Michael V. Gangone

Wireless Monitoring of a Multispan Bridge Superstructure for Diagnostic Load Testing and System Identification

This article focuses on the deployment of a wireless sensor system (WSS) developed at Clarkson University for structural monitoring purposes. The WSS is designed specifically for diagnostic bridge monitoring, providing independent conditioning for accelerometers, strain transducers, and temperature sensors in addition to high-rate wireless data transmission and is capable of supporting large-scale sensor arrays. A three-span simply supported structure was subjected to diagnostic load testing as well as ambient vibration monitoring. A total of 90 wireless and several wired sensors, including accelerometers and strain transducers were used in the deployment. Strain measurements provided capacity and demand characteristics of the structure in the form of neutral axis locations, load distributions, and dynamic allowances which ultimately produced an inventory and operating load rating for the structure. Additionally, modal characteristics of the structure, including natural frequencies and mode shapes, were derived from measured accelerations and discussed briefly.

Highway Bridge Assessment Using an Adaptive Real-Time Wireless Sensor Network

A real-time wireless sensor network platform capable of maintaining lossless data transmission over several minutes of continuous, high-rate sampling is presented in this paper. The platform was designed specifically to provide the capability to enable expeditious system identification, as well as load rating of highway bridges without compromising the typical data acquisition parameters employed in comparable cable-based tests. Consequently, the hardware signal conditioning interface permits data collection from a variety of sensors typical to structural health monitoring, including accelerometers, strain transducers, and temperature sensors. The embedded software features a proprietary network transmission protocol capable of lossless, real-time delivery of up to 40 measurement channels at an effective sampling rate of 128 samples per second per channel. Documented in this paper is a field study on an end-of-service highway bridge in which ambient vibration monitoring was performed using 60 accelerometers interfaced with 30 wireless sensor nodes operating within one of two simultaneously operating star topology networks. In addition, an experimental load rating of the entire structure was performed through large-scale strain measurement facilitated by the same wireless sensor network platform.

Operational modal analysis of a multi-span skew bridge using real-time wireless sensor networks

A large-scale field deployment of high-density, real-time wireless sensors networks for the acquisition of local acceleration measurements across a medium length, multi-span highway bridge is presented. The advantages, performance characteristics, and limitations of employing this emerging technology in favor of the traditional cable-based acquisition systems are discussed in the context of the in-service instrumentation and ambient vibration testing of a multi-span bridge. Of particular highlight in this study is the deployment of a large number of stationary rather than reference-based accelerometers to uniquely permit simultaneous acquisition of vibration measurements across the structure and thereby ensure consistent temperature, ambient vibration, and traffic loading. The deployment consisted of 30 dual-axis accelerometers installed across the girders of the bridge and interfaced with 30 wireless acquisition and transceiver nodes operating in two star topology networks. Real-time wireless acquisition at a per channel sampling rate of 128 samples per second was maintained across both networks for the specified test durations of 3 min with insignificant data loss. Output-only system identification of the structure from the experimental data is presented to provide estimates of natural frequencies, damping ratios, and operational mode shapes for 19 modes. The analysis of the structure under test provides a unique case study documenting the measured response of a multiple-span skewed bridge supported by elastomeric bearings. The feasibility of embedded wireless instrumentation for structural health monitoring of large civil constructions is concluded while highlighting relevant technological shortcomings and areas of further development required. In particular, previously undocumented obstacles relating to radio transmission of the sensor data using low-power 2.4 GHz wireless instrumentation, such as the effect of solid piers within the line-of-sight and the reflection of the radio waves on the surface of the water, are discussed.

Field deployment of a dense wireless sensor network for condition assessment of a bridge superstructure

With the increased demand placed on aging infrastructure, there is great interest in new condition assessment tools for bridges. The routine deterioration that bridges undergo causes a loss in the intended performance that, if undetected or unattended, can eventually lead to structural failure. Currently the primary method of bridge condition assessment involves a qualitative bridge inspection routine based on visual observations. Discussed in this paper are methods of in-situ quantitative bridge condition assessment using a dense wireless sensor array. At the core of the wireless system is an integrated network which collects data from a variety of sensors in real-time and provides analysis, assessment and decision-making tools. The advanced wireless sensor system, developed at Clarkson University for diagnostic bridge monitoring, provides independent conditioning for both accelerometers and strain transducers with high-rate wireless data transmission in a large-scale sensor network. Results from a field deployment of a dense wireless sensor network on a bridge located in New York State are presented. The field deployment and testing aid to quantify the current bridge response as well as demonstrate the ability of the system to perform bridge monitoring and condition assessment.

Development of a wireless bridge monitoring system for condition assessment using hybrid techniques

The introduction and development of wireless sensor network technology has resulted in rapid growth within the field of structural health monitoring (SHM), as the dramatic cable costs associated with instrumentation of large civil structures is potentially alleviated. Traditionally, condition assessment of bridge structures is accomplished through the use of either vibration measurements or strain sensing. One approach is through quantifying dynamic characteristics and mode shapes developed through the use of relatively dense arrays of accelerometers. Another widely utilized method of condition assessment is bridge load rating, which is enabled through the use of strain sensors. The Wireless Sensor Solution (WSS) developed specifically for diagnostic bridge monitoring provides a hybrid system that interfaces with both accelerometers and strain sensors to facilitate vibration-based bridge evaluation as well as load rating and static analysis on a universal platform. This paper presents the development and testing of a wireless bridge monitoring system designed within the Laboratory for Intelligent Infrastructure and Transportation Technologies (LIITT) at Clarkson University. The system interfaces with low-cost MEMS accelerometers using custom signal conditioning for amplification and filtering tailored to the spectrum of typical bridge vibrations, specifically from ambient excitation. Additionally, a signal conditioning and high resolution ADC interface is provided for strain gauge sensors. To permit compensation for the influence of temperature, thermistor-based temperature sensing is also enabled. In addition to the hardware description, this paper presents features of the software applications and host interface developed for flexible, user-friendly in-network control of and acquisition from the sensor nodes. The architecture of the software radio protocol is also discussed along with results of field deployments including relatively large-scale networks and throughput rates sufficient for bridge monitoring.

Deployment of a Dense Hybrid Wireless Sensing System for Bridge Assessment

Discussed in this paper is the deployment of a dense wireless sensor system on a short span integral abutment bridge superstructure located in St. Lawrence County, New York. The Wireless Sensor Solution (WSS) is designed specifically for diagnostic bridge monitoring providing independent conditioning for accelerometers and strain transducers. During deployment, strain measurements are obtained in real-time under ambient environmental and traffic loading. Strain transducers are placed at various locations along the girders, including the top and bottom flanges of a heavily instrumented interior girder at the mid-span and the abutment ends where the neutral axis location, section modulus, and girder moments are obtained. Results from the strain data analysis aid in quantifying the bridge response; notably, detection of end fixity, load distribution, and composite action between the girders and bridge deck. The measured responses are illustrated to propose a deterioration profile based on the level of capacity and demand.

Development of performance assessment tools for a highway bridge resulting from controlled progressive monitoring

As highway bridges continue to deteriorate given the increased service life, increase in vehicle demand and exposure to harsh environmental climates, new methods of monitoring their in situ performance are of high priority. Damage within the structure can alter various load demand and capacity characteristics, affecting the overall integrity of the bridge. Discussed in this paper is the monitoring of a simple span bridge superstructure under various induced damage states. Strain measurements were recorded at the midspan and north abutment of each girder. Six levels of damage progression were implemented at a rocker bearing and various diaphragms to girder connections. Transverse load distribution factors (DFs) and neutral axis (NA) locations were measured for each damage case and evaluated against the baseline undamaged response. These measurements serve to provide a possible method of damage detection using load-testing parameters already employed by various transportation agencies. Next, a performance index (PI) is developed for this stringer/multi-girder bridge utilising the NA and DF response from the steel girder system and the allowable stress design load-rating data. The ratio of NA to DF was compared to the inventory load rating for each girder at each damaged state. The data were fitted with a power regression model to form the PI. Furthermore, a 95% prediction interval was used around the predicted response to capture all the data from the testing. The model was applied to the damaged structure as well as two additional stringer/multi-girder bridges. The objective of the PI is to complement existing qualitative assessment protocols with quantitative results for improving the condition assessment process.

Experimental characterization and diagnostics of the early‐age behavior of a semi‐integral abutment FRP deck bridge

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to further validate a wireless sensor system developed at Clarkson University for structural monitoring of highway bridges. The particular bridge monitored employs a fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) panel system which is fairly innovative in the field of civil engineering design. The superstructure was monitored on two separate occasions to determine a change in structural response and see how the structural system performs over time.Design/methodology/approach – A series of wireless sensor units was deployed at various locations of the steel superstructure, to measure both the modal response from acceleration measurements as well as quasi‐static and dynamic strain response. Ambient and forced loading conditions were applied to measure the response. Data results were compared over two separate periods approximately nine months apart.Findings – The first eight mode shapes were produced from output‐only system identification providing natural frequencies ranging from app...

Wireless vibration monitoring for damage detection of highway bridges

The development of low-cost wireless sensor networks has resulted in resurgence in the development of ambient vibration monitoring methods to assess the in-service condition of highway bridges. However, a reliable approach towards assessing the health of an in-service bridge and identifying and localizing damage without a priori knowledge of the vibration response history has yet to be formulated. A two-part study is in progress to evaluate and develop existing and proposed damage detection schemes. The first phase utilizes a laboratory bridge model to investigate the vibration response characteristics induced through introduction of changes to structural members, connections, and support conditions. A second phase of the study will validate the damage detection methods developed from the laboratory testing with progressive damage testing of an in-service highway bridge scheduled for replacement. The laboratory bridge features a four meter span, one meter wide, steel frame with a steel and cement board deck composed of sheet layers to regulate mass loading and simulate deck wear. Bolted connections and elastomeric bearings provide a means for prescribing variable local stiffness and damping effects to the laboratory model. A wireless sensor network consisting of fifty-six accelerometers accommodated by twenty-eight local nodes facilitates simultaneous, real-time and high-rate acquisition of the vibrations throughout the bridge structure. Measurement redundancy is provided by an array of wired linear displacement sensors as well as a scanning laser vibrometer. This paper presents the laboratory model and damage scenarios, a brief description of the developed wireless sensor network platform, an overview of available test and measurement instrumentation within the laboratory, and baseline measurements of dynamic response of the laboratory bridge model.

Wireless sensing system for bridge condition assessment and health monitoring

Discussed in this paper is the deployment of a universal and low-cost dense wireless sensor system for structural monitoring, load rating and condition assessment of bridges. The wireless sensor system developed is designed specifically for diagnostic bridge monitoring, providing independent conditioning for both accelerometers and strain transducers in addition to high-rate wireless data transmission. The system was field deployed on a three span simply supported bridge superstructure, where strain and acceleration measurements were obtained simultaneously and in realtime at critical locations under several loading conditions, providing reliable quantitative information as to the actual performance level of the bridge. Monitoring was also conducted as the bridge was subjected to various controlled damage scenarios on the final day of testing. Select cases of detected damage using strain and modal based analysis are presented.