Nicolas A. Batara

Phototropic growth control of nanoscale pattern formation in photoelectrodeposited Se–Te films

Significance Phototropism, in which plants grow toward a source of illumination, uses dynamic feedback between the light source and photosensitive hormones within the plant to direct the curvature of the plant as it grows. In this manuscript, we describe an adaptive inorganic system that dynamically alters its emergent nanoscale morphology in response to changes in the illumination conditions during growth. Phototropic growth control of nanoscale pattern formation in photoelectrodeposited selenium–tellurium films provides the ability to grow nanostructures of entirely different geometries, periods, and directions abruptly on top of one another, and the ability to change the physical growth direction of the material by changing the direction of the incident light beam. Photoresponsive materials that adapt their morphologies, growth directions, and growth rates dynamically in response to the local incident electromagnetic field would provide a remarkable route to the synthesis of complex 3D mesostructures via feedback between illumination and the structure that develops under optical excitation. We report the spontaneous development of ordered, nanoscale lamellar patterns in electrodeposited selenium–tellurium (Se–Te) alloy films grown under noncoherent, uniform illumination on unpatterned substrates in an isotropic electrolyte solution. These inorganic nanostructures exhibited phototropic growth in which lamellar stripes grew toward the incident light source, adopted an orientation parallel to the light polarization direction with a period controlled by the illumination wavelength, and showed an increased growth rate with increasing light intensity. Furthermore, the patterns responded dynamically to changes during growth in the polarization, wavelength, and angle of the incident light, enabling the template-free and pattern-free synthesis, on a variety of substrates, of woodpile, spiral, branched, or zigzag structures, along with dynamically directed growth toward a noncoherent, uniform intensity light source. Full-wave electromagnetic simulations in combination with Monte Carlo growth simulations were used to model light–matter interactions in the Se–Te films and produced a model for the morphological evolution of the lamellar structures under phototropic growth conditions. The experiments and simulations are consistent with a phototropic growth mechanism in which the optical near-field intensity profile selects and reinforces the dominant morphological mode in the emergent nanoscale patterns.

Self-Optimizing Photoelectrochemical Growth of Nanopatterned Se-Te Films in Response to the Spectral Distribution of Incident Illumination.

Photoelectrochemical growth of Se-Te films spontaneously produces highly ordered, nanoscale lamellar morphologies with periodicities that can be tuned by varying the illumination wavelength during deposition. This phenomenon has been characterized further herein by determining the morphologies of photoelectrodeposited Se-Te films in response to tailored spectral illumination profiles. Se-Te films grown under illumination from four different sources, having similar average wavelengths but having spectral bandwidths that spanned several orders of magnitude, all nevertheless produced similar structures which had a single, common periodicity as quantitatively identified via Fourier analysis. Film deposition using simultaneous illumination from two narrowband sources, which differed in average wavelength by several hundred nanometers, resulted in a structure with only a single periodicity intermediate between the periods observed when either source alone was used. This single periodicity could be varied by manipulating the relative intensity of the two sources. An iterative model that combined full-wave electromagnetic effects with Monte Carlo growth simulations, and that considered only the fundamental light-material interactions during deposition, was in accord with the morphologies observed experimentally. Simulations of light absorption and concentration in idealized lamellar arrays, in conjunction with all of the available data, additionally indicated that a self-optimization of the periodicity of the nanoscale pattern, resulting in the maximization of the anisotropy of interfacial light absorption in the three-dimensional structure, is consistent with the observed growth process of such films.

Morphological Expression of the Coherence and Relative Phase of Optical Inputs to the Photoelectrodeposition of Nanopatterned Se-Te Films

Highly anisotropic and ordered nanoscale lamellar morphologies can be spontaneously generated over macroscopic areas, without the use of a photomask or any templating agents, via the photoelectrodeposition of Se-Te alloy films. To form such structures, the light source can be a single, linearly polarized light source that need not necessarily be highly coherent. In this work, the variation in the morphologies produced by this deposition process was evaluated in response to differences in the coherence and relative phase between multiple simultaneous linearly polarized illumination inputs. Specifically, the morphologies of photoelectrodeposits were evaluated when two tandem same-wavelength sources with discrete linear polarizations, both either mutually incoherent or mutually coherent (with defined phase differences), were used. Additionally, morphologies were simulated via computer modeling of the interfacial light scattering and absorption during the photoelectrochemical growth process. The morphologies that were generated using two coherent, in-phase sources were equivalent to those generated using only a single source. In contrast, the use of two coherent, out-of-phase sources produced a range of morphological patterns. For small out-of-phase addition of orthogonal polarization components, lamellar-type patterns were observed. When fully out-of-phase orthogonal sources (circular polarization) were used, an isotropic, mesh-type pattern was instead generated, similar to that observed when unpolarized illumination was utilized. In intermediate cases, anisotropic lamellar-type patterns were superimposed on the isotropic mesh-type patterns, and the relative height between the two structures scaled with the amount of out-of-phase addition of the orthogonal polarization components. Similar results were obtained when two incoherent sources were utilized. In every case, the long axis of the lamellar-type morphology component aligned parallel to the intensity-weighted average polarization orientation. The observations consistently agreed with computer simulations, indicating that the observed morphologies were fully determined by the nature of the illumination utilized during the growth process. The collective data thus indicated that the photoelectrodeposition process exhibits sensitivity toward the coherency, relative phase, and polarization orientations of all optical inputs and that this sensitivity is physically expressed in the morphology of the deposit.

Polarization Control of Morphological Pattern Orientation During Light-Mediated Synthesis of Nanostructured Se–Te Films

The template-free growth of well ordered, highly anisotropic lamellar structures has been demonstrated during the photoelectrodeposition of Se-Te films, wherein the orientation of the pattern can be directed by orienting the linear polarization of the incident light. This control mechanism was investigated further herein by examining the morphologies of films grown photoelectrochemically using light from two simultaneous sources that had mutually different linear polarizations. Photoelectrochemical growth with light from two nonorthogonally polarized same-wavelength sources generated lamellar morphologies in which the long axes of the lamellae were oriented parallel to the intensity-weighted average polarization orientation. Simulations of light scattering at the solution-film interface were consistent with this observation. Computer modeling of these growths using combined full-wave electromagnetic and Monte Carlo growth simulations successfully reproduced the experimental morphologies and quantitatively agreed with the pattern orientations observed experimentally by considering only the fundamental light-material interactions during growth. Deposition with light from two orthogonally polarized same-wavelength as well as different-wavelength sources produced structures that consisted of two intersecting sets of orthogonally oriented lamellae in which the relative heights of the two sets could be varied by adjusting the relative source intensities. Simulations of light absorption were performed in analogous, idealized intersecting lamellar structures and revealed that the lamellae preferentially absorbed light polarized with the electric field vector along their long axes. These data sets cumulatively indicate that anisotropic light scattering and light absorption generated by the light polarization produces the anisotropic morphology and that the resultant morphology is a function of all illumination inputs despite differing polarizations.

Template-Free Synthesis of Periodic Three-Dimensional PbSe Nanostructures via Photoelectrodeposition

Highly periodic, geometrically directed, anisotropic Se-Pb films have been synthesized at room temperature from an isotropic aqueous solution without the use of physical templates by photoelectrodeposition using a series of discrete input illumination polarizations and wavelengths from an unstructured, uncorrelated, incoherent light source. Dark growth did not generate deposits with substantial long-range order, but growth using unpolarized illumination resulted in an ordered, nanoscale, mesh-type morphology. Linearly polarized illumination generated Se-Pb deposits that displayed an ordered, highly anisotropic lamellar pattern wherein the long axes of the lamellae were aligned parallel to the light polarization vector. The pitch of the lamellar features was proportional to the input light wavelength, as confirmed by Fourier analysis. Full-wave electromagnetic and Monte Carlo growth simulations that incorporated only the fundamental light-matter interactions during growth successfully reproduced the experimentally observed morphologies and quantitatively matched the pattern periodicities. Electrochemical postprocessing of the as-deposited Se-Pb structures resulted in the generation of stoichiometric, crystalline PbSe while preserving the nanopatterned morphology, thus broadening the genus of materials that can be prepared with controlled three-dimensional morphologies through maskless photoelectrodeposition.