Mrn Murthy

Structural studies on chimeric Sesbania mosaic virus coat protein: Revisiting SeMV assembly

The capsid protein (CP) of Sesbania mosaic virus (SeMV, a T=3 plant virus) consists of a disordered N-terminal R-domain and an ordered S-domain. Removal of the R-domain results in the formation of T=1 particles. In the current study, the R-domain was replaced with unrelated polypeptides of similar lengths: the B-domain of Staphylococcus aureus SpA, and SeMV encoded polypeptides P8 and P10. The chimeric proteins contained T=3 or larger virus-like particles (VLPs) and could not be crystallized. The presence of metal ions during purification resulted in a large number of heterogeneous nucleoprotein complexes. N∆65-B (R domain replaced with B domain) could also be purified in a dimeric form. Its crystal structure revealed T=1 particles devoid of metal ions and the B-domain was disordered. However, the B-domain was functional in N∆65-B VLPs, suggesting possible biotechnological applications. These studies illustrate the importance of N-terminal residues, metal ions and robustness of the assembly process.

Insights into stabilizing interactions in the distorted domain-swapped dimer of Salmonella typhimurium survival protein.

The survival protein SurE from Salmonella typhimurium (StSurE) is a dimeric protein that functions as a phosphatase. SurE dimers are formed by the swapping of a loop with a pair of β-strands and a C-terminal helix between two protomers. In a previous study, the Asp230 and His234 residues were mutated to Ala to abolish a hydrogen bond that was thought to be crucial for C-terminal helix swapping. These mutations led to functionally inactive and distorted dimers in which the two protomers were related by a rotation of 167°. New salt bridges involving Glu112 were observed in the dimeric interface of the H234A and D230A/H234A mutants. To explore the role of these salt bridges in the stability of the distorted structure, E112A, E112A/D230A, E112A/H234A, E112A/D230A/H234A, R179L/H180A/H234A and E112A/R179L/H180A/H234A mutants were constructed. X-ray crystal structures of the E112A, E112A/H234A and E112A/D230A mutants could be determined. The dimeric structures of the E112A and E112A/H234A mutants were similar to that of native SurE, while the E112A/D230A mutant had a residual rotation of 11° between the B chains upon superposition of the A chains of the mutant and native dimers. The native dimeric structure was nearly restored in the E112A/H234A mutant, suggesting that the new salt bridge observed in the H234A and D230A/H234A mutants was indeed responsible for the stability of their distorted structures. Catalytic activity was also restored in these mutants, implying that appropriate dimeric organization is necessary for the activity of SurE.

Structural characterization of a mitochondrial 3-ketoacyl-CoA (T1)-like thiolase from Mycobacterium smegmatis.

Thiolases catalyze the degradation and synthesis of 3-ketoacyl-CoA molecules. Here, the crystal structures of a T1-like thiolase (MSM-13 thiolase) from Mycobacterium smegmatis in apo and liganded forms are described. Systematic comparisons of six crystallographically independent unliganded MSM-13 thiolase tetramers (dimers of tight dimers) from three different crystal forms revealed that the two tight dimers are connected to a rigid tetramerization domain via flexible hinge regions, generating an asymmetric tetramer. In the liganded structure, CoA is bound to those subunits that are rotated towards the tip of the tetramerization loop of the opposing dimer, suggesting that this loop is important for substrate binding. The hinge regions responsible for this rotation occur near Val123 and Arg149. The Lα1-covering loop-Lα2 region, together with the Nβ2-Nα2 loop of the adjacent subunit, defines a specificity pocket that is larger and more polar than those of other tetrameric thiolases, suggesting that MSM-13 thiolase has a distinct substrate specificity. Consistent with this finding, only residual activity was detected with acetoacetyl-CoA as the substrate in the degradative direction. No activity was observed with acetyl-CoA in the synthetic direction. Structural comparisons with other well characterized thiolases suggest that MSM-13 thiolase is probably a degradative thiolase that is specific for 3-ketoacyl-CoA molecules with polar, bulky acyl chains.

Molecular dynamics studies on the domain swapped Salmonella typhimurium survival protein SurE: insights on the possible reasons for catalytic cooperativity

Stationary phase survival protein SurE from Salmonella typhimurium is a dimeric protein formed by the swapping of a tetramerization loop involved in the formation of a loose tetramer and a C-terminal helix. It functions as a phosphatase. The two-fold symmetry of the dimeric protein was lost in the mutants H234A and D230A/H234A in which a crucial hydrogen bond in the hinge involved in C-terminal helix swapping was eliminated. The catalytic activity of both mutants was drastically reduced. In contrast to the native protein, H234A exhibited positive cooperativity in its catalytic activity. In order to relate these observations to the dynamics of the native and distorted mutants, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were carried out using GROMACS v4.0.7. In all the simulations, the swapped segments and a segment near the active site were found to be highly flexible. These segments exhibited distinct dynamic features in the two protomers (A and B) of the dimeric protein. The dimeric organization was more significantly affected in the mutants when compared to the native structure, suggesting that the mutations enhance the intrinsic flexibility of the protein. The larger flexibility of the mutants affects the relative movement between the loops near the two active sites. The positive cooperativity observed in H234A mutant is most likely due to this increased flexibility and loop movement.

Evaluation of phasing models used for molecular replacement structure determination

Nearly 90% of the structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) have been determined by X-ray crystallographic methods. Of these structures, 78% of the entries deposited in the last five years have been determined using the Molecular Replacement (MR) technique. MR has several advantages over other crystallographic techniques as it is based on the phase information that could be obtained from the structure of a related protein (phasing model) as a valid approximation to the unknown structure and hence, eliminates the need for more diffraction data to carry out experimental phasing. Since 2010, PDB has grown tremendously by over 50,000 depositions while the growth in the number of unique folds is negligible in comparison [1]. For a given target protein, it is likely that more than one structure is available in the PDB that could be used as a suitable phasing model. In such cases, selecting the best phasing model from among the available pool of structures requires careful examination of the parameters that determine the reliability of the phasing model for MR structure determination. Hence, it is necessary to understand the relationship between properties of phasing model and quality of the structure determined (MR model) to arrive at most reasonable MR model. In this study, we provide quantitative measures of intuitive ideas on the strategies that might be useful in choosing the best phasing model. Towards this goal, redetermination of selected structures from the PDB was carried out using the X-ray intensity data of the selected protein deposited in the PDB and several homologous structures as phasing models. A total of 716 phasing models were considered for MR structure determination of three proteins from Triosephosphate isomerase fold and Lysozyme-like fold. The RMSD of corresponding Cα positions between MR model and the structure of the selected protein re-determined by an identical MR protocol using the deposited coordinates of the protein (positive control) was calculated. A ‘Q score’ based on the polypeptide length normalized RMSD was considered as a measure of the accuracy of the MR model (MR accuracy). Resolution of the target protein was found to be the most important factor for the success of MR. The success of MR increased with the increase in sequence identity between target protein and phasing model. However, CART modeling [2] indicated that after a defined sequence identity threshold, quality of phasing model (measured by Resolution, Real-space correlation coefficient, Rwork/Rfree) seem to have a greater influence on the MR accuracy than sequence identity. Correlation of phasing model properties and MR accuracy scores obtained by using phasing models with sequence identity above the threshold also supports this observation in both the folds studied. Further, a similar trend is observed in proteins from other folds as well. However, the sequence identity threshold above which the quality of the phasing model assumes importance varies for different folds. [1] Hatti, K., et. al., (2016). Acta Crystallogr. Sect. D. 72, 1081–1089. [2] Breiman, L., et. al., (1984). Classification and Regression Trees.

Structural studies on tobacco streak virus coat protein: Insights into the pleomorphic nature of ilarviruses

Tobacco streak virus (TSV), the type member of Ilarvirus genus, is a major plant pathogen. TSV purified from infected plants consists of a ss-RNA genome encapsidated in spheroidal particles with diameters of 27, 30 and 33nm constructed from multiple copies of a single species of coat protein (CP) subunits. Apart from protecting the viral genome, CPs of ilarviruses play several key roles in the life cycle of these viruses. Unlike the related bromo and cucumoviruses, ilarvirus particles are labile and pleomorphic, which has posed difficulties in their crystallization and structure determination. In the current study, a truncated TSV-CP was crystallized in two distinct forms and their structures were determined at resolutions of 2.4Å and 2.1Å, respectively. The core of TSV CP was found to possess the canonical β-barrel jelly roll tertiary structure observed in several other viruses. Dimers of CP with swapped C-terminal arms (C-arm) were observed in both the crystal forms. The C-arm was found to be flexible and is likely to be responsible for the polymorphic and pleomorphic nature of TSV capsids. Consistent with this observation, mutations in the hinge region of the C-arm that reduce the flexibility resulted in the formation of more uniform particles. TSV CP was found to be structurally similar to that of Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) accounting for similar mechanism of genome activation in alfamo and ilar viruses. This communication represents the first report on the structure of the CP from an ilarvirus.