Michael Bedford Taylor

The Raw microprocessor: a computational fabric for software circuits and general-purpose programs

Wire delay is emerging as the natural limiter to microprocessor scalability. A new architectural approach could solve this problem, as well as deliver unprecedented performance, energy efficiency and cost effectiveness. The Raw microprocessor research prototype uses a scalable instruction set architecture to attack the emerging wire-delay problem by providing a parallel, software interface to the gate, wire and pin resources of the chip. An architecture that has direct, first-class analogs to all of these physical resources will ultimately let programmers achieve the maximum amount of performance and energy efficiency in the face of wire delay.

Baring it all to software: Raw machines

The most radical of the architectures that appear in this issue are Raw processors-highly parallel architectures with hundreds of very simple processors coupled to a small portion of the on-chip memory. Each processor, or tile, also contains a small bank of configurable logic, allowing synthesis of complex operations directly in configurable hardware. Unlike the others, this architecture does not use a traditional instruction set architecture. Instead, programs are compiled directly onto the Raw hardware, with all units told explicitly what to do by the compiler. The compiler even schedules most of the intertile communication. The real limitation to this architecture is the efficacy of the compiler. The authors demonstrate impressive speedups for simple algorithms that lend themselves well to this architectural model, but whether this architecture will be effective for future workloads is an open question.

Evaluation of the Raw Microprocessor: An Exposed-Wire-Delay Architecture for ILP and Streams

This paper evaluates the Raw microprocessor. Raw addresses the challenge of building a general-purpose architecture that performs well on a larger class of stream and embedded computing applications than existing microprocessors, while still running existing ILP-based sequential programs with reasonable performance in the face of increasing wire delays. Raw approaches this challenge by implementing plenty of on-chip resources - including logic, wires, and pins - in a tiled arrangement, and exposing them through a new ISA, so that the software can take advantage of these resources for parallel applications. Raw supports both ILP and streams by routing operands between architecturally-exposed functional units over a point-to-point scalar operand network. This network offers low latency for scalar data transport. Raw manages the effect of wire delays by exposing the interconnect and using software to orchestrate both scalar and stream data transport. We have implemented a prototype Raw microprocessor in IBMs 180 nm, 6-layer copper, CMOS 7SF standard-cell ASIC process. We have also implemented ILP and stream compilers. Our evaluation attempts to determine the extent to which Raw succeeds in meeting its goal of serving as a more versatile, general-purpose processor. Central to achieving this goal is Raws ability to exploit all forms of parallelism, including ILP, DLP, TLP, and Stream parallelism. Specifically, we evaluate the performance of Raw on a diverse set of codes including traditional sequential programs, streaming applications, server workloads and bit-level embedded computation. Our experimental methodology makes use of a cycle-accurate simulator validated against our real hardware. Compared to a 180nm Pentium-III, using commodity PC memory system components, Raw performs within a factor of 2/spl times/ for sequential applications with a very low degree of ILP, about 2/spl times/ to 9/spl times/ better for higher levels of ILP, and 10/spl times/-100/spl times/ better when highly parallel applications are coded in a stream language or optimized by hand. The paper also proposes a new versatility metric and uses it to discuss the generality of Raw.

Conservation cores: reducing the energy of mature computations

Growing transistor counts, limited power budgets, and the breakdown of voltage scaling are currently conspiring to create a utilization wall that limits the fraction of a chip that can run at full speed at one time. In this regime, specialized, energy-efficient processors can increase parallelism by reducing the per-computation power requirements and allowing more computations to execute under the same power budget. To pursue this goal, this paper introduces conservation cores. Conservation cores, or c-cores, are specialized processors that focus on reducing energy and energy-delay instead of increasing performance. This focus on energy makes c-cores an excellent match for many applications that would be poor candidates for hardware acceleration (e.g., irregular integer codes). We present a toolchain for automatically synthesizing c-cores from application source code and demonstrate that they can significantly reduce energy and energy-delay for a wide range of applications. The c-cores support patching, a form of targeted reconfigurability, that allows them to adapt to new versions of the software they target. Our results show that conservation cores can reduce energy consumption by up to 16.0x for functions and by up to 2.1x for whole applications, while patching can extend the useful lifetime of individual c-cores to match that of conventional processors.

Is dark silicon useful?: harnessing the four horsemen of the coming dark silicon apocalypse

Due to the breakdown of Dennardian scaling, the percentage of a silicon chip that can switch at full frequency is dropping exponentially with each process generation. This utilization wall forces designers to ensure that, at any point in time, large fractions of their chips are effectively dark or dim silicon, i.e., either idle or significantly underclocked. As exponentially larger fractions of a chips transistors become dark, silicon area becomes an exponentially cheaper resource relative to power and energy consumption. This shift is driving a new class of architectural techniques that “spend” area to “buy” energy efficiency. All of these techniques seek to introduce new forms of heterogeneity into the computational stack. We envision that ultimately we will see widespread use of specialized architectures that leverage these techniques in order to attain orders-of-magnitude improvements in energy efficiency. However, many of these approaches also suffer from massive increases in complexity. As a result, we will need to look towards developing pervasively specialized architectures that insulate the hardware designer and the programmer from the underlying complexity of such systems. In this paper, I discuss four key approaches - the four horsemen - that have emerged as top contenders for thriving in the dark silicon age. Each class carries with its virtues deep-seated restrictions that requires a careful understanding of the underlying tradeoffs and benefits.

The GreenDroid Mobile Application Processor: An Architecture for Silicon's Dark Future

This article discusses about Greendroid mobile Application Processor. Dark silicon has emerged as the fundamental limiter in modern processor design. The Greendroid mobile application processor demonstrates an approach that uses dark silicon to execute general-purpose smart phone applications with less energy than todays most energy efficient designs.

The RAW benchmark suite: computation structures for general purpose computing

The RAW benchmark suite consists of twelve programs designed to facilitate comparing, validating, and improving reconfigurable computing systems. These benchmarks run the gamut of algorithms found in general purpose computing, including sorting, matrix operations, and graph algorithms. The suite includes an architecture-independent compilation framework, Raw Computation Structures (RawCS), to express each algorithms dependencies and to support automatic synthesis, partitioning, and mapping to a reconfigurable computer. Within this framework, each benchmark is portably designed in both C and Behavioral Verilog and scalably parameterized to consume a range of hardware resource capacities. To establish initial benchmark ratings, we have targeted a commercial logic emulation system based on virtual wires technology to automatically generate designs up to millions of gates (14 to 379 FPGAs). Because the virtual wires techniques abstract away machine-level details like FPGA capacity and interconnect, our hardware target for this system is an abstract reconfigurable logic fabric with memory-mapped host I/O. We report initial speeds in the range of 2X to 1800X faster than a 2.82 SPECint95 SparcStation 20 and encourage others in the field to run these benchmarks on other systems to provide a standard comparison.

SD-VBS: The San Diego Vision Benchmark Suite

In the era of multi-core, computer vision has emerged as an exciting application area which promises to continue to drive the demand for both more powerful and more energy efficient processors. Although there is still a long way to go, vision has matured significantly over the last few decades, and the list of applications that are useful to end users continues to grow. The parallelism inherent in vision applications makes them a promising workload for multi-core and many-core processors.

Scalar operand networks

The bypass paths and multiported register files in microprocessors serve as an implicit interconnect to communicate operand values among pipeline stages and multiple ALUs. Previous superscalar designs implemented this interconnect using centralized structures that do not scale with increasing ILP demands. In search of scalability, recent microprocessor designs in industry and academia exhibit a trend toward distributed resources such as partitioned register files, banked caches, multiple independent compute pipelines, and even multiple program counters. Some of these partitioned microprocessor designs have begun to implement bypassing and operand transport using point-to-point interconnects. We call interconnects optimized for scalar data transport, whether centralized or distributed, scalar operand networks. Although these networks share many of the challenges of multiprocessor networks such as scalability and deadlock avoidance, they have many unique requirements, including ultra-low latency (a few cycles versus tens of cycles) and ultra-fast operation-operand matching. This work discusses the unique properties of scalar operand networks (SONs), examines alternative ways of implementing them, and introduces the AsTrO taxonomy to distinguish between them. It discusses the design of two alternative networks in the context of the Raw microprocessor, and presents timing, area, and energy statistics for a real implementation. The paper also presents a 5-tuple performance model for SONs and analyzes their performance sensitivity to network properties for ILP workloads.

A 16-issue multiple-program-counter microprocessor with point-to-point scalar operand network

This microprocessor explores an architectural solution to scalability problems in scalar operand networks. The 0.15/spl mu/m 6M process, 331 mm/sup 2/ research prototype issues 16 unique instructions per cycle and uses an on-chip point-to-point scalar operand network to transfer operands among distributed functional units.