Michaela Kotrova

Standardized flow cytometry for highly sensitive MRD measurements in B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia

A fully-standardized EuroFlow 8-color antibody panel and laboratory procedure was stepwise designed to measure minimal residual disease (MRD) in B-cell precursor (BCP) acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) patients with a sensitivity of ≤10-5, comparable to real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RQ-PCR)-based MRD detection via antigen-receptor rearrangements. Leukocyte markers and the corresponding antibodies and fluorochromes were selected based on their contribution in separating BCP-ALL cells from normal/regenerating BCP cells in multidimensional principal component analyses. After 5 multicenter design-test-evaluate-redesign phases with a total of 319 BCP-ALL patients at diagnosis, two 8-color antibody tubes were selected, which allowed separation between normal and malignant BCP cells in 99% of studied patients. These 2 tubes were tested with a new erythrocyte bulk-lysis protocol allowing acquisition of high cell numbers in 377 bone marrow follow-up samples of 178 BCP-ALL patients. Comparison with RQ-PCR-based MRD data showed a clear positive relation between the percentage concordant cases and the number of cells acquired. For those samples with >4 million cells acquired, concordant results were obtained in 93% of samples. Most discordances were clarified upon high-throughput sequencing of antigen-receptor rearrangements and blind multicenter reanalysis of flow cytometric data, resulting in an unprecedented concordance of 98% (97% for samples with MRD < 0.01%). In conclusion, the fully standardized EuroFlow BCP-ALL MRD strategy is applicable in >98% of patients with sensitivities at least similar to RQ-PCR (≤10-5), if sufficient cells (>4 × 106, preferably more) are evaluated.

The predictive strength of next-generation sequencing MRD detection for relapse compared with current methods in childhood ALL

To the editor:nnMinimal residual disease (MRD) monitoring via antigen receptor quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) is an important predictor of outcome in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), is rigorously standardized within the EuroMRD consortium and has a greater sensitivity

Is Next-Generation Sequencing the way to go for Residual Disease Monitoring in Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia?

Minimal residual disease (MRD) is the most important independent prognostic factor in acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Since it has been implemented into in treatment stratification strategies, cure rates have improved significantly for all age groups. Real time quantitative (RQ)-PCR of clonal immunoglobulin and T-cell receptor gene rearrangements using allele-specific primers is currently regarded as the gold standard for MRD analysis in ALL, as it is not only highly sensitive and specific but also provides accurate MRD quantification. Following recent advances in next-generation sequencing (NGS), much attention has been devoted to the development of NGS-based MRD assays. This new technique can enhance sensitivity provided that sufficient numbers of cells are analyzed. Recent reports have shown that NGS-MRD also tends to be more specific for relapse prediction than RQ-PCR. In addition, NGS provides information on the physiological B- and T-cell repertoire during and after treatment, which has been shown to be prognostically relevant. However, before implementation of NGS-MRD detection in clinical practice, several issues must be addressed and the whole workflow needs to be standardized, including not only the analytical phase (spike-in calibrators, quality controls) but also the pre-analytical (e.g. sample preparation) and the post-analytical phases (e.g. bioinformatics pipeline, guidelines for correct data interpretation). These topics are currently addressed by a European network, the EuroClonality-NGS Consortium. In conclusion, NGS is a promising tool for MRD detection with the potential to overcome most of the limitations of RQ-PCR and to become the new gold standard for MRD detection in ALL.

Next-generation sequencing indicates false-positive MRD results and better predicts prognosis after SCT in patients with childhood ALL

Minimal residual disease (MRD) monitoring via quantitative PCR (qPCR) detection of Ag receptor gene rearrangements has been the most sensitive method for predicting prognosis and making post-transplant treatment decisions for patients with ALL. Despite the broad clinical usefulness and standardization of this method, we and others have repeatedly reported the possibility of false-positive MRD results caused by massive B-lymphocyte regeneration after stem cell transplantation (SCT). Next-generation sequencing (NGS) enables precise and sensitive detection of multiple Ag receptor rearrangements, thus providing a more specific readout compared to qPCR. We investigated two cohorts of children with ALL who underwent SCT (30 patients and 228 samples). The first cohort consisted of 17 patients who remained in long-term CR after SCT despite having low MRD positivity (<0.01%) at least once during post-SCT monitoring using qPCR. Only one of 27 qPCR-positive samples was confirmed to be positive by NGS. Conversely, 10 of 15 samples with low qPCR-detected MRD positivity from 13 patients who subsequently relapsed were also confirmed to be positive by NGS (P=0.002). These data show that NGS has a better specificity in post-SCT ALL management and indicate that treatment interventions aimed at reverting impending relapse should not be based on qPCR only.

The TREC/KREC assay for the diagnosis and monitoring of patients with DiGeorge syndrome.

DiGeorge syndrome (DGS) presents with a wide spectrum of thymic pathologies. Nationwide neonatal screening programs of lymphocyte production using T-cell recombination excision circles (TREC) have repeatedly identified patients with DGS. We tested what proportion of DGS patients could be identified at birth by combined TREC and kappa-deleting element recombination circle (KREC) screening. Furthermore, we followed TREC/KREC levels in peripheral blood (PB) to monitor postnatal changes in lymphocyte production. Methods TREC/KREC copies were assessed by quantitative PCR (qPCR) and were related to the albumin control gene in dry blood spots (DBSs) from control (nu200a=u200a56), severe immunodeficiency syndrome (SCID, nu200a=u200a10) and DGS (nu200a=u200a13) newborns. PB was evaluated in DGS children (nu200a=u200a32), in diagnostic samples from SCID babies (nu200a=u200a5) and in 91 controls. Results All but one DGS patient had TREC levels in the normal range at birth, albeit quantitative TREC values were significantly lower in the DGS cohort. One patient had slightly reduced KREC at birth. Postnatal DGS samples revealed reduced TREC numbers in 5 of 32 (16%) patients, whereas KREC copy numbers were similar to controls. Both TREC and KREC levels showed a more pronounced decrease with age in DGS patients than in controls (p<0.0001 for both in a linear model). DGS patients had higher percentages of NK cells at the expense of T cells (p<0.0001). The patients with reduced TREC levels had repeated infections in infancy and developed allergy and/or autoimmunity, but they were not strikingly different from other patients. In 12 DGS patients with paired DBS and blood samples, the TREC/KREC levels were mostly stable or increased and showed similar kinetics in respective patients. Conclusions The combined TREC/KREC approach with correction via control gene identified 1 of 13 (8%) of DiGeorge syndrome patients at birth in our cohort. The majority of patients had TREC/KREC levels in the normal range.

ETV6/RUNX1‐like acute lymphoblastic leukemia: A novel B‐cell precursor leukemia subtype associated with the CD27/CD44 immunophenotype

We have shown previously that ETV6/RUNX1‐positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) is distinguishable from other ALL subtypes by CD27pos/CD44low‐neg immunophenotype. During diagnostic immunophenotyping of 573 childhood B‐cell precursor ALL (BCP‐ALL), we identified eight cases with this immunophenotype among “B‐other ALL” (BCP‐ALL cases negative for routinely tested chromosomal/genetic aberrations). We aimed to elucidate whether these cases belong to the recently described ETV6/RUNX1‐like ALL defined by the ETV6/RUNX1‐specific gene expression profile (GEP), harboring concurrent ETV6 and IKZF1 lesions. We performed comprehensive genomic analysis using single nucleotide polymorphism arrays, whole exome and transcriptome sequencing and GEP on microarrays. In unsupervised hierarchical clustering based on GEP, five out of seven analyzed CD27pos/CD44low‐neg B‐other cases clustered with ETV6/RUNX1‐positive ALL and were thus classified as ETV6/RUNX1‐like ALL. The two cases clustering outside ETV6/RUNX1‐positive ALL harbored a P2RY8/CRLF2 fusion with activating JAK2 mutations and a TCF3/ZNF384 fusion, respectively, assigning them to other ALL subtypes. All five ETV6/RUNX1‐like cases harbored ETV6 deletions; uniform intragenic ARPP21 deletions and various IKZF1 lesions were each found in three ETV6/RUNX1‐like cases. The frequency of ETV6 and ARPP21 deletions was significantly higher in ETV6/RUNX1‐like ALL compared with a reference cohort of 42 B‐other ALL. In conclusion, we show that ETV6/RUNX1‐like ALL is associated with CD27pos/CD44low‐neg immunophenotype and identify ARPP21 deletions to contribute to its specific genomic profile enriched for ETV6 and IKZF1 lesions. In conjunction with previously published data, our study identifies the ETV6 lesion as the only common genetic aberration and thus the most likely key driver of ETV6/RUNX1‐like ALL.

Minimal residual disease in adult ALL: technical aspects and implications for correct clinical interpretation

Nowadays, minimal residual disease (MRD) is accepted as the strongest independent prognostic factor in acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). It can be detected by molecular methods that use leukemia-specific or patient-specific molecular markers (fusion gene transcripts, or immunoglobulin/T-cell receptor [IG/TR] gene rearrangements), and by multi-parametric flow cytometry. The sensitivity and specificity of these methods can vary across treatment time points and therapeutic settings. Thus, knowledge of the principles and limitations of each technology is of the utmost importance for correct interpretation of MRD results. Time will tell whether new molecular and flow cytometric high-throughput technologies can overcome the limitations of current standard methods and eventually bring additional benefits. MRD during standard ALL chemotherapy is the strongest overall prognostic indicator and has therefore been used for refining initial treatment stratification. Moreover, MRD positivity after the maintenance phase of treatment may point to an impending relapse and thus enable salvage treatment to be initiated earlier, which could possibly improve treatment results. The prognostic relevance of pretransplantation MRD was shown by several studies, and MRD high-risk patients were shown to benefit from stem cell transplantation (SCT). Also, MRD positivity after SCT correlates with worse outcomes. In addition, MRD information is very instructive in current clinical trials that test novel agents to evaluate their treatment efficacy. Although conventional clinical risk factors lose their independent prognostic significance when combined with MRD information, recently identified genetic markers may further improve the treatment stratification in ALL.

Association of 17q24.2-q24.3 deletions with recognizable phenotype and short telomeres

Microdeletions of 17q24.2‐q24.3 have been described in several patients with developmental and speech delay, growth retardation, and other features. The relatively large size and limited overlap of the deletions complicate the genotype‐phenotype correlation. We identified a girl with intellectual disability, growth retardation, dysmorphic features, and a de novo 2.8 Mb long deletion of 17q24.2‐q24.3. Her phenotype was strikingly similar to one previously described boy with Dubowitz syndrome (MIM 223370) and a de novo 3.9 Mb long deletion encompassing the deletion of our patient. In addition, both patients had the shortest telomeres among normal age‐matched controls. Our review of all 17q24.2‐q24.3 deletion patients revealed additional remarkable phenotypic features shared by the patients, some of which have consequences for their management. Proposed novel genotype‐phenotype correlations based on new literature information on the region include the role of PSMD12 and BPTF, the genes recently associated with syndromic neurodevelopmental disorders, and a possible role of the complex topologically associated domain structure of the region, which may explain some of the phenotypic discrepancies observed between patients with similar but not identical deletions. Nevertheless, although different diagnoses including the Dubowitz, Nijmegen breakage (MIM 251260), Silver‐Russell (MIM 180860), or Myhre (MIM 139210) syndromes were originally considered in the 17q24.2‐q24.3 deletion patients, they clearly belong to one diagnostic entity defined by their deletions and characterized especially by developmental delay, specific facial dysmorphism, abnormalities of extremities and other phenotypes, and possibly also short telomere length.