Nicolas Chatron

Mutations in GABRB3: From febrile seizures to epileptic encephalopathies

Objective: To examine the role of mutations in GABRB3 encoding the β3 subunit of the GABAA receptor in individual patients with epilepsy with regard to causality, the spectrum of genetic variants, their pathophysiology, and associated phenotypes. Methods: We performed massive parallel sequencing of GABRB3 in 416 patients with a range of epileptic encephalopathies and childhood-onset epilepsies and recruited additional patients with epilepsy with GABRB3 mutations from other research and diagnostic programs. Results: We identified 22 patients with heterozygous mutations in GABRB3, including 3 probands from multiplex families. The phenotypic spectrum of the mutation carriers ranged from simple febrile seizures, genetic epilepsies with febrile seizures plus, and epilepsy with myoclonic-atonic seizures to West syndrome and other types of severe, early-onset epileptic encephalopathies. Electrophysiologic analysis of 7 mutations in Xenopus laevis oocytes, using coexpression of wild-type or mutant β3, together with α5 and γ2s subunits and an automated 2-microelectrode voltage-clamp system, revealed reduced GABA-induced current amplitudes or GABA sensitivity for 5 of 7 mutations. Conclusions: Our results indicate that GABRB3 mutations are associated with a broad phenotypic spectrum of epilepsies and that reduced receptor function causing GABAergic disinhibition represents the relevant disease mechanism.

Refinement of genotype-phenotype correlation in 18 patients carrying a 1q24q25 deletion

Interstitial deletion 1q24q25 is a rare rearrangement associated with intellectual disability, growth retardation, abnormal extremities and facial dysmorphism. In this study, we describe the largest series reported to date, including 18 patients (4M/14F) aged from 2 days to 67 years and comprising two familial cases. The patients presented with a characteristic phenotype including mild to moderate intellectual disability (100%), intrauterine (92%) and postnatal (94%) growth retardation, microcephaly (77%), short hands and feet (83%), brachydactyly (70%), fifth finger clinodactyly (78%) and facial dysmorphism with a bulbous nose (72%), abnormal ears (67%) and micrognathia (56%). Other findings were abnormal palate (50%), single transverse palmar crease (53%), renal (38%), cardiac (38%), and genital (23%) malformations. The deletions were characterized by chromosome microarray. They were of different sizes (490 kb to 20.95 Mb) localized within chromosome bands 1q23.3–q31.2 (chr1:160797550–192912120, hg19). The 490 kb deletion is the smallest deletion reported to date associated with this phenotype. We delineated three regions that may contribute to the phenotype: a proximal one (chr1:164,501,003–167,022,133), associated with cardiac and renal anomalies, a distal one (chr1:178,514,910–181,269,712) and an intermediate 490 kb region (chr1:171970575–172460683, hg19), deleted in the most of the patients, and containing DNM3, MIR3120 and MIR214 that may play an important role in the phenotype. However, this genetic region seems complex with multiple regions giving rise to the same phenotype.

Novel homozygous missense variant of GRIN1 in two sibs with intellectual disability and autistic features without epilepsy

We report on two consanguineous sibs affected with severe intellectual disability and autistic features due to a homozygous missense variant of GRIN1. Massive parallel sequencing was performed using a gene panel including 450 genes related to intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorders. We found a homozygous missense variation of GRIN1 (c.679G>C; p.(Asp227His)) in the two affected sibs, which was inherited from both unaffected heterozygous parents. Heterozygous variants of GRIN1, encoding the GluN1 subunit of the NMDA receptor, have been reported in patients with neurodevelopmental disorders including epileptic encephalopathy, severe intellectual disability, and movement disorders. The p.(Asp227His) variant is located in the same aminoterminal protein domain as the recently published p.(Arg217Trp), which was found at the homozygous state in two patients with a similar phenotype of severe intellectual disability and autistic features but without epilepsy. In silico predictions were consistent with a deleterious effect. The present findings further expand the clinical spectrum of GRIN1 variants and support the existence of hypomorphic variants causing severe neurodevelopmental impairment with autosomal recessive inheritance.

Comparison of two next-generation sequencing kits for diagnosis of epileptic disorders with a user-friendly tool for displaying gene coverage, DeCovA

In recent years, molecular genetics has been playing an increasing role in the diagnostic process of monogenic epilepsies. Knowing the genetic basis of one patients epilepsy provides accurate genetic counseling and may guide therapeutic options. Genetic diagnosis of epilepsy syndromes has long been based on Sanger sequencing and search for large rearrangements using MLPA or DNA arrays (array-CGH or SNP-array). Recently, next-generation sequencing (NGS) was demonstrated to be a powerful approach to overcome the wide clinical and genetic heterogeneity of epileptic disorders. Coverage is critical for assessing the quality and accuracy of results from NGS. However, it is often a difficult parameter to display in practice. The aim of the study was to compare two library-building methods (Haloplex, Agilent and SeqCap EZ, Roche) for a targeted panel of 41 genes causing monogenic epileptic disorders. We included 24 patients, 20 of whom had known disease-causing mutations. For each patient both libraries were built in parallel and sequenced on an Ion Torrent Personal Genome Machine (PGM). To compare coverage and depth, we developed a simple homemade tool, named DeCovA (Depth and Coverage Analysis). DeCovA displays the sequencing depth of each base and the coverage of target genes for each genomic position. The fraction of each gene covered at different thresholds could be easily estimated. None of the two methods used, namely NextGene and Ion Reporter, were able to identify all the known mutations/CNVs displayed by the 20 patients. Variant detection rate was globally similar for the two techniques and DeCovA showed that failure to detect a mutation was mainly related to insufficient coverage.

The epilepsy phenotypic spectrum associated with a recurrent CUX2 variant: CUX2 and Epilepsy With Intellectual Disability

Cut homeodomain transcription factor CUX2 plays an important role in dendrite branching, spine development, and synapse formation in layer II to III neurons of the cerebral cortex. We identify a recurrent de novo CUX2 p.Glu590Lys as a novel genetic cause for developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (DEE).

Electrical status epilepticus in sleep, a constitutive feature of Christianson syndrome?

Christianson syndrome (CS) is a X-linked neurodevelopmental disorder, including severe intellectual disability (ID), progressive microcephaly, ataxia, autistic behaviour (ASD), near absent speech, and epilepsy. Electrical status epilepticus in sleep (ESES) has been reported in two patients. We describe five male patients from three unrelated families with Christianson syndrome caused by a pathogenic nucleotide variation or a copy-number variation involving SLC9A6. ESES was present in three out of the five patients in the critical age window between 4 and 8 years. All patients presented with severe intellectual disability, autistic features, and hyperactivity. Epilepsy onset occurred within the first two years of life. Seizures were of various types. In the two boys with a 20-years follow-up, epilepsy was drug-resistant during childhood, and became less active in early adolescence. Psychomotor regression was noted in two patients presenting with ESES. It was difficult to assess to what extent ESES could have contributed to the pathophysiological process, leading to regression of the already very limited communication skills. The two published case reports and our observation suggests that ESES could be a constitutive feature of Christianson syndrome, as it has already been shown for other Mendelian epileptic disorders, such as GRIN2A and CNKSR2-related developmental epileptic encephalopathies. Sleep EEG should be performed in patients with Christianson syndrome between 4 and 8 years of age. ESES occurring in the context of ID, ASD and severe speech delay, could be helpful to make a diagnosis of CS.

Genetic Counselling Pitfall: Co-Occurrence of an 11.8-Mb Xp22 Duplication and an Xp21.2 Duplication Disrupting IL1RAPL1

We report a 3-generation family in which 2 Xp copy number variations (CNVs) co-segregate. The proband presented with syndromic intellectual disability. The CNV had been revealed by conventional karyotyping, identifying a large Xp22 duplication causing an Xp functional disomy. Family studies found that this duplication was inherited from the probands mother and was also present in one of his sisters. This sister had conventional karyotyping performed during pregnancy with a normal result. Postnatally, her child, the probands nephew, presented with autism spectrum disorders. aCGH revealed a 339-kb IL1RAPL1 duplication. Overall, the proband, his mother, and one of his sisters all harboured both CNVs, while his other sister and the 2 sons of each sister only carried the IL1RAPL1 intragenic duplication. As seen in this family, we emphasise the importance of small CNV detection, the pathogenicity of IL1RAPL1 exonic duplications in male carriers, and the difficulties for genetic counselling with the risk of double diagnosis in a single patient.