Michele Colajanni

Dynamic load balancing on Web-server systems

Popular Web sites cannot rely on a single powerful server nor on independent mirrored-servers to support the ever-increasing request load. Distributed Web server architectures that transparently schedule client requests offer a way to meet dynamic scalability and availability requirements. The authors review the state of the art in load balancing techniques on distributed Web-server systems, and analyze the efficiencies and limitations of the various approaches.

The state of the art in locally distributed Web-server systems

The overall increase in traffic on the World Wide Web is augmenting user-perceived response times from popular Web sites, especially in conjunction with special events. System platforms that do not replicate information content cannot provide the needed scalability to handle large traffic volumes and to match rapid and dramatic changes in the number of clients. The need to improve the performance of Web-based services has produced a variety of novel content delivery architectures. This article will focus on Web system architectures that consist of multiple server nodes distributed on a local area, with one or more mechanisms to spread client requests among the nodes. After years of continual proposals of new system solutions, routing mechanisms, and policies (the first dated back to 1994 when the NCSA Web site had to face the first million of requests per day), many problems concerning multiple server architectures for Web sites have been solved. Other issues remain to be addressed, especially at the network application layer, but the main techniques and methodologies for building scalable Web content delivery architectures placed in a single location are settled now. This article classifies and describes main mechanisms to split the traffic load among the server nodes, discussing both the alternative architectures and the load sharing policies. To this purpose, it focuses on architectures, internal routing mechanisms, and dispatching request algorithms for designing and implementing scalable Web-server systems under the control of one content provider. It identifies also some of the open research issues associated with the use of distributed systems for highly accessed Web sites.

Analysis of task assignment policies in scalable distributed web-server systems

A distributed multiserver Web site can provide the scalability necessary to keep up with growing client demand at popular sites. Load balancing of these distributed Web-server systems, consisting of multiple, homogeneous Web servers for document retrieval and a Domain Name Server (DNS) for address resolution, opens interesting new problems. In this paper, we investigate the effects of using a more active DNS which, as an atypical centralized scheduler, applies some scheduling strategy in routing the requests to the most suitable Web server. Unlike traditional parallel/distributed systems in which a centralized scheduler has full control of the system, the DNS controls only a very small fraction of the requests reaching the multiserver Web site. This peculiarity, especially in the presence of highly skewed load, makes it very difficult to achieve acceptable load balancing and avoid overloading some Web servers. This paper adapts traditional scheduling algorithms to the DNS, proposes new policies, and examines their impact under different scenarios. Extensive simulation results show the advantage of strategies that make scheduling decisions on the basis of the domain that originates the client requests and limited server state information (e.g., whether a server is overloaded or not). An initially unexpected result is that using detailed server information, especially based on history, does not seem useful in predicting the future load and can often lead to degraded performance.

Dynamic load balancing in geographically distributed heterogeneous Web servers

With ever increasing Web traffic, a distributed multi server Web site can provide scalability and flexibility to cope with growing client demands. Load balancing algorithms to spread the requests across multiple Web servers are crucial to achieve the scalability. Various domain name server (DNS) based schedulers have been proposed in the literature, mainly for multiple homogeneous servers. The presence of heterogeneous Web servers not only increases the complexity of the DNS scheduling problem, but also makes previously proposed algorithms for homogeneous distributed systems not directly applicable. This leads us to propose new policies, cabled adaptive TTL algorithms, that take into account both the uneven distribution of client request rates and heterogeneity of Web servers to adaptively set the time-to-live (TTL) value for each address mapping request. Extensive simulation results show that these strategies are robust and effective in balancing load among geographically distributed heterogeneous Web servers.

Geographic load balancing for scalable distributed Web systems

Users of highly popular Web sites may experience long delays when accessing information. Upgrading content site infrastructure from a single node to a locally distributed Web cluster composed by multiple server nodes provides limited relief, because the cluster wide-area connectivity may become the bottleneck. A better solution is to distribute Web clusters over the Internet by placing content nodes in strategic locations. A geographically distributed architecture where the Domain Name System (DNS) servers evaluate network proximity and users are served from the closest cluster reduces network impact on response time. On the other hand, serving closest requests only may cause unbalanced servers and may increase system impact on response time. To achieve a scalable Web system, we propose to integrate DNS proximity scheduling with an HTTP request redirection mechanism that any Web server can activate. We demonstrate through simulation experiments that this further dispatching mechanism augments the percentage of requests with guaranteed response time, thereby enhancing the Quality of Service of geographically distributed Web sites. However, HTTP request redirection should be used selectively because the additional round-trip increases network impact on latency time experienced by users. As a further contribution, this paper proposes and compares various mechanisms to limit reassignments with no negative consequences on load balancing.

Request redirection algorithms for distributed Web systems

Replication of information among multiple servers is necessary to support high request rates to popular Web sites. We consider systems that maintain one interface to users, even it they consist of multiple nodes with visible IP addresses that are distributed among different networks. In these systems, first-level dispatching is achieved through the Domain Name System (DNS) during the address lookup phase. Distributed Web systems can use a request redirection mechanism as second-level dispatching because the DNS routing scheme has limited control on offered load. Redirection is always executed by the servers, but there are many alternatives that are worth investigating. We explore the combination of DNS dispatching with redirection schemes that use centralized or distributed control on the basis of global or local state information. In fully distributed schemes, DNS dispatching is carried out by simple algorithms because load sharing is taken by some redirection mechanisms that each server activates autonomously. On the other hand, in fully centralized schemes, redirection is used as a tool to enforce decisions taken by the same centralized entity that provides the first-level dispatching. We also investigate hybrid strategies. We conclude that distributed algorithms are preferable over their centralized counterpart because they provide stable performance, take content-aware dispatching decisions, limit the percentage of redirected requests, and their implementation is much simpler than that required by centralized schemes.

A client-aware dispatching algorithm for web clusters providing multiple services

The typical Web cluster architecture consists of replicated back-end and Web servers, and a network Web switch that routes client requests among the nodes. In this paper, we propose a new scheduling policy, namely client-aware policy (CAP), for Web switches operating at layer-7 of the OSI protocol stack. Its goal is to improve load sharing in Web clusters that provide multiple services such as static, dynamic and secure information. CAP classi es the client requests on the basis of their expected impact on main server resources, that is, network interface, CPU, disk. At run-time, CAP schedules client requests reaching the Web cluster with the goal of sharing all classes of services among the server nodes. We demonstrate through a large set of simulations and some prototype experiments that dispatching policies aiming to improve locality in server caches give best results for Web publishing sites providing static information and some simple database searches. When we consider Web sites providing also dynamic and secure services, CAP is more e ective than state-of-the-art layer-7 Web switch policies. The proposed client-aware algorithm is also more robust than server-aware policies whose performance depends on optimal tuning of system parameters, very hard to achieve in a highly dynamic system such as a Web site.

Redirection algorithms for load sharing in distributed Web-server systems

Replication of information among multiple World Wide Web servers is necessary to support high request rates to popular Web sites. A clustered Web server organization is preferable to multiple independent mirrored servers because it maintains a single interface to the users and has the potential to be more scalable, fault-tolerant and better load-balanced. In this paper, we propose a Web cluster architecture in which the Domain Name System (DNS) server, which dispatches the user requests among the servers through the URL name to the IP address mapping mechanism, is integrated with a redirection request mechanism based on HTTP. This should alleviate the side-effect of caching the IP address mapping at intermediate name servers. We compare many alternative mechanisms, including synchronous vs. asynchronous activation and centralized vs. distributed decisions on redirection. Moreover, we analyze the reassignment of entire domains or individual client requests, different types of status information and different server selection policies for redirecting requests. Our results show that the combination of centralized and distributed dispatching policies allows the Web server cluster to handle high load skews in the WWW environment.

Dynamic Load Management of Virtual Machines in Cloud Architectures

Cloud infrastructures must accommodate changing demands for different types of processing with heterogeneous workloads and time constraints. In a similar context, dynamic management of virtualized application environments is becoming very important to exploit computing resources, especially with recent virtualization capabilities that allow live sessions to be moved transparently between servers. This paper proposes novel management algorithms to decide about reallocations of virtual machines in a cloud context characterized by large numbers of hosts. The novel algorithms identify just the real critical instances and take decisions without recurring to typical thresholds. Moreover, they consider load trend behavior of the resources instead of instantaneous or average measures. Experimental results show that proposed algorithms are truly selective and robust even in variable contexts, thus reducing system instability and limit migrations when really necessary.

Scheduling algorithms for distributed Web servers

A distributed Web system, consisting of multiple servers for data retrieval and a Domain Name Server (DNS) for address resolution, can provide the scalability necessary to keep up with growing client demand at popular sites. However, balancing the requests among these atypical distributed servers opens interesting new challenges. Unlike traditional distributed systems in which a centralized scheduler has full control of the system, the DNS controls only a small fraction of the requests reaching the Web site. This makes it very difficult to avoid overloading situations among the multiple Web servers. We adapt traditional scheduling algorithms to the DNS, propose new policies, and examine their impact. Extensive simulation results show the advantage of using strategies that schedule requests on the basis of the origin of the clients and very limited state information, such as whether a server is overloaded or not. Conversely, algorithms that use detailed state information often exhibit the worst performance.