Michel Raynal

Radical radiation therapy of breast cancer

Abstract The 5 year results of radical radiation therapy in operable, infiltrating breast cancer (T1, T2, T3; NO, N1a, N1b) in 177 patients are presented. The treatment protocol included a pre-radiotherapy tumorectomy for T1 and certain T2 tumors (those less than 3cm diameter). Patients with larger tumors were treated by radiotherapy alone. The treatment technique incorporated both conventional fractionated radiotherapy (60 Co and electrons) and endocurietherapy (192 Ir). At 5 years, the uncorrected, disease-free survival rates were 84 % for T1, 79% for T2 and 56% for T3: loco-regional persistent or recurrent disease was seen in 4.5 % of patients with Tl disease, 7.5 % of those with T2, and 23 % of T3 patients; 16 mastectomies had been performed. Of the patients with T1 and T2 disease, 95 % had retained their breast and the esthetic result was judged to be good in 75 %. We recommend this technique of radical radiotherapy in early breast cancer because of this high rate of tumor control, associated with a low rate of normal tissue damage and survival figures comparable to those achieved by radical surgery.

Salvage irradiation of oropharyngeal cancers using iridium 192 wire implants: 5-Year results of 70 cases

Between May 1971 and November 1980, 70 patients with recurrent or new oropharyngeal cancers arising in previously irradiated tissues were treated using iridium 192 afterloading techniques. The actuarial local control was 72% at 2 years and 69% at 5 years. Although local control of the tumor was achieved in the majority of these patients, only 10 patients remained alive at 5 years (14%). Patients with lesions of the faucial arch and posterior pharyngeal wall had the best results; local control was achieved in 100% of these patients. Patients with lesions of the base of tongue and of the glosso-tonsillar sulcus had poorer results; local control was achieved in 61%. Because these results compare favorably with the results of previously published series, we recommend re-irradiation with brachytherapy for recurrent or new malignancies arising in a previously irradiated oropharynx. When the lesion is located in the faucial arch, brachytherapy is the treatment of choice. When the lesion is located in the base of tongue, brachytherapy is a reasonable option.

Combined external irradiation and interstitial implantation for T1 and T2 epidermoid carcinomas of base of tongue: The creteil experience (1971–1981)

Forty-eight patients with T1 or T2 epidermoid carcinomas of the base of tongue were treated at the Henri Mondor Hospital between 1971 and 1981. Forty-one patients received moderate dose 60Co external beam irradiation (mean: 48.6 Gy) to the primary tumor and regional nodes, followed by an interstitial iridium 192 implant to the primary tumor (mean: 32 Gy). This completed the treatment for the 30 node negative patients, but those with clinically positive nodes were managed by either an additional electron beam boost to the involved nodes or a neck dissection. Seven tumors were treated exclusively by implantation to the base of tongue (mean: 63 Gy). Five-year crude disease-free survival is 50% with 35% of patients dying of recurrent disease. Definitive local control for T1 lesions is 85% (11/13) and for T2 is 71% (25/35). A dose response effect was observed with local control of 79% (26/33) obtained with a combined dose greater than or equal to 75 Gy, but only 50% (4/8) for less than or equal to 70 Gy. For N0 patients definitive regional control is 97% and for N1-3 is 89%. Minor or moderate soft tissue ulceration was observed in 12 patients, including 3 cases that progressed to osteonecrosis. None required surgical intervention. No correlation exists between necrosis and tumor size or total dose.

Iridium 192 implantation of T1 and T2 carcinomas of the mobile tongue

Between 1970 and 1986, 166 patients with T1 or T2 epidermoid carcinomas of the mobile tongue were treated by iridium 192 implantation (70 T1N0, 83 T2N0, 13 T1-2 N1-3). Five-year actuarial survival was 52% for T1N0, 44% for T2aN0, and 8% for or T1-2 N1-3. Cause specific survivals were 90%, 71%, and 46%, respectively. Local control was 87% for both T1N0 and T2N0, and 69% for T1-2 N1-3. Seven of 23 failures were salvaged by surgery, increasing local control to 96% for T1 and 90% for T2. Thirty-six patients developed a minor or moderate necrosis (16% T1, 28% T2). Half of these involved bone but only five required surgical intervention. Both local control (LC) and necrosis (nec) increased with increasing dose but improvement beyond 65 Gy is minimal (less than or equal to 60 Gy: LC = 78% nec = 13%; 65 Gy: LC = 90% nec = 29%; greater than or equal to 70 Gy: LC = 94% nec = 23%). For N0 patients, neck management consisted of surveillance (n = 78), elective neck dissection followed with external irradiation for pathologically positive nodes (n = 72), or irradiation (n = 3). Clinically positive nodes (13 patients) were managed by either neck dissection followed by external irradiation if pathologically positive (n = 10) or irradiation alone (n = 3). Regional control was 79% for N0 patients, improving to 88% after surgical salvage, and was 9/13 for N1-3 patients. We recommend that T1 and T2 carcinomas of the mobile tongue be treated by iridium 192 implantation to deliver 65 Gy. Mandibular necrosis should be reduced by using an intra-oral lead-lined dental mold.

Comparison of curietherapy versus external irradiation combined with curietherapy in Stage II squamous cell carcinomas of the mobile tongue

One hundred and ten patients with Stage II epidermoid carcinomas of the mobile tongue were treated by interstitial irradiation (Group I: 85 patients) or external irradiation to the primary and the regional lymphatics followed by an interstitial boost (Group II: 25 patients). The neck was managed by either an elective neck dissection (43 patients) completed by external irradiation in 13 patients with pathological specimen or close follow-up (40 patients) with therapeutic neck dissection for relapses (7 patients) in Group I. Primary local control was 88% in Group I and 36% in Group II. Regional control was 91% in Group I and 5/6 in Group II for patients whose primary tumor was controlled. Five-year absolute disease-free survival (DFS) was 42% in Group I and 24% in Group II, but there was an imbalance in the distribution of larger tumors favoring Group I. There were 30 radiation-induced complications and four patients required corrective surgery. This retrospective analysis showed better results in patients whose primary was treated by interstitial irradiation alone which has the extra advantage of preserving salivary function.

Interstitial radiation therapy for carcinoma of the penis using iridium 192 wires: the Henri Mondor experience (1970-1979)

From 1970 to 1979, a group of 50 patients was treated for squamous cell carcinoma of the penis by interstitial irradiation using an afterloading technique and iridium 192 wires. The group included 9 patients with T1 tumors, 27 with T2 tumors, and 14 with T3 tumors. Forty-five patients presented with no metastatic inguinal nodes (N0), 3 patients with N1 nodes, and 2 patients had N3 nodes. After treatment, 11 patients (1 T1, 6 T2 and 4T3) developed local recurrences; 10 of these 11 patients underwent penile amputation which controlled the tumor in 7 of the patients. One patient refused amputation. Three patients developed post-therapeutic necrosis which necessitated partial amputation in 2 cases. Eight patients developed post-therapeutic urethral stenosis, which required surgical treatment in three of the cases. Overall, at their last follow-up examinations, 74% of the patients were free of disease with conservation of penile morphology and function. Most patients without metastatic nodes (37/45) at diagnosis did not receive prophylatic treatment of the groin. Two of these patients developed delayed metastatic nodes; one was successfully salvaged. All 5 patients presenting with metastatic nodes at diagnosis died, four with uncontrolled regional disease. Twenty-one percent of the patients died of their disease. We advocate interstitial irradiation using iridium 192 wires for the treatment of non-infiltrating or moderately infiltrating squamous cell carcinoma of the penis in which the largest dimension does not exceed 4 cm. Pre-implant circumcision and regular long-term follow-up are necessary. More extensive tumors are better managed surgically. When regular follow-up can be assured, it is reasonable to forgo prophylactic treatment of the inguinal nodes in patients presenting without groin metastasis.

Iridium-192 curietherapy for T1 and T2 epidermoid carcinomas of the floor of mouth

From 1970 to 1986, 117 patients with T1 (47) or T2 (70) epidermoid carcinomas of the floor of the mouth (SCC) were treated by iridium-192 implantation (192 Ir). The dose was prescribed according to the Paris System and varied over those years. Follow-up information was available on 116 patients. There were 46 T1N0, 47 T2N0, and 23 T2N1-3. Neck management varied for the 93 N0 patients consisting of surveillance (24 T1, 17 T2) or elective neck dissection (22 T1:all pN-, 30 T2: 20 pN-, 10 pN+). Cause specific survival rates were 94% for T1N0, 61.5% for T2N0, and 28% for T2N1-3 at 5 years. Primary local control was 93.5%, 74.5%, and 65%, respectively, and 98%, 79%, and 65% after salvage. Patients with gingival extension or a tumor size over 3 cm (T2b) had a local control of 50% (9/18) and 58% (15/26), respectively. Nodal control was 93.5% for Stage I, 85% for Stage II, and 48% for T2N1-3 patients. There was no difference in nodal control with regard to treatment policy for Stage I-II patients. There were few complications including three deaths: two from surgery and one from 192 Ir. Nodal status, tumor size defined as T1, T2a (less than or equal to 3 cm), T2b (greater than 3 cm), and gingival extension were the only independent prognostic factors. The management of T1N0 and T2N0 SCC by 192 Ir to a dose of 65 or 70 Gy, using the Paris System, is recommended for lesions 3 cm or less and without gingival extension.

Stage I-II squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity treated by iridium- 192: is elective neck dissection indicated ?

This is a retrospective analysis of 233 evaluable patients with stage I-II squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity treated by definitive branchytherapy. Minimum follow-up is 3 years. Treatment of neck was chosen by a multidisciplinary team, according to age, medical status and availability for regular follow-up. One hundred and ten patients (47%) underwent elective neck dissection (END); 28 (25%) had positive nodes and received neck irradiation post-operatively. One hundred and twenty three patients (53%) were regularly followed up only, with therapeutic neck dissection (TND) reserved for cases of node relapses. In the END group, there were 19 neck relapses (17%): 12/60 (20%) in patients with mobile tongue carcinoma and 7/50 (14%) in patients with floor of the mouth carcinoma. Salvage treatment was successful in 9/19 (47%) cases. In the TND group, there were 21 neck relapses (17%): 16/82 (20%) in patients with mobile tongue carcinoma and 5/41 (10%) in patients with floor of the mouth carcinoma. Salvage treatment was successful in 13/21 (62%) cases. Ten-year survival is 37% for the END group and 31% for the TND group. Tumour stage and infiltration into underlying tissues increased the probability of neck relapse and death. Furthermore, a multivariate analysis showed that patients treated in the TND group had a higher probability of death than patients treated in the END group (p less than 0.04).

Definitive radiation treatment for early stage carcinoma of the soft palate and uvula: the indications for iridium 192 implantation.

From 1971 to 1984 59 T1 and T2 carcinomas of the soft palate and uvula were treated definitively by irradiation at the Henri Mondor hospital. Included are ten patients previously irradiated to the oropharyngeal area for either a carcinoma of the soft palate or another malignancy. Sixteen patients were treated by external irradiation alone, 14 by Iridium 192 implantation, and 29 by a combination of the two. Two techniques of implantation were used: the guide gutter technique (33 patients) and the plastic tube technique (10 patients). Clinically negative neck nodes (51/59) either received prophylactic telecobalt therapy (39/51) or were surveilled (12/51). Clinically involved nodes (8/59) were managed either by external irradiation alone (4/8) or combined with neck dissection (4/8). Local failure was 25% (4/16) after exclusive telecobalt therapy, 18% (5/19) after combined telecobalt therapy and implantation, and 0% (0/14) after Iridium 192 implantation alone. No local failures were seen with the plastic tube technique (0/10) as compared to 15% (5/33) for guide gutters. Only two nodal failures were observed (2/59: 3%). Crude 5-year disease-free survival was 33%. Severe complications were limited to one osteonecrosis, one soft tissue necrosis, and one partial palatal incompetence. Salivary impairment was reduced when implantation was used for part or all of the treatment. We recommend 45 Gy external radiation followed by 30 Gy from Iridium 192 implantation using the plastic tube method unless there has been prior oropharyngeal irradiation, in which case we give 60 Gy from implantation alone. For clinically negative neck nodes, we recommend 45 Gy prophylactic external neck irradiation. For clinically positive lymph nodes, this should be followed by either a 25 to 30 Gy boost to the involved nodes or a neck dissection.

Interstitial radiation therapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the tonsillar region: The creteil experience (1971–1981)

From July 1971 to December 1981, 33 selected patients with T1, T2 tumors of the tonsillar region were treated according to the following protocol: 1. Telecobalt therapy to the primary site and to neck nodes to a dose of 45 Gy. 2. Brachytherapy to the primary site to a dose of 30 Gy using iridium 192. 3. Boost dose to involved neck nodes with electrons, or radical neck dissection, whether N1, N2, or N3. The actuarial disease-free survival was 76% when all patient groups were included and 80% for the N0 patients. The local control rate was 100%. Disease control in the neck was 94% overall and 100% for the N0 group. These results favor the use of this protocol for superficial, minimally infiltrating tumors less than 4 cm in diameter, without obvious extension to the base of the tongue or retromolar trigone.