O. Nadazdin

CD154 Blockade for Induction of Mixed Chimerism and Prolonged Renal Allograft Survival in Nonhuman Primates

Costimulatory blockade with anti‐CD154 monoclonal antibody (aCD154) prolongs allograft survival in nonhuman primates, but has not reliably induced tolerance when used alone. In the current studies, we evaluated the effect of adding CD154 blockade to a chimerism inducing nonmyeloablative regimen in primates. We observed a significant improvement of donor bone marrow (DBM) engraftment, which has been associated with a lower incidence of acute rejection and long‐term survival of renal allografts without the need for previously required splenectomy. Among the long‐term survivors, four never showed evidence of rejection, with the longest survival exceeding 1700 days following discontinuation of immunosuppression. Nevertheless, late chronic rejection was observed in three of eight recipients, indicating the necessity of further modifications of the regimen. Control recipients receiving no DBM or donor splenocytes in place of DBM rejected their allografts. Thus, DBM engraftment with, at least, transient mixed chimerism appears essential for induction of allograft tolerance using this conditioning regimen. Modification of the original mixed chimerism approach, by the addition of costimulatory blockade, has been shown to enhance mixed chimerism and induce renal allograft tolerance with less morbidity in nonhuman primates.

Depletion of CD8 memory T cells for induction of tolerance of a previously transplanted kidney allograft.

Heterologous immunologic memory has been considered a potent barrier to tolerance induction in primates. Induction of such tolerance for a previously transplanted organ may be more difficult, because specific memory cells can be induced and activated by a transplanted organ. In the current study, we attempted to induce tolerance to a previously transplanted kidney allograft in nonhuman primates. The conditioning regimen consisted of low dose total body irradiation, thymic irradiation, antithymocyte globulin, and anti‐CD154 antibody followed by a brief course of a calcineurin inhibitor. This regimen had been shown to induce mixed chimerism and allograft tolerance when kidney transplantation (KTx) and donor bone marrow transplantation (DBMT) were simultaneously performed. However, the same regimen failed to induce mixed chimerism when delayed DBMT was performed after KTx. We found that significant levels of memory T cells remained after conditioning, despite effective depletion of naïve T cells. By adding humanized anti‐CD8 monoclonal antibody (cM‐T807), CD8 memory T cells were effectively depleted and these recipients successfully achieved mixed chimerism and tolerance. The current studies provide ‘proof of principle’ that the mixed chimerism approach can induce renal allograft tolerance, even late after organ transplantation if memory T‐cell function is adequately controlled.

Four Stages and Lack of Stable Accommodation in Chronic Alloantibody-Mediated Renal Allograft Rejection in Cynomolgus Monkeys

The etiology of immunologically mediated chronic renal allograft failure is unclear. One cause is thought to be alloantibodies. Previously in Cynomolgus monkeys, we observed a relationship among donor‐specific alloantibodies (DSA), C4d staining, allograft glomerulopathy, allograft arteriopathy and progressive renal failure. To define the natural history of chronic antibody‐mediated rejection and its effect on renal allograft survival, we now extend this report to include 417 specimens from 143 Cynomolgus monkeys with renal allografts. A subset of animals with long‐term renal allografts made DSA (48%), were C4d positive (29%), developed transplant glomerulopathy (TG) (22%) and chronic allograft arteriopathy (CAA) (19%). These four features were highly correlated and associated with statistically significant shortened allograft survival. Acute cellular rejection, either Banff type 1 or 2, did not correlate with alloantibodies, C4d deposition or TG. However, endarteritis (Banff type 2) correlated with later CAA. Sequential analysis identified four progressive stages of chronic antibody‐mediated rejection: (1) DSA, (2) deposition of C4d, (3) TG and (4) rising creatinine/renal failure. These new findings provide strong evidence that chronic antibody‐mediated rejection develops without enduring stable accommodation, progresses through four defined clinical pathological stages and shortens renal allograft survival.

Effect of mixed hematopoietic chimerism on cardiac allograft survival in cynomolgus monkeys.

Background. We have previously reported the successful induction of mixed chimerism and long-term acceptance of renal allografts in MHC-mismatched nonhuman primates after nonmyeloablative conditioning and donor bone marrow transplantation. In this study, we extended our regimen to cardiac allotransplantation and compared the immunological responses of heart and kidney allograft recipients. Methods. Five cynomolgus monkeys were conditioned with low-dose total body irradiation (1.5 Gy on days −6 and −5), supplemental thymic irradiation (7 Gy on day −1), antithymocyte globulin (50 mg/kg on days −2, −1, and 0), splenectomy (day 0), donor bone marrow transplantation (day 0), and a 4-week posttransplant course of cyclosporine. Heart allografts from MHC-mismatched donors were transplanted heterotopically on day 0. Results. Two monkeys failed to develop multilineage chimerism and rejected their allografts soon after cyclosporine was stopped (postoperative days [PODs] 43 and 56). Three monkeys developed multilineage chimerism, which persisted 20 to 43 days posttransplant by flow cytometric analysis and to POD 124 by polymerase chain reaction analysis. Allograft survival in these recipients was prolonged to 138, 428, and 509 days, and in vitro mixed leukocyte reaction and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays demonstrated donor-specific hyporesponsiveness. However, in contrast to kidney allograft recipients, long-term heart allograft recipients eventually developed humoral and cellular immunity against the donor and rejected the grafts. At the time of rejection, 1.3% to 9.5% of donor coronary arteries exhibited intimal proliferation. Conclusions. The induction of transient mixed hematopoietic chimerism leads to long-term heart allograft survival in MHC disparate monkeys without chronic immunosuppression. However, unlike kidney allografts, full tolerance to cardiac allografts was not achieved. Organ-specific modifications of the preparative regimen may be necessary to prevent the chronic cellular and humoral immune responses elicited by cardiac allografts.

Host Alloreactive Memory T Cells Influence Tolerance to Kidney Allografts in Nonhuman Primates

Only nonhuman primates with low frequencies of donor-specific memory T cells develop tolerance and accept allogeneic kidney transplants. The Slippery Slope of Transplantation Tolerance Although science is respected as an impartial pursuit, even the most unbiased observer must begin with assumptions to design experiments. But even seemingly reasonable hypotheses don’t always survive experimental scrutiny. Transplantation researchers began with the credible assumption that laboratory mice can serve as a model for human transplantation. Thus, when scientists showed that mice can accept human grafts without life-long immunosuppression, researchers enthusiastically attempted to translate these findings to nonhuman primates and patients—to no avail. Nadazdin et al. now provide a potential explanation for this discrepancy—a pre-existing pool of graft-reactive memory T cells. Memory T cells respond more rapidly and with greater strength than other T cells that have not previously seen a specific antigen. As the name suggests, memory T cells are long-lived in patients and explain in part the success of vaccination in preventing subsequent infections. Laboratory mice lack large numbers of memory T cells because they live in germ-free conditions, unlike people who, despite their best efforts, do not. This lifestyle difference was not thought to be a problem for transplantation studies, because people have not been previously exposed to donor-derived alloantigens and thus were not expected to have a memory response. In an unexpected twist, primates have been shown to have a relatively high frequency of alloreactive memory T cells before transplantation, perhaps as a result of cross-reactivity from previous infections. Nadazdin et al. now investigate the effects of these preexisting alloreactive memory T cells on transplant tolerance in nonhuman primates. The authors found that transplanted organs are rejected from monkeys with high numbers of preexisting alloreactive memory T cells, but survive long-term in monkeys with low numbers of these cells. Indeed, the animals with low numbers of alloreactive memory cells were rendered tolerant to the transplanted kidney, which was not rejected despite a lack of continued immunosuppression. This tolerance was allospecific, because both tolerant and rejecting monkeys had similar levels of homeostatic memory T cell expansion, but only rejecting monkeys displayed expanded levels of donor-reactive memory T cells after transplantation. These findings suggest two approaches to improving tolerance induction in transplant patients: One could either pair grafts with patients who have low numbers of donor-specific memory T cells or devise a way to eliminate these memory T cells from patients before transplantation. In this case, questioning assumptions did not validate the assumption, but instead yielded new information that may help researchers overcome barriers to transplant tolerance. Transplant tolerance, defined as indefinite allograft survival without immunosuppression, has been regularly achieved in laboratory mice but not in nonhuman primates or humans. In contrast to laboratory mice, primates regularly have high frequencies of alloreactive memory T cells (TMEMs) before transplantation. These TMEMs are poorly sensitive to conventional immunosuppression and costimulation blockade, and the presence of donor-reactive TMEMs in primates may account for their resistance to transplant tolerance protocols that have proven consistently effective in mice. We measured the frequencies of anti-donor TMEMs before and after transplantation in a series of rejecting and tolerant monkeys that underwent nonmyeloablative conditioning, short-term immunosuppression, and combined allogeneic kidney/cell transplantation. Transplants were acutely rejected in all the monkeys with high numbers of donor-specific TMEMs before transplantation. In contrast, long-term survival was observed in the recipients harboring lower frequencies of anti-donor TMEMs before transplantation. Similar amounts of TMEM homeostatic expansion were recorded in all transplanted monkeys upon hematopoietic reconstitution; however, only the tolerant monkeys had no expansion or activation of donor-reactive TMEMs after transplantation. These results indicate that the presence of high frequencies of host donor-reactive TMEMs before transplantation impairs tolerance induction to kidney allografts in this nonhuman primate model. Indeed, recipients harboring a low anamnestic reactivity to their donor before transplantation were successfully rendered tolerant via infusion of donor cells and short-term immunosuppression. This suggests that selection of allogeneic donors with low memory responses in recipients may be essential to successful transplant tolerance induction in patients.

Chronic Antibody Mediated Rejection of Renal Allografts: Pathological, Serological and Immunologic Features in Nonhuman Primates

The pathogenesis of late renal allograft loss is heterogeneous and difficult to diagnose. We have analyzed renal allografts in nonhuman primates to determine the relationship between alloantibodies and the graft pathology of late graft loss. Seventeen Cynomolgus monkeys were chosen from among those on several protocols for renal allotransplantation with mixed chimerism induction so that animals with and without alloantibodies were included. All animals received transient CD154 blockade and short‐term cyclosporine treatment until day 28. Serial blood samples were tested for alloantibodies. Protocol biopsies and autopsy kidneys were scored for pathology and C4d deposition. Group 1, defined by complete lack of C4d deposition (24 tissue samples; 8 recipients), had no detectable alloantibodies (33 serum samples; 1–7 samples per recipient) and no evidence of chronic rejection. Three survived greater than 2 years with normal function and histology. Group 2, defined as having C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries, all made alloantibodies (100%), and most grafts later showed chronic allograft glomerulopathy (89%), and/or arteriopathy (89%). All grafts in Group 2 failed (3–27 months). Pathologic lesions of typical of chronic rejection in humans develop in monkeys, correlate with antecedent alloantibodies/C4d deposition and predict chronic rejection rather than durable accommodation.

Overcoming memory T-cell responses for induction of delayed tolerance in nonhuman primates.

The presence of alloreactive memory T cells is a major barrier for induction of tolerance in primates. In theory, delaying conditioning for tolerance induction until after organ transplantation could further decrease the efficacy of the regimen, since preexisting alloreactive memory T cells might be stimulated by the transplanted organ. Here, we show that such “delayed tolerance” can be induced in nonhuman primates through the mixed chimerism approach, if specific modifications to overcome/avoid donor‐specific memory T‐cell responses are provided. These modifications include adequate depletion of CD8+ memory T cells and timing of donor bone marrow administration to minimize levels of proinflammatory cytokines. Using this modified approach, mixed chimerism was induced successfully in 11 of 13 recipients of previously placed renal allografts and long‐term survival without immunosuppression could be achieved in at least 6 of these 11 animals.

Phenotype, Distribution and Alloreactive Properties of Memory T Cells from Cynomolgus Monkeys

The high frequency of memory T cells present in primates is thought to represent a major barrier to tolerance induction in transplantation. Therefore, it is crucial to characterize these memory T cells and determine their functional properties. High numbers of memory T cells were detected in peripheral blood and all lymphoid tissues except lymph nodes, which were essentially the site of naïve T cells. The majority of CD8+ memory T cells were effector memory cells located in the blood and bone marrow while most CD4+ memory T cells were central memory cells present in the spleen. Next, memory T cells from over 100 monkeys were tested for their response to alloantigens by ELISPOT. Memory alloreactivity mediated via direct but not indirect allorecognition was detected in all animals. The frequency of allospecific memory T cells varied dramatically depending upon the nature of the responder/stimulator monkey combination tested. MHC gene matching was generally associated with a low‐memory alloreactivity. Nevertheless, low anamnestic alloresponses were also found in a significant number of fully MHC‐mismatched monkey combinations. These results show that selected donor/recipient combinations displaying a low memory alloresponsiveness can be found. These combinations may be more favorable for transplant tolerance induction.

Association of natural killer cell depletion with induction of mixed chimerism and allograft tolerance in non-human primates.

BACKGROUND Nonmyeloablative T cell depletion followed by donor bone marrow infusion has proved to be an effective approach to induction of mixed chimerism and tolerance of organ allografts in non-human primates. To help define the mechanisms involved we have compared T cell depletion with ATG versus anti-CD2 monoclonal antibody with respect to establishment of mixed chimerism and induction of tolerance. METHOD Both nonmyeloablative regimens included low dose total body irradiation (1.5 Gy x 2), thymic irradiation (7 Gy), splenectomy and kidney plus donor bone marrow transplantation, followed by a 4-week posttransplant course of cyclosporine. In addition, the ATG group (13 recipients) received antithymocyte globulin, although the LOCD2b group (10 recipients) were treated with an anti-CD2 monoclonal antibody (LOCD2b). RESULTS In the ATG group, 11 of 13 monkeys developed multilineage chimerism and 9 survived for more than 100 days without kidney allograft rejection. In contrast, 0/10 monkeys in the LOCD2b group developed chimerism, 5 died of infection and 5 suffered progressive rejection; only 1 recipient survived beyond 100 days. Sequential monitoring of peripheral blood mononuclear cells revealed greater T cell (CD3+) depletion in the LOCD2b-treated animals compared to those receiving ATG. However, NK cells (CD16+CD8+) were significantly more depleted in the ATG group and NK function remained abrogated longer after ATG than LOCD2b treatment (3 weeks vs. <5 days). CONCLUSION Despite excellent T cell depletion by LoCD2b, ATG was more effective in inducing chimerism and tolerance. This difference correlated with anti-NK activity of the two reagents. These data suggest that NK cells may also resist engraftment of allogeneic bone marrow cells in this model.

Tolerance of Lung Allografts Achieved in Nonhuman Primates via Mixed Hematopoietic Chimerism

While the induction of transient mixed chimerism has tolerized MHC‐mismatched renal grafts in nonhuman primates and patients, this approach has not been successful for more immunogenic organs. Here, we describe a modified delayed‐tolerance‐induction protocol resulting in three out of four monkeys achieving long‐term lung allograft survival without ongoing immunosuppression. Two of the tolerant monkeys displayed stable mixed lymphoid chimerism, and the other showed transient chimerism. Serial biopsies and post‐mortem specimens from the tolerant monkeys revealed no signs of chronic rejection. The tolerant recipients also exhibited T cell unresponsiveness and a lack of alloantibody. This is the first report of durable mixed chimerism and successful tolerance induction of MHC‐mismatched lungs in primates.