P.A. Gómez

Mild head injury: differences in prognosis among patients with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 13 to 15 and analysis of factors associated with abnormal CT findings

We performed a retrospective study of 2484 consecutive patients with mild head injury (Glasgow Coma Scale score 13-15) who were seen during a period of 18 months. Of these, 2351 (94.6%) patients scored 15 points, 88 (3.5%) scored 14 points and 45 (1.3%) 13 points. A multivariate analysis showed that advanced age, a lower GCS (13-14) and the presence of skull fracture, and focal signs, significantly increased the incidence of abnormal computed tomography (CT) findings. By contrast, the gender, the mechanism of injury, the occurrence of initial loss of consciousness, posttraumatic amnesia and coagulation disorders did not significantly increase the incidence of abnormal CT findings. Patients with 13-14 GCS had a significantly higher incidence of initial loss of consciousness, of skull fracture, abnormal CT findings, need for hospital admission, delayed neurological deterioration and need for operation than patients with a GCS of 15. Thus, we suggest separating patients with a GCS of 13-14 into a different category and recommend performing CT in all those not improving within 4-6 h of injury. Such a policy makes skull radiography unnecessary in this subgroup. By contrast, skull radiographs may be useful for the triage of patients with a GCS of 15 that represent most of the mild head injury cases; radiographs should be obtained in patients presenting with initial loss of consciousness or posttraumatic amnesia (27.9% of the total cases) as these two findings were associated with a significantly higher incidence of fracture. Patients without these two findings (72.1% of the cases) showed a very low incidence of skull fracture (0.9% in this study) and may be discharged home with a warning sheet.

Risk factors predicting recurrence in patients operated on for intracranial meningioma. A multivariate analysis.

Summary The authors undertook a follow-up study of 286 patients who underwent surgical treatment for intracranial meningioma between 1973 and 1994, in order to analyse clinical, radiological, topographic, histopathological and therapeutic factors significantly influencing tumour recurrence. All patients were followed by using either computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance from 3 months to 17 years since first surgery (mean follow-up: 4.1 years). Forty-four (15.4%) recurrences were detected during this time period. Overall recurrence rates were 14%, 37% and 61% at 5, 10 and 15 years, respectively. Factors significantly associated with tumour relapse in bivariate analysis were: tumour location at petroclival and parasagittal (middle third) regions, incomplete surgical resection (assessed by Simpsons classification), atypical and malignant histological types (WHO classification), presence of nucleolar prominence, presence of more than 2 mitosis per 10 high-power fields, and heterogeneous tumour contrast enhancement on the CT scan. The multivariate analysis using the Coxs proportional hazards model identified the following risk factors for recurrence: incomplete surgical resection (Relative risk: 2.2; 95% Confidence interval: 1.33–3.64), non conventional histological type (RR: 2.13; 95%CI: 1–4.53), heterogeneous contrast enhancement on the CT scan (RR: 2.25; 95%CI: 1.1–4.72) and presence of more than 2 mitosis per 10 high-power fields (RR: 2.28; 95%CI: 0.99–5.27). Patients without any of these features showed low recurrence rates (4% and 18% at 5 and 10 years), and thus, they need less clinical and radiological controls through the follow-up than patients with some of these risk factors.

Intracranial Hemangiopericytoma: Study of 12 Cases

Summary Most hemangiopericytomas (HPCs) are located in the musculoskeletal system and the skin, while the intracranial location is rare. They represent 2 to 4% in large series of meningeal tumours, thus accounting for less than 1% of all intracranial tumours. Many authors have argued about the true origin of this tumour. The current World Health Organization classification of Central Nervous System tumours distinguishes HPC as an entity of its own, and classified it into the group of “mesenchymal, non-meningothelial tumours”. Radical surgery is the treatment of choice, but must be completed with postoperative radiotherapy, which has proved to be the therapy most strongly related to the final prognosis. HPCs have a relentless tendency for local recurrence and metastases outside the central nervous system which can appear even many years after diagnosis and adequate treatment of the primary tumour. Twelve patients with intracranial HPC were treated at our Unit between 1978 and 1999. There were 10 women and 2 men. Ten tumours were supratentorial and most located at frontoparietal parasagittal level. The most common manner of presentation was a focal motor deficit. All tumours were hyperdense in the basal Computed Tomography scans and most enhanced homogeneously following intravenous contrast injection. In 50% of cases, tumour margins were irregular or lobulated. Seven tumours were studied with Magnetic Resonance Imaging, being six of them iso-intense with the cortical gray matter on T1-weighted and T2-weighted images. Twenty operations were performed in the 12 patients. In 10 cases radical excision could be achieved with no operative mortality. Total recurrence rate was 33.3%. Eight patients were treated with external radiotherapy at some time through the course of their disease. Eight out of the 12 patients in this series are disease-free (Glasgow Outcome Scale categories 1 and 2) after a mean follow up of 52 months.

Sequential computerized tomography changes and related final outcome in severe head injury patients

SummaryThe authors analysed the serial computerized tomography (CT) findings in a large series of severely head injured patients in order to assess the variability in gross intracranial pathology through the acute posttraumatic period and determine the most common patterns of CT change. A second aim was to compare the prognostic significance of the different CT diagnostic categories used in the study (Traumatic Coma Data Bank CT pathological classification) when gleaned either from the initial (postadmission) or the control CT scans, and determine the extent to which having a second CT scan provides more prognostic information than only one scan.92 patients (13.3% of the total population) died soon after injury. Of the 587 who survived long enough to have at least one control CT scan 23.6% developed new diffuse brain swelling, and 20.9% new focal mass lesions most of which had to be evacuated. The relative risk for requiring a delayed operation as related to the diagnostic category established by using the initial CT scans was by decreasing order: diffuse injury IV (30.7%), diffuse injury III (30.5%), non evacuated mass (20%), evacuated mass (20.2%), diffuse injury II (12.1%), and diffuse injury I (8.6%).Overall, 51.2% of the patients developed significant CT changes (for worse or better) occurring either spontaneously or following surgery, and their final outcomes were more closely related to the control than to the initial CT diagnoses. In fact, the final outcome was more accurately predicted by using the control CT scans (81.2% of the cases) than by using the initial CT scans (71.5% of the cases only). Since the majority of relevant CT changes developed within 48 hours after injury a pathological categorization made by using an early control CT scan seems to be most useful for prognostic purposes.Prognosis associated with the CT pathological categories used in the study was similar independently of the moment of the acute posttraumatic period at which diagnoses were made.

Prognostic Factors on Hospital Admission after Spontaneous Subarachnoid Haemorrhage

Summary Background and Objective. Factors related to prognosis after subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) have been mainly extracted from surgical series, and only few authors have considered these factors in total management or population series. Though the level of consciousness is a major determinant of outcome after subarachnoid haemorrhage, there is not a consensus about which classification should be used to define it. The objective of this study was twofold. Firstly to find which factors recorded on hospital admission relate to outcome determining their relative importance in a non-selected series of patients suffering from aneurysmal SAH admitted to our centre, and secondly to assess the validity of the WFNS clinical scale for predicting the final result. Methods. A series of 294 patients consecutively admitted to Hospital 12 de Octubre Madrid between January 1990 and June 2000 with the diagnosis of aneurysmal SAH were retrospectively reviewed. All factors possibly related to prognosis were recorded on hospital admission. Outcome was measured by means of the Glasgow Outcome Scale measured one month after hospital discharge. Relationship between factors and outcome was evaluated by univariate and logistic regression multivariate analysis. Results. Although several factors appeared related to prognosis in the univariate analysis, only the age, the level of consciousness defined by the WFNS scale and the presence of global brain hypodensity on the initial CT scan had a significant prognostic influence in the logistic regression model. Global brain hypodensity was strongly related to mortality. Since a number of factors associated with poor outcome in the univariate analysis are related to age, their influence could be explained by the difficulty of recovery of the ageing brain. The WFNS grading scale failed to predict significant differences in outcome between some of its grades. Conclusions. Age and clinical grade on admission are the most important factors influencing the final outcome of patients suffering aneurysmal SAH. A reappraisal of the WFNS grading scale should be considered as no significant differences in outcome were found between some of its grades.

Brain oedema in patients with intracranial meningioma. Correlation between clinical, radiological, and histological factors and the presence and intensity of oedema.

SummaryThe authors analysed the correlation between different clinical, radiological, and pathological variables and the presence and intensity of brain oedema associated to intracranial meningioma in 400 consecutive patients studied by computerized tomography (CT).The following factors did not show significant correlation with brain oedema development: the age and sex of the patient, the occurrence of focal deficits, the presence of skull changes (endostosis, exostosis, osteolysis), the occurrence of tumour calcification, the density of the tumour on plain CT scan, the presence of a cystic component, the pathological subtype of meningioma (both conventional and non-conventional), and the presence of histological features of tumour aggressiveness, such as an increased vascularization, high cellularity, high mitotic index, pleomorphism, necrosis, and brain infiltration.Factors showing a statistically significant correlation with the presence and intensity of brain oedema at the bivariate analysis were: the presence of symptoms (p < 0.001), the duration of the clinical history (p < 0.05), the location and size of the tumour (p < 0.001), the type (heterogeneous vs homogeneous), and intensity of tumour contrast enhancement (p < 0.001), the presence of irregular tumour margins (p < 0.001), and the existence of focal low density intratumoural areas (p < 0.001).The multivariate analysis using only clinical parameters showed that the group of variables with the highest power for predicting the presence of brain oedema (concordance level of 76.8%) included: the presence of symptoms, the occurrence of seizures (focal or generalized), the presence of an intracranial hypertension syndrome, and the age of the patient. The multivariate analysis using only anatomico-radiological parameters showed that the model which included the size of the tumour, the intensity of contrast enhancement, the tumour margins, and meningioma location, predicted the presence of brain oedema in 80.8% of the cases.Though the results of the present study do not definitively support any of the major physiopathological theories proposed to explain brain oedema formation in patients with intracranial meningioma, some findings could favour the so-called hydrodynamic theory.

Age and Outcome After Severe Head Injury

Summary¶ The authors analyzed the relationship between patient age and the final outcome in a series of 810 patients aged 14 years or older who were consecutively admitted between 1987 and 1996 after suffering a severe closed head injury. The most relevant clinico-radiological variables were prospectively collected in a Data Bank. Stratified and logistic regression analyses were performed in order to assess the influence of age on adverse outcome and the interaction between patient age and other prognostic indicators. Our results reaffirm that the adverse outcome rate increases steadily with age in severe head injured patients and that age effect on outcome is independent of other prognostic variables. The odds of having an adverse outcome increases significantly over 35 years of age being 10 times higher in patients older than 65 years as compared to those aged 15–25 years (reference age group). The adverse influence of an advanced age on the final outcome has not yet been satisfactorily explained but an older brain may have an impaired ability to recover after a pathological insult as compared to a younger one.

Ganglioglioma of the Brainstem REPORT OF THREE CASES AND REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE

BACKGROUND Brainstem gangliogliomas are rare low-grade tumors that usually have a long clinical history. However, they may cause sudden death. There are only 31 cases of brainstem ganglioglioma reported in the literature, and only one has been studied with magnetic resonance (MR). We present three new cases of brainstem ganglion cell tumor studied with computed tomography (CT) (3 cases) and MR (2 cases) and discuss the clinical presentation, diagnostic imaging and treatment of these tumors. CASE DESCRIPTION Age at presentation ranged from 19 to 59 years old. Two patients were female and 1 male. Duration of symptoms before diagnosis ranged from 1 year to nearly 14 years. Presenting complaints included syncope spells, cranial nerve deficits, headache, and gait instability. Imaging studies revealed well-circumscribed lesions involving the brainstem; the lesion was cystic in one case and calcified in one. They were iso- or hyperdense on CT scan, isodense on T1-weighted and hyperdense on T2-weighted MRI and frequently showed contrast enhancement. All tumors were operated through a posterior fossa craniectomy. Using microsurgical techniques only partial resection could be achieved, as there was no sharp delineation from the surrounding tissue in any case. Two of our patients had increased neurological deficits after surgery. Radiotherapy was not given. Follow-up of tumoral remnants has not shown clear tumor growth after 1, 3.5, and 10 years. CONCLUSIONS Imaging characteristics of brainstem gangliogliomas do not seem to differ from those in other locations and are not specific. Radical surgery is rarely if ever possible, nor is it advisable because of the risk of functional deterioration. However, because of their benign histology, partial resection seems to carry a similar prognosis as tumors in other locations that are amenable to complete resection.

Comparison of the Clinical Presentation of Symptomatic Arteriovenous Malformations (Angiographically Visualized) and Occult Vascular Malformations

The authors compared the clinical presentations of angiographically apparent arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) and angiographically occult vascular malformations (AOVMs) of the brain in 188 consecutive patients treated when computed tomography and magnetic resonance were available. There were 133 patients (70.7%) with AVMs and 55 patients (29.2%) with AOVMs. AOVMs tended to occur more frequently in male patients and in the posterior fossa and to present earlier clinically than AVMs, but differences were not significant. One distinctive feature was the greater size of AVMs, as compared with AOVMs. Presentation by hemorrhage occurred in 64.3% of the patients with AVMs and in 61.8% of those with AOVMs. Malformations of both types located in the posterior fossa presented with hemorrhage more frequently (84.2% of AVMs and 78.5% of AOVMs) than similar lesions lying above the tentorium (60.8% of AVMs and 56% of AOVMs). Bleeding was more severe in patients with AVMs than in those with AOVMs, as indicated by the higher mortality associated with hemorrhage (7.5 vs. 3.6% of the cases) and the more frequent and marked decrease in the level of consciousness observed at admission (34 vs. 16.2% of drowsy or comatose patients). Brain hematomas caused by AVMs were on average bigger than those caused by AOVMs (58.8 and 20% of large hematomas, respectively), and intraventricular and subarachnoid hemorrhages were also more common and profuse in patients with AVMs. However, AOVMs bled subsequently more times than AVMs (61.7 vs. 15.6%), before they were diagnosed and treated, leading to a higher nonoperative morbidity (16.3 vs. 13.6%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Severe Traumatic Head Injury: Prognostic Value of Brain Stem Injuries Detected at MRI

Because traumatic brain stem injuries are thought to imply a poor prognosis, these authors studied 188 patients with TBI and correlated their imaging findings with outcomes at 6 months. Brain stem lesions were found in 51 instances and 66% of these patients had a poor outcome, with those who had bilateral, posteriorly located, and hemorrhagic lesions having the worst outcome. Nonhemorrhagic brain stem lesions had the best outcome in this group of patients. BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Traumatic brain injuries represent an important cause of death for young people. The main objectives of this work are to correlate brain stem injuries detected at MR imaging with outcome at 6 months in patients with severe TBI, and to determine which MR imaging findings could be related to a worse prognosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred and eight patients with severe TBI were studied by MR imaging in the first 30 days after trauma. Brain stem injury was categorized as anterior or posterior, hemorrhagic or nonhemorrhagic, and unilateral or bilateral. Outcome measures were GOSE and Barthel Index 6 months postinjury. The relationship between MR imaging findings of brain stem injuries, outcome, and disability was explored by univariate analysis. Prognostic capability of MR imaging findings was also explored by calculation of sensitivity, specificity, and area under the ROC curve for poor and good outcome. RESULTS: Brain stem lesions were detected in 51 patients, of whom 66% showed a poor outcome, as expressed by the GOSE scale. Bilateral involvement was strongly associated with poor outcome (P < .05). Posterior location showed the best discriminatory capability in terms of outcome (OR 6.8, P < .05) and disability (OR 4.8, P < .01). The addition of nonhemorrhagic and anterior lesions or unilateral injuries showed the highest odds and best discriminatory capacity for good outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The prognosis worsens in direct relationship to the extent of traumatic injury. Posterior and bilateral brain stem injuries detected at MR imaging are poor prognostic signs. Nonhemorrhagic injuries showed the highest positive predictive value for good outcome.