Paolo Fattorini

Highly informative Y-chromosomal haplotypes by the addition of three new STRs DYS437, DYS438 and DYS439.

Abstract The Y chromosome STRs DYS437, DYS438 and DYS439 were selected from publicly available genome databases and used to analyse an Italian population sample. A tetraplex PCR reaction including the highly informative DYS385 locus, was set up and used for the analysis of 131 male samples to determine allele frequencies and STR diversity values. The number of different haplotypes and the haplotype diversity value found from the analysis of the STRs included in the tetraplex reaction were very similar to those found from the analysis of the basic set of 7 Y-STRs (DYS19, DYS389I/II, DYS390, DYS391, DYS392 and DYS393) previously carried out on the same population sample. By combining the allelic states of the 11 Y-chromosomal STRs we could construct highly informative haplotypes that allowed the discrimination of 93.8% (120 out of 128) of the samples tested. This approach represents a very powerful tool for individual identification and paternity testing in forensic medicine.

Fidelity of polymerase chain reaction-direct sequencing analysis of damaged forensic samples.

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) direct sequence analysis was performed on aged forensic samples, six or thirteen years old. This method allowed unambiguous genetic typing, but PCR products from such samples showed several artifacts. Control samples generated sequence ambiguities at a frequency of 1 in 567 bases, but the aged samples had an error frequency about 30‐fold higher. In order to study the molecular composition of these aged DNA samples, reversed‐phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was performed. Reduced amounts of the four DNA bases were observed and anomalous peaks were found. These peaks were analyzed by ionization mass spectrometry and identified as molecular products of DNA oxidation. The frequency of sequencing artifacts was found to be proportional to the decay of the PCR templates. Although PCR fidelity is a relevant concern in the forensic analysis of damaged samples, our data indicate that the risk of mistyping is circumventable by sequencing both strands and by performing replicate amplifications from the same PCR template.

Estimating the integrity of aged DNA samples by CE.

A CE/UV method was developed to separate by a micellar system the four DNA bases and other five purinic–pyrimidinic compounds (5‐methyl‐cytosine, uracil, xanthyne, hypoxanthyne and 5‐bromo‐uracil). Selectivity, precision, accuracy and sensitivity were assessed and proved to be suitable for the analysis of the primary structure of DNA. This method was adopted to study 16 aged samples including two Egyptian mummies, formaldehyde‐fixed paraffin‐embedded tissues and other forensic specimens. Lower relative values of the four canonical unmodified DNA bases (uDNAb) and more complex pherograms were found in the aged samples when compared with the modern controls. The results of the CE analysis, together with those obtained by classical molecular methods (agarose gel electrophoresis, DNase I and RNase A assays, and UV spectrophotometry), were finally evaluated for assessing the reliability of STR typing. Since samples with low uDNAb showed no amplification or unreliable STR profiles, the uDNAb value is discussed as a further quality criterion in the evaluation of the genetic data obtained from aged samples.

Molecular characterisation of the nucleic acids recovered from aged forensic samples.

Abstract.The molecular composition of the genetic substrate recovered from seven aged forensic samples has been extensively investigated. A simple enzymatic test based on DNAseI incubation of the extracts showed that the UV-fluorescent material from the forensic specimens is composed of nucleic acids, with the DNA fraction representing at least 90% of the total amount. Since spectrophotometric determinations of the extracts showed unreliable results due to anomalous OD260/OD280 ratios, quantification of the nuclease-sensitive genetic material was performed by a slightly modified agarose plate method. The first quantitative data on exogenous contamination in aged forensic samples are provided by slot-blot hybridisation of the extracts to human, bacterial and fungal probes. Only limited amounts of human and contaminant DNA were detected in the samples. The molecular integrity of the primary structure of these aged DNA samples was analysed by reversed-phase HPLC/MS. The data show a good correlation between the degree of chemical damage and the ability to hybridise to molecular probes. The ability to achieve specific genetic profiles was assessed by multiplex PCR amplification of STR loci. Our data show that accurate determination of the molecular composition of the DNA recovered from forensic samples can be extremely useful for a reliable evaluation of the PCR typing results.

Performance of the ForenSeqTM DNA Signature Prep kit on highly degraded samples: Nucleic Acids

Next generation sequencing (NGS) is the emerging technology in forensic genomics laboratories. It offers higher resolution to address most problems of human identification, greater efficiency and potential ability to interrogate very challenging forensic casework samples. In this study, a trial set of DNA samples was artificially degraded by progressive aqueous hydrolysis, and analyzed together with the corresponding unmodified DNA sample and control sample 2800 M, to test the performance and reliability of the ForenSeqTM DNA Signature Prep kit using the MiSeq Sequencer (Illumina). The results of replicate tests performed on the unmodified sample (1.0 ng) and on scalar dilutions (1.0, 0.5 and 0.1 ng) of the reference sample 2800 M showed the robustness and the reliability of the NGS approach even from sub‐optimal amounts of high quality DNA. The degraded samples showed a very limited number of reads/sample, from 2.9–10.2 folds lower than the ones reported for the less concentrated 2800 M DNA dilution (0.1 ng). In addition, it was impossible to assign up to 78.2% of the genotypes in the degraded samples as the software identified the corresponding loci as “low coverage” (< 50x). Amplification artifacts such as allelic imbalances, allele drop outs and a single allele drop in were also scored in the degraded samples. However, the ForenSeqTM DNA Sequencing kit, on the Illumina MiSeq, was able to generate data which led to the correct typing of 5.1–44.8% and 10.9–58.7% of 58 of the STRs and 92 SNPs, respectively. In all trial samples, the SNP markers showed higher chances to be typed correctly compared to the STRs. This NGS approach showed very promising results in terms of ability to recover genetic information from heavily degraded DNA samples for which the conventional PCR/CE approach gave no results. The frequency of genetic mistyping was very low, reaching the value of 1.4% for only one of the degraded samples. However, these results suggest that further validation studies and a definition of interpretation criteria for NGS data are needed before implementation of this technique in forensic genetics.

CE analysis and molecular characterisation of depurinated DNA samples

A DNA sample was partially degraded by scalar heat‐acid treatments to study the extent of apurinic–apyrimidinic (A‐P) lesions produced along the molecule. A CE‐UV method allowed us to measure the rate of depurination at pH 5.0 and 70°C which was calculated to be 5.41×10−6 s−1 for adenine and 6.27×10−6 s−1 for guanine. CE identified depurination on treated samples when it occurred with a loss of >4% of the basic moieties. The molecular features of the A‐P enriched samples were investigated by using molecular assays (agarose gel electrophoresis, UV spectrophotometry and quantitative PCR) and the consistency of the results of the STR typing were compared with the degree of depurination of the PCR template. The treated DNA samples showed molecular features such as fragmentation, altered OD260/OD280 ratios and decreased ability of the quantitative PCR to synthesise the human target, related to the severity of depurination. A satisfactory correlation between the degree of damage and the amount of residual PCR‐sensitive target sequences was also demonstrated (r2=0.9717). The conventional and mini‐STR typing of the samples showed that the genetic outcome was influenced by a depurination damage that exceeded 4% when locus drop‐outs and artefactual PCR results were evident. As the success of STR typing depends on the integrity of the DNA recovered from the samples, the CE‐UV, physical and molecular assays described here are proposed as a set of useful methods in the analysis of certain forensic and clinical samples, for a critical evaluation of the outcome of the genetic testing.

The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics

The role of DNA damage in PCR processivity/fidelity is a relevant topic in molecular investigation of aged/forensic samples. In order to reproduce one of the most common lesions occurring in postmortem tissues, a new protocol based on aqueous hydrolysis of the DNA was developed in vitro. Twenty‐five forensic laboratories were then provided with 3.0 μg of a trial sample (TS) exhibiting, in mean, the loss of 1 base of 20, and a molecular weight below 300 bp. Each participating laboratory could freely choose any combination of methods, leading to the quantification and to the definition of the STR profile of the TS, through the documentation of each step of the analytical approaches selected. The results of the TS quantification by qPCR showed significant differences in the amount of DNA recorded by the participating laboratories using different commercial kits. These data show that only DNA quantification “relative” to the used kit (probe) is possible, being the “absolute” amount of DNA inversely related to the length of the target region (r2 = 0.891). In addition, our results indicate that the absence of a shared stable and certified reference quantitative standard is also likely involved. STR profiling was carried out selecting five different commercial kits and amplifying the TS for a total number of 212 multiplex PCRs, thus representing an interesting overview of the different analytical protocols used by the participating laboratories. Nine laboratories decided to characterize the TS using a single kit, with a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 12, obtaining only partial STR profiles. Most of the participants determined partial or full profiles using a combination of two or more kits, and a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 27. The performance of each laboratory was described in terms of number of correctly characterized loci, dropped‐out markers, unreliable genotypes, and incorrect results. The incidence of unreliable and incorrect genotypes was found to be higher for participants carrying out a limited number of amplifications, insufficient to define the correct genotypes from damaged DNA samples such as the TS. Finally, from a dataset containing about 4500 amplicons, the frequency of PCR artifacts (allele dropout, allele drop‐in, and allelic imbalance) was calculated for each kit showing that the new chemistry of the kits is not able to overcome the concern of template‐related factors. The results of this collaborative exercise emphasize the advantages of using a standardized degraded DNA sample in the definition of which analytical parameters are critical for the outcome of the STR profiles.

DNA damage promotes mistyping in the allele specific oligonucleotide probing analysis of forensic samples

Five polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products which could not be reliably typed by allele‐specific oligonucleotide (ASO) probing at the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) DQA1 locus were analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and direct sequencing. The first method revealed the preferential amplification of only one of the two alleles in two cases. Direct sequencing of PCR products allowed unambiguous genetic typing but a high number of artifacts was observed. Several of these artifacts occurred in the sequences recognized by the ASOs. This finding provides an explanation for the mistyping in the ASO probing procedure because Taq polymerase errors both created new genetic specificities and eliminated site‐specific polymorphisms. Reversed‐phase HPLC‐MS of the five forensic templates showed a high degree of DNA damage. These data together indicate that the risk of mistyping when using the ASO probing procedure cannot be neglected in the forensic analysis of damaged DNA samples.

Variation of minisatellites in chemically induced mutagenesis and in gene amplification

A mutation assay in cultured mammalian cells was developed based on direct analysis of minisatellite DNA. Chinese hamster cells (V79) were mutagenized with nitrosoguanidine and independent colonies were isolated and expanded. DNA fingerprints were then obtained after digestion with HinfI or HaeIII and hybridization with 33.15 and 33.6 probes (Jeffreys et al., 1985). 12 colonies from untreated cells were also analyzed. Digestion with HaeIII and hybridization with 33.15 probe detected the highest frequency of induced variants. The results suggest that minisatellite sequences are hypermutable sites that can be used to monitor the mutagenic effect of chemical agents. We have also analyzed the DNA fingerprints of 17 independent Chinese hamster (CHO) cell lines carrying amplification of the CAD gene. The DNA fingerprint analysis showed a variation in minisatellite regions in 3 lines while no variation was observed in independent colonies from the CHO parental cell line. The results suggest that these sequences may be hot spots for recombination during gene amplification.

DNA Extraction from Blood and Forensic Samples

Genetic analyses are performable from all the biological samples containing DNA. Thus, DNA extraction is the first and probably one of the most crucial steps of any genetic test. This chapter provides protocols for DNA extraction from both fresh blood and the big variety of biological samples that can be studied in the Forensic Laboratory. First, the general precautions which have to be adopted to prevent cross-contamination of the samples are underlined. All the extraction protocols (based upon Proteinase K/SDS lysis followed by ethanol precipitation) are carefully described while crucial steps are pointed out by footnotes. In addition, since PCR failure is common when handling aged/forensic specimens, strategies to remove substances acting as PCR inhibitors are described as well. At least, a simple and inexpensive PCR-based method allowing discriminating between removable and un-removable PCR inhibition is shown.