Patrick Monnier

Large shifts in color appearance from patterned chromatic backgrounds

The perceived color of a light varies with the background on which it is seen. In the present study, patterned backgrounds composed of two different chromaticities caused larger shifts in perceived color than did a uniform background at either chromaticity within the pattern. Cortical receptive-field organization, but not optical factors or known retinal neurons, can account for the color shifts from patterned backgrounds.

Chromatic induction from S-cone patterns.

Chromatic induction from patterned backgrounds depends on the spatial as well as the chromatic aspects of the background light. Color appearance with patterned and uniform backgrounds was compared using chromaticities distinguished by only the S cones; all backgrounds were equivalent to equal-energy white in terms of L-cone and M-cone stimulation. The measurements showed larger shifts in color appearance with a patterned chromatic background than with a uniform background at any chromaticity within the pattern. The measurements also showed that inducing light within different spatial regions could cause opposite shifts in color appearance: inducing light near a test field shifted appearance toward the inducing chromaticity (assimilation), while the same light some distance from the test shifted appearance away from the inducing chromaticity (simultaneous contrast). The shifts in color appearance were accounted for by a neural receptive field with S-cone spatial antagonism.

Color shifts from S-cone patterned backgrounds: contrast sensitivity and spatial frequency selectivity

Patterned backgrounds that selectively stimulate the S-cones cause conspicuous color shifts. These shifts are accounted for by an S-cone antagonistic (+S/-S) center-surround receptive field [Monnier, P., & Shevell, S. K. (2004). Chromatic induction from S-cone patterns. Vision Research, 44, 849-856]. The present study tested two additional implications of the S-cone receptive field for color shifts: (1) proportionality of the shifts with respect to S-cone contrast within the inducing pattern and (2) bandpass selectivity of the shifts with respect to the spatial frequency of the inducing pattern. Measurements showed that the magnitude of the color shift was linear with S-cone contrast and that the largest color shift was observed with inducing patterns at an intermediate spatial frequency. These results further support an S-cone spatially antagonistic receptive field as the neural substrate mediating the large color shifts from S-cone patterns.

Uncertainty, attentional capacity and chromatic mechanisms in visual search

Two general questions were investigated using a visual search task. First, we asked whether effects of target uncertainty on reaction time varied with the discriminability of the target and distractors. Second, a higher order chromatic mechanism model was tested against a flexible model in which the signals in cardinal color-opponent mechanisms are combined through an attentional process. The models were tested by measuring the effects of target uncertainty on search time. A regression analysis indicated that the magnitude of the uncertainty effect was approximately constant in logarithmic units as a function of the chromatic difference between the target and distractors. The constant magnitude of the uncertainty effect suggested that an attentional capacity limit was exceeded when observers were required to monitor several chromatic mechanisms at several locations. The results of experiments 3 and 4 suggested that search for chromatic targets among distractors was mediated by diagonally tuned higher order chromatic mechanisms, rather than by signals in cardinal color-opponent mechanisms that were combined through an attentional mechanism.

Searching for variegated elements.

Visual search performance was investigated for variegated elements that differed from each other either in space-average chromaticity (identical chromatic contrast; Experiment 1) or in the chromatic contrast of the variegation (identical space-average chromaticity; Experiment 2). Specifically, search performance was measured as a function of noise contrast articulated either along the same color direction or orthogonally from the signal (target) variegation. Target-to-distractor difference thresholds were estimated in a two-alternative forced-choice task with briefly presented displays. First, when the signal and noise variegations were articulated along the same direction in color space, elements that differed from each other in space-average chromaticity were less susceptible to noise compared to elements that differed in the contrast of the variegation. Second, orthogonal noise had little effect on threshold supporting independence between the mechanisms mediating these searches. Third, the effect of the noise was similar across the different chromatic directions as well as between observers (but still differed for the two types of variegation) when differences in sensitivity between the various color directions and between observers were taken into account. This last statement only holds because the color space was normalized for each participant.

Detection of multidimensional targets in visual search

Search performance for targets defined along multiple dimensions was investigated with an accuracy visual search task. Initially, threshold was measured for targets that differed from homogeneous distractors along a single dimension (e.g., a reddish target among achromatic distractors, or a right-tilted target among vertically oriented distractors). Threshold was then measured for a multidimensional target (a redundant target) that differed from homogeneous distractors along two dimensions (e.g., a reddish AND right-tilted target among achromatic, vertically oriented distractors). Search performance for multidimensional target combinations of chromaticity and luminance, chromaticity and orientation, and chromaticity and spatial frequency was tested. Measurements were evaluated within several summation models, allowing for a test of the mechanisms mediating the detection of multidimensional targets in search. Measurements were generally consistent with probability summation suggesting the particular combinations of stimulus dimensions tested were coded along independent, noisy, neural mechanisms.

Set-size and chromatic uncertainty in an accuracy visual search task

Thresholds for chromatic differences were measured in a simple visual search task in which the target differed from the distractors in chromaticity only. In Experiment 1, the spatial separation between stimulus elements was varied. Slopes of threshold versus set-size (2-16) for elements in close proximity were somewhat elevated, suggesting non-independence of the stimulus elements. In Experiment 2, chromatic uncertainty was introduced to increase the attentional load beyond that accomplished with the set-size manipulation. The results were accounted for by a model assuming no limit in attention capacity. Furthermore, chromatic uncertainty was successfully modeled as a simple increase in the number of monitored signals.

Redundant coding assessed in a visual search task

Potential advantages for redundantly coded target elements were assessed using a latency visual search task. Search times for targets that differed from distractors in both color and orientation, color only, or orientation only were compared. The comparisons were performed at six levels of chromatic difference between the target and distractors and at two different levels of orientation discriminability. The results show redundant coding generally did not result in significantly faster search times compared to the other two conditions. Instead, response time for the redundant target was in large part determined by the most discriminable feature; orientation at low levels of chromatic difference and color at high levels of chromatic difference.

Color shifts induced by S-cone patterns are mediated by a neural representation driven by multiple cone types.

This study investigated chromatic induction from inhomogeneous background patterns. Previous work showed that a background pattern detected by only S cones induced strong color shifts in a nearby test area (Monnier & Shevell, 2003). In that work, the S-cone patterns were composed with constant L- and M-cone stimulation over the entire background; in terms of L and M cones, therefore, the background was uniform. S-cone stimulation was varied over space to produce S-cone-isolated background patterns. These S-cone patterns, however, established spatial structure (the pattern) at both the receptoral level (S-cone stimulation) and the postreceptoral level (S/(L+M)). Here, these two levels of pattern representation were unconfounded to determine whether color shifts induced by S-cone patterns were due to spatial structure within an S-cone-specific neural pathway versus a pathway that combines responses from S cones and other cone types (e.g. S/(L+M)). The results showed that the induced color shifts were mediated by signals within a pathway that combines responses from multiple cone types. These results are consistent with a +s/-s spatially antagonistic neural receptive field, which is found in some neurons in V1 and V2.

Influence of motion on chromatic detection.

Intense scrutiny has been focused on whether chromatic stimuli contribute to motion perception. The present study considers a related but different question: how does motion affect chromatic detection? Detection thresholds were measured for a disk that underwent a brief (13.3 ms) chromatic change in the L/(L+M) chromatic direction. The disks presentation sequence and speed (0-16 deg/s) were manipulated. In the coherent presentation sequence, the disk moved smoothly along a circular path centered on the fixation point. In the random presentation sequence, the disk appeared randomly at positions along the circular path. In both types of sequences, the disk underwent a brief chromatic change midway through the temporal presentation sequence. Threshold was elevated in the coherent condition compared to the random condition, and threshold decreased with an increase in speed. The threshold elevation observed in the coherent presentation sequence can be accounted for by temporal integration. The decrease in threshold with an increase in speed can be accounted for by spatial integration. The results, therefore, can be explained by spatiotemporal integration, without invoking a neural mechanism specialized for motion.