Nabieh Ayoub

HP1-β mobilization promotes chromatin changes that initiate the DNA damage response

Minutes after DNA damage, the variant histone H2AX is phosphorylated by protein kinases of the phosphoinositide kinase family, including ATM, ATR or DNA-PK. Phosphorylated (γ)-H2AX—which recruits molecules that sense or signal the presence of DNA breaks, activating the response that leads to repair—is the earliest known marker of chromosomal DNA breakage. Here we identify a dynamic change in chromatin that promotes H2AX phosphorylation in mammalian cells. DNA breaks swiftly mobilize heterochromatin protein 1 (HP1)-β (also called CBX1), a chromatin factor bound to histone H3 methylated on lysine 9 (H3K9me). Local changes in histone-tail modifications are not apparent. Instead, phosphorylation of HP1-β on amino acid Thr 51 accompanies mobilization, releasing HP1-β from chromatin by disrupting hydrogen bonds that fold its chromodomain around H3K9me. Inhibition of casein kinase 2 (CK2), an enzyme implicated in DNA damage sensing and repair, suppresses Thr 51 phosphorylation and HP1-β mobilization in living cells. CK2 inhibition, or a constitutively chromatin-bound HP1-β mutant, diminishes H2AX phosphorylation. Our findings reveal an unrecognized signalling cascade that helps to initiate the DNA damage response, altering chromatin by modifying a histone-code mediator protein, HP1, but not the code itself.

The Carboxyl Terminus of Brca2 Links the Disassembly of Rad51 Complexes to Mitotic Entry

Summary Background The Rad51 recombinase assembles on DNA to execute homologous DNA recombination (HR). This process is essential to repair replication-associated genomic lesions before cells enter mitosis, but how it is started and stopped during the cell cycle remains poorly understood. Rad51 assembly is regulated by the breast cancer suppressor Brca2, via its evolutionarily conserved BRC repeats, and a distinct carboxy (C)-terminal motif whose biological function is uncertain. Using “hit-and-run” gene targeting to insert single-codon substitutions into the avian Brca2 locus, we report here a previously unrecognized role for the C-terminal motif. Results We show that the avian C-terminal motif is functionally cognate with its human counterpart and identify point mutations that either abolish or enhance Rad51 binding. When these mutations are introduced into Brca2, we find that they affect neither the assembly of Rad51 into nuclear foci on damaged DNA nor DNA repair by HR. Instead, foci disassemble more rapidly in a point mutant that fails to bind Rad51, associated with faster mitotic entry. Conversely, the slower disassembly of foci in a point mutant that constitutively binds Rad51 correlates with delayed mitosis. Indeed, Rad51 foci do not persist in mitotic cells even after G2 checkpoint suppression, suggesting that their disassembly is a prerequisite for chromosome segregation. Conclusions We conclude that Rad51 binding by the C-terminal Brca2 motif is dispensable for the execution of HR but instead links the disassembly of Rad51 complexes to mitotic entry. This mechanism may ensure that HR terminates before chromosome segregation. Our findings assign a biological function for the C-terminal Brca2 motif in a mechanism that coordinates DNA repair with the cell cycle.

Mobilization and recruitment of HP1β: A bimodal response to DNA breakage

The pathways that signal double-strand DNA breaks (DSBs) in mammalian cells are central to the maintenance of genome integrity. We have reported (Ayoub et al., Nature 2008; 453: 682-6) that the rapid mobilization of the heterochromatin protein, HP1β, within seconds from DSB sites promotes chromatin changes like H2AX phosphorylation that trigger this response. Notably, this paper and a subsequent report (Ayoub et al., Cell Cycle 2009; 8: 1494-500), demonstrate that transient HP1β mobilization is followed by its accumulation over time at DSB sites. Indeed, two recent papers (Luijsterburg et al., J Cell Biol 2009; 185:577-86 and Zarebski et al., Cytometry A May 2009) suggest that HP1 recruitment to damage sites, rather than its rapid mobilization, is the predominant behaviour exhibited by this protein. Here, we present new experimental analyses which corroborate that fluorophore-tagged HP1β exhibits two distinct behaviours at DSB sites in living cells – rapid, transient mobilization, most evident in heterochromatic regions, followed by slower recruitment. Experimental methods allowing visualization of these behaviours are described. Interestingly, chemical inhibition of the DNA-damage responsive enzyme, casein kinase 2 (CK2), suppresses HP1β mobilization while permitting recruitment. Our findings reconcile recent findings in a new model, wherein rapid HP1β mobilization from DSBs mediated by its phosphorylation on Thr51 by CK2, is followed by, and may overlap with, its accumulation at these sites via the chromoshadow domain, independent of Thr51. Our analyses provide fresh insight into the earliest events that trigger the DNA damage response in mammalian cells.

A cancer-associated BRCA2 mutation reveals masked nuclear export signals controlling localization

Germline missense mutations affecting a single BRCA2 allele predispose humans to cancer. Here we identify a protein-targeting mechanism that is disrupted by the cancer-associated mutation, BRCA2D2723H, and that controls the nuclear localization of BRCA2 and its cargo, the recombination enzyme RAD51. A nuclear export signal (NES) in BRCA2 is masked by its interaction with a partner protein, DSS1, such that point mutations impairing BRCA2-DSS1 binding render BRCA2 cytoplasmic. In turn, cytoplasmic mislocalization of mutant BRCA2 inhibits the nuclear retention of RAD51 by exposing a similar NES in RAD51 that is usually obscured by the BRCA2-RAD51 interaction. Thus, a series of NES-masking interactions localizes BRCA2 and RAD51 in the nucleus. Notably, BRCA2D2723H decreases RAD51 nuclear retention even when wild-type BRCA2 is also present. Our findings suggest a mechanism for the regulation of the nucleocytoplasmic distribution of BRCA2 and RAD51 and its impairment by a heterozygous disease-associated mutation.

A DNA-Damage Selective Role for BRCA1 E3 Ligase in Claspin Ubiquitylation, CHK1 Activation, and DNA Repair

BACKGROUND The breast and ovarian cancer suppressor BRCA1 is essential for cellular responses to DNA damage. It heterodimerizes with BARD1 to acquire an E3 ubiquitin (Ub) ligase activity that is often compromised by cancer-associated mutations. Neither the significance of this activity to damage responses, nor a relevant in vivo substrate, is clear. RESULTS We have separated DNA-damage responses requiring the BRCA1 E3 ligase from those independent of it, using a gene-targeted point mutation in vertebrate DT40 cells that abrogates BRCA1s catalytic activity without perturbing BARD1 binding. We show that BRCA1 ubiquitylates claspin, an essential coactivator of the CHK1 checkpoint kinase, after topoisomerase inhibition, but not DNA crosslinking by mitomycin C. BRCA1 E3 inactivation decreases chromatin-bound claspin levels and impairs homology-directed DNA repair by interrupting signal transduction from the damage-activated ATR kinase to its effector, CHK1. CONCLUSIONS Our findings identify claspin as an in vivo substrate for the BRCA1 E3 ligase and suggest that its modification selectively triggers CHK1 activation for the homology-directed repair of a subset of genotoxic lesions. This mechanism unexpectedly defines an essential but selective function for BRCA1 E3 ligase activity in cellular responses to DNA damage.

Paving the way for H2AX phosphorylation: chromatin changes in the DNA damage response.

The dynamics of chromatin-associated proteins control the accessibility of DNA to essential biological transactions like transcription, replication, recombination and repair. Here, we briefly outline what is known about the chromatin changes that occur during the cellular response to DNA breakage, focusing on our recent findings revealing that the chromatin factor HP1β is mobilized within seconds after DNA damage by an unrecognized signalling cascade mediated by casein kinase 2 (CK2) phosphorylation, paving the way for histone H2AX phosphorylation. We also show here that HP1β mobilization is neither associated with histone H3 modification on Ser10, an alteration proposed to assist in HP1 ejection from chromatin, nor with evidence of a physical interaction between HP1β and the CK2 regulatory subunit. Interestingly, following its rapid mobilization, we find that HP1β gradually re-accumulates on damaged chromatin over a longer time period, suggesting that temporal changes in HP1β dynamics and interaction with chromatin may assist in different stages of the cellular response to DNA breakage.

DNA damage regulates the mobility of Brca2 within the nucleoplasm of living cells

How the biochemical reactions that lead to the repair of DNA damage are controlled by the diffusion and availability of protein reactants within the nucleoplasm is poorly understood. Here, we use gene targeting to replace Brca2 (a cancer suppressor protein essential for DNA repair) with a functional enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-tagged form, followed by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to measure Brca2-EGFP diffusion in the nucleoplasm of living cells exposed to DNA breakage. Before damage, nucleoplasmic Brca2 molecules exhibit complex states of mobility, with long dwell times within a sub-fL observation volume, indicative of restricted motion. DNA damage significantly enhances the mobility of Brca2 molecules in the S/G2 phases of the cell cycle, via signaling through damage-activated protein kinases. Brca2 mobilization is accompanied by increased binding within the nucleoplasm to its cargo, the Rad51 recombinase, measured by fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy. Together, these results suggest that DNA breakage triggers the redistribution of soluble nucleoplasmic Brca2 molecules from a state of restricted diffusion, into a mobile fraction available for Rad51 binding. Our findings identify signal-regulated changes in nucleoplasmic protein diffusion as a means to control biochemical reactions in the cell nucleus.

The emerging role of lysine demethylases in DNA damage response: dissecting the recruitment mode of KDM4D/JMJD2D to DNA damage sites

KDM4D is a lysine demethylase that removes tri- and di- methylated residues from H3K9 and is involved in transcriptional regulation and carcinogenesis. We recently showed that KDM4D is recruited to DNA damage sites in a PARP1-dependent manner and facilitates double-strand break repair in human cells. Moreover, we demonstrated that KDM4D is an RNA binding protein and mapped its RNA-binding motifs. Interestingly, KDM4D-RNA interaction is essential for its localization on chromatin and subsequently for efficient demethylation of its histone substrate H3K9me3. Here, we provide new data that shed mechanistic insights into KDM4D accumulation at DNA damage sites. We show for the first time that KDM4D binds poly(ADP-ribose) (PAR) in vitro via its C-terminal region. In addition, we demonstrate that KDM4D-RNA interaction is required for KDM4D accumulation at DNA breakage sites. Finally, we discuss the recruitment mode and the biological functions of additional lysine demethylases including KDM4B, KDM5B, JMJD1C, and LSD1 in DNA damage response.

95 Identification of synthetic lethality compounds from natural products for cancers

L. Packer, S. Byron, C. Mahon, D. Loch, A. Wortmann, K. Nones, S. Grimmond, J. Pearson, N. Waddell, P. Pollock. Translational Research Institute, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane Qld, Australia; Translational Genomics Research Institute, Phoenix, USA; Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane Qld, Australia; Institute of Molecular Biology, University of Queensland, Brisbane Qld, Australia; QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute, Brisbane Qld, Australia