Michele R. Chierotti

Solvent effect in a “solvent free” reaction

Vapour digestion of a mixture of solid [Fe(η5-C5H4–C5H4N)2] and solid pimelic acid HOOC(CH2)5COOH in the presence of solvent vapours generates co-crystals of different stoichiometry depending on the protic or aprotic nature of the solvent. The nature of the products has been ascertained by a combined use of SSNMR and X-ray diffraction.

Solid-state NMR studies of weak interactions in supramolecular systems

The field of application of solid-state NMR to the study of supramolecular systems is growing rapidly, with many research groups involved in the development of techniques for the study of crystalline and amorphous phases. This Feature Article aims to provide an overview of the recent contributions of our research group to this field, paying particular attention to the study of the weak interactions such as hydrogen bonds in supramolecular systems through solid-state NMR investigations. The structure and dynamic behaviour of selected host-guest systems will be also discussed.

Halogen Bonding and Pharmaceutical Cocrystals: The Case of a Widely Used Preservative

3-Iodo-2-propynyl-N-butylcarbamate (IPBC) is an iodinated antimicrobial product used globally as a preservative, fungicide, and algaecide. IPBC is difficult to obtain in pure form as well as to handle in industrial products because it tends to be sticky and clumpy. Here, we describe the preparation of four pharmaceutical cocrystals involving IPBC. The obtained cocrystals have been characterized by X-ray diffraction, solution and solid-state NMR, IR, and DSC analyses. In all the described cases the halogen bond (XB) is the key interaction responsible for the self-assembly of the pharmaceutical cocrystals thanks to the involvement of the 1-iodoalkyne moiety of IPBC, which functions as a very reliable XB-donor, with both neutral and anionic XB-acceptors. Most of the obtained cocrystals have improved properties with respect to the source API, in terms, e.g., of thermal stability. The cocrystal involving the GRAS excipient CaCl2 has superior powder flow characteristics compared to the pure IPBC, representing a promising solution to the handling issues related to the manufacturing of products containing IPBC.

The Thermodynamically Stable Form of Solid Barbituric Acid: The Enol Tautomer

Barbituric acid, which has been known since 1863, is drawn in textbooks always as the keto tautomeric form 1 (Scheme 1). Indeed, this is the most stable form in the gas phase and in solution. Also in the solid state, the keto tautomer is observed in the metastable phase I, the commercial phase II, and a high-temperature phase III, as well as in its dihydrates. In contrast, we now observe that the recently discovered tautomeric polymorph IV consists of molecules in the enol form 2, and that this polymorph is actually the thermodynamically stable phase at ambient conditions. The preference for the enol form in the solid state is explained by the formation of an additional strong hydrogen bond in the crystal, leading to a more favorable lattice energy. Polymorph IV is obtained from phase II by grinding or milling. Solid-state NMR (SSNMR), IR, and Raman experiments revealed this to be a tautomeric polymorph, which does not consist of the keto tautomer 1, but of one of the enol forms. The spectroscopic data suggested the trienol tautomer, but other enol tautomers could not be ruled out. All attempts to obtain single crystals of phase IV by recrystallization failed, and dehydration of the dihydrate yielded only phase II. The grinding or milling processes resulted in powders of poor crystallinity. However, it was possible to index the laboratory X-ray powder data and to solve the crystal structure by simulated annealing, while refinement was carried out by the Rietveld method from synchrotron data (Figure 1). The bond lengths in the OCN framework revealed phase IV to consist of molecules in the enol form 2. Scheme 1. Barbituric acid in the keto (1) and enol (2) tautomeric forms.

Making crystals from crystals: three solvent-free routes to the hydrogen bonded co-crystal between 1,1′-di-pyridyl-ferrocene and anthranilic acid

The organometallic complex [Fe(η5-C5H4–C5H4N)2] has been reacted with the anthranilic acid (C6H4)NH2COOH to generate the hydrogen bonded supramolecular macrocycle {[Fe(η5-C5H4–C5H4N)2] [(C6H4)NH2COOH]}2. The product has been fully characterized by means of X-ray powder diffraction, 13C and 15N solid-state NMR and single crystal X-ray diffraction. It has been shown that the same product can be obtained, quantitatively, by three different processes, namely kneading, i.e. solid-state mixing in the presence of a catalytic amount of MeOH, wet compression, i.e. pressure without mixing in the presence of MeOH, and vapour digestion, i.e. a mixture of the solid reactants is left in an atmosphere of MeOH vapours. The product can also be obtained via thermally induced reaction of a mixture of the two solid reactants, while no reaction is observed by dry mixing and dry compression. These experiments provide new insights into the factors controlling the process suggesting that the reaction requires the intermediacy of a catalytic amount of solvent or melting of one reactant to take place.

Didanosine Polymorphism in a Supercritical Antisolvent Process

Solid-state properties of active ingredients are crucial in pharmaceutical development owing to their significant clinical and economical implications. In the present work we investigated the solid-state properties and the solubility in water of didanosine, DDI, re-crystallized from a dimethylsulfoxide solution using supercritical CO(2) as an antisolvent (SAS process) for comparison with the commercially available drug product. We also applied modern solid-state NMR (SS NMR) techniques, namely 2D (1)H DQ CRAMPS (Combined Rotation And Multiple Pulse Spectroscopy) and (1)H-(13)C on- and off-resonance CP (cross polarization) FSLG-HETCOR experiments, known for providing reliable information about (1)H-(1)H and (1)H-(13)C intra- and intermolecular proximities, in order to address polymorphism issues arising from the crystallization of a new form in the supercritical process. A new polymorph of didanosine was obtained from the supercritical antisolvent process and characterized by means of 1D and 2D multinuclear ((1)H, (13)C, (15)N) SS NMR. The particle size of the new crystal phase was reduced by varying the antisolvent density through a pressure increase. The structural differences between the commercial product and the SAS re-crystallized DDI are highlighted by X-ray diffractometry and well described by solid-state NMR. The carbon C6 (13)C chemical shift suggests that both commercial and re-crystallized didanosine samples are in the enol form. The analysis of homo- and heteronuclear proximities obtained by means of 2D NMR experiments shows that commercial and SAS re-crystallized DDI possess very similar molecular conformation and hydrogen bond network, but different packing. The new polymorph proved to be a metastable form at ambient conditions, showing higher solubility in water and lower stability to mechanical stress.

Remarkable reversal of melting point alternation by co-crystallization

The pronounced melting point alternation of α,ω-alkanedicarboxylic acids (HOOC–(CH2)n−2–COOH, n = 4–10) is maintained in co-crystals of the same acids with 1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethane (BPA), which contains an even number of carbon atoms in the chain, and is reversed in co-crystals with 1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)propane (BPP), which contains an odd number of carbon atoms in the aliphatic chain.

NMR crystallography: the use of dipolar interactions in polymorph and co-crystal investigation

The use of dipolar interaction in solid-state NMR spectroscopy represents a powerful tool to access information on chemical structure at molecular level on solid compounds and materials. The study of polymorphs and co-crystals is one of the more active research fields where the possibilities offered by the new emerging NMR crystallography reveal their potential. The aim of this article is to offer the state-of-the-art on this subject in order to develop new insights and to promote cooperative efforts in the fascinating field of polymorphs and co-crystals.

Biosurfactants from Urban Green Waste

From waste came forth surfactants: Humic acid like substances isolated from 0-60 day-old compost display excellent surface activity and solvent properties. These biosurfactants were used to solubilize a dye in water below and above their critical micellar concentration. The biosurfactant unimers appear to have higher dye-solubilizing power than the corresponding micelles.Humic acid like substances isolated from compost show potential as chemical auxiliaries. In the present study, three surfactant samples were obtained from green waste composted for 0-60 days to assess aging effects of the source on the properties of the products. The surface activity, dye solubility enhancement, and chemical nature of these substances were compared. No differences in performance were established among the samples. They lower water surface tension and enhance the dye solubility upon increasing their concentration. However, the ratio of soluble dye to added surfactant is higher in the premicellar than in the postmicellar concentration region. Structural investigations indicated the humic acid like substances to be amphiphiles with molecular weights in the range of 1-3 x 10(5) g mol(-1). The surfactant samples were also compared to sodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate, polyacrylic acid, and soil and water humic substances. The results encourage the application of compost as a source of low-cost biosurfactant.

Hetero‐Seeding and Solid Mixture to Obtain New Crystalline Forms

Para-methyl benzyl alcohol (p-MeBA II) and para-chloro benzyl alcohol (p-ClBA) are quasi-isostructural and share the same hydrogen-bond patterns, but their crystals are not isomorphous. No new polymorphs could be obtained by conventional polymorph screening based on different solvents and different crystallization conditions. Formation of a new polymorph of p-MeBA named p-MeBA I, isomorphous with the crystal of p-ClBA, was induced by hetero-seeding with a small quantity of powdered p-ClBA added to a supersaturated solution of p-MeBA in hexane, while seeding of p-ClBA with p-MeBA II failed to give a new phase of p-ClBA isomorphous with known crystalline p-MeBA II. Mixed crystals of p-MeBA and p-ClBA were also prepared with different p-MeBA/p-ClBA ratios to understand the role of the different functional groups in the crystal structure. Crystal phases were characterized by combined use of single-crystal and powder X-ray diffraction, differential scanning calorimetry, and solid-state NMR spectroscopy.