Paola Monti

p53 mutants can often transactivate promoters containing a p21 but not Bax or PIG3 responsive elements.

The human p53 protein acts mainly as a stress inducible transcription factor transactivating several genes involved in cell cycle arrest (e.g. p21) or apoptosis (e.g. Bax, PIG3). Roughly half of all human tumours contains p53 missense mutations. Virtually all tumour-derived p53 mutants are unable to activate Bax transcription but some retain the ability to activate p21 transcription. Identification of these mutants may have valuable clinical implications. We have determined the transactivation ability of 77 p53 mutants using reporter yeast strains containing a p53-regulated ADE2 gene whose promoter is regulated by p53 responsive elements derived from the regulatory region of the p21, Bax and PIG3 genes. We also assessed the influence of temperature on transactivation. Our results indicate that a significant proportion of mutants [16/77 (21%); 10/64 (16%) considering only tumour-derived mutants] are transcriptionally active, especially with the p21 promoter. Discriminant mutants preferentially affect less conserved (P<0.04, Fishers exact test), more rarely mutated (P<0.006, Fishers exact test) amino acids. Temperature sensitivity is frequently observed, but is more common among discriminant than non-discriminant mutants (P<0.003, Fishers exact test). Finally, we extended the analysis to a group of mutants isolated in BRCA-associated tumours that surprisingly were indistinguishable from wild type in standard transcription, growth suppression and apoptosis assays in human cells, but showed gain of function in transformation assays. The incidence of transcriptionally active mutations among this group was significantly higher than in the panel of mutants studied previously (P<0.001, Fishers exact test). Since it is not possible to predict the behaviour of a mutant from first principles, we propose that the yeast assay be used to compile a functional p53 database and fill the gap between the biophysical, pharmacological and clinical fields.

Tumour p53 mutations exhibit promoter selective dominance over wild type p53.

The tumour suppressor gene p53 is frequently mutated in human cancer. Tumour derived p53 mutants are usually transcriptionally inactive, but some mutants retain the ability to transactivate a subset of p53 target genes. In addition to simple loss of function, some p53 mutants may be carcinogenic through a dominant negative mechanism. Aiming at a more general classification of p53 mutants into predictive functional categories it is important to determine (i) which p53 mutants are dominant, (ii) what features characterize dominant mutants and (iii) whether dominance is target gene specific. The ability of 71 p53 mutants to inhibit wild type p53 was determined using a simple yeast transcriptional assay. Approximately 30% of the mutants were dominant. They preferentially affect highly conserved amino acids (P<0.005), which are frequently mutated in tumours (P<0.005), and usually located near the DNA binding surface of the protein (P<0.001). Different tumour-derived amino acid substitutions at the same codon usually have the same dominance phenotype. To determine whether the ability of p53 mutants to inhibit wild type p53 is target gene specific, the dominance towards p21, bax, and PIG3 binding sites was examined. Approximately 40% of the 45 mutants examined were dominant for the p21 (17/45) or PIG3 (20/45) responsive elements and 71% (32/45) were dominant for the bax responsive element. These differences are statistically significant (p21 vs bax, P<0.003; bax vs PIG3, P<0.02, Fishers exact test) and defined a hierarchy of dominance. Finally, we extended the analysis to a group of mutants isolated in BRCA-associated tumours, some of which retained wild type level of transcription in yeast as well as in human cells, but show gain of function in transformation assays. Since transformation assays require transdominant inhibition of the endogenous wild type allele, one possible explanation for the behaviour of the BRCA-associated mutants is that they adopt conformations able to bind DNA alone but not in mixed tetramers with wild type p53. The yeast data do not support this explanation, because all BRCA-associated mutants that behaved as wild type in transcription assay were recessive in dominance assays.

p53 mutants exhibiting enhanced transcriptional activation and altered promoter selectivity are revealed using a sensitive, yeast-based functional assay.

Changes in promoter specificity and binding affinity that may be associated with p53 mutations or post-translational modifications are useful in understanding p53 structure/function relationships and categorizing tumor mutations. We have exploited variable expression of human p53 in yeast to identify mutants with novel phenotypes that would correspond to altered promoter selectivity and affinity. The p53 cDNA regions coding for the DNA binding and tetramerization domains were subjected to random PCR mutagenesis and were cloned directly by recombination in yeast into a vector with a GAL1 promoter whose level of expression could be easily varied. p53 variants exhibiting higher than wild type levels of transactivation (supertrans) for the RGC responsive element were identified at low level of p53 protein expression. All the p53 mutants obtained with this screen were located in the DNA binding domain. Two out of 17 supertrans mutants have been found in tumors. Six mutations were in the L1 loop region between amino acids 115 and 124. The transactivation potential of a panel of supertrans p53 mutants on different promoters was evaluated using the p53 responsive elements, RGC, PIG3, p21 and bax. Although all mutants retained some activity with all promoters, we found different patterns of induction based on strength and promoter specificity. In particular none of the mutants was supertrans for the p21 responsive element. Interestingly, further analysis in yeast showed that the transactivation function could be retained even in the presence of dominant-negative p53 tumor mutations that could inhibit wild type p53. Five mutants were also characterized in human cells in terms of growth suppression and transactivation of various promoters. These novel supertrans p53 mutants may be useful in studies aimed at dissecting p53 downstream pathways, understanding specific interactions between p53 and the DNA, and could replace wild type p53 in cancer gene therapy protocols. The approach may also prove useful in identifying p53 tumor mutations.

Amifostine (WR2721) restores transcriptional activity of specific p53 mutant proteins in a yeast functional assay

Many p53 mutants found in human cancer have an altered ability to bind DNA and transactivate gene expression. Re-expression of functional p53 in cells in which the endogenous TP53 gene is inactivated has been demonstrated to restore a non-tumorigenic phenotype. Pharmacological modulation of p53 mutant conformation may therefore represent a mechanism to reactivate p53 function and consequently improve response to radio- and chemotherapy. We have recently reported that the radio- and chemoprotector Amifostine (WR2721, Ethyol®) activates wild-type p53 in cultured mammalian cells. In the present study, we have used a yeast functional assay to investigate the effect of WR2721 on the transcriptional activity of p53. WR2721 restored this activity in a temperature-sensitive mutant V272M (valine to methionine at codon 272) expressed at the non-permissive temperature and it also partially restored the transcriptional activity of several other conformationally flexible p53 mutants. The results indicate that the yeast functional assay may be used to identify compounds that modulate p53 activity, with potential therapeutic implications.

Determining mutational fingerprints at the human p53 locus with a yeast functional assay: a new tool for molecular epidemiology

In order to isolate experimentally induced p53 mutations, a yeast expression vector harbouring a human wild-type p53 cDNA was treated in vitro with the antineoplastic drug chloroethyl-cyclohexyl-nitroso-urea (CCNU) and transfected into a yeast strain containing the ADE2 gene regulated by a p53-responsive promoter. p53 mutations were identified in 32 out of 39 plasmids rescued from independent ade- transformants. Ninety-two percent of CCNU induced mutations were GC-targeted single base pair substitutions, and GC>AT transitions represented 73% of all single base pair substitutions. In 70% of the cases the mutated G was preceded 5′ by a purine. The distribution of the mutations along the p53 cDNA was not random: positions 734 and 785 appeared as CCNU mutational hotspots (n=3, P<0.0003) and CCNU induced only GC>AT transitions at those positions. The features of these CCNU-induced mutations are consistent with the hypothesis that O6-alkylguanine is the major causative lesion. One third of the CCNU-induced mutants were absent from a huge collection of 4496 p53 mutations in human tumours and cell lines, thus demonstrating that CCNU has a mutational spectrum which is uniquely different from that of naturally selected mutations. This strategy allows direct comparison of observed natural mutation spectra with experimentally induced mutation spectra and opens the way to a more rigorous approach in the field of molecular epidemiology.

Characterization of the p53 mutants ability to inhibit p73β transactivation using a yeast-based functional assay

p53 is the most frequently altered tumor suppressor gene in a wide spectrum of human tumors. The large majority of p53 mutations observed in tumors are missense mutations. The p73 gene, encoding a protein with significant sequence similarity to p53, expresses multiple transcription-competent spliced variants, or transcription-incompetent forms (i.e. ΔNp73). It was clearly shown that p73 transactivation from a p53-responsive promoter is inhibited by some tumor-derived p53 mutants in eucaryotic cells. In this study, we adapted a yeast-based p53 functional assay for the analysis of the influences of different p53 mutants on the activity of one of the p73 isoforms, namely p73β. We determined the ability of a panel of 61 p53 mutants to inhibit p73β activity following the net transcription of the ADE2 color (red/white) reporter gene driven by a p53-responsive promoter. By analysing a large number of mutants, we could conclude that interference: (a) is a quite frequent phenomenon (more than 70% of p53 mutants analysed are interfering); (b) is not confined to p53 mutations located in particular topological regions of the DNA binding domain; (c) does not appear to be dependent on the kind of side chains introduced at a specific position; (d) appears to significantly correlate with evolutionary conservation of the mutated p53 codon, frequency of occurrence of the mutation in tumors. The influence of a common R/P polymorphism at codon 72 on the ability of p53 mutants to interfere with p73β was also studied. Two sets of polymorphic variants (R and P) for 14 mutants were constructed and analysed. In all cases, the R/P 72 polymorphism was phenotypically irrelevant. In conclusion, our results suggest that the interpretation of the biological effects of p53 mutants should take into consideration the possibility that p53 mutants show loss or gain of function also through the interference with p53 family members.

Transcriptional Functionality of Germ Line p53 Mutants Influences Cancer Phenotype

Purpose: The TP53 tumor suppressor gene encodes a sequence-specific transcription factor that is able to transactivate several sets of genes, the promoters of which include appropriate response elements. Although human cancers frequently contain mutated p53, the alleles as well as the clinical expression are often heterogeneous. Germ line mutations of TP53 result in cancer proneness syndromes known as Li-Fraumeni, Li-Fraumeni–like, and nonsyndromic predisposition with or without family history. p53 mutants can be classified as partial deficiency alleles or severe deficiency alleles depending on their ability to transactivate a set of human target sequences, as measured using a standardized yeast-based assay (see http://www.umd.be:2072/index.html). We have investigated the extent to which the functional features of p53 mutant alleles determine clinical features in patients who have inherited these alleles and have developed cancer. Experimental Design: We retrieved clinical data from the IARC database (see http://www.p53.iarc.fr/Germline.html) for all cancer patients with germ line p53 mutations and applied stringent statistical evaluations to compare the functional classification of p53 alleles with clinical phenotypes. Results: Our analyses reveal that partial deficiency alleles are associated with a milder family history (P = 0.007), a lower numbers of tumors (P = 0.007), and a delayed disease onset (median, 31 versus 15 years; P = 0.007) which could be related to distinct tumor spectra. Conclusions: These findings establish for the first time significant correlations between the residual transactivation function of individual TP53 alleles and clinical variables in patients with inherited p53 mutations who develop cancer.

Structure of p73 DNA-binding domain tetramer modulates p73 transactivation.

The transcription factor p73 triggers developmental pathways and overlaps stress-induced p53 transcriptional pathways. How p53-family response elements determine and regulate transcriptional specificity remains an unsolved problem. In this work, we have determined the first crystal structures of p73 DNA-binding domain tetramer bound to response elements with spacers of different length. The structure and function of the adaptable tetramer are determined by the distance between two half-sites. The structures with zero and one base-pair spacers show compact p73 DNA-binding domain tetramers with large tetramerization interfaces; a two base-pair spacer results in DNA unwinding and a smaller tetramerization interface, whereas a four base-pair spacer hinders tetramerization. Functionally, p73 is more sensitive to spacer length than p53, with one base-pair spacer reducing 90% of transactivation activity and longer spacers reducing transactivation to basal levels. Our results establish the quaternary structure of the p73 DNA-binding domain required as a scaffold to promote transactivation.

p53 Transactivation and the Impact of Mutations, Cofactors and Small Molecules Using a Simplified Yeast-Based Screening System

Background The p53 tumor suppressor, which is altered in most cancers, is a sequence-specific transcription factor that is able to modulate the expression of many target genes and influence a variety of cellular pathways. Inactivation of the p53 pathway in cancer frequently occurs through the expression of mutant p53 protein. In tumors that retain wild type p53, the pathway can be altered by upstream modulators, particularly the p53 negative regulators MDM2 and MDM4. Methodology/Principal Findings Given the many factors that might influence p53 function, including expression levels, mutations, cofactor proteins and small molecules, we expanded our previously described yeast-based system to provide the opportunity for efficient investigation of their individual and combined impacts in a miniaturized format. The system integrates i) variable expression of p53 proteins under the finely tunable GAL1,10 promoter, ii) single copy, chromosomally located p53-responsive and control luminescence reporters, iii) enhanced chemical uptake using modified ABC-transporters, iv) small-volume formats for treatment and dual-luciferase assays, and v) opportunities to co-express p53 with other cofactor proteins. This robust system can distinguish different levels of expression of WT and mutant p53 as well as interactions with MDM2 or 53BP1. Conclusions/Significance We found that the small molecules Nutlin and RITA could both relieve the MDM2-dependent inhibition of WT p53 transactivation function, while only RITA could impact p53/53BP1 functional interactions. PRIMA-1 was ineffective in modifying the transactivation capacity of WT p53 and missense p53 mutations. This dual-luciferase assay can, therefore, provide a high-throughput assessment tool for investigating a matrix of factors that can influence the p53 network, including the effectiveness of newly developed small molecules, on WT and tumor-associated p53 mutants as well as interacting proteins.

The yeast p53 functional assay: a new tool for molecular epidemiology. Hopes and facts.

The assumption of molecular epidemiology that carcinogens leave fingerprints has suggested that analysis of the frequency, type, and site of mutations in genes frequently altered in carcinogenesis may provide clues to the identification of the factors contributing to carcinogenesis. In this mini-review, we revise the development, and validation of the yeast-based p53 functional assay as a new tool for molecular epidemiology. We show that this assay has some very interesting virtues but also has some drawbacks. The yeast functional assay can be used to determine highly specific mutation fingerprints in the human p53 cDNA sequence. Discrimination is possible when comparing mutation spectra induced by sufficiently different mutagens. However, we also reported that the same carcinogen may induce distinguishable mutation spectra due to known influencing factors.