Oense M. Neijssel

Bioenergetic aspects of aerobic growth of Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418 in carbon-limited and carbon-sufficient chemostat culture

Carbon-limited chemostat cultures of Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418 consumed more oxygen per unit of cell synthesis when growing on mannitol or glycerol than when growing on glucose; and since the “maintenance” requirements were similar, this suggested that the extra reducing equivalents present in these compounds were oxidized wastefully. By comparison with carbon-limited cultures, carbon-sufficient cultures that were ammonia-, sulphate- or phosphate-limited generally consumed considerably more oxygen per unit of cell synthesis, particularly at low growth rates. Thus, according to the theory of Pirt, these carbon-sufficient cultures had a greatly increased “maintenance energy” requirement but nevertheless used the remaining energy with a much increased efficiency compared with carbon-limited cultures. This, we suggest, is a false conclusion which stems from the basic assumption that the maintenance requirement does not change with growth rate. Thus we propose an alternative theory which allows for this possibility, and present evidence to show that it may be applicable to both carbon-limited and carbon-sufficient chemostat cultures. Finally we offer an explanation of the high “maintenance” rate of oxygen consumption found with carbon-sufficient cultures, and consider this phenomenon in relation to the loose coupling between respiration and growth extant in most microbial cultures.

The regulation of carbohydrate metabolism in Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418 organisms, growing in chemostat culture

Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418 was grown in chemostat cultures (D=0.17 hr-1; pH 6.8; 35° C) that were, successively, carbon-, sulphate-, ammonia-, and phosphate-limited, and which contained as the sole carbon-substrate first glucose, then glycerol, mannitol and lactate. Quantitative analyses of carbon-substrate used and products formed allowed carbon balances to be constructed and direct comparisons to be made of the effciency of substrate utilization. With all sixteen cultures, carbon recoveries of better than 90% were obtained.Optimum utilization of the carbon substrate was invariably found with the carbon-limited cultures, the sole products being organisms and carbon dioxide. But the extent to which excess substrate was over-utilized varied markedly with both the nature of the growth-limitation and the identity of the carbon-substrate. In general, sulphate-, ammonia-, and phosphate-limited cultures utilized glycerol more efficiently than mannitol, mannitol better than lactate, and glucose least efficiently. Glucose-containing cultures also synthesized some extracellular polysaccharide.When the carbon source was in excess, a range of acidic compounds generally were excreted. Sulphate-limited cultures, growing on glucose, excreted much pyruvate and acetate, whereas similarly-limited cultures growing on glycerol, mannitol or lactate produced only acetate. Ammonialimited cultures invariably excreted 2-oxoglutarate and acetate, whereas phosphate-limited cultures produced gluconic acid, 2-ketogluconic acid and acetate, when growing on glucose, but only acetate when growing on mannitol or lactate.From the rates of substrate and oxygen consumption, and the rates of cell synthesis, yield values for both substrate and oxygen were calculated. These showed different trends, but were similar in being highest under carbon-limitation and substantially lower under all other limitations.The physiological significance of these findings, and the probable nature of the regulatory mechanisms underlying “overflow metabolism” are discussed.

The role of energy-spilling reactions in the growth ofKlebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418 in aerobic chemostat culture

When cell-saturating amounts of glucose and phosphate were added to steady state cultures ofKlebsiella aerogenes that were, respectively, glucose-and phosphate-limited, the organisms responded immediately with an increased oxygen consumption rate. This suggested that in neither case was glucose transport the rate-limiting process, and also that organisms must posses effective mechanisms for spilling the excess energy initially generated when a growth-limitation is temporarily relieved.Steady state cultures of mannitol- or glucose-limited organisms also seemingly generated energy at a greater rate than was required for cell synthesis since gluconate-limited cultures consumed oxygen at a lower rate, at each corresponding growth rate, than did mannitol- or glucose-limited cultures, and there-fore expressed a higherYo value. Thus, mannitol- and glucose-limitations must be essentially carbon (and not energy) limitations. The excess energy generated by glucose metabolism is one component of “maintenance” and could be used at lower growth rates to maintain an increased solute gradient across the cell membrane, imposed by the addition of 2%, w/v, NaCl to the growth environment.The maintenance rates of oxygen consumption ofK. aerogenes also could be caused to increase by adding glucose discontinuously (drop-wise) to a glucose-limited chemostat culture, or by exchanging nitrate for ammonia as the sole utilizable nitrogen source.The significance of these findings to an assessment of the physiological factors circumscribing energy-spilling reactions in aerobic cultures ofK. aerogenes is discussed.

Involvement of pyruvate dehydrogenase in product formation in pyruvate-limited anaerobic chemostat cultures of Enterococcus faecalis NCTC 775

Enterococcus faecalis NCTC 775 was grown anaerobically in chemostat culture with pyruvate as the energy source. At low culture pH values, high in vivo and in vitro activities were found for both pyruvate dehydrogenase and lactate dehydrogenase. At high culture pH values the carbon flux was shifted towards pyruvate formate lyase. Some mechanisms possibly involved in this metabolic switch are discussed. In particular attention is paid to the NADH/NAD ratio (redox potential) and the fructose-1,6-bisphosphate-dependent lactate dehydrogenase activity as possible regulatory factors.

Bioenergetic consequences of microbial adaptation to low-nutrient environments

A striking property of many prokaryotes is their enormous metabolic flexibility with respect not only to catabolic and anabolic substrates but also with respect to the continuously changing availability of nutrients. The phenotypic responses to low-nutrient growth conditions involve structural changes in the cellular make-up, changes in the specific capacity of the enzyme system(s) involved in uptake and/or assimilation of the limiting nutrient and changes in the affinity of these enzymes. Here the responses of some members of the Enterobacteriaceae to potassium-, ammonium- and energy source-limited conditions will be reviewed. The focus will be on the energetic consequences of these adaptations as reflected by the growth yield value for the energy source (Y energy source). It will be illustrated that Y energy source values can be dramatically lowered as a result of incomplete oxidation of the energy source (overflow metabolism), bypassing potential sites of energy conservation (uncoupling) or catabolic cycles that have no other apparent effect than the hydrolysis of ATP (futile cycles). Thus, it is concluded that adaptation to low nutrient conditions aims at maintaining high metabolic fluxes at low nutrient concentrations at the cost of a loss in the energetic efficiency of the overall metabolism.

Metabolic and energetic aspects of the growth of Clostridium butyricum on glucose in chemostat culture

The influence of a number of environmental parameters on the fermentation of glucose, and on the energetics of growth of Clostridium butyricum in chemostat culture, have been studied. With cultures that were continuously sparged with nitrogen gas, glucose was fermented primarily to acetate and butyrate with a fixed stoichiometry. Thus, irrespective of the growth rate, input glucose concentration specific nutrient limitation and, within limits, the culture pH value, the acetate/butyrate molar ratio in the culture extracellular fluids was uniformly 0.74±0.07. Thus, the efficiency with which ATP was generated from glucose catabolism also was constant at 3.27±0.02 mol ATP/mol glucose fermented. However, the rate of glucose fermentation at a fixed growth rate, and hence the rate of ATP generation, varied markedly under some conditions leading to changes in the Yglucose and YATP values. In general, glucose-sufficient cultures expressed lower yield values than a correponding glucose-limited culture, and this was particularly marked with a potassium-limited culture. However, with a glucose-limited culture increasing the input glucose concentration above 40g glucose·l-1 also led to a significant decrease in the yield values that could be partially reversed by increasing the sparging rate of the nitrogen gas. Finally glucose-limited cultures immediately expressed an increased rate of glucose fermentation when relieved of their growth limitation. Since the rate of cell synthesis did not increase instantaneously, again the yield values with respect to glucose consumed and ATP generated transiently decreased.Two conditions were found to effect a change in the fermentation pattern with a lowering of the acetate/butyrate molar ratio. First, a significant decrease in this ratio was observed when a glucose-limited culture was not sparged with nitrogen gas; and second, a substantial (and progressive) decrease was observed to follow addition of increasing amounts of mannitol to a glucose-limited culture. In both cases, however, there was no apparent change in the YATP value.These results are discussed with respect to two imponder-ables, namely the mechanism(s) by which C. butyricum might partially or totally dissociate catabolism from anabolism, and how it might dispose of the excess reductant [as NAD(P)H] that attends both the formation of acetate from glucose and the fermentation of mannitol. With regards to the latter, evidence is presented that supports the conclusion that the ferredoxin-mediated oxidation of NAD(P)H, generating H2, is neither coupled to, nor driven by, an energy-yielding reaction.

The energetics of bacterial growth: a reassessment.

The growth yield of microbial cultures can be used to estimate the efficiency of energy generation during a fermentation or respiration, in the past, the assessment of this efficiency in organisms carrying out a respiration has been the subject of many heated debates. This has partly been caused by the complexity of microbial respiratory chains. Strains of Escherichia coli specifically modified in their respiratory chain have been used recently to re‐evaluate the energetic efficiency of the bacterial respiration using chemostat cultures. The different strains indeed show different growth efficiencies. The physiological significance of energetically less‐efficient branches of the respiratory chain is discussed.

Futile cycling of ammonium ions via the high affinity potassium uptake system (Kdp) of Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli Frag1 was grown under various nutrient limitations in chemostat culture at a fixed temperature, dilution rate and pH both in the presence and the absence of a high concentration of ammonium ions by using either ammonium chloride or dl-alanine as the sole nitrogen source. The presence of high concentrations of ammonium ions in the extracellular fluids of potassium-limited cultures of E. coli Frag1 caused an increase of the specific rate of oxygen consumption of these cultures. In contrast, under phosphate-, sulphate- or magnesium-limited growth conditions no such increase could be observed. The presence of high concentrations of ammonium ions in potassium-limited cultures of E. coli Frag5, a mutant strain of E. coli Frag1 which lacks the high affinity potassium uptake system (Kdp), did not increase the specific rate of oxygen consumption.These results indicate that ammonium ions, very similar to potassium ions both in charge and size, are transported via the K dp leading to a futile cycle of ammonium ions and ammonia molecules (plus protons) across the cytoplasmic membrane. Both the uptake of ammonium ions and the extrusion of protons would increase the energy requirement of the cells and therefore increase their specific rate of oxygen consumption. The involvement of a (methyl)ammonium transport system in this futile cycle could be excluded.

The functional significance of glucose dehydrogenase in Klebsiella aerogenes

In order to assess the functional significance of the quinoprotein glucose dehydrogenase recently found to be present in K+-limited Klebsiella aerogenes, a broad study was made of the influence of specific environmental conditions on the cellular content of this enzyme. Whereas high activities were manifest in cells from glucose containing chemostat cultures that were either potassium- or phosphate-limited, only low activities were apparent in cells from similar cultures that were either glucose-, sulphate- or ammonia-limited. With these latter two cultures, a marked increase in glucose dehydrogenase activity was observed when 2,4-dinitrophenol (1 mM end concentration) was added to the growth medium. These results suggested that the synthesis of glucose dehydrogenase is not regulated by the level of glucose in the growth medium, but possibly by conditions that imposed an energetic stress upon the cells. This conclusion was further supported by a subsequent finding that K+-limited cells that were growing on glycerol also synthesized substantial amounts of glucose dehydrogenase.The enzyme was found to be membrane associated, and preliminary evidence has been obtained that it is located on the periplasmic side of the cytoplasmic membrane and functionally linked to the respiratory chain. This structural and functional orientation is consistent with glucose dehydrogenase serving as a low impedance energy generating system.

Production of gluconic acid and 2-ketogluconic acid by Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418

Abstract2-Ketogluconic acid and, to a lesser extent, gluconic acid were found to be major products of glucose catabolism by phosphate-limited cultures of Klebsiella aerogenes NCTC 418, and together accounted for up to 46% of the glucose carbon that was metabolized.Although the concentrations of both acids increased sub-stantially at low growth rates, their specific rates of synthesis decreased markedly, as did the proportion of glucose converted into these products.Determination of the affinity constant, for glucose, of phosphate-limited organisms showed it to be not significantly different from that of glucose-limited organisms (Ks≤50 μM), indicative of the phosphotransferase uptake system. And since these organisms possessed an active glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase, and had no detectable glucose dehydrogenase activity, it was concluded that gluconic acid and 2-ketogluconic acid arose from their corresponding phosphorylated metabolites, and not directly from glucose.