Nathan T. Harvey

Squamoproliferative lesions arising in the setting of BRAF inhibition.

Abstract:In recent years, there has been increasing use of several novel agents that specifically target the V600E BRAF mutation in melanoma and other malignancies. One significant side effect of these drugs is the development of cutaneous squamoproliferative lesions, variously described as keratoacanthomas (KAs) and well-differentiated squamous cell carcinomas. We undertook a histopathological review of lesions excised from patients on BRAF inhibitor therapy, and found that 73% of lesions were squamoproliferative in nature. Of these, 33% met histologic criteria for a diagnosis of keratoacanthoma, whereas 43% showed features more in keeping with verruca vulgaris and were designated as BRAF inhibitor associated verrucous keratosis. To our knowledge this represents the first detailed histological analysis of the squamoproliferative lesions which arise in the context of treatment with BRAF inhibitors, and highlights the morphological diversity of these lesions. With the ongoing success of these drugs in clinical trials, these lesions are likely to be more often encountered in routine dermatopathology practice.

Immunohistochemical staining for p16 is a useful adjunctive test in the diagnosis of Bowen’s disease

Aims: The aim of this study was to document the pattern of immunohistochemical staining seen with p16 (INK4a) in actinic keratosis, Bowens disease and seborrhoeic keratosis. Methods: We gathered 20 examples each of actinic keratosis, Bowens disease and seborrheic keratosis. The cases were stained for p16 using standard immunohistochemical techniques, and the staining patterns were categorised into one of five different patterns. Results: All cases of Bowens disease as defined in our practice showed strong positive staining in all abnormal cells, and 95% of these cases showed a distinctive pattern of sparing in a layer of palisaded basal cells. None of the actinic keratoses or seborrheic keratoses, as defined by our morphological criteria, showed this distinctive pattern. Conclusions: Bowens disease, as we define the term, shows a distinctive, repeatable pattern of staining with p16, characterised by moderate to strong staining of all abnormal cells with sparing of a layer of basal cells. This pattern is not seen in actinic keratoses or in seborrheic keratoses. Thus immunohistochemistry for p16 is a useful adjunctive test in the differential diagnosis of these lesions.

Interobserver variability in the diagnosis of circumscribed sebaceous neoplasms of the skin

Aims: Separation of sebaceous adenoma, sebaceoma and well differentiated sebaceous carcinoma is a clinically important distinction which relies on a number of subjective criteria. In routine practice we had noted significant interobserver variability in the classification of these lesions. This study sought to determine the degree of interobserver variability between general surgical pathologists and dermatopathologists in the diagnosis of well differentiated cutaneous sebaceous neoplasms. Methods: We circulated 61 examples of well circumscribed cutaneous sebaceous neoplasms to nine pathologists, including dermatopathologists and general surgical pathologists who were asked to submit a diagnosis for each case. Fleiss’ kappa statistic was used for assessment of interobserver agreement. Results: We found that only seven cases (11%) had consensus agreement across all nine pathologists. Many cases had multiple diagnoses suggested, with three or more submitted diagnoses in 26 cases (43%), while 38 cases (62%) were diagnosed as sebaceous carcinoma by at least one pathologist. There was marked variability amongst the individual pathologists in the proportion of cases diagnosed as carcinoma, ranging from 5% to 57% of cases. Fleiss’ kappa statistic for all pathologists across all diagnostic categories was 0.44, amounting to only fair to moderate agreement. Conclusions: These data indicate that there is substantial interobserver variability in the diagnosis of well circumscribed sebaceous neoplasms. This was seen in both the separation of benign and malignant lesions, as well as in the classification of the benign entities. This interobserver variability is likely to have significant clinical implications in terms of potential for over- or under-treatment, as well as in selection of cases for mismatch repair protein evaluation.

Merkel cell Polyomavirus and p63 status in Merkel cell carcinoma by immunohistocnemistry: Merkel cell Polyomavirus positivity is inversely correlated with sun damage, but neither is correlated with outcome

Summary The aim of this study was to determine the frequency of Merkel cell polyomavirus (MPyV) and p63 positivity by immunohistochemistry in a large cohort of primary Merkel cell carcinoma (MCC) from a region with high rates of actinic damage. We also aimed to determine whether there is any relationship between these markers and histological correlates of chronic sun exposure and to identify whether these markers have prognostic significance in our population. Ninety-five cases of primary cutaneous MCC were identified and stained with immunohistochemical markers for MPyV and p63. The presence of solar elastosis and squamous dysplasia in the overlying/adjacent skin were recorded as markers of actinic damage. Follow up data were obtained from the Western Australian Cancer Registry. MPyV was detected by immunohistochemistry in 23% of cases. There was a statistically significantly lower rate of positivity in tumours associated with markers of chronic sun damage as assessed by the presence of solar elastosis and squamous dysplasia. There was no association with overall or disease specific survival. p63 positivity was detected in 17% of cases. There was no association with markers of actinic damage or with overall or disease specific survival. Our data demonstrate a significant difference in rates of immunohistochemical positivity for MPyV between MCC in sun-damaged and non-sun-damaged sites. This may go some way to explaining previously identified geographical differences. When compared with a number of studies from Europe and North America, p63 positivity is less common in our population and does not show the strong prognostic significance that has been found in these other regions.

Circumscribed sebaceous neoplasms: a morphological, immunohistochemical and molecular analysis

Sebaceous neoplasms encompass a range of lesions, including benign entities such as sebaceous adenoma and sebaceoma, as well as sebaceous carcinoma. The distinction of sebaceous carcinoma from benign lesions relies on histological identification of architectural or cytological features of malignancy. In this study we have assessed the diagnostic discriminatory ability of mitotic rate and immunohistochemical markers (p53, bcl-2 and p16) in a selected group of well circumscribed sebaceous neoplasms, incorporating examples of sebaceous adenoma, sebaceoma and sebaceous carcinoma. We found that mitotic rate was significantly higher in malignant lesions as compared to benign lesions, but none of the immunohistochemical markers showed a discriminatory expression pattern. In addition, we performed a mutational analysis on the same group of lesions using next generation sequencing (NGS) technology. The most commonly mutated gene was TP53, although there was no correlation between the p53 immunohistochemical results and number or type of TP53 mutation detected. CDKN2A, EGFR, CTNNB1 and KRAS were also commonly mutated across all lesions. No particular gene, mutation profile or individual mutation could be identified which directly correlated with the consensus histological diagnosis. In conclusion, within this diagnostically challenging group of lesions, mitotic activity, but not immunohistochemical labelling for p16 or bcl-2, correlates with diagnostic category. While a number of genes potentially involved in the genesis of sebaceous neoplasia were uncovered, any molecular differences between the histological diagnostic categories remain unclear.

Detection of copy number variations in melanocytic lesions utilising array based comparative genomic hybridisation

Distinction between melanocytic naevi and melanoma occasionally poses a diagnostic challenge in ambiguous cases showing overlapping histological features. Melanomas are characterised by the presence of multiple genomic copy number variants (CNVs), while this is not a feature of naevi. We assessed the feasibility and utility of array-based comparative genomic hybridisation (aCGH) to assess CNVs in melanocytic lesions. DNA was extracted from formalin fixed, paraffin embedded (FFPE) sections of unambiguous naevi (n=19) and melanomas (n=19). The test DNA and gender mismatched human reference DNA were differentially labelled with fluorophores. Equal quantities of the two DNA samples were mixed and co-hybridised to a SurePrint G3 Human CGH 8x60K array, and digitally scanned to capture and quantify the relative fluorescence intensities. The ratio of the fluorescence intensities was analysed by Cytogenomics software (Agilent). Frequent large CNVs were identified in 94.7% of melanoma samples, including losses of 9p (73.6%), 9q (52.6%), 10q (36.8%), 11q (36.8%), 3p (21%), and 10p (21%), and gains of 6p (42.1%), 7p (42.1%), 1q (36.8%), 8q (31.5%) and 20q (21%). Only one naevus showed two large copy number changes. Overall aCGH showed a specificity and sensitivity of 94.7% in separating naevi from melanomas. Based on our results, aCGH can be successfully used to analyse CNVs of melanocytic lesions utilising FFPE derived biopsy samples, providing a potentially useful adjunctive test for the classification of diagnostically challenging melanocytic proliferations.

Basal cell carcinosarcoma: a report of 4 cases and review of the literature.

Background:To describe the features of 4 cases of basal cell carcinosarcoma and systematically review previously reported cases. Methods:Four cases of basal cell carcinosarcoma were identified from the practice of the authors. A search of the literature revealed an additional 40 cases, variously described in small series and single case reports. The clinical and pathological features of these 44 cases are described. Results:Basal cell carcinosarcoma is largely a tumor of elderly men (male:female 3:1, average age: 76 years). The majority of these lesions are relatively small (<25 mm). Heterologous elements are common, particularly an osteosarcomatous component, which is present in 45% of cases. Although there are relatively limited follow-up data, only 1 case formally reported in the literature has shown distant metastasis. Conclusions:Despite relatively high reported rates of local recurrence and metastasis for “carcinosarcoma” as an unrefined entity, it seems that the subgroup of basal cell carcinosarcoma has a relatively good prognosis, with adequate local excision being curative in the majority of cases. Recognition of this entity is critical for accurate diagnosis and its separation from other types of carcinosarcoma may have significant prognostic implications.

Histopathological features associated with application of black salve to cutaneous lesions: A series of 16 cases and review of the literature

Aims: To document the histopathological features of self-treatment of cutaneous lesions with the escharotic agent black salve. Methods: Retrospective review of cutaneous lesions treated with black salve retrieved from the files of four pathology practices in Western Australia and review of the published literature. Results: 16 lesions from 11 patients who self administered black salve for the treatment of skin lesions were reviewed. Clinical diagnoses at the time of biopsy included scar, keloid scar, pseudomelanoma, basal cell carcinoma, squamous cell carcinoma and cutaneous necrosis. Histopathological features identified in our series included scarring, granulomatous inflammation, implanted foreign material, reactive stromal atypia and suppurative necrosis. Residual neoplasia was present in two of 16 cases, including a basal cell carcinoma and a melanocytic naevus. An additional 13 lesions in 10 patients were identified in the medical literature, including cases with poor cosmetic outcomes and cases of malignant tumours masked by uncontrolled escharotic treatment. Conclusions: Availability of black salve through easily accessible internet sites appears to be associated with persisting use of this agent for the self-management of cutaneous lesions. Awareness of the potential complications and range of histopathological features associated with self-administration of escharotic agents is of importance to dermatologists and histopathologists.

Paediatric cutaneous adnexal tumours: a study of 559 cases

Cutaneous adnexal tumours encompass a wide group of lesions with apocrine, eccrine, follicular, sebaceous and mixed differentiation. The large majority are benign and represent sporadic lesions, though malignant forms are occasionally encountered and some cases develop in the setting of inherited tumour syndromes. Accurate histological classification can be difficult as there are numerous histological appearances, many of which are individually uncommon, and complex, overlapping and historically variable nomenclature is typical. The aim of this study was to review and classify the spectrum of cutaneous adnexal tumours seen in patients 18 years of age and under in two major tertiary centres over a 20 year period. A total of 559 cases were included, with 60% occurring in female patients. The large majority (87%) occurred in the head and neck region and were benign. Only one (0.2%) was malignant. The original diagnosis was supported by histological review in 99% of cases of pilomatricoma reviewed, but in only 71% of non-pilomatricoma cases reviewed. The most common lineage was follicular (97%), with pilomatricoma accounting for the large majority of lesions. Predominant glandular/ductal differentiation was seen in 3% of cases, with no tumours showing predominant sebaceous differentiation.

Cutaneous Metastatic Melanoma Resembling a Halo Nevus, in the Setting of PD-1 Inhibition

Malignant melanoma is a common source of cutaneous metastases and can occasionally adopt a histological appearance which mimics a primary melanocytic lesion, either benign or malignant. The authors describe a case of new cutaneous deposits of metastatic melanoma in a 70-year-old woman with a prominent admixed lymphocytic infiltrate, imparting a striking resemblance to a halo nevus. The authors believe this appearance was a direct reflection of treatment with pembrolizumab, a humanized antibody against the immune checkpoint inhibitor programmed death-1. With increasing use of immune-modulating drugs, this potential histological mimic may be seen more frequently in the future.