described east–west barrier to gene flow in the Caribbean is refined. A multi‐prong approach, integrating genetic data and spatially realistic models of larval dispersal and genetic projection, provides complementary insights into the processes underpinning population connectivity in marine invertebrates on evolutionary timescales.

Male Reproductive Success in Sessile Invertebrates: Competition for Fertilizations

Recent in situ fertilization studies of free spawning and brooding marine organisms have focused almost exclusively on the yield of fertilized ova (female repro- ductive success). As a consequence, we know little about the factors that determine male reproductive success. If marine organisms compete for fertilizations (as do many terrestrial organisms), then a males reproductive success should be reduced by the presence of other males. We tested this hypothesis via in situ experiments employing allozyme markers for both a colonial ascidian (Botryllus schlosseri) and a bryozoan (Celleporella hyalina). Under moderate density conditions, the presence of closer male-functioning colonies reduced the fertilization success of more distant males in both species. In C. hyalina, male fertilization success also increased with allocation to sperm production. In addition, selfing rates in this species were negatively correlated with the abundance of outcross sperm. These results suggest that male reproductive success in sessile marine invertebrates must be assessed as a function of the gamete output and spatial distribution of other males in a population, and that the performance of isolated males may yield overestimates of male fertilization success in natural populations.

Genetic mosaic in a marine species flock.

We used molecular approaches to study the status of speciation in coral reef fishes known as hamlets (Serranidae: Hypoplectrus). Several hamlet morphospecies coexist on Caribbean reefs, and mate assortatively with respect to their strikingly distinct colour patterns. We provide evidence that, genetically, the hamlets display characteristics common in species flocks on land and in freshwaters. Substitutions within two mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) protein‐coding genes place hamlets within a monophyletic group relative to members of two related genera (Serranus and Diplectrum), and establish that the hamlet radiation must have been very recent. mtDNA distances separating hamlet morphospecies were slight (0.6 ± 0.04%), yielding a coalescent estimate for the age of the hamlet flock of approximately 430 000 years. Morphospecies did not sort into distinct mtDNA haplotype phylogroups, and alleles at five hypervariable microsatellite loci were shared broadly across species boundaries. None the less, molecular variation was not distributed at random. Analyses of mtDNA haplotype frequencies and nested clades in haplotype networks revealed significant genetic differences between geographical regions and among colour morphospecies. We also observed significant microsatellite differentiation between geographical regions and in Puerto Rico, among colour morphospecies; the latter providing evidence for reproductive isolation between colour morphospecies at this locale. In our Panama collection, however, colour morphospecies were mostly genetically indistinguishable. This mosaic pattern of DNA differentiation implies a complex interaction between population history, mating behaviour and geography and suggests that porous boundaries separate species in this flock of brilliantly coloured coral reef fishes.

SEA URCHIN BINDIN DIVERGENCE PREDICTS GAMETE COMPATIBILITY

Abstract Studies on the evolution of reproductive proteins have shown that they tend to evolve more rapidly than other proteins, frequently under positive selection. Progress on understanding the implications of these patterns is possible for marine invertebrates, where molecular evolution can be linked to gamete compatibility. In this study, we surveyed data from the literature from five genera of sea urchins for which there was information on gamate compatibility, divergence of the sperm‐egg recognition protein bindin, and mitochondrial divergence. We draw three conclusions: (1) bindin divergence at nonsynonymous sites predicts gamete compatibility, whereas (2) bindin divergence at synonymous sites and mitocondrial DNA divergence do not, and (3) as few as 10 amino acid changes in bidin can lead to complete gamete incompatibility between species. Using mitochondrial divergence as a proxy for time, we find that complete gamete incompatibility can evolve in approximately one and a half million years, whereas sister can maintain complete gamete compatibility for as long as five million years.

Quantitative Analysis of Gametic Incompatibility Between Closely Related Species of Neotropical Sea Urchins

Species of the sea urchin genus Echinometra found on the two coasts of Panamá are recently diverged and only partially isolated by incomplete barriers to interspecific fertilization. This study confirms previous work that revealed incompatibility between the eggs of the Atlantic E. lucunter and the sperm of the other two neotropical species, whereas eggs of its sympatric congener E. viridis and allopatric E. vanbrunti are largely compatible with heterospecific sperm. Here we quantify fertilization using a range of sperm dilutions. We demonstrate a much stronger block to cross-species fertilization of E. lucunter eggs than was previously shown at fixed sperm concentrations, and mild incompatibility of the other two species’ eggs where previous crosses between species were not distinguishable from within-species controls. Additionally, we present evidence for intraspecific variation in egg receptivity towards heterospecific sperm. Our findings here again discount the “reinforcement model” as a viable explanation for the pattern of prezygotic isolation. Gamete incompatibility in these Echinometra has appeared recently—within the last 1.5 million years—but is weaker in sympatry than in allopatry. Accidents of history may help explain why incompatibility of eggs emerged in one species and not in others. Compensatory sexual selection on sperm in this species could follow, and promote divergence of proteins mediating sperm-egg recognition.

SEX ALLOCATION AND MALE FITNESS GAIN IN A COLONIAL, HERMAPHRODITIC MARINE INVERTEBRATE

While simultaneous hermaphroditism occurs in most animal phyla, theories for its adaptive significance remain untested. Sex allocation theory predicts that combined sexes are favored in sedentary and sessile organisms because localized gamete dispersal and local mate competition (LMC) among gametes promote decelerating fitness “gain curves” that relate male investment to reproductive success. Under this LMC model, males fertilize all locally available eggs at low sperm output, additional output leads to proportionally fewer fertilizations, and combined sexes with female‐biased sex allocation are favored. Decelerating male gain curves have been found in hermaphroditic flowering plants, but the present paper reports the first analysis in an animal. The colonial hermaphroditic bryozoan Celleporella hyalina forms unisexual male and female zooids that can be counted to estimate absolute and relative gender allocations. I placed “sperm donor” colonies—each with different numbers of male zooids, and each homozygous for diagnostic allozyme alleles—among target maternal colonies on field mating arrays, and estimated donor fertilization success by scoring allozyme markers in target‐colony progeny. Fertilization success increased with numbers of donor male zooids, but linear and not decelerating curves fit the data best. Mean sex allocation was not female biased, consistent with nondecelerating male gain. Sperm donors, moreover, did not monopolize matings as expected under high LMC, but rather shared paternity with rival colonies. Hence localized water‐borne gamete dispersal alone may not yield decelerating male gain and favor the maintenance of hermaphroditism; relaxed sperm competition in low density populations might also be required. In free‐spawning marine organisms, males cannot control access to fertilizations, intense sperm competition may be commonplace, and high male sex allocation may be selected to enhance siring success under competition.

EXTRAORDINARY AFLP FINGERPRINT SIMILARITY DESPITE STRONG ASSORTATIVE MATING BETWEEN REEF FISH COLOR MORPHOSPECIES

Abstract Recent theoretical models and empirical studies of fruit flies, birds, and fish indicate that assortative mating may initiate speciation when physical barriers to gene flow are absent, and before postzygotic barriers evolve. These are important results for marine animals like coral reef fish, where ocean currents can carry planktonic larvae over broad ranges, interconnecting populations and slowing genetic divergence. The Caribbean hamlets (genus Hypoplectrus) are a flock of reef fish morphospecies with highly distinct color pattern that mate like with like, but show little mitochondrial or microsatellite DNA differentiation. Here, we broadly screen genomic diversity using amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) and survey mating pair formation between two morphospecies in the Florida Keys, the butter hamlet (H. unicolor) and the blue hamlet (H. gemma). No AFLP was species-diagnostic (fixed), and neighbor-joining analyses revealed no clustering of individuals consistent with morphospecies boundaries. Assignment tests, however, placed most individuals within their morphospecies of origin. Field surveys showed that > 98% of mating pairs, including those of rare morphospecies, were of like color pattern. Spawning by a single mixed pair adds to earlier observations suggesting that infrequent hybridization may be a genetically homogenizing force in Hypoplectrus. This study provides a clear example of strong assortative mating in a system with limited genetic differentiation.

Comparison of Gamete Compatibility Between Two Blue Mussel Species in Sympatry and in Allopatry

Recent demonstrations of positive selection on genes controlling gamete compatibility have resulted in a proliferation of hypotheses concerning the sources of selection. We tested a prediction of one prominent hypothesis, selection to avoid hybridization (i.e., reinforcement), by comparing heterospecific gamete compatibility in two Mytilus edulis populations: one population in Cobscook Bay, Maine, in which the close congener, M. trossulus, is abundant (a region of sympatry), and one population in Kittery, Maine, in which M. trossulus is absent (a region of allopatry). Three diagnostic nuclear DNA markers were used to identify mussels to species and to estimate the frequency of both species and their hybrids in the two populations. Controlled crosses were then conducted by combining eggs of M. edulis females with a range of M.edulis and M. trossulus sperm concentrations. Results were not consistent with the reinforcement hypothesis. M. edulis females collected from the region of sympatry were no more incompatible with M. trossulus males than were M. edulis females collected from the region of allopatry. A trend in the opposite direction, toward greater compatibility in sympatry, suggests that introgression of M. trossulus genes that control egg compatibility, such as those encoding receptors for sperm, may influence evolution of gametic isolation in hybridizing populations.

Identifying exoskeleton proteins in the blue crab from an expressed sequence tag (EST) library

A blue crab (Callinectes sapidus) expressed sequence tag project was designed for multiple purposes including discovery of genes for cuticular (exoskeletal) proteins, some of which may regulate mineralization. One of the expression libraries sequenced was from the hypodermis (the epithelium depositing the cuticle). RNAs used for cDNA synthesis were pooled from arthrodial and mid-dorsal hypodermis at both pre-ecdysis and post-ecdysis. This ensured representation from both calcifying and non-calcifying regions and from layers of cuticle deposited both before and after ecdysis. The EST database was mined for cuticular protein sequences in three ways. First, we searched for sequences coding for known cuticle-specific motifs like the Rebers-Riddiford chitin-binding sequence and a motif known only from proteins extracted from mineralized exoskeletons of other decapods. Second, we checked the associated annotations in the EST project for similarity to known cuticular proteins, often from insects. Third, BLAST was used to search the EST data for significant homology to published cuticular protein sequences from other crustaceans. In all, the database contains at least 73 contigs or singlets representing transcripts of cuticular proteins. Forty-five of these distribute among ten clusters of very similar transcripts, possibly representing alternative splicing or recent gene duplications. The rest share less similarity. We have obtained complete sequences for 25 of the transcripts, have produced phylogenetics trees comparing them with similar proteins from insects and other crustaceans, and have determined expression patterns across the molt in calcifying versus non-calcifying cuticle. The combination of homology analysis and gene expression analysis allows us to infer putative functions in cuticle synthesis and calcification.