Mieko Kodaira

No Evidence of Radiation Effect on Mutation Rates at Hypervariable Minisatellite Loci in the Germ Cells of Atomic Bomb Survivors

Abstract Kodaira, M., Izumi, S., Takahashi, N. and Nakamura, N. No Evidence of Radiation Effect on Mutation Rates at Hypervariable Minisatellite Loci in the Germ Cells of Atomic Bomb Survivors. Radiat. Res. 162, 350–356 (2004). Human minisatellites consist of tandem arrays of short repeat sequences, and some are highly polymorphic in numbers of repeats among individuals. Since these loci mutate much more frequently than coding sequences, they make attractive markers for screening populations for genetic effects of mutagenic agents. Here we report the results of our analysis of mutations at eight hypervariable minisatellite loci in the offspring (61 from exposed families in 60 of which only one parent was exposed, and 58 from unexposed parents) of atomic bomb survivors with mean doses of >1 Sv. We found 44 mutations in paternal alleles and eight mutations in maternal alleles with no indication that the high doses of acutely applied radiation had caused significant genetic effects. Our finding contrasts with those of some other studies in which much lower radiation doses, applied chronically, caused significantly increased mutation rates. Possible reasons for this discrepancy are discussed.

An improved method for the detection of genetic variations in DNA with denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis.

We have examined the feasibility of denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) of RNA:DNA duplexes to detect variations in genomic and cloned DNAs. The result has demonstrated that employment of RNA:DNA duplexes makes DGGE much more practical for screening a large number of samples than that of DNA:DNA heteroduplexes originally developed by Lerman et al. (1986), because preparation of RNA probes is easier than that of DNA probes. Three different 32P-labeled RNA probes were produced. Genomic or cloned DNAs were digested with restriction enzymes and hybridized to labeled RNA probes, and resulting RNA:DNA duplexes were examined by DGGE. The presence of mismatch(es) was detected as a difference in mobility of bands on the gel. The experimental conditions were determined using DNA segments from cloned normal and 3 thalassemic human beta-globin genes. The results of the experiments on the cloned DNAs suggest that DGGE of RNA:DNA duplexes will detect nucleotide substitutions and deletions in DNA. In the course of these studies, a polymorphism due to a single-base substitution at position 666 of IVS2 (IVS2-666) of the human beta-globin gene was directly identified using genomic DNA samples. A study of 59 unrelated Japanese from Hiroshima was made in which the frequency of the allele with C at IVS2-666 was 0.48 and that of the allele with T was 0.52. This approach was found to be very effective for the detection of heritable variation and should be a powerful tool for the detection of fresh mutations in DNA, which occur outside the known restriction sites.

A genome scanning approach to assess the genetic effects of radiation in mice and humans

Abstract Asakawa, J., Kuick, R., Kodaira, M., Nakamura, N., Katayama, H., Pierce, D., Funamoto, S., Preston, D., Satoh, C., Neel, J. V. and Hanash, S. A Genome Scanning Approach to Assess the Genetic Effects of Radiation in Mice and Humans. Radiat. Res. 161, 380–390 (2004). We used Restriction Landmark Genome Scanning (RLGS) to assess, on a genome-wide basis, the mutation induction rate in mouse germ cells after radiation exposure. Analyses of 1,115 autosomal NotI DNA fragments per mouse for reduced spot intensity, indicative of loss of one copy, in 506 progeny derived from X-irradiated spermatogonia (190, 237 and 79 mice in 0-, 3-, and 5-Gy groups, respectively), permitted us to identify 16 mutations affecting 23 fragments in 20 mice. The 16 mutations were composed of eight small changes (1–9 bp) at microsatellite sequences, five large deletions (more than 25 kb), and three insertions of SINE B2 or LINE1 transposable elements. The maximum induction rate of deletion mutations was estimated as (0.17 ± 0.09) × 10−5/locus Gy–1. The estimate is considerably lower than 1 × 10−5/locus Gy–1, the mean induction rate of deletion mutations at Russells 7 loci, which assumed that deletion mutations comprise 50% of all mutations. We interpret the results as indicating that the mean induction rate of mutations in the whole genome may be substantially lower than that at the 7 loci. We also demonstrate the applicability of RLGS for detection of human mutations, which allows direct comparisons between the two species.

The Genetic Risk in Mice from Radiation: An Estimate of the Mutation Induction Rate per Genome

Restriction Landmark Genome Scanning (RLGS) is a method that uses end-labeled 32P NotI sites that are mostly associated with coding genes to visualizes thousands of DNA fragments as spots in two-dimensional autoradiograms. This approach allows direct detection of autosomal deletions as spots with half normal intensity. The method was applied to mouse offspring derived from spermatogonia exposed to 4 Gy of X rays. A genome-wide assessment of the mutation induction rate was estimated from the detected deletions. Examinations were made of 1,007 progeny (502 derived from control males and 505 from irradiated males) and 1,190 paternal and 1,240 maternal spots for each mouse. The results showed one deletion mutation in the unirradiated paternal genomes of 502 offspring (0.2%) and 5 deletions in the irradiated paternal genomes of 505 offspring (1%). The difference was marginally significant, with the deletion sizes ranged from 2–13 Mb. If the frequencies are taken at face value, the net increase was 0.8% after an exposure of 4 Gy, or 0.2% per Gy per individual if a linear dose response is assumed. Since the present RLGS analysis examined 1,190 NotI sites, while the mouse genome contains ∼25,000 genes, the genomic probability of any gene undergoing a deletion mutation would be 25× 0.2%, or 5% per Gy. Furthermore, since the present RLGS screened about 0.2% of the total genome, the probability of detecting a deletion anywhere in the total genome would be estimated to be 500 times 0.2% or 100% (i.e., 1 deletion per Gy). These results are discussed with reference to copy number variation in the human genome.

Detection of deletions, insertions and single nucleotide substitutions in cloned β-globin genes and new polymorphic nucleotide substitutions in β-globin genes in a Japanese population using ribonuclease cleavage at mismatches in RNA: DNA duplexes

The applicability of ribonuclease cleavage at mismatches in RNA:DNA duplexes (RNase cleavage method) for determining nucleotide variant rates has been examined in a Japanese population. DNA segments of various lengths obtained from 4 different regions of a normal and 3 thalassemic cloned human beta-globin genes were inserted into transcription vectors. Sense and antisense RNA probes uniformly labeled with 32P were prepared. When RNA probes of 771 nucleotides (nt) or less were hybridized with cloned DNAs and the resulting duplexes were treated with a mixture of RNases A and T1, the length of products agreed with theoretical values. Twelve possible mismatches were examined. Since both sense and antisense probes were used, uncleavable mismatches such as G:T and G:G which were made from one combination of RNA and DNA strands could be converted to the cleavable C:A and C:C mismatches, respectively, by using the opposite combination. Deletions and insertions of 1 (G), 4 (TTCT), 5 (ATTTT) and 10 (ATTTTATTTT) nt were easily detected. A polymorphic substitution of T to C at position 666 of the second intervening sequence (IVS2-666) of the beta-globin gene was detected using genomic DNAs from cell lines established from the peripheral B lymphocytes of 59 unrelated Japanese from Hiroshima or those amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The frequency of the gene with C at the IVS2-666 (allele C) was 0.48 and that of the gene with T (allele T) was 0.52. The associations of the 2 alleles were in agreement with Hardy-Weinberg proportions. No contradiction to Mendelian inheritance was observed in the results obtained from 11 family studies. Two new polymorphic substitutions of C to A and A to T were detected at nucleotide positions 1789 and 1945 from the capping site, respectively, using genomic DNAs amplified by PCR. The feasibility of the RNase cleavage method combined with PCR for large-scale screening of variation in chromosomal DNA is discussed.

Detection of partial deletion and partial duplication of dystrophin gene in Japanese patients with Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy

SummaryThe dystrophin gene was analyzed in 59 Japanese patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) from 48 unrelated families, including 11 pairs of siblings, and three patients with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) from two unrelated families, including one pair of siblings. The relationship between the type of gene abnormality and clinical symptoms was examined. Twenty-seven of 50 (54.0%) unrelated DMD or BMD patients were found to have partial deletions, and five (10%) appeared to have partial duplications in the dystrophin gene. Nine DMD patients, including three pairs of siblings, showed mental retardation, the existence of which was coincident in each pair of siblings, but deletion of an identical exon was not always related to mental retardation in unrelated patients.

Genome-Wide Deletion Screening with the Array CGH Method in Mouse Offspring Derived from Irradiated Spermatogonia Indicates that Mutagenic Responses are Highly Variable among Genes

Until the end of the 20th century, mouse germ cell data on induced mutation rates, which were collected using classical genetic methods at preselected specific loci, provided the principal basis for estimates of genetic risks from radiation in humans. The work reported on here is an extension of earlier efforts in this area using molecular methods. It focuses on validating the use of array comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) methods for identifying radiation-induced copy number variants (CNVs) and specifically for DNA deletions. The emphasis on deletions stems from the view that it constitutes the predominant type of radiation-induced genetic damage, which is relevant for estimating genetic risks in humans. In the current study, deletion mutations were screened in the genomes of F1 mice born to unirradiated or 4 Gy irradiated sires at the spermatogonia stage (100 offspring each). The array CGH analysis was performed using a “2M array” with over 2 million probes with a mean interprobe distance of approximately 1 kb. The results provide evidence of five molecularly-confirmed paternally-derived deletions in the irradiated group (5/100) and one in the controls (1/100). These data support a calculation, which estimates that the mutation rate is 1 × 10–2/Gy per genome for induced deletions; this is much lower than would be expected if one assumes that the specific locus rate of 1 × 10–5/locus per Gy (at 34 loci) is applicable to other genes in the genome. The low observed rate of induced deletions suggests that the effective number of genes/genomic regions at which recoverable deletions could be induced would be only approximately 1,000. This estimate is far lower than expected from the size of the mouse genome (>20,000 genes). Such a discrepancy between observation and expectation can occur if the genome contains numerous genes that are far less sensitive to radiation-induced deletions, if many deletion-bearing offspring are not viable or if the current method is substandard for detecting small deletions.

Duplication detection in Japanese Duchenne muscular dystrophy patients and identification of carriers with partial gene deletions using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis.

DNA samples from 21 unrelated Japanese patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) with nondeletion-type abnormality in the dystrophin gene and three samples from possible deletion carriers were analyzed using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Among the 21 patients, 7 were found to carry partial duplications of the dystrophin gene spanning 50–400 kb. Of these 7 patients, 4 carried duplications corresponding to the major hot-spot regions for deletions (7.5–8.5 kb from the 5′ end of cDNA), whereas two cases contained duplications in a region about 10 kb from the 5′ end of cDNA, where causative mutations are reported to be rare. Only 1 case was found to contain a duplication of a region about 1 kb from the 5′ end of cDNA, which is the reported duplication prone region. A combination of Southern blot analyses of conventional agarose gel electrophoresis and PFGE was confirmed to be useful, not only for detecting duplications and deletions, per se, but also for identifying carriers in the affected family.

Radiation-Induced Deletions in Mouse Spermatogonia are Usually Large (over 200 kb) and Contain Little Sequence Similarity at the Junctions

Ionizing radiation can induce mutations, and the majority of radiation-induced mutations in mammalian cells are deletions. The most critical types of radiation-induced DNA damage are DNA double-strand breaks, and these breaks are repaired by either the homologous recombination (HR) pathway or the non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway. The HR pathway is not as mutagenic as the NHEJ pathway, and it is expected that radiation-induced deletions would usually have little sequence similarity around the deletion junction points. Here we report sequence data from the regions around the rejoined junctions of 33 de novo copy-number mutations (27 deletions and 6 duplications) obtained from offspring sired by male mice that were irradiated at the spermatogonia stage and from nonirradiated controls. The results indicate that deletions can be classified into three major groups. In group 1, nine deletions were found to share long blocks of similar sequences (200–6,000 bp) at the junctions and the deletion size varied extensively (1 kb to 2 Mb) (e.g., illegitimate recombination). In group 2, five deletions shared short identical sequences (0–7 bp) at the junctions, and the deletion sizes were shorter than 200 kb (e.g., micro-homology-mediated repair). Additional three-deletion candidates of this group were also found but turned out to be inherited from mosaic parents. They are therefore not included in germline mutations. In group 3, twelve deletions shared little sequence similarity (only 0–2 bp) at the junctions (likely due to NHEJ repair) and deletion sizes were longer than 200 kb. Group 1 consisted of deletions found in both spontaneous and irradiated genomes and thus, were probably caused by spontaneous events during meiosis or DNA replication. Group 2 consisted mainly of deletions found in nonexposed genomes. Group 3 consisted primarily of deletions that occurred in the irradiated genomes. Among the duplications, we found no indication of any association with radiation exposures. These results indicate that large size (>200 kb) and little sequence similarity around the rejoined sites are likely to be a hallmark of radiation-induced deletions in mice.