Patricia E. Birk

Banff '05 Meeting Report: Differential Diagnosis of Chronic Allograft Injury and Elimination of Chronic Allograft Nephropathy (‘CAN’)

The 8th Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology was held in Edmonton, Canada, 15–21 July 2005. Major outcomes included the elimination of the non‐specific term ‘chronic allograft nephropathy’ (CAN) from the Banff classification for kidney allograft pathology, and the recognition of the entity of chronic antibody‐mediated rejection. Participation of B cells in allograft rejection and genomics markers of rejection were also major subjects addressed by the conference.

Evolution and clinical pathologic correlations of de novo donor-specific HLA antibody post kidney transplant.

The natural history for patients with de novo donor‐specific antibodies (dnDSA) and the risk factors for its development have not been well defined. Furthermore, clinical and histologic correlation with serologic data is limited. We studied 315 consecutive renal transplants without pretransplant DSA, with a mean follow‐up of 6.2 ± 2.9 years. Protocol (n = 215) and for cause (n = 163) biopsies were analyzed. Solid phase assays were used to screen for dnDSA posttransplant. A total of 47 out of 315 (15%) patients developed dnDSA at a mean of 4.6 ± 3.0 years posttransplant. Independent predictors of dnDSA were HLA‐DRβ1 MM > 0 (OR 5.66, p < 0.006); and nonadherence (OR 8.75, p < 0.001); with a strong trend toward clinical rejection episodes preceding dnDSA (OR 1.57 per rejection episode, p = 0.061). The median 10‐year graft survival for those with dnDSA was lower than the No dnDSA group (57% vs. 96%, p < 0.0001). Pathology consistent with antibody‐mediated injury can occur and progress in patients with dnDSA in the absence of graft dysfunction and furthermore, nonadherence and cellular rejection contribute to dnDSA development and progression to graft loss.

Class II HLA Epitope Matching—A Strategy to Minimize De Novo Donor‐Specific Antibody Development and Improve Outcomes

De novo donor‐specific antibody (dnDSA) develops in 15–25% of renal transplant recipients within 5 years of transplantation and is associated with 40% lower graft survival at 10 years. HLA epitope matching is a novel strategy that may minimize dnDSA development. HLAMatchmaker software was used to characterize epitope mismatches at 395 potential HLA‐DR/DQ/DP conformational epitopes for 286 donor–recipient pairs. Epitope specificities were assigned using single antigen HLA bead analysis and correlated with known monoclonal alloantibody epitope targets. Locus‐specific epitope mismatches were more numerous in patients who developed HLA‐DR dnDSA alone (21.4 vs. 13.2, p < 0.02) or HLA‐DQ dnDSA alone (27.5 vs. 17.3, p < 0.001). An optimal threshold for epitope mismatches (10 for HLA‐DR, 17 for HLA‐DQ) was defined that was associated with minimal development of Class II dnDSA. Applying these thresholds, zero and 2.7% of patients developed dnDSA against HLA‐DR and HLA‐DQ, respectively, after a median of 6.9 years. Epitope specificity analysis revealed that 3 HLA‐DR and 3 HLA‐DQ epitopes were independent multivariate predictors of Class II dnDSA. HLA‐DR and DQ epitope matching outperforms traditional low‐resolution antigen‐based matching and has the potential to minimize the risk of de novo Class II DSA development, thereby improving long‐term graft outcome.

Rates and Determinants of Progression to Graft Failure in Kidney Allograft Recipients With De Novo Donor-Specific Antibody

Understanding rates and determinants of clinical pathologic progression for recipients with de novo donor‐specific antibody (dnDSA), especially subclinical dnDSA, may identify surrogate endpoints and inform clinical trial design. A consecutive cohort of 508 renal transplant recipients (n = 64 with dnDSA) was studied. Recipients (n = 388) without dnDSA or dysfunction had an eGFR decline of −0.65 mL/min/1.73 m2/year. In recipients with dnDSA, the rate eGFR decline was significantly increased prior to dnDSA onset (−2.89 vs. −0.65 mL/min/1.73 m2/year, p < 0.0001) and accelerated post‐dnDSA (−3.63 vs. −2.89 mL/min/1.73 m2/year, p < 0.0001), suggesting that dnDSA is both a marker and contributor to ongoing alloimmunity. Time to 50% post‐dnDSA graft loss was longer in recipients with subclinical versus a clinical dnDSA phenotype (8.3 vs. 3.3 years, p < 0.0001). Analysis of 1091 allograft biopsies found that dnDSA and time independently predicted chronic glomerulopathy (cg), but not interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy (IFTA). Early T cell–mediated rejection, nonadherence, and time were multivariate predictors of IFTA. Independent risk factors for post‐dnDSA graft survival available prior to, or at the time of, dnDSA detection were delayed graft function, nonadherence, dnDSA mean fluorescence intensity sum score, tubulitis, and cg. Ultimately, dnDSA is part of a continuum of mixed alloimmune‐mediated injury, which requires solutions targeting T and B cells.

The use of mycophenolate mofetil suspension in pediatric renal allograft recipients.

Abstract. Mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) is widely used to prevent acute rejection in adults after renal, cardiac, and liver transplantation. This study investigated the safety, tolerability, and pharmacokinetics of MMF suspension in pediatric renal allograft recipients. One hundred renal allograft recipients were enrolled into three age groups (33 patients, 3 months to <6 years; 34 patients, 6 to <12 years; 33 patients, 12 to 18 years). Patients received MMF 600 mg/m2 b.i.d. concomitantly with cyclosporine and corticosteroids with or without antilymphocyte antibody induction. One year after transplantation, patient and graft survival (including death) were 98% and 93%, respectively. Twenty-five patients (25%) experienced a biopsy-proven (Banff grade borderline or higher) or presumptive acute rejection within the first 6 months post-transplantation. Analysis of pharmacokinetic parameters for mycophenolic acid (MPA) and mycophenolic acid glucuronide showed no clinically significant differences among the age groups. The dosing regimen of MMF 600 mg/m2 b.i.d. achieved the targeted early post-transplantation MPA 12-h area under concentration-time curve (AUC0–12) of 27.2 µg h per ml. Adverse events had similar frequencies among the age groups (with the exception of diarrhea, leukopenia, sepsis, and anemia, which were more frequent in the <6 years age group) and led to withdrawal of MMF in about 10% of patients. Administration of MMF 600 mg/m2 b.i.d. is effective in prevention of acute rejection, provides predictable pharmacokinetics, and is associated with an acceptable safety profile in pediatric renal transplant recipients.

Surveillance biopsies are superior to functional studies for the diagnosis of acute and chronic renal allograft pathology in children

Abstract:  In this report of our 3‐yr protocol biopsy program, we describe the evolution of acute rejection (AR) and chronic renal allograft nephropathy (CAN) in a cohort of 21 children treated with antibody induction, tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisone. The aims of this study were to compare the pathogenicity of clinical acute rejection (CAR) and subclinical acute rejection (SAR), and to determine whether functional studies accurately represent acute and chronic renal allograft pathology in pediatric recipients with disproportionately large grafts. Using concurrent biopsies, we evaluated: (i) the utility of changes in the baseline sCr (ΔsCr) to predict both the onset of AR and the response to immunosuppressive therapy; and (ii) the relationship of the calculated creatinine clearance and the presence of pathologic proteinuria to the severity of CAN. We performed 112 biopsies: 11 donor, 73 protocol, 16 acute graft dysfunction and 12 1‐month follow‐up AR therapy. CAR and SAR were similar in incidence, timing and histologic severity. Progression of CAN was associated with the first episode of CAR (p < 0.02) and the cumulative number of episodes of CAR (p < 0.01), SAR (p < 0.05), CAR plus SAR (p < 0.002) and borderline SAR (B‐SAR) (p < 0.006). One‐month post‐treatment ΔsCrs could not distinguish 1‐month follow‐up biopsies with histologically confirmed worsened or unchanged AR from those with improved histology (35.2 ± 74.8% vs. 23.8 ± 24.9%, p = NS). These findings led to the addition of anti‐lymphocyte antibody therapy in five of 10 (50%) cases. Despite 100% 3‐yr actuarial graft survival and excellent function (GFR = 111 ± 36 mL/min/1.73 m2), 18 of 21 (86%) patients had grade I CAN or greater chronic histology at a mean ± sd follow‐up period of 18.2 ± 13.1 months. Thirteen of 21 (62%) patients progressed to grade I CAN at 5.2 ± 3.6 months and five (38%) of these patients progressed to grade II CAN at 17.8 ± 11.3 months. Schwartz GFR did not differ between patients with or without CAN (108 ± 38 mL/min/1.73 m2 vs. 127 ± 8 mL/min/1.73 m2, p = NS). In biopsies with CAN and no associated AR, neither the Banff chronic tubulointerstitial (Banff ci) score nor the Banff chronic grade correlated with the GFR. Proteinuria was not associated with CAN. Clinical AR and SAR are similar histologic lesions with a capacity for CAN progression. In pediatric renal transplant recipients, longitudinal protocol biopsies are superior to functional studies for the diagnosis and post‐therapeutic monitoring of AR and for the surveillance of CAN.

Does subclinical rejection contribute to chronic rejection in renal transplant patients

Renal allograft biopsies have traditionally been performed in the setting of acute graft dysfunction. However, several groups have performed graft biopsies at times of stable graft function, and more recently, after treatment of rejection episodes. Surprisingly, unequivocal histologic criteria for acute rejection have been demonstrated in a high proportion of these protocol biopsies. The Winnipeg Transplant Group has documented the high prevalence of clinically silent inflammatory infiltrates in early protocol biopsies, and demonstrated their inflammatory and cytotoxic potential by immunohistochemical and molecular biological techniques. Furthermore, in a randomized trial, our group has demonstrated that subclinical rejection, if untreated, is associated with the development of early chronic pathology and late graft dysfunction. In this overview, we will summarize the early data on subclinical allograft inflammation, present the experience of the Winnipeg Transplant Group, and discuss the possible implications of subclinical rejection on the development of chronic rejection.

Quantitation of allograft fibrosis and chronic allograft nephropathy

Abstract: Despite improvements in the prevention and treatment of acute renal allograft rejection, the long‐term survival of renal transplants has not increased. Immunologic and non‐immunologic factors contribute to the gradual deterioration of graft function and to the histologic lesion characterized by vascular and interstitial fibrosis (‘chronic rejection’). Quantitation of this process has been attempted using various invasive and non‐invasive methods. These methods, performed at different times post‐transplant, are reviewed in this article. In particular, pathology scoring systems and the potential of using computerized image analysis of biopsy material are discussed.

Macroalbuminuria and Renal Pathology in First Nation Youth With Type 2 Diabetes

OBJECTIVE To determine the prevalence of macroalbuminuria and to describe the clinical and renal pathological changes associated with macroalbuminuria in a population of Canadian First Nation children and adolescents with type 2 diabetes. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS We conducted a retrospective chart review at a single tertiary care pediatric diabetes center, and a case series was constructed. We collected data on microalbuminuria (≥3 mg/mmol creatinine [26.5 mg/g]) and macroalbuminuria (≥28 mg/mmol creatinine [247.5 mg/g]), estimated glomerular filtration rate, renal pathology, and aggravating risk factors (poor glycemic control, obesity, hypertension, glomerular hyperfiltration, hypercholesterolemia, smoking, and exposure to diabetes in utero). RESULTS We reviewed 90 charts of children and adolescents with type 2 diabetes. A total of 53% had at least one random urine albumin-to-creatinine ratio ≥3 mg/mmol (26.5 mg/g). There were 14 of 90 (16%) who had persistent macroalbuminuria at or within 8 years of diagnosis of diabetes. Of these 14 subjects, 1 had orthostatic albuminuria and 3 had spontaneous resolution of albuminuria. A total of 10 had renal biopsies performed. There were 9 of 10 who exhibited immune complex disease or glomerulosclerosis, and none had classic diabetic nephropathy. CONCLUSIONS This study suggests that the diagnosis of renal disease in children with type 2 diabetes cannot be reliably determined by clinical and laboratory findings alone. Renal biopsy is necessary for accurate diagnosis of renal disease in children and adolescents with type 2 diabetes and macroalbuminuria. The additional burden of nondiabetic kidney disease may explain the high rate of progression to end-stage kidney failure in this population.

Evaluation of C1q Status and Titer of De Novo Donor‐Specific Antibodies as Predictors of Allograft Survival

De novo donor‐specific antibodies (dnDSAs) that develop after renal transplantation are independent predictors of allograft loss. However, it is unknown if dnDSA C1q status or titer at the time of first detection can independently predict allograft loss. In a consecutive cohort of 508 renal transplant recipients, 70 developed dnDSAs. Histologic and clinical outcomes were correlated with the C1q assay or dnDSA titer. C1q positivity correlated with dnDSA titer (p < 0.01) and mean fluorescence intensity (p < 0.01) and was more common in class II versus class I dnDSAs (p < 0.01). C1q status correlated with tubulitis (p = 0.02) and C4d status (p = 0.03) in biopsies at the time of dnDSA development, but not T cell–mediated rejection (TCMR) or antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR). De novo DSA titer correlated with Banff g, i, t, ptc, C4d scores, TCMR (p < 0.01) and ABMR (p < 0.01). Post‐dnDSA graft loss was observed more frequently in recipients with C1q‐positve dnDSA (p < 0.01) or dnDSA titer ≥ 1:1024 (p ≤ 0.01). However, after adjustment for clinical phenotype and nonadherence in multivariate models, neither C1q status nor dnDSA titer were independently associated with allograft loss, questioning the utility of these assays at the time of dnDSA development.