Mickael L. Perrin

Large tunable image-charge effects in single-molecule junctions

Metal/organic interfaces critically determine the characteristics of molecular electronic devices, because they influence the arrangement of the orbital levels that participate in charge transport. Studies on self-assembled monolayers show molecule-dependent energy-level shifts as well as transport-gap renormalization, two effects that suggest that electric-field polarization in the metal substrate induced by the formation of image charges plays a key role in the alignment of the molecular energy levels with respect to the metals Fermi energy. Here, we provide direct experimental evidence for an electrode-induced gap renormalization in single-molecule junctions. We study charge transport through single porphyrin-type molecules using electrically gateable break junctions. In this set-up, the position of the occupied and unoccupied molecular energy levels can be followed in situ under simultaneous mechanical control. When increasing the electrode separation by just a few ångströms, we observe a substantial increase in the transport gap and level shifts as high as several hundreds of meV. Analysis of this large and tunable gap renormalization based on atomic charges obtained from density functional theory confirms and clarifies the dominant role of image-charge effects in single-molecule junctions.

Large negative differential conductance in single-molecule break junctions

Molecular electronics aims at exploiting the internal structure and electronic orbitals of molecules to construct functional building blocks. To date, however, the overwhelming majority of experimentally realized single-molecule junctions can be described as single quantum dots, where transport is mainly determined by the alignment of the molecular orbital levels with respect to the Fermi energies of the electrodes and the electronic coupling with those electrodes. Particularly appealing exceptions include molecules in which two moieties are twisted with respect to each other and molecules in which quantum interference effects are possible. Here, we report the experimental observation of pronounced negative differential conductance in the current-voltage characteristics of a single molecule in break junctions. The molecule of interest consists of two conjugated arms, connected by a non-conjugated segment, resulting in two coupled sites. A voltage applied across the molecule pulls the energy of the sites apart, suppressing resonant transport through the molecule and causing the current to decrease. A generic theoretical model based on a two-site molecular orbital structure captures the experimental findings well, as confirmed by density functional theory with non-equilibrium Greens functions calculations that include the effect of the bias. Our results point towards a conductance mechanism mediated by the intrinsic molecular orbitals alignment of the molecule.

Influence of the Chemical Structure on the Stability and Conductance of Porphyrin Single‐Molecule Junctions

The use of porphyrin molecules as building blocks of functional molecular devices has been widely investigated. The structural flexibility and well-developed synthetic chemistry of porphyrins allows their physical and chemical properties to be tailored by choosing from a wide library of macrocycle substituents and central metal atoms. Nature itself offers magnificent examples of processes that utilize porphyrin derivatives, such as the activation and the transport of molecular oxygen in mammals and the harvesting of sunlight in plant photosynthetic systems. In order to exploit the highly desirable functionality of porphyrins in artificial molecular devices, it is imperative to understand and control the interactions that occur at the molecule–substrate interface. Such interactions largely depend on the electronic and conformational structures of the adsorbed molecules, which can be studied using techniques such as scanning tunneling microscopy, UV photoemission spectroscopy, and X-ray photoemission spectroscopy, and on a theoretical level with density functional calculations. Recent studies on conjugated rod-like molecules have shown that molecular conductance measurements can be significantly affected by the binding geometry, coupling of the p orbitals to the leads, or p–p stacking between adjacent molecules. Herein, we present the results of a study of the interaction of laterally extended p-conjugated porphyrin molecules with electrodes by means of timeand stretching-dependent conductance measurements on molecular junctions. We further investigate strategies to reduce interactions of the molecular p electrons with the metal electrodes by modifying the chemical structure of the porphyrin molecules. We used the series of molecules represented in Figure 1a– c to examine the influence of the molecular structure on the formation of porphyrin single-molecule junctions. Since the thiol group is most commonly used to contact rod-like molecules to form straight molecular bridges, we first compared 5,10,15,20-tetraphenylporphyrin without thiol termination (H2-TPP; Figure 1a) to a nearly identical molecule with two thiol groups on opposite sides of the molecule (5,15di(p-thiophenyl)-10,20-di(p-tolyl)porphyrin (H2-TPPdT); Figure 1b). To investigate the influence of the molecular backbone geometry on the junction formation we further studied a thiol-terminated porphyrin molecule with two bulky pyridine axial groups attached through an octahedral Ru ion ([Ru{5,15-di(p-thiophenyl)-10,20-diphenylporphyrin}(py)2] (Ru-TPPdT); Figure 1c). As a consequence of steric hindrance, the pyridine groups in Ru-TPPdT reduce the direct interaction of the metal electrodes with the p face of the porphyrin. A similar strategy was used previously. Prior to electrical characterization, the molecules were deposited using self-assembly from solution. To study the conductance of these molecules we used lithographic mechanically controllable break junctions (MCBJs) in vacuum at room temperature. The layout of an MCBJ device in a threepoint bending mechanism is shown in Figure 1d. Details concerning the synthesis of the molecules and the experimental procedures are given in the Supporting Information. Sets of 1000 consecutive breaking traces from individual junctions were analyzed numerically to construct “trace histograms” of the conductance (log10G versus the electrode displacement d). This statistical method maps the breaking dynamics of the junctions beyond the point of rupture of the last monatomic gold contact (defined as d= 0), which has a conductance of one quantum unit G0= 2e h. Areas of high counts represent the most typical breaking behavior of the molecular junctions. Figure 2 presents trace histograms as well as examples of individual breaking traces for acetone as reference, H2-TPP, H2-TPPdT, and Ru-TPPdT. For all three porphyrin molecules as well as for the reference sample several junctions were measured (see the Supporting Information). Herein, we only show a typical set of junctions. In the junction which was exposed to pure acetone (Figure 2a), the Au bridge initially gets stretched until a plateau around the conductance quantum (G G0) is observed (only visible in the individual traces shown in [*] M. L. Perrin, F. Prins, Dr. C. A. Martin, Prof. Dr. H. S. J. van der Zant, Dr. D. Dulic Kavli Institute of Nanoscience, Delft University of Technology Lorentzweg 1, 2628 CJ Delft (The Netherlands) E-mail: d.dulic@tudelft.nl

Electrical properties and mechanical stability of anchoring groups for single-molecule electronics

Summary We report on an experimental investigation of transport through single molecules, trapped between two gold nano-electrodes fabricated with the mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique. The four molecules studied share the same core structure, namely oligo(phenylene ethynylene) (OPE3), while having different aurophilic anchoring groups: thiol (SAc), methyl sulfide (SMe), pyridyl (Py) and amine (NH2). The focus of this paper is on the combined characterization of the electrical and mechanical properties determined by the anchoring groups. From conductance histograms we find that thiol anchored molecules provide the highest conductance; a single-level model fit to current–voltage characteristics suggests that SAc groups exhibit a higher electronic coupling to the electrodes, together with better level alignment than the other three groups. An analysis of the mechanical stability, recording the lifetime in a self-breaking method, shows that Py and SAc yield the most stable junctions while SMe form short-lived junctions. Density functional theory combined with non-equlibrium Green’s function calculations help in elucidating the experimental findings.

Charge transport in a zinc–porphyrin single-molecule junction

Summary We have investigated charge transport in ZnTPPdT–Pyr (TPPdT: 5,15-di(p-thiolphenyl)-10,20-di(p-tolyl)porphyrin) molecular junctions using the lithographic mechanically controllable break-junction (MCBJ) technique at room temperature and cryogenic temperature (6 K). We combined low-bias statistical measurements with spectroscopy of the molecular levels in the form of I(V) characteristics. This combination allows us to characterize the transport in a molecular junction in detail. This complex molecule can form different junction configurations, having an observable effect on the trace histograms and the current–voltage (I(V)) measurements. Both methods show that multiple, stable single-molecule junction configurations can be obtained by modulating the interelectrode distance. In addition we demonstrate that different ZnTPPdT–Pyr junction configurations can lead to completely different spectroscopic features with the same conductance values. We show that statistical low-bias conductance measurements should be interpreted with care, and that the combination with I(V) spectroscopy represents an essential tool for a more detailed characterization of the charge transport in a single molecule.

Multiscale Approach to the Study of the Electronic Properties of Two Thiophene Curcuminoid Molecules.

We studied the electronic and conductance properties of two thiophene-curcuminoid molecules, 2-thphCCM (1) and 3-thphCCM (2), in which the only structural difference is the position of the sulfur atoms in the thiophene terminal groups. We used electrochemical techniques as well as UV/Vis absorption studies to obtain the values of the HOMO-LUMO band gap energies, showing that molecule 1 has lower values than 2. Theoretical calculations show the same trend. Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of these molecules were studied by using electrochemistry, showing that the interaction with gold reduces drastically the HOMO-LUMO gap in both molecules to almost the same value. Single-molecule conductance measurements show that molecule 2 has two different conductance values, whereas molecule 1 exhibits only one. Based on theoretical calculations, we conclude that the lowest conductance value, similar in both molecules, corresponds to a van der Waals interaction between the thiophene ring and the electrodes. The one order of magnitude higher conductance value for molecule 2 corresponds to a coordinate (dative covalent) interaction between the sulfur atoms and the gold electrodes.

C–Au Covalently Bonded Molecular Junctions Using Nonprotected Alkynyl Anchoring Groups

We report on an approach to realize carbon-gold (C-Au) bonded molecular junctions without the need for an additive to deprotect the alkynyl carbon as endstanding anchor group. Using the mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique, we determine the most probable conductance value of a family of alkynyl terminated oligophenylenes (OPA(n)) connected to gold electrodes through such an akynyl moiety in ambient conditions. The molecules bind to the gold leads through an sp-hybridized carbon atom at each side. Comparing our results with other families of molecules that present organometallic C-Au bonds, we conclude that the conductance of molecules contacted via an sp-hybridized carbon atom is lower than the ones using sp(3) hybridization due to strong differences in the coupling of the conducting orbitals with the gold leads.

Conductance Switching in Expanded Porphyrins through Aromaticity and Topology Changes

Expanded porphyrins are flexible enough to switch between different π-conjugation topologies, namely Möbius, Hückel and twisted-Hückel, each with distinct electronic properties and aromaticity. Since these switches can be induced by different external stimuli, expanded porphyrins represent a promising platform to develop a novel type of molecular switch for molecular electronic devices. In this work, the feasibility of conductance switches based on topology and/or aromaticity changes in expanded porphyrins is assessed for the first time. In particular, the electron transport properties of penta-, hexa- and heptaphyrins with different π-conjugation topologies and aromaticity were carefully investigated using the nonequilibrium Greens function formalism in combination with density functional theory for various configurations of the gold contacts. Our results highlight the importance of the macrocyclic aromaticity and connectivity and, to a lesser extent, the molecular topology, in determining the transmission functions and local currents. When the electrodes are connected along the longitudinal axis of the macrocycle, we found that aromaticity of Hückel expanded porphyrins increases single-molecule junction conductance, contrary to the negative relationship between conductance and aromaticity found in single five-membered rings. For this particular connectivity, antiaromatic Hückel structures with [4n] π-electrons exhibit a sharp reduction in transmission near the Fermi level due to destructive quantum interference between the HOMO and LUMO. Belt-shaped Möbius aromatic structures exhibit a lower conductance as compared to the Hückel aromatic structures, and the current flow avoids the molecular twist. Importantly, we show that expanded porphyrins, upon redox and topology interconversions, could act as efficient three-level molecular switches with high ON/OFF ratio, up to 103 at low bias voltage.

Probing the local environment of a single OPE3 molecule using inelastic tunneling electron spectroscopy

Summary We study single-molecule oligo(phenylene ethynylene)dithiol junctions by means of inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS). The molecule is contacted with gold nano-electrodes formed with the mechanically controllable break junction technique. We record the IETS spectrum of the molecule from direct current measurements, both as a function of time and electrode separation. We find that for fixed electrode separation the molecule switches between various configurations, which are characterized by different IETS spectra. Similar variations in the IETS signal are observed during atomic rearrangements upon stretching of the molecular junction. Using quantum chemistry calculations, we identity some of the vibrational modes which constitute a chemical fingerprint of the molecule. In addition, changes can be attributed to rearrangements of the local molecular environment, in particular at the molecule–electrode interface. This study shows the importance of taking into account the interaction with the electrodes when describing inelastic contributions to transport through single-molecule junctions.

Current-induced nanogap formation and graphitization in boron-doped diamond films

A high-current annealing technique is used to fabricate nanogaps and hybrid diamond/graphite structures in boron-doped nanocrystalline diamond films. Nanometer-sized gaps down to ∼1 nm are produced using a feedback-controlled current annealing procedure. The nanogaps are characterized using scanning electron microscopy and electronic transport measurements. The structural changes produced by the elevated temperature, achieved by Joule heating during current annealing, are characterized using Raman spectroscopy. The formation of hybridized diamond/graphite structure is observed at the point of maximum heat accumulation.