Michael J. O'Connor

Seizure control and mortality in epilepsy.

Mortality rates are increased among people with epilepsy, and may be highest in those with uncontrolled seizures. Because epilepsy surgery eliminates seizures in some people, we used an epilepsy surgery population to examine how seizure control influences mortality. We tested the hypothesis that patients with complete seizure relief after surgery would have a lower mortality rate than those who had persistent seizures. Three hundred ninety‐three patients who had epilepsy surgery between January 1986 and January 1996 were followed after surgery to assess long‐term survival; 347 had focal resection or transection, and 46 had anterior or complete corpus callosotomy. A multivariate survival analysis was performed, contrasting survival in those who had seizure recurrence with survival of those who remained seizure free. Standardized mortality ratios and 95% confidence intervals were calculated. Overall, seizure‐free patients had a lower mortality rate than those with persistent seizures. This was true for the subset of patients with localized resection or multiple subpial transection. No patients died among 199 with no seizure recurrence, whereas of 194 patients with seizure recurrence, 11 died. Six of the deaths were sudden and unexplained. Most patients who died had a substantial reduction in postoperative seizure frequency. The standardized mortality ratio for patients with recurrent seizures was 4.69, and the risk of death in these patients was 1.37 in 100 person‐years, whereas among patients who became seizure free, there was no difference in mortality rate compared with the age‐ and sex‐matched population of the United States. Elimination of seizures after surgery reduces mortality rates in people with epilepsy to a level indistinguishable from that of the general population, whereas patients with recurrent seizures continue to suffer from high mortality rates. This suggests that uncontrolled seizures are a major risk factor for excess mortality in epilepsy. Achieving complete seizure control with epilepsy surgery in refractory patients reduces the risk of death, so the long‐term risk of continuing medical treatment appears to be higher than the risk of epilepsy surgery in suitable candidates. Ann Neurol 1999;46:45–50

Psychiatric aspects of temporal lobe epilepsy before and after anterior temporal lobectomy

OBJECTIVES Psychopathology has been reported to be prevalent both before and after surgical treatment for medically intractable temporal lobe epilepsy. Individual patients were evaluated prospectively to assess the effect of anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) on prevalence and severity of psychiatric disease. METHODS Psychiatric status was assessed in a consecutive series of epilepsy patients before and 6 months after ATL using a structured psychiatric interview, psychiatric rating scales, and self report mood measures. RESULTS A DSM-III-R axis I diagnosis was present in 65% of patients before and after surgery. The most common diagnoses were depression, anxiety, and organic mood/personality disorders. There was a trend for major psychiatric diagnoses to be more common in patients with right compared to left temporal lobe seizure focus, both before and after surgery. The apparent stability in the overall rate of psychiatric dysfunction concealed onset of new psychiatric problems in 31% of patients in the months shortly after surgery, and resolution of psychiatric diagnoses in 15% of patients. In the group as a whole, the severity of psychiatric symptoms was lower at 6 months postsurgery than before temporal lobectomy. CONCLUSIONS The overall prevalence of psychiatric dysfunction was comparably high before and after ATL, but individual changes in psychiatric status and changes in severity of symptoms occurred in many patients in the 6 months after surgery.

Predictors of outcome after anterior temporal lobectomy Positron emission tomography

We assessed the relationship between temporal lobe metabolism measured quantitatively and qualitatively with PET using [18F]-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) and postoperative seizure frequency after anterior temporal lobectomy. Forty-three patients with refractory partial epilepsy had anterior temporal lobectomy and preoperative assessment with PET-FDG. Qualitative PET analysis was performed visually by two blinded observers, and quantitative PET analysis was performed using an anatomic template for six control and six temporal lobe subregions, deriving an asymmetry index for each region. Seizure outcome was assessed 1 year after surgery; patients were classified as being seizure-free or as having persistent seizures. Qualitative data were analyzed using Fishers exact test and the t test, and quantitative data were analyzed using a repeated-measures ANOVA. Thirty-two patients (74%) were seizure-free at follow-up, and 11 had persistent seizures, although most improved. Twenty-nine of 35 patients (83%) with restricted temporal lobe hypometabolism by visual analysis were seizure-free, compared with three of eight patients (37.5%) with normal scans or multilobar hypometabolism. Quantitative analysis revealed that an asymmetry of mesial temporal lobe glucose consumption (uncal region) correlated with improved surgical outcome (p < 0.02). We developed a logistic regression model to predict individual outcome based on the asymmetry in uncal metabolism. Lateral temporal metabolism did not correlate with outcome. We conclude that both visual PET analysis and quantitative PET analysis predict outcome after temporal lobectomy, although quantitative measures offer more precise information.

The syndrome of frontal lobe epilepsy Characteristics and surgical management

Article abstract-We reviewed the historical features, preoperative diagnostic evaluation, operative procedure, and surgical outcome in 16 patients with refractory frontal lobe epilepsy. Clinical expression of the epilepsy varied widely, particularly with respect to seizure characteristics, although high monthly seizure frequency and absence of a risk factor for epilepsy before age 5 occurred more often than is reported in temporal lobe epilepsy patients. Seizures often caused early bilateral movements, were brief, and lacked oroalimentary automatisms and a prolonged postictal state. Both the interictal and ictal scalp EEGs had relatively poor sensitivity and specificity and often either contained no epileptiform abnormalities or were misleading. MRI usually identified structural lesions when these were present, although it was negative in two patients with tumors. In the absence of an MRI lesion, intracranial EEG usually identified the area to be resected, although it too provided misleading information in one case. Surgical procedures consisted of focal resections with or without anterior corpus callosotomy, or of corpus callosotomy alone. Nearly all patients improved after surgery, with a majority (67%) becoming seizure-free (average follow-up, 46 months). Preoperative seizure frequency correlated with seizure relief after surgery, as did age of seizure onset, whereas presence of tumor did not. We conclude that frontal lobe epilepsy warrants aggressive investigation and that surgical treatment often can be successful. NEUROLOGY 1995;45: 780-787

Comparison of depth and subdural electrodes in recording temporal lobe seizures

Intracranial EEG recording is often required to identify an area of the brain for resective surgery for intractable epilepsy. We simultaneously compared bilaterally placed depth and limited subdural electrode EEG to determine the most effective method of recording seizures from the temporal lobes. Localized complex partial seizures usually appeared earlier in hippocampal depth electrodes and spread later to subdural recording sites. In 3 patients, hippocampal recordings showed localized seizure origin but subdural recording was nonlocalizing due to rapid bilateral seizure propagation. In 1 patient with nonlocalized seizures presumably of extratemporal origin, subdural electrodes incorrectly lateralized seizure origin to a temporal lobe. Auras and subclinical seizures detected by depth electrode recording were often not evident with subdural electrodes. We conclude that EEG recording with hippocampal depth electrodes correctly identifies and lateralizes temporal lobe seizures more often than with limited subdural electrodes.

Association between variation in the human KCNJ10 potassium ion channel gene and seizure susceptibility.

PURPOSE Our research program uses genetic linkage and association analysis to identify human seizure sensitivity and resistance alleles. Quantitative trait loci mapping in mice led to identification of genetic variation in the potassium ion channel gene Kcnj10, implicating it as a putative seizure susceptibility gene. The purpose of this work was to translate these animal model data to a human genetic association study. METHODS We used single stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) electrophoresis, DNA sequencing and database searching (NCBI) to identify variation in the human KCNJ10 gene. Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis, SSCP and Pyrosequencing were used to genotype a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP, dbSNP rs#1130183) in KCNJ10 in epilepsy patients (n = 407) and unrelated controls (n = 284). The epilepsy group was comprised of patients with refractory mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (n = 153), childhood absence (n = 84), juvenile myoclonic (n = 111) and idiopathic generalized epilepsy not otherwise specified (IGE-NOS, n = 59) and all were of European ancestry. RESULTS SNP rs#1130183 (C > T) alters amino acid 271 (of 379) from an arginine to a cysteine (R271C). The C allele (Arg) is common with conversion to the T allele (Cys) occurring twice as often in controls compared to epilepsy patients. Contingency analysis documented a statistically significant association between seizure resistance and allele frequency, Mantel-Haenszel chi square = 5.65, d.f. = 1, P = 0.017, odds ratio 0.52, 95% CI 0.33-0.82. CONCLUSION The T allele of SNP rs#1130183 is associated with seizure resistance when common forms of focal and generalized epilepsy are analyzed as a group. These data suggest that this missense variation in KCNJ10 (or a nearby variation) is related to general seizure susceptibility in humans.

A noninvasive protocol for anterior temporal lobectomy

We report the results of a protocol for choosing candidates for temporal lobectomy using a standard battery of objective tests without intracranial electrodes. We assigned each test a level of importance, and an algorithm was used to determine whether temporal lobectomy could be performed. Fifty-one patients (total pool, 103 patients) met protocol requirements and had an anterior temporal lobectomy with a mean follow-up of 39.4 months (range, 21 to 64 months), most remaining on anticonvulsant therapy. Eighty percent are seizure free, 12% have <3 seizures per year or only nocturnal seizures, and 8% have >80% reduction in seizure frequency. One-third of patients who failed protocol criteria did not have temporal lobe seizures when studied with intracranial electrodes. We analyzed and modified the algorithm after comparing these patients with others who were poor candidates for temporal lobectomy. We conclude that this protocol is effective and recommend using such an objective algorithm.

Multiple subpial transection for intractable partial epilepsy: an international meta-analysis.

Summary:  Purpose: Because the number and variety of patients at any single facility is not sufficient for clinical or statistical analysis, data from six major epilepsy centers that performed multiple subpial transections (MSTs) for medically intractable epilepsy were collected.

Language Before and After Temporal Lobectomy: Specificity of Acute Changes and Relation to Early Risk Factors

Summary: We evaluated language functions in 154 patients with left hemisphere speech dominance undergoing anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL). Measures of phonemic and semantic fluency, confrontation naming, repetition, comprehension, and reading were administered before and 3 weeks postoperatively. Patients were grouped by focus (left, LT; right, RT) and presence of early risk factors for development of seizures (ER, early risk, 5 years; NER, no early risk): (LT‐ER, n = 45; RT‐ER, n = 49; LT‐NER, n = 27; RT‐NER, n = 33). Preoperatively, the LT group showed a selective naming deficit as compared with the RT group. Postoperatively only the LTNER group showed significant overall decline in language. For this group, the change was attributable to a selective decline in naming as compared with other functions. These data indicate that there is a specific risk to naming after dominant ATL for adult temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients with a left hemisphere focus and the absence of an early risk factor for the development of seizures.

Predictors of outcome after anterior temporal lobectomy The intracarotid amobarbital test

The intracarotid amobarbital test (IAT) examines hemispheric memory and language. We set out to determine whether memory performance on the IAT correlated with seizure relief after anterior temporal lobectomy in 117 patients with refractory epilepsy. The IAT assessed recognition memory performance for nine items with correction for false-positive recognitions. We then compared performance of one hemisphere with that of the other, defining a correctly lateralized memory deficit as worse performance when using the hemisphere containing the operated temporal lobe than when using the other hemisphere. The analysis included concurrent factors that might also affect outcome, such as age at first risk for epilepsy, presence or absence of tumor, and Full Scale IQ. A discriminant function analysis demonstrated that patients with a correctly lateralized memory deficit on the IAT had an increased probability of being seizure-free following surgery after controlling for other predictors. The performance of the nonoperated temporal lobe related to outcome, although less strongly. The magnitude of the difference in performance between the two hemispheres and the performance of the operated hemisphere did not relate to outcome. Patients who became seizure-free had an earlier age at first risk than did those with persistent seizures, and tumor presence weakly correlated with postoperative outcome. IQ did not correlate with outcome. We conclude that the IAT predicts seizure relief after anterior temporal lobectomy independent of other known risk factors we examined.