Nuthar Jassam

A category 1 EQA scheme for comparison of laboratory performance and method performance: An international pilot study in the framework of the Calibration 2000 project

INTRODUCTION In the modern healthcare service, patients receive care in multiple hospitals and healthcare settings. Therefore, harmonization of results from different methods and instruments, both between and within laboratories, is of the utmost importance. The present pilot study aims to test the use of a Category 1 EQA scheme across four European countries by assessing the current level of equivalence of test results. METHOD This work was led by the Dutch External Quality Assurance Scheme SKML and involved 28 laboratories from three regions in the UK, Spain and Portugal, and 120 laboratories from The Netherlands. A set of six commutable samples, targeted with reference methods, were circulated and 18 biochemistry analytes were tested. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS The Total Error (TE) score, defined as the probability (%) that results are within the Total Error Acceptable (TEA) limits, for the eighteen analytes was calculated. Our data show that there is a need for further harmonization of laboratory data, in particular for electrolytes (calcium, chloride, magnesium, sodium), enzymes (ALT, amylase, AST, LDH), lipids (HDL-cholesterol), and for substrates (creatinine, total protein). Lack of performance consistency between instruments was seen for most analytes. The lack of harmonization is still present despite manufacturer claims of established traceability.

Consumptive hypothyroidism: a case report and review of the literature.

Hepatic haemangioendothelioma is a rare vascular tumour in infants and may be associated with a unique form of thyroid function abnormalities. Hepatic haemangioendotheliomata is capable of producing an excess of the thyroid hormone inactivating enzyme, type 3 iodothyronine deiodinase. The increased enzyme activity leads to rapid degradation of thyroid hormones, resulting in frank hypothyroidism. We report a case of a three-month-old neonate with multiple hepatic haemangioendotheliomata and associated hypothyroidism. The patient required increasing doses of thyroid hormone.

Analytical performance of 17 general chemistry analytes across countries and across manufacturers in the INPUtS project of EQA organizers in Italy, the Netherlands, Portugal, United Kingdom and Spain

Abstract Background: Optimum patient care in relation to laboratory medicine is achieved when results of laboratory tests are equivalent, irrespective of the analytical platform used or the country where the laboratory is located. Standardization and harmonization minimize differences and the success of efforts to achieve this can be monitored with international category 1 external quality assessment (EQA) programs. Methods: An EQA project with commutable samples, targeted with reference measurement procedures (RMPs) was organized by EQA institutes in Italy, the Netherlands, Portugal, UK, and Spain. Results of 17 general chemistry analytes were evaluated across countries and across manufacturers according to performance specifications derived from biological variation (BV). Results: For K, uric acid, glucose, cholesterol and high-density density (HDL) cholesterol, the minimum performance specification was met in all countries and by all manufacturers. For Na, Cl, and Ca, the minimum performance specifications were met by none of the countries and manufacturers. For enzymes, the situation was complicated, as standardization of results of enzymes toward RMPs was still not achieved in 20% of the laboratories and questionable in the remaining 80%. Conclusions: The overall performance of the measurement of 17 general chemistry analytes in European medical laboratories met the minimum performance specifications. In this general picture, there were no significant differences per country and no significant differences per manufacturer. There were major differences between the analytes. There were six analytes for which the minimum quality specifications were not met and manufacturers should improve their performance for these analytes. Standardization of results of enzymes requires ongoing efforts.

The implementation of a system for managing analytical quality in networked laboratories.

Background In a network of laboratories analytical variability between instruments, even of the same type, may exist for reasons beyond the control of laboratory staff. Controlling variability is a prerequisite for the application of shared reference ranges and for ensuring the transferability of patient test results. Controlling variability requires a robust, non-conventional quality system to detect poor performance of analysers that are geographically distant. Essential to this quality system is a set of well-defined quality specifications. Methods The approach used in our study started with (1) selection of a model for quality specifications based on biological variation; the ‘three-level model’ (TLM) was selected on the basis of its flexibility to accommodate various levels of analytical performance; (2) determination of the performance characteristics of the 71 analytes measured in core biochemistry in terms of imprecision and bias; (3) defining quality requirements in the form of imprecision, bias and total error for 71 analytes measured routinely in core biochemistry; and (4) developing software to assist a consistent wide application of the quality specifications and to monitor analytical indices to the common quality specifications. Results In this paper we describe how we have implemented this model across our network. Forty-six of the 71 analytes in our core laboratory repertoire were allocated to the TLM. We were able to demonstrate equivalence of results on all analysers, for 42 out of 46 analytes allocated to this model. Conclusions We propose that other networked laboratories should investigate the suitability of this quality system for use in their network.

Prolactin and macroprolactin: a case report of hyperprolactinaemia highlighting the interpretation of discrepant results

Immunoassay methods for prolactin detect macroprolactin (i.e. high molecular mass complexes of prolactin) to various degrees. Therefore it is generally assumed that the widely differing results by methods that measure both moieties to a differing extent are due to the presence of macroprolactin. We present a case which challenges such an assumption and suggest that precipitation by polyethylene glycol is the most reliable screen for identifying macroprolactin (and/or interfering antibodies if present).

Post-standardization of routine creatinine assays: are they suitable for clinical applications

Introduction Reliable serum creatinine measurements are of vital importance for the correct classification of chronic kidney disease and early identification of kidney injury. The National Kidney Disease Education Programme working group and other groups have defined clinically acceptable analytical limits for creatinine methods. The aim of this study was to re-evaluate the performance of routine creatinine methods in the light of these defined limits so as to assess their suitability for clinical practice. Method In collaboration with the Dutch External Quality Assurance scheme, six frozen commutable samples, with a creatinine concentration ranging from 80 to 239 μmol/L and traceable to isotope dilution mass spectrometry, were circulated to 91 laboratories in four European countries for creatinine measurement and estimated glomerular filtration rate calculation. Two out of the six samples were spiked with glucose to give high and low final concentrations of glucose. Results Results from 89 laboratories were analysed for bias, imprecision (%CV) for each creatinine assay and total error for estimated glomerular filtration rate. The participating laboratories used analytical instruments from four manufacturers; Abbott, Beckman, Roche and Siemens. All enzymatic methods in this study complied with the National Kidney Disease Education Programme working group recommended limits of bias of 5% above a creatinine concentration of 100 μmol/L. They also did not show any evidence of interference from glucose. In addition, they also showed compliance with the clinically recommended %CV of ≤4% across the analytical range. In contrast, the Jaffe methods showed variable performance with regard to the interference of glucose and unsatisfactory bias and precision. Conclusion Jaffe-based creatinine methods still exhibit considerable analytical variability in terms of bias, imprecision and lack of specificity, and this variability brings into question their clinical utility. We believe that clinical laboratories and manufacturers should work together to phase out the use of relatively non-specific Jaffe methods and replace them with more specific methods that are enzyme based.

Transient rise in alkaline phosphatase activity in adults

Benign transient hyperphosphatasia (BTH) is a condition that occurs mainly in infants and children and is characterised by a transient increase of serum alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity up to several fold the adult upper reference limit (URL). The present report concerns BTH in 2 patients, aged 59 and 52 years old, who showed no evidence of bone or liver disease but had an increase in ALP activity up to 20-fold and 13-fold the adult URL, respectively. The diagnosis of BTH in the first case was made retrospectively, and after excluding liver and bone disease. However, in the second case the diagnosis was made early in the course of the disease, by performing an ALP isoenzyme electrophoresis test. Lengthy and extensive investigations were avoided in the second case. These cases highlight the occurrence of this condition in adulthood as well as in infancy and childhood.

Does creatinine analytical performance support robust identification of acute kidney injury within individual laboratories in a region

Nuthar Jassam*, Wycliffe Mbagaya, Anders Kallner, Robert Hill, Dan Carless, Julian H. Barth on behalf of Yorkshire Laboratory Medicine Discussion Group (YLMDG): other members who contributed to this work are, H. Delaney, C. Lippiatt, J. Shepherd, S. Glover, S. Slack, K. Mitchell, A. Strafen and M.P. Bosomworth Does creatinine analytical performance support robust identification of acute kidney injury within individual laboratories in a region

Persistently raised aspartate aminotransferase (AST) due to macro-AST in a rheumatology clinic

Abstract Macrocomplexes between immunoglobins and aspartate aminotransferase (macro-AST) may result in persistently increased AST concentration. The presence of macro-AST in patients has been implicated in unnecessary investigations of abnormal liver function tests. We report the case of a 44-year-old female who presented to the rheumatology clinic with a 12-months’ history of constant widespread pain affecting her limbs and was found to have an elevated AST concentration. Further information from her GP revealed a 14-years’ history of elevated AST with otherwise normal liver function. Previous abdominal ultrasound and two liver biopsies carried out 2 years apart were normal. This prompted further analytical investigation by the biochemistry department which identified macro-AST as the cause. This case illustrates that persistently raised isolated AST concentration with no other abnormal indices may warrant macroenzyme analysis potentially avoiding unnecessary invasive investigations.

Calcium adjustment equations in neonates and children

Background Calcium exists in human blood in a free form and in a form bound to plasma proteins, principally albumin. Since it is the ionized form that is biologically active, it has long been common practice to present calcium adjusted on the basis of serum albumin concentration. The concept of adjusted calcium has only been evaluated in adults. In this study, we evaluated the use of the adult-adjusted equation to report calcium in children. Methods We searched the laboratory information system over three teaching hospitals for young patients aged between newborn and 18 years old with a request for calcium and albumin analysis but with no evidence of disturbances of calcium homeostasis. These data were organized on the basis of age and was separated into four age groups (birth to 1 month old, 1 month to 1 year old, 1 to 5 years old and 5 to 18 years old). These data were subjected to regression analysis to derive the calcium-adjusted equation for each age group. Results There is an inverse relationship between the bias value and the age. The younger the age, the higher the difference between the adjusted calcium calculated by the adult equation and that calculated by the age-specific equation. This pattern was maintained on all sites. Conclusion For all sites, the adult-adjusted calcium equation may be used to calculate the adjusted calcium for children aged one year old and above.