Narendra Nathoo

Craniotomy Improves Outcomes for Cranial Subdural Empyemas: Computed Tomography-Era Experience with 699 Patients

OBJECTIVEUncertainty regarding the best surgical management for subdural empyemas (SDEs) continues. Our unit has considered craniotomy the preferred method of surgical drainage for all cranial SDEs since 1988. We performed an analysis of our previously published, computed tomography-era, experience with 699 patients. METHODSTwo analyses of the database (1983–1997) were performed. First, analysis of the periods from 1983 to 1987 and from 1988 to 1997 was performed. Second, analysis of the composite database was performed. Outcomes were compared for possible outcome predictors by univariate analysis. Multivariate analysis was used to identify variables that contributed independently to outcomes, using stepwise discriminant analysis. RESULTSSignificant correlations between the analyzed periods with respect to outcome and type of surgery (P = 0.001) were noted. Analysis of the entire database (1983–1997) revealed a significant relationship between outcome and surgery type (P = 0.05). Pairwise comparison of limited procedures such as burr holes or craniectomies with wide-exposure surgical procedures such as primary craniotomies or procedures proceeding to full craniotomies indicated significant correlation with outcomes (P = 0.027). Reoperation and morbidity rates were increased with limited procedures. Stepwise discriminant analyses revealed that the type of surgery was correlated with outcomes (P = 0.0008, partial r2 = 0.034). CONCLUSIONCraniotomy was determined to be the surgical procedure of choice for treatment of cranial SDEs, allowing complete evacuation of the pus and, more importantly, decompressing the underlying cerebral hemisphere. Limited procedures such as burr holes or craniectomies may be performed for patients in septic shock, for patients with parafalcine empyemas, or for children with SDEs secondary to meningitis.

Transcranial Brainstem Stab Injuries: A Retrospective Analysis of 17 Patients

OBJECTIVETranscranial stab injuries remain a frequent cause of emergent neurosurgical admissions to neurosurgical units in South Africa. Brainstem stabs are an uncommon, yet often fatal, form of brain injury. METHODSA retrospective audit of 597 patients with transcranial stab injuries admitted to our unit over a 12-year period (January 1987 to December 1998) identified 17 patients (2.85%) with brainstem stab injuries. The computed tomographic scans of all patients were analyzed, and a detailed autopsy examination of the skull and its contents was performed in all patients who died. Stepwise linear regression analysis was used to formulate a predictive model of outcome for the entire series of 597 patients. RESULTSThe majority of the patients were males (16 patients), and the study group had a mean age of 28.65 ± 9.59 years and a mean Glasgow Coma Scale score of 8.59 ± 2.76. Knives (82%) were the most common instruments of penetration. Cerebral angiography identified 3 patients with vascular abnormalities, and autopsy revealed an additional 4 patients with vascular injury. Emergency ventriculostomy was performed in 10 patients for obstructive hydrocephalus. Four of the 17 patients survived (76.5% mortality). Factors significantly predictive of outcome in patients with transcranial stab injuries were the Glasgow Coma Scale score (F = 43.7), the occurrence of intraventricular hemorrhage (F = 22.8), the type of associated lesion (intracranial bleed, vascular abnormality, or brain abscess) (F = 5.9), and the number of operations (F = 3.2). CONCLUSIONThe Glasgow Coma Scale score is the most significant predictor of outcome in low-velocity transcranial stab injuries. Brainstem stab injuries have a great propensity for vascular damage. Survivors are incapacitated by severe, fixed neurological deficits.

Infratentorial empyema: analysis of 22 cases.

OBJECTIVEnInfratentorial empyema is an uncommon form of intracranial suppuration that is usually secondary to neglected otogenic infection. The diagnosis is frequently delayed and often confused with that of meningitis. The associated mortality is distressingly high, yet it has, as a clinical entity, received scant attention in the literature. We present a 13-year experience of this condition.nnnPATIENTS AND METHODSnFrom a retrospective analysis of 3865 patients with intracranial suppuration during a 13-year period, 22 patients with infratentorial empyema were identified. The inpatient notes for these patients were analyzed with reference to clinical, radiological, bacteriological, operative, and outcome data.nnnRESULTSnTwenty-two patients with infratentorial empyema accounted for 0.6% of admissions caused by intracranial suppuration during the study period. Of these 22 empyemas, 13 were subdural and 9 epidural. Hydrocephalus was present in 17 (77.3%). Except for two epidural empyemas that did not warrant neurosurgical intervention, all patients underwent standard surgical management (wide posterior fossa craniectomy). Nineteen underwent mastoidectomy because the source of infection was otogenic. Concomitant and persistent hydrocephalus was treated aggressively. Five patients died (mortality rate of 22.7%). All fatalities had subdural empyemas, and all three patients with cerebellopontine angle extension of subdural purulent collections died.nnnCONCLUSIONnAlthough rare, infratentorial empyema, especially when subdural, is a lethal disease. Cerebellopontine angle extension of pus was a particularly ominous sign in our experience. Early surgical drainage via wide posterior fossa craniectomy, aggressive treatment of associated hydrocephalus, eradication of the primary source of sepsis, and, finally, intravenous high dosage of appropriate antibiotics form the mainstay of treatment.

Cranial Extradural Empyema in the Era of Computed Tomography: A Review of 82 Cases

OBJECTIVEnIntracranial suppurative disorders (abscesses and empyemas) continue to be common neurosurgical emergencies in South Africa. Cranial extradural empyema (EDE) occurs less frequently than its subdural counterpart but remains a potentially devastating disease process. We present our 15-year experience with this condition in the era of computed tomography.nnnMETHODSnOf the 4623 patients with intracranial sepsis who were admitted to the neurosurgical unit at Wentworth Hospital (Durban, South Africa) during a 15-year period (1983-1997), 76 patients with EDEs were identified. An additional six patients who were identified from our outpatient records were treated nonsurgically. Analyses were performed with respect to clinical, radiological, bacteriological, surgical, and outcome data. All information for this study was obtained from the computerized databank for the unit. Statistical analyses of the related pre- and postoperative clinical data were performed.nnnRESULTSnThe 76 patients with EDEs accounted for 1.6% of the total number of patients admitted for treatment of intracranial sepsis during the study period. Thirteen patients (15.8%) had infratentorial pus collections. Male patients predominated by a ratio of 2:1, and 66 patients were between the ages of 6 and 20 years (mean age, 16.56+/-9.87 yr). The origins of the sepsis were paranasal sinusitis for 53 patients (64.6%), mastoiditis for 16 patients, trauma for 5 patients, dental caries for 1 patient, and miscellaneous causes for 7 patients. The most common clinical presenting features were fever, neck stiffness, and periorbital edema. Surgery was performed in the form of burrholes for 21 patients, small craniectomies for 39 patients, and craniotomies for 5 patients. The additional five patients, while having drainage of their infected paranasal sinuses, had simultaneous drainage of their extradural pus collections by the ear, nose, and throat surgeon. The majority of patients (81 patients) experienced good outcomes (Glasgow Outcome Scale scores of 4 or 5). A single patient died after surgery (mortality rate, 1.22%).nnnCONCLUSIONnEDEs occur less frequently than subdural empyemas and are associated with better prognoses. Surgical drainage (burrholes), simultaneous eradication of the source of sepsis, and high-dose intravenous antibiotic therapy remain the mainstays of treatment. Selective nonsurgical management of small EDEs is possible, provided the source of sepsis is surgically eradicated. It is our opinion that EDE is a disease that should be managed without morbidity or death.

To determine the effect of metoclopramide on gastric emptying in severe head injuries: A prospective, randomized, controlled clinical trial

To determine the effect of 8-hourly administration of 10mg intravenous metoclopramide, over a 48-h period on gastric emptying in severe head injury (SHI), 22 patients were prospectively randomized (Glasgow Coma Score of 3–8) to receive 2 ml of intravenous metoclopramide or 2 ml of 5% saline 8-hourly for 48 h. Baseline and serial blood paracetamol absorption assays were performed at time (t) = 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 90 and 120 min on day 0 and day 2. The area under the curve between the day 0 and day 2 was used to measure the degree of gastric emptying. In SHI, sequential doses of metoclopramide did not appear to improve gastric motility within subject comparisons (p = 0.65) and between subject comparisons (placebo p = 0.4 and drug p = 0.12). Metoclopramide has no significant prokinetic effect on gastric emptying in SHI patients when given in the early postinjury period.

Combined spinal subdural tuberculous empyema and intramedullary tuberculoma in an HIV-positive patient.

Abstract.nTuberculous involvement of the spinal subdural and intramedullary compartments is extremely uncommon. Simultaneous involvement of both compartments has never been reported, to our knowledge. We present an HIV-positive patient with such kind of combined involvement. Diagnosis was made on the basis of a prior history of pulmonary tuberculous infection and a positive therapeutic response to antituberculous chemotherapy. Magnetic resonance imaging is the diagnostic procedure of choice in order to determine the exact level, site, and size of the disease. Tuberculosis of the spine should always be considered in the differential diagnosis of spinal cord compression if the patient lives in or comes from a region where tuberculosis is endemic or if the patient is immunocompromised.

Role of cerebrospinal fluid shunting for human immunodeficiency virus-positive patients with tuberculous meningitis and hydrocephalus.

OBJECTIVETuberculous meningitis (TBM) and its complications continue to have devastating neurological consequences for patients. Budgetary constraints, especially in developing countries, have made it necessary to select patients for shunting who are likely to experience good recoveries. To date, the value of cerebrospinal fluid shunting for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-positive patients with TBM has not been clearly established. METHODSThirty patients with TBM and hydrocephalus were prospectively evaluated. Coincidentally, one-half of the patients were HIV-positive. All patients underwent uniform treatment, including ventriculoperitoneal shunt placement and antituberculosis treatment. CD4 counts were measured for all patients. Outcomes were assessed at 1 month. RESULTSNo complications related to shunt insertion were noted. The HIV-positive group fared poorly (death, 66.7%; poor outcome, 64.7%), compared with the HIV-negative group (death, 26.7%; poor outcome, 30.8%). Despite cerebrospinal fluid shunting, no patient in the HIV-positive group experienced a good recovery (Glasgow Outcome Scale score of 5). This is in contrast to the six patients (40%) in the HIV-negative group who, with the same treatment, experienced good recoveries (Glasgow Outcome Scale scores of 5) at discharge (P < 0.14). No patient (either HIV-positive or HIV-negative) who presented in TBM Grade 4 survived, whereas no HIV-positive patient who presented in TBM Grade 3 survived. A significant relationship was noted between CD4 counts and patient outcomes (P < 0.031). CONCLUSIONIn the absence of obvious clinical benefit, HIV-positive patients with TBM should undergo a trial of ventricular or lumbar cerebrospinal fluid drainage, and only those who exhibit significant neurological improvement should proceed to shunt surgery.

Civilian infratentorial gunshot injuries: outcome analysis of 26 patients

BACKGROUNDnCraniocerebral missile injuries have steadily increased to become the most common form of penetrating neurotrauma in our environment resulting in continued morbidity and neuropsychological sequelae. Civilian infratentorial gunshot injuries are uncommon but generally regarded as fatal injuries, with many patients dying before reaching hospital.nnnMETHODSnA retrospective analysis of 1,069 patients with civilian gunshot wounds (GSW), admitted to our unit over a 14-year period (1986-2000), identified 26 patients with infratentorial gunshot injuries (2.4%). A detailed analysis of these patients was carried out, which included demographic factors, clinical and anatomic correlation, computed tomography scans, surgical management, and outcome.nnnRESULTSnAll patients were male. The mean age was 26.5 +/- 11.5 years and the mean admission Glasgow Coma Score 11.8 +/- 2.7. Twenty-four of 26 patients required cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) diversion to control secondary hydrocephalus. The second commonest surgical procedure was posterior fossa decompression. Five of 26 patients died (19.2%). Severe morbidity was noted in 9 of 21 surviving patients (42.8%). Significant predictors: good outcome was associated with primary missile entry of the infratentorial compartment (p = 0.005), while patients with supratentorial to infratentorial missile trajectory were noted to have a poorer outcome (p = 0.041). Location of cerebellar injury (lateral or medial) and missile caliber had no significant influence on patient outcome.nnnCONCLUSIONnEarly control of incipient or established hydrocephalus and aggressive surgical management where appropriate, with careful postoperative monitoring, is necessary for good outcome in patients with civilian infratentorial missile injuries.

Home-made gun injury: spontaneous version and anterior migration of bullet

We report a unique case of a self-inflicted brain injury using an ingenious home-made gun with spontaneous anterior migration of the intact bullet. On admission, the patient was fully conscious with no neurological deficits. Computed tomography (CT) confirmed a penetrating missile injury with transventricular across midline trajectory and multi-lobe injury with the bullet lodged in the occipital lobe. Serial CT revealed spontaneous version with anterior migration of the bullet from the occipital lobe to finally come to rest in the ipsilateral frontobasal region. The bullet was removed via a left supra-orbital craniotomy. The patient experienced good outcome. Home-made gun injuries, although uncommon today, represent a special form of missile injury with unique low velocity terminal ballistics. As these weapons are seen infrequently today, surgeons should be alerted to their existence as patients with this form of injury usually have a good prognosis if vital brain structures are spared.

Traumatic cranial empyemas: a review of 55 patients

A 15-year (1983-1997) review of our units computed tomographic experience with traumatic cranial empyema (TCE) is reported. Fifty-five patients with documented history and clinical evidence of neurotrauma with secondary cranial empyema at surgery were identified. The clinical records and CT scans were analysed. TCE [four extradural and 51 subdural collections (SDE)] accounted for 7.86% of the total cranial empyemas seen during the study period. Most of the patients were young males (44 patients) and neurological deficits on admission were found only in the SDE group. Forty-one of 53 patients presented with septic compound skull fractures. Fifty-four patients had urgent surgical drainage. Eighty per cent of patients experienced a good outcome (GOS 4 or 5). A morbidity of 16.4% (including postoperative seizures) was noted and eight patients died (mortality rate 14.5%). Urgent surgical drainage, removal of osteitic bone, wound debridement and high dose intravenous antibiotic therapy form the mainstay of treatment.A 15-year (1983-1997) review of our units computed tomographic experience with traumatic cranial empyema (TCE) is reported. Fifty-five patients with documented history and clinical evidence of neurotrauma with secondary cranial empyema at surgery were identified. The clinical records and CT scans were analysed. TCE [four extradural and 51 subdural collections (SDE)] accounted for 7.86% of the total cranial empyemas seen during the study period. Most of the patients were young males (44 patients) and neurological deficits on admission were found only in the SDE group. Forty-one of 53 patients presented with septic compound skull fractures. Fifty-four patients had urgent surgical drainage. Eighty per cent of patients experienced a good outcome (GOS 4 or 5). A morbidity of 16.4% (including postoperative seizures) was noted and eight patients died (mortality rate 14.5%). Urgent surgical drainage, removal of osteitic bone, wound debridement and high dose intravenous antibiotic therapy form the mainstay of treatment.