Miglena I. Angelova

Membrane Deformation under Local pH Gradient: Mimicking Mitochondrial Cristae Dynamics

Mitochondria are cell substructures (organelles) critical for cell life, because biological fuel production, the ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation, occurs in them driven by acidity (pH) gradients. Mitochondria play a key role as well in the cell death and in various fatigue and exercise intolerance syndromes. It is clear now that mitochondria present an astonishing variety of inner membrane morphologies, dynamically correlated with their functional state, coupled with the rate of the ATP synthesis, and characteristic for normal as well as for pathological cases. Our work offers some original insights into the factors that determine the dynamical tubular structures of the inner membrane cristae. We show the possibility to induce, by localized proton flow, a macroscopic cristae-like shape remodeling of an only-lipid membrane. We designed a minimal membrane system (GUV) and experimentally showed that the directional modulation of local pH gradient at membrane level of cardiolipin-containing vesicles induces dynamic cristae-like membrane invaginations. We propose a mechanism and theoretical model to explain the observed tubular membrane morphology and suggest the underlying role of cardiolipin. Our results support the hypothesis of localized bioenergetic transduction and contribute to showing the inherent capacity of cristae morphology to become self-maintaining and to optimize the ATP synthesis.

Lipid packing variations induced by pH in cardiolipin-containing bilayers: The driving force for the cristae-like shape instability

Cardiolipin is a four-tailed acidic lipid found predominantly within the inner membrane of mitochondria, and is thought to be a key component in determining inner membrane properties and potential. Thus, cardiolipin may be involved in the dynamics of the inner membrane characteristic invaginations (named cristae) that protrude into the matrix space. In previous studies, we showed the possibility to induce, by localized proton flow, a macroscopic cristae-like shape remodeling of an only-lipid model membrane mimicking the inner mitochondrial membrane. In addition, we reported a theoretical model describing the dynamics of a chemically driven membrane shape instability caused by a modification of the plane-shape equilibrium density of the lipids in the membrane. In the present work, we focus on the lipid-packing modifications observed in a model cardiolipin-containing lipid membrane submitted to pH decrease because this is the driving force of the instability. Laurdan fluorescence and ζ-potential measurements show that under pH decrease, membrane surface charge decreases, but that significant modification of the lipid packing is observed only for CL-containing membranes. Our giant unilamellar vesicle experiments also indicate that cristae-like morphologies are only observed for CL-containing lipid membranes. Taken together, these results highlight the fact that only a strong modulation of the lipid packing of the exposed monolayer leads to membrane shape instability and suggest that mitochondrial lipids, in particular the cardiolipin, play a specific role under pH modulation in inner mitochondrial membrane morphology and dynamics.

Lipid membrane deformation in response to a local pH modification: theory and experiments

We study the deformation of a lipid membrane in response to a local pH modification. Experimentally, a basic solution is microinjected close to a giant unilamellar vesicle. A local deformation appears in the zone of the membrane that is closest to the micropipette, and relaxes when the injection is stopped. A theoretical description of this phenomenon is provided. It fully takes into account the spatiotemporal evolution of the concentration of hydroxide ions during and after the microinjection, as well as the linear dynamics of the membrane. This description applies to a local injection of any substance that reacts reversibly with the membrane lipids. We compare experimental data obtained in the domain of small deformations to the results of our linear description, and we obtain a good agreement between theory and experiments. In addition, we present direct experimental observations of the pH profile on the membrane during and after the microinjection, using pH-sensitive fluorescent lipids.

Dynamical membrane curvature instability controlled by intermonolayer friction.

We study a dynamical curvature instability caused by a local chemical modification of a phospholipid membrane. In our experiments, a basic solution is microinjected close to a giant unilamellar vesicle, which induces a local chemical modification of some lipids in the external monolayer of the membrane. This modification causes a local deformation of the vesicle, which then relaxes. We present a theoretical description of this instability, taking into account both the change of the equilibrium lipid density and the change of the spontaneous membrane curvature induced by the chemical modification. We show that these two types of changes of the membrane properties yield different dynamics. In contrast, it is impossible to distinguish them when studying the equilibrium shape of a vesicle subjected to a global modification. In our model, the longest relaxation timescale is related to the intermonolayer friction, which plays an important part when there is a change in the equilibrium density in one monolayer. We compare our experimental results to the predictions of our model by fitting the measured time evolution of the deformation height to the solution of our dynamical equations. We obtain good agreement between theory and experiments. Our fits enable us to estimate the intermonolayer friction coefficient, yielding values that are consistent with previous measurements.

Interplay of Packing and Flip-flop in Local Bilayer Deformation. How Phosphatidylglycerol Could Rescue Mitochondrial Function in a Cardiolipin-deficient Yeast Mutant

In a previous work, we have shown that a spatially localized transmembrane pH gradient, produced by acid micro-injection near the external side of cardiolipin-containing giant unilamellar vesicles, leads to the formation of tubules that retract after the dissipation of this gradient. These tubules have morphologies similar to mitochondrial cristae. The tubulation effect is attributable to direct phospholipid packing modification in the outer leaflet, that is promoted by protonation of cardiolipin headgroups. In this study, we compare the case of cardiolipin-containing giant unilamellar vesicles with that of giant unilamellar vesicles that contain phosphatidylglycerol (PG). Local acidification also promotes formation of tubules in the latter. However, compared with cardiolipin-containing giant unilamellar vesicles the tubules are longer, exhibit a visible pearling, and have a much longer lifetime after acid micro-injection is stopped. We attribute these differences to an additional mechanism that increases monolayer surface imbalance, namely inward PG flip-flop promoted by the local transmembrane pH gradient. Simulations using a fully nonlinear membrane model as well as geometrical calculations are in agreement with this hypothesis. Interestingly, among yeast mutants deficient in cardiolipin biosynthesis, only the crd1-null mutant, which accumulates phosphatidylglycerol, displays significant mitochondrial activity. Our work provides a possible explanation of such a property and further emphasizes the salient role of specific lipids in mitochondrial function.

Making a tool of an artifact: the application of photoinduced Lo domains in giant unilamellar vesicles to the study of Lo/Ld phase spinodal decomposition and its modulation by the ganglioside GM1.

Electroformed giant unilamellar vesicles containing liquid-ordered Lo domains are important tools for the modeling of the physicochemical properties and biological functions of lipid rafts. Lo domains are usually imaged using fluorescence microscopy of differentially phase-partionioning membrane-embedded probes. Recently, it has been shown that these probes also have a photosensitizing effect that leads to lipid chemical modification during the fluorescence microscopy experiments. Moreover, the lipid reaction products are able as such to promote Lo microdomain formation, leading to potential artifacts. We show here that this photoinduced effect can also purposely be used as a new approach to study Lo microdomain formation in giant unilamellar vesicles. Photosensitized lipid modification can promote Lo microdomain appearance and growth uniformly and on a faster time scale, thereby yielding new information on such processes. For instance, in egg phosphatidylcholine/egg sphingomyelin/cholesterol 50:30:20 (mol/mol) giant unilamellar vesicles, photoinduced Lo microdomain formation appears to occur by the rarely observed spinodal decomposition process rather than by the common nucleation process usually observed for Lo domain formation in bilayers. Moreover, temperature and the presence of the ganglioside GM1 have a profound effect on the morphological outcome of the photoinduced phase separation, eventually leading to features such as bicontinuous phases, phase percolation inversions, and patterns evoking double phase separations. GM1 also has the effect of destabilizing Lo microdomains. These properties may have consequences for Lo nanodomains stability and therefore for raft dynamics in biomembranes. Our data show that photoinduced Lo microdomains can be used to obtain new data on fast raft-mimicking processes in giant unilamellar vesicles.

Segregative Clustering of Lo and Ld Membrane Microdomains Induced by Local pH Gradients in GM1-Containing Giant Vesicles: A Lipid Model for Cellular Polarization

Several cell polarization processes are coupled to local pH gradients at the membrane surface. We have investigated the involvement of a lipid-mediated effect in such coupling. The influence of lateral pH gradients along the membrane surface on lipid microdomain dynamics in giant unilamellar vesicles containing phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin, cholesterol, and the ganglioside GM1 was studied. Lo/Ld phase separation was generated by photosensitization. A lateral pH gradient was established along the external membrane surface by acid local microinjection. The gradient promotes the segregation of microdomains: Lo domains within an Ld phase move toward the higher pH side, whereas Ld domains within an Lo phase move toward the lower pH side. This results in a polarization of the vesicle membrane into Lo and Ld phases poles in the axis of the proton source. A secondary effect is inward tubulation in the Ld phase. None of these processes occurs without GM1 or with the analog asialo-GM1. These are therefore related to the acidic character of the GM1 headgroup. LAURDAN fluorescence experiments on large unilamellar vesicles indicated that, with GM1, an increase in lipid packing occurs with decreasing pH, attributed to the lowering of repulsion between GM1 molecules. Packing increase is much higher for Ld phase vesicles than for Lo phase vesicles. It is proposed that the driving forces for domain vectorial segregative clustering and vesicle polarization are related to such differences in packing variations with pH decrease between the Lo and Ld phases. Such pH-driven domain clustering might play a role in cellular membrane polarization processes in which local lateral pH gradients are known to be important, such as migrating cells and epithelial cells.

pH sensing by lipids in membranes: The fundamentals of pH-driven migration, polarization and deformations of lipid bilayer assemblies

Most biological molecules contain acido-basic groups that modulate their structure and interactions. A consequence is that pH gradients, local heterogeneities and dynamic variations are used by cells and organisms to drive or regulate specific biological functions including energetic metabolism, vesicular traffic, migration and spatial patterning of tissues in development. While the direct or regulatory role of pH in protein function is well documented, the role of hydrogen and hydroxyl ions in modulating the properties of lipid assemblies such as bilayer membranes is only beginning to be understood. Here, we review approaches using artificial lipid vesicles that have been instrumental in providing an understanding of the influence of pH gradients and local variations on membrane vectorial motional processes: migration, membrane curvature effects promoting global or local deformations, crowding generation by segregative polarization processes. In the case of pH induced local deformations, an extensive theoretical framework is given and an application to a specific biological issue, namely the structure and stability of mitochondrial cristae, is described. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Emergence of Complex Behavior in Biomembranes edited by Marjorie Longo.

Migration of Deformable Vesicles Induced by Ionic Stimuli

We have investigated the dynamics of phospholipid vesicles composed of 1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine triggered by ionic stimuli using electrolytes such as CaCl2, NaCl, and NaOH. The ionic stimuli induce two characteristic vesicle dynamics, deformation due to the ion binding to the lipids in the outer leaflet of the vesicle and migration due to the concentration gradient of ions, that is, diffusiophoresis or the interfacial energy gradient mechanism. We examined the deformation pathway for each electrolyte as a function of time and analyzed it based on the surface dissociation model and the area difference elasticity model, which reveals the change of the cross-sectional area of the phospholipid by the ion binding. The metal ions such as Ca2+ and Na+ encourage inward budding deformation by decreasing the cross-sectional area of a lipid, whereas the hydroxide ion (OH-) encourages outward budding deformation by increasing the cross-sectional area of a lipid. When we microinjected these electrolytes toward the vesicles, a strong coupling between the deformation and the migration of the vesicle was observed for CaCl2 and NaOH, whereas for NaCl, the coupling was very weak. This difference probably originates from the binding constants of the ions.

Developing Cell-Scale Biomimetic Systems: A Tool for Understanding Membrane Organization and Its Implication in Membrane-Associated Pathological Processes

Abstract Giant unilamellar vesicles have become a versatile tool to mimic lateral membrane organization and membrane-associated processes in cells. The interest in sphingolipids has grown rapidly since the establishment of their role in cell signaling. This review summarizes our results on the impact of sphingolipids (sphingomyelin (SM), ceramide (CER), and sphingosine (SPH)) on the formation of membrane domains. CER and SPH form gel domains in the glycerophospholipid (GPL) matrix. Addition of CER and SPH to raft mixtures induces larger liquid-ordered (Lo) domains compared to the control phosphatidylcholine (PC)/SM/cholesterol (CHOL) ones. The presence of SM in PC/SM/CER/CHOL mixtures stabilizes the gel phase and thus decreases CER miscibility. More competitive CER/SM interactions compared to SM/CHOL ones change the conditions of Lo phase formation. The bacterial sphingomyelinase and secretory phospholipase A2 (sPLA2) activities on homogeneous and Lo/Ld (liquid-disordered) heterogeneous membranes were visualized. The enzyme-induced generation of CER from raft-containing SM leads to disintegration of the rafts. sPLA2 activity on substrate vesicles provokes vesicle shrinking and burst. SM is a sPLA2 inhibitor and its addition to the substrate vesicles increases the membrane resistance. CHOL restores sPLA2 activity in raft-containing mixtures. The enzyme induces continuous Lo domain budding and fission. CER augments, additionally, sPLA2 activity, and an appearance of holes in the membrane bilayer is observed. CER and CHOL seem to sequestrate SM making the phospholipid substrate more susceptible to enzyme attack. Possible molecular mechanism for Lo domain budding and fission is proposed, suggesting that PLA2 might be a factor for triggering, developing, and finalizing the process of rafts-transporting vesicle formation.