Michael R. Price

Summary Report on the ISOBM TD-4 Workshop: Analysis of 56 Monoclonal Antibodies against the MUC1 Mucin

Sixteen research groups participated in the ISOBM TD-4 Workshop in which the reactivity and specificity of 56 monoclonal antibodies against the MUC1 mucin was investigated using a diverse panel of target antigens and MUC1 mucin- related synthetic peptides and glycopeptides. The majority of antibodies (34/56) defined epitopes located within the 20-amino acid tandem repeat sequence of the MUC1 mucin protein core. Of the remaining 22 antibodies, there was evidence for the involvement of carbohydrate residues in the epitopes for 16 antibodies. There was no obvious relationship between the type of immunogen and the specificity of each antibody. Synthetic peptides and glycopeptides were analyzed for their reactivity with each antibody either by assay of direct binding (e.g. by ELISA or BiaCore) or by determining the capacity of synthetic ligands to inhibit antibody binding interactions. There was good concordance between the research groups in identifying antibodies reactive with peptide epitopes within the MUC1 protein core. Epitope mapping tests were performed using the Pepscan analysis for antibody reactivity against overlapping synthetic peptides, and results were largely consistent between research groups. The dominant feature of epitopes within the MUC1 protein core was the presence, in full or part, of the hydrophilic sequence of PDTRPAP. Carbohydrate epitopes were less easily characterized and the most useful reagents in this respect were defined oligosaccharides, rather than purified mucin preparations enriched in particular carbohydrate moieties. It was evident that carbohydrate residues were involved in many epitopes, by regulating epitope accessibility or masking determinants, or by stabilizing preferred conformations of peptide epitopes within the MUC1 protein core. Overall, the studies highlight concordance between groups rather than exposing inconsistencies which gives added confidence to the results of analyses of the specificity of anti-mucin monoclonal antibodies.

Reactivity of natural and induced human antibodies to MUC1 mucin with MUC1 peptides and n‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) peptides

Antibodies (Abs) to MUC1 occur naturally in both healthy subjects and cancer patients and can be induced by MUC1 peptide vaccination. We compared the specificity of natural and induced MUC1 Abs with the objective of defining an effective MUC1 vaccine for active immunotherapy of adenocarcinoma patients. Serum samples, selected out of a screened population of 492 subjects for their high levels of IgG and/or IgM MUC1 Abs, were obtained from 55 control subjects and from 26 breast cancer patients before primary treatment, as well as from 19 breast cancer patients immunized with MUC1 peptides coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and mixed with QS‐21. The samples were tested with enzyme‐linked immunoassays for reactivity with (1) overlapping hepta‐ and 20‐mer peptides spanning the MUC1 tandem repeat sequence; (2) two modified 60‐mer peptides with substitutions in the PDTR (PDTA) or in the STAPPA (STAAAA) sequence of each tandem repeat; and (3) four 60‐mer glycopeptides with each 1, 2, 3 and 5 mol N‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) per repeat. More than one minimal epitopic sequence could be defined, indicating that Abs directed to more than one region of the MUC1 peptide core can coexist in one and the same subject. The most frequent minimal epitopic sequence of natural MUC1 IgG and IgM Abs was RPAPGS, followed by PPAHGVT and PDTRP. MUC1 peptide vaccination induced high titers of IgM and IgG Abs predominantly directed, respectively, to the PDTRPAP and the STAPPAHGV sequences of the tandem repeat. Natural MUC1 Abs from breast cancer patients reacted more strongly with the N‐acetylgalactosamine (GalNAc) peptides than with the naked 60‐mer peptide, while reactivity with the GalNAc‐peptides was significantly reduced (2‐tailed p < 0.0001) in the MUC1 IgG and IgM Abs induced by MUC1 peptide vaccination. Whereas in cancer patients glycans appear to participate in epitope conformation, the epitope(s) recognized by MUC1 Abs induced by peptide vaccination are already masked by minimal glycosylation. Therefore, our results indicate that a MUC1 glycopeptide would be a better vaccine than a naked peptide. Int. J. Cancer 86:702–712, 2000.

Immunological and structural features of the protein core of human polymorphic epithelial mucin

The protein core of high mol. wt polymorphic epithelial mucin (PEM--approximately 400 kDa glycoprotein) which is associated with breast carcinomas, consists of a repeating 20 amino acid peptide motif [Gendler et al. (1988) J. biol. Chem. 263, 12,820-12,823]. Monoclonal antibodies C595 (anti-urinary mucin) and NCRC-11 (anti-breast carcinoma cells), and other antibodies against human milk fat globule membranes, were found to recognize determinants present within this 20 amino acid peptide. A model of the peptide was developed based on hydropathicity and structure prediction calculations and these indicated that the repeated structure is dominated by a hydrophilic domain of seven amino acids, extending into two flanking beta turns. NMR analysis of the 20 amino acid peptide was undertaken to probe the secondary structure. Epitope mapping experiments involving solid phase synthesis of overlapping heptapeptides in the repeat unit identified the minimum structures for antibody binding as Arg-Pro-Ala-Pro and Arg-Pro-Ala for the C595 and NCRC-11 antibodies, respectively. These determinants were found within the predicted hydrophilic turn region domain of the peptide. The epitopes for six other PEM-reactive monoclonal antibodies were also determined to reside within the predicted hydrophilic turn domain. This evidence is in accord with the disposition of this region of the PEM peptide core being at the exterior of the glycoprotein where it would be accessible to antibody recognition and binding events.

Tumour localization of monoclonal antibody against a rat mammary carcinoma and suppression of tumour growth with adriamycin-antibody conjugates

SummaryMonoclonal antibody to the rat mammary carcinoma Sp4 isolated from hybridoma supernatants and labelled with 125I showed preferential in vivo localization into subcutaneous growths of Sp4 compared with normal tissues and a range of other transplanted tumours. No specific localization was seen with 125I-labelled normal rat immunoglobulin. Adriamycin conjugated to monoclonal antibody significantly retarded Sp4 tumour growth at 1/25th of the effective dose of the free drug, and in some cases brought about total tumour regression. Normal rat immunoglobulin-adriamycin conjugates were relatively ineffective. These studies indicate that monoclonal antibody directed against tumour cell surface antigens may be highly effective for tumour targeting of therapeutic agents.

Detection of Circulating Hepatoma D23 Antigen and Immune Complexes in Tumour Bearer Serum

Serum from rats bearing progressively growing aminoazo dye-induced rat hepatomata has been fractionated by Sephadex G150 gel filtration chromatography and isolated fractions have been examined by indirect membrane immunofluorescence techniques to detect tumour specific antigen and antibody. Hepatoma D23-specific antigenic activity was associated with material (of approximate molecular weight <150,000) isolated in the included volume of the gel at pH 7·3. The fraction excluded from the gel (of approximate molecular weight >150,000) was adjusted to pH 3·0 and further separated by Sephadex G150 gel filtration chromatography at pH 3·0 into gel included and excluded fractions. Hepatoma D23 specific antibody, demonstrable by membrane immunofluorescence staining of hepatoma D23 cells, was found to be eluted in the excluded volume and specific antigenic activity was retarded into the included volume of the gel. These results indicate that hepatoma D23 bearer serum contains free circulating tumour specific antigen in excess, together with specific immune complexes. The presence of these factors in tumour bearer serum is discussed in terms of “blocking” phenomena whereby serum factors may protect tumour cells from sensitized lymphocyte cytotoxic attack.

Tissue and Serum MUC1 Mucin Detection in Breast Cancer Patients

Tumor MUC1 expression as well as levels of MUC1, MUC1 circulating immune complexes (MUC1-CIC) and free antibodies against MUC1 (IgG and IgM-MUC1) were evaluated in 70 breast cancer patients with different stages of disease. Controls included: 135 serum samples from healthy women, normal mammary tissue samples (n=7) and benign breast disease specimens (n=6). In all assays, pre- and post-vaccination serum samples from breast cancer patients belonging to a vaccination protocol developed at the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (New York, USA) were included as controls. Serum MUC1 was measured through Cancer Associated Serum Antigen test and CA15-3 test. Employing ELISA, MUC1-CIC-IgG/M were measured with either C595 or SM3 monoclonal antibodies (MAb) as catchers and also free antibodies against MUC1 (IgG and IgM) using 100mer peptide as catcher. Employing multivariate statistical analysis, results were correlated with age, tumor type, stage of disease and grade of differentiation. By quantitative immunohistochemistry using three anti-MUC1 core protein MAbs (C595, HMFG2 and SM3), tumor MUC1 was detected in 60/70 (86%) breast cancer specimens which reacted with at least one of these MAbs. High MUC1 serum levels were detected in 14/67 (21%); IgG and IgM anti-MUC1 antibodies were found elevated in 32 and 14%, respectively, while IgG-MUC1-CIC-measured with C595 in 42% and IgM-MUC1-CIC in 54%; finally, SM3 was positive in 43 and 18%, respectively. Results of these studies demonstrate that in a group of breast cancer patients, MUC1 was detected both in tissue specimens as well as free in serum samples; furthermore, MUC1 can also circulate complexed with IgG and IgM antibodies; thus an accurate measurement should include free and complexed forms. On the other hand, immunohistochemical studies on breast cancer tissues may contribute to reveal different MUC1 glycoforms.

Immunity in the tumor‐bearing host and its modification by serum factors

Tumor‐bearing individuals initiate immune responses to tumor‐associated neoantigens. These responses are demonstrable by in vitro analyses of cell‐mediated and humoral immune reactions, although it is emphasized that in most human studies, their correlation with positive tumor rejection reactions has not as yet been fully substantiated. Detection of cell‐mediated immunity in tumor‐bearing hosts has led to the concept that its effectiveness in controlling tumor growth may be modified or impaired by antagonistic humoral factors. This proposal is discussed with regard to the role of blocking reactions operative at the level of the target tumor cell, and with respect to direct inhibition of lymphocyte cytotoxicity by interaction with humoral factors. Available evidence indicates that blocking reactions are probably mediated by tumor‐specific immune complexes, and although antibody‐mediated blocking has been detected, its relevance in abrogating cell‐mediated immunity in the tumor‐bearing host is questionable. Alternatively, inhibition of the reactivity of sensitized lymphocytes, by tumor antigen or immune complexes, may prove to be of more importance in the immunologic control of tumor growth.

Humoral immune response induced by the protein core of MUC1 mucin in pregnant and healthy women.

Serum levels of MUC1 and antibodies (Abs) against MUC1 (IgG and IgM-MUC1) were evaluated in healthy women related to pregnancy and lactation status. A total of 149 serum samples were obtained from: nulliparous, primiparous pregnant, multiparous pregnant that have lactated, multiparous pregnant without lactation, multiparous non-pregnant actual lactating, multiparous non-pregnant that have lactated and finally, multiparous non-pregnant women without lactation. In all assays, we included pre- and post-serum samples belonging to a breast cancer patient vaccinated with a MUC1 derived peptide. CASA test was employed to measure MUC1 while IgG- and IgM-MUC1 serum Abs were evaluated with an ELISA using a 100 mer peptide as catcher. In all groups, mean IgM levels were higher than IgG mean values; when samples were grouped in pregnants versus non-pregnants, a significant difference was detected with both Abs, being raised in non-pregnants. When samples were grouped in lactating versus non-lactating a significant difference was detected with IgG-MUC1, being raised in lactating women while no significant difference was found with IgM-MUC1. The evaluation of serum MUC1 levels confirmed previous results since a significant difference between pregnant versus non-pregnant groups was found while lactating versus non-lactating samples did not. Conclusions: (i) Increased MUC1 serum levels are apparently associated with pregnancy but not with lactation; (ii) MUC1 Abs are mainly associated with lactation and with non-pregnant status. These results may be considered a contribution on studies about protection against breast cancer induced by pregnancy and lactation.

Survival Defects of Cryptococcus neoformans Mutants Exposed to Human Cerebrospinal Fluid Result in Attenuated Virulence in an Experimental Model of Meningitis

ABSTRACT Cryptococcus neoformans is a fungal pathogen that encounters various microenvironments during growth in the mammalian host, including intracellular vacuoles, blood, and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Because the CSF is isolated by the blood-brain barrier, we hypothesize that CSF presents unique stresses that C. neoformans must overcome to establish an infection. We assayed 1,201 mutants for survival defects in growth media, saline, and human CSF. We assessed CSF-specific mutants for (i) mutant survival in both human bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid and fetal bovine serum (FBS), (ii) survival in macrophages, and (iii) virulence using both Caenorhabditiselegans and rabbit models of cryptococcosis. Thirteen mutants exhibited significant survival defects unique to CSF. The mutations of three of these mutants were recreated in the clinical serotype A strain H99: deletions of the genes for a cation ATPase transporter (ena1Δ), a putative NEDD8 ubiquitin-like protein (rub1Δ), and a phosphatidylinositol 4-kinase (pik1Δ). Mutant survival rates in yeast media, saline, and BAL fluid were similar to those of the wild type; however, survival in FBS was reduced but not to the levels in CSF. These mutant strains also exhibited decreased intracellular survival in macrophages, various degrees of virulence in nematodes, and severe attenuation of survival in a rabbit meningitis model. We analyzed the CSF by mass spectrometry for candidate compounds responsible for the survival defect. Our findings indicate that the genes required for C. neoformans survival in CSF ex vivo are necessary for survival and infection in this unique host environment.

Effects of glycosylation on fragments of tumour associated human epithelial mucin MUC1.

The glycodecapeptide AcPAPGS(alpha GalNAc)T(alpha GalNAc)APPA and the C-terminal glycohexapeptide AcS(alpha GalNAc)T(alpha GalNAc)APPA have been synthesized by applying the N-terminal Fmoc group in combination with the heptyl ester cleavable by lipase-catalyzed hydrolysis at pH 7. The solution conformation of these MUC1-related synthetic glycopeptides and the control, non-glycosylated decapeptide AcPAPGSTAPPA have been investigated using NMR spectroscopy. The structural studies indicate that the glycohexapeptide has a folded structure in solution. For this molecule, unrestrained molecular dynamics has been used to confirm the presence of the observed solution through-space connections. The results indicate that the non-globular nature of MUC1 is due to both protein core sequence and the effect of carbohydrate.