Nils Lachmann

Consensus guidelines on the testing and clinical management issues associated with HLA and non-HLA antibodies in transplantation.

Background The introduction of solid-phase immunoassay (SPI) technology for the detection and characterization of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies in transplantation while providing greater sensitivity than was obtainable by complement-dependent lymphocytotoxicity (CDC) assays has resulted in a new paradigm with respect to the interpretation of donor-specific antibodies (DSA). Although the SPI assay performed on the Luminex instrument (hereafter referred to as the Luminex assay), in particular, has permitted the detection of antibodies not detectable by CDC, the clinical significance of these antibodies is incompletely understood. Nevertheless, the detection of these antibodies has led to changes in the clinical management of sensitized patients. In addition, SPI testing raises technical issues that require resolution and careful consideration when interpreting antibody results. Methods With this background, The Transplantation Society convened a group of laboratory and clinical experts in the field of transplantation to prepare a consensus report and make recommendations on the use of this new technology based on both published evidence and expert opinion. Three working groups were formed to address (a) the technical issues with respect to the use of this technology, (b) the interpretation of pretransplantation antibody testing in the context of various clinical settings and organ transplant types (kidney, heart, lung, liver, pancreas, intestinal, and islet cells), and (c) the application of antibody testing in the posttransplantation setting. The three groups were established in November 2011 and convened for a “Consensus Conference on Antibodies in Transplantation” in Rome, Italy, in May 2012. The deliberations of the three groups meeting independently and then together are the bases for this report. Results A comprehensive list of recommendations was prepared by each group. A summary of the key recommendations follows. Technical Group: (a) SPI must be used for the detection of pretransplantation HLA antibodies in solid organ transplant recipients and, in particular, the use of the single-antigen bead assay to detect antibodies to HLA loci, such as Cw, DQA, DPA, and DPB, which are not readily detected by other methods. (b) The use of SPI for antibody detection should be supplemented with cell-based assays to examine the correlations between the two types of assays and to establish the likelihood of a positive crossmatch (XM). (c) There must be an awareness of the technical factors that can influence the results and their clinical interpretation when using the Luminex bead technology, such as variation in antigen density and the presence of denatured antigen on the beads. Pretransplantation Group: (a) Risk categories should be established based on the antibody and the XM results obtained. (b) DSA detected by CDC and a positive XM should be avoided due to their strong association with antibody-mediated rejection and graft loss. (c) A renal transplantation can be performed in the absence of a prospective XM if single-antigen bead screening for antibodies to all class I and II HLA loci is negative. This decision, however, needs to be taken in agreement with local clinical programs and the relevant regulatory bodies. (d) The presence of DSA HLA antibodies should be avoided in heart and lung transplantation and considered a risk factor for liver, intestinal, and islet cell transplantation. Posttransplantation Group: (a) High-risk patients (i.e., desensitized or DSA positive/XM negative) should be monitored by measurement of DSA and protocol biopsies in the first 3 months after transplantation. (b) Intermediate-risk patients (history of DSA but currently negative) should be monitored for DSA within the first month. If DSA is present, a biopsy should be performed. (c) Low-risk patients (nonsensitized first transplantation) should be screened for DSA at least once 3 to 12 months after transplantation. If DSA is detected, a biopsy should be performed. In all three categories, the recommendations for subsequent treatment are based on the biopsy results. Conclusions A comprehensive list of recommendations is provided covering the technical and pretransplantation and posttransplantation monitoring of HLA antibodies in solid organ transplantation. The recommendations are intended to provide state-of-the-art guidance in the use and clinical application of recently developed methods for HLA antibody detection when used in conjunction with traditional methods.

Anti-human leukocyte antigen and donor-specific antibodies detected by luminex posttransplant serve as biomarkers for chronic rejection of renal allografts.

Background. Although the incidence of early acute rejection could have been diminished in the past, the long-term renal allograft survival could not benefit from the introduction of more effective immunosuppressive regimens mainly aiming at cellular rejection mechanisms. The cause of chronic rejection is still discussed controversially. Here, we demonstrate to what extent human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (HLAab) posttransplant contribute to late graft outcome. Methods. A total of 1014 deceased kidney transplant recipients transplanted at the Charité hospital were monitored in a cross-sectional manner for the development of HLAab using Luminex Single Antigen beads. Patients with stable kidney function at a median of 5-years posttransplant were tested once for HLAab and monitored for 5.5 years after testing. Results. Thirty percent of recipients showed HLAab. Donor-specific antibodies (DSA) were found in 31% of antibody positive patients. The presence of DSA was associated with a significantly lower graft survival of 49% vs. 83% in the HLAab negative group (P≤0.0001). Non-DSAs also had an adverse effect on graft survival (70% vs. 83%; P=0.0001). In a prospective analysis of 195 patients with repeatedly no detectable HLAab, the survival probability was 94% as opposed to 79% survival among patients who developed HLAab de novo after the first testing (P=0.05). Conclusions. We confirmed that HLAab produced even late after transplantation are detrimental to graft outcome. DSA were proven to have a strong adverse impact on graft survival. The results indicate that a posttransplant HLAab monitoring routine could be appropriate to improve long-term results.

Donor‐Specific HLA Antibodies in a Cohort Comparing Everolimus With Cyclosporine After Kidney Transplantation

Donor‐specific HLA antibodies (DSA) have a negative impact on kidney graft survival. Therefore, we analyzed the occurrence of DSA and antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) in patients from two prospective randomized trials in our center. At 3–4.5 months posttransplant 127 patients were randomized to continue cyclosporine or converted to everolimus therapy. The presence of DSA was prospectively assessed using Luminex assays. AMR was defined according to the Banff 2009 classification. Antibody screening was available in 126 patients with a median follow‐up of 1059 days. Seven out of 65 (10.8%) patients on cyclosporine developed DSA after a median of 991 days. In comparison, 14/61 patients (23.0%) randomized to everolimus developed DSA after 551 days (log‐rank: p = 0.048). Eight patients on everolimus compared to two patients on cyclosporine developed AMR (log‐rank: p = 0.036). Four of 10 patients with AMR—all in the everolimus group—lost their graft. A multivariate regression model revealed everolimus, >3 mismatches and living donor as significant risk factors for DSA. Acute rejection within the first year, >3 mismatches, everolimus and living donor were independent risk factors for AMR. This single center analysis demonstrates for the first time that everolimus‐based immunosuppression is associated with an increased risk for the development of DSA and AMR.

Comparison between bortezomib and rituximab in the treatment of antibody-mediated renal allograft rejection

BACKGROUND Antibody-mediated rejection (ABMR) following kidney transplantation is associated with poor allograft survival. Conventional treatment based on plasmapheresis (PPH) and the administration of intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIG) is not satisfactory. Two compounds, more specifically targeting B cells and plasma cells, may help to improve the prognosis: rituximab, a B-cell-depleting monoclonal antibody, and bortezomib, a proteasome inhibitor causing apoptosis of plasma cells. METHODS Starting in February 2009, we treated 10 consecutive patients with ABMR according to current Banff criteria with one cycle of bortezomib [1.3 mg/m(2) intravenously (i.v.), Day 1, 4, 8, 11]. This group was compared to a historical control group of patients (n = 9) treated with a fixed single dose of rituximab (500 mg i.v.). All patients received PPH (6×) and IVIG (30 g). Patients with acute ABMR additionally received methylprednisolone (3 × 500 mg i.v.). RESULTS Patient survival in both groups was 100%. At 18 months after treatment, graft survival was 6/10 in the bortezomib group as compared to 1/9 functioning grafts in the rituximab group (P = 0.071). Renal function was superior in patients treated with bortezomib as compared to rituximab-treated patients (serum creatinine at 9 months: 2.5 ± 0.6 versus 5.1 ± 2.1 mg/dL, P = 0.008). Proteinuria was not different between both groups (9 months: 1.3 ± 1.0 versus 1.6 ± 1.6 g/day, P = n.s.). CONCLUSIONS Treatment of ABMR with bortezomib in addition to standard therapy was partially effective, whereas treatment with a fixed dose of rituximab in addition to standard therapy with PPH and IVIG did not result in sufficient long-term graft survival. In the future, new strategies including the combination of both substances and the application of higher doses must be discussed.

Intact HLA Not β2m-free Heavy Chain-Specific HLA Class I Antibodies Are Predictive of Graft Failure

Background. We investigated the effects of intact and &bgr;2m-free heavy chain (HC)-specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I antibodies on long-term graft survival. Methods. HLA class I mixed antigen beads were used to detect intact and &bgr;2m-free HC-specific antibodies, whereas elution buffer-treated beads were used to detect antibodies against &bgr;2m-free HC. Donor-specific antibodies (DSAs) were identified using single-antigen beads. Complement-dependent cytotoxicity assays were performed to determine the cytotoxicity of DSA. Results. Three hundred seventy-nine of 994 of patients (38%) had antibodies against intact HLA and &bgr;2m-free HC. There was no survival rate difference between antibody-positive and -negative groups. When the 379 antibody-positive patients were further tested with &bgr;2m-free HC-coated beads, 179 of them with antibodies only against intact form of antigens had a 4-year graft survival rate of 76%, which is significantly lower than that of 200 patients with antibodies against &bgr;2m-free HC of HLA antigens (88%, P=0.0056). Patients with intact antigen specific DSAs had a significantly lower graft survival rate as compared with those with no DSAs (70% vs. 89%, P=0.0073). More patients with strong donor-specific cytotoxic antibodies lost allografts than those with weak-cytotoxic or noncytotoxic antibodies. However, cytotoxic activity of DSA was not correlated to antibody level. Conclusions. We concluded that intact antigen-specific antibodies, especially DSAs, are predictive of graft failure. DSAs were not always cytotoxic. Strong cytotoxic activity of DSA was associated with a higher rate of graft loss but not correlated to the antibody level. Antibodies against &bgr;2m-free HC negatively interfere with the predictive value of intact antigen-specific antibodies.

Non-HLA antibodies targeting vascular receptors enhance alloimmune response and microvasculopathy after heart transplantation.

Background Non–human leukocyte antigen antibodies (Abs) targeting vascular receptors are implicated in the pathogenesis of renal allograft vascular rejection and in progressive vasculopathy in patients with systemic sclerosis. Methods We prospectively tested in 30 heart transplant recipients the impact of Abs directed against endothelin-1 type A (ETAR) and angiotensin II type 1 receptors (AT1R, cell-enzyme–linked immunosorbent assay) at time of transplantation and during the first posttransplantation year on cellular and Ab-mediated rejection (immunohistochemistry, C3d, and immunoglobulins) and microvasculopathy in endomyocardial biopsy. Results Cellular rejection, Ab-mediated rejection, and microvasculopathy was found in 40% and 13%, 57% and 18%, and 37% and 40% of biopsies at 1 month and 1 year posttransplantation, respectively. Maximum levels of AT1R and ETAR Abs were higher in patients with cellular (16.5±2.6 vs. 9.4±1.3; P=0.021 and 16.5±2.5 vs. 9.9±1.9; P=0.041) and Ab-mediated rejection (19.0±2.6 vs. 10.0±1.3; P=0.004 and 19.4±2.7 vs. 9.0±1.7; P=0.002), as compared with patients who had no rejection. Patients with elevated AT1R Abs (53% [16/30]) or ETAR Abs (50% [15/30]; pretransplantation prognostic rejection cutoff >16.5 U/L) presented more often with microvasculopathy (both, 67% vs. 23%; P=0.048) than patients without. Conclusions Elevated levels of AT1R and ETAR Abs are associated with cellular and Ab-mediated rejection and early onset of microvasculopathy and should be routinely monitored after heart transplantation.

Immune response to an adjuvanted influenza A H1N1 vaccine (Pandemrix®) in renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND In the course of the influenza A H1N1 pandemic, transplanted patients were recommended to receive vaccination. In the present study, we evaluated the immune response to an adjuvanted influenza A H1N1 vaccine (Pandemrix®) in renal allograft recipients. METHODS Sixty patients and 22 healthy controls participated in a prospective observational study and received a single dose of Pandemrix®. H1N1 antibody titres as well as anti-HLA antibodies were determined before and after vaccination. In 19 patients, a booster vaccination was performed and the outcome of all vaccinated renal allograft recipients (n = 107) in our clinic was reviewed. RESULTS Two out of sixty patients had an elevated influenza A H1N1 titre before vaccination. Of the remaining 58 patients, only 20/58 (34.5%) developed a protective immune response in contrast to 20/22 (91%) of the control group. After booster vaccination, a protective titre was present in 8/19 (42%) of patients. Of the 107 patients, 6 (5.6%) developed new donor-specific HLA antibodies after vaccination. CONCLUSIONS These data suggest that Pandemrix® does not provide a protective immune response in the majority of kidney transplant recipients. Therefore, for new vaccines, efficacy as well as safety profiles should be evaluated in this subgroup of patients.

Systematic comparison of four cell- and Luminex-based methods for assessment of complement-activating HLA antibodies.

Background Efforts to increase the specificity and sensitivity of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibody detection assays recently led to the establishment of two novel Luminex bead-based assays to detect complement-activating antibodies by the assessment of complement products C1q or C4d. Here, we present a systematic comparison of the four methods, complement-dependent lymphocytotoxicity (CDC) and C1q-, C4d-, and IgG-Luminex, to assess or predict the complement-binding capability of HLA IgG antibodies. Methods Forty-five sera of highly immunized patients have been assessed by in-house modified C1q- and C4d-Luminex assays and compared with standard CDC and IgG-Luminex. Results Antibody specificities assigned by the C1q- and C4d-Luminex assay revealed an excellent concordance of 94% and 97% for HLA class I and II, respectively. Complement-fixing HLA class II antibodies were found less frequently among IgG antibodies compared with class I. Both C1q- and C4d-Luminex detected, on average, three times more specificities than CDC. Although we found a high correlation of mean fluorescence intensity values between C1q- and C4d-Luminex assays, IgG mean fluorescence intensity was not a suitable surrogate marker for the prediction of complement binding. Conclusions C1q- and C4d-Luminex assays are characterized by an increased sensitivity and specificity compared with CDC, the current standard in detecting complement-fixing HLA antibodies. Pretransplantation risk assessment for transplantation but also posttransplantation monitoring are important applications for both assays to improve overall allograft survival.

Clinical relevance of the de novo production of anti‐HLA antibodies following intestinal and multivisceral transplantation

Despite a negative pretransplant cross‐match, intestinal transplant recipients can mount humoral immune responses soon after transplantation. Moreover, the development of donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibodies (DSAs) is associated with severe graft injury. Between June 2000 and August 2011, 30 patients (median age 37.6 ± 9.8 years) received isolated intestinal transplantations (ITX, n = 18) or multivisceral transplantations (MVTXs, n = 12) at our center. We screened for human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies pre‐ and post‐transplant. If patients produced DSAs, treatment with plasmapheresis and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) was initiated. In the event of DSA persistence and/or treatment‐refractory rejection, rituximab and/or bortezomib were added. Ten patients developed DSAs and simultaneously showed significant signs of rejection. These patients received plasmapheresis and IVIG. Eight patients additionally received rituximab, and two patients were treated with bortezomib. DSA values decreased upon antirejection therapy in 8 of the 10 patients. The development of DSAs following ITX is often associated with acute rejection. We observed that the number of mismatched antigens and epitopes correlates with the probability of developing de novo DSAs. Early diagnosis and therapy, including B‐cell depletion and plasma cell inhibition, are crucial to preventing further graft injury.

Luminex(®) and its applications for solid organ transplantation, hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, and transfusion.

The detection of antibodies against the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) complex has become indispensable in every clinical practice. The development of solid-phase assays like the Luminex allows the standardized measurement of anti-HLA antibodies (HLAab) with high sensitivity, albeit the relevance for some clinical settings remains a matter of debate. In this review we aim to describe the principle of Luminex-based antibody detection, including two modifications that allow identifying solely complement-activating antibodies. We then describe three applications for Luminex: i) detection of HLAab preceding solid-organ transplantation and monitoring of donor-specific antibodies posttransplant as a risk factor for antibody-mediated rejection; ii) presence of HLAab in recipients as a risk for graft failure in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, especially in haploidentical or mismatched transplantations; iii) role of HLAab in blood transfusion including refractory thrombocytopenia and selection of suitable platelet donors, transfusion-related lung injury after plasma transfusion, and immunization against HLA after red blood cell transfusion despite leukodepletion. Although the Luminex platform constitutes a potent technology for HLA antibody detection, some drawbacks require the well-educated analysis and interpretation of data in critical cases. In addition, Luminex has become an important tool to identify clinically relevant antibodies.