Peter F. Hitchcock

Stem cells in the teleost retina: persistent neurogenesis and injury-induced regeneration

The retina of the adult teleost fish is an important model for studying persistent and injury-induced neurogenesis in the vertebrate central nervous system. All neurons, with the exception of rod photoreceptors, are continually appended to the extant retina from an annulus of progenitors at the margin. Rod photoreceptors, in contrast, are added to differentiated retina only from a lineage of progenitors dedicated to making rods. Further, when the retina is lesioned, the lineage that produces only rods ceases this activity and regenerates retinal neurons of all types. The progenitors that supply neurons at the retinal margin and rod photoreceptors and regenerated neurons in the mature tissue originate from multipotent stem cells. Recent data suggest that the growth-associated neurogenic activity in the retina is regulated as part of the growth hormone/insulin-like growth factor-I axis. This paper reviews recent evidence for the presence of stem cells in the teleost retina and the molecular regulation of neurogenesis and presents a consensus cellular model that describes persistent and injury-induced neurogenesis in the retinas of teleost fish.

Persistent and injury-induced neurogenesis in the vertebrate retina

The brains of all vertebrates are persistently neurogenic. However, this is not true for the neural retinas. Only three extant classes of vertebrates show significant posthatch/postnatal retinal neurogenesis: amphibians, birds and fish. The retinas of these animals contain an annulus of progenitors at the margin, from which differentiated neurons emerge. In posthatch amphibians and fish the vast majority of the adult retina is added from the margin and neurogenesis is lifelong, whereas in posthatch birds neurogenesis is limited. Unique to fish, rod photoreceptors are added in situ from stem cells within the mature retina. Strikingly, for each class of animal retinal lesions stimulate neuronal regeneration, however the cellular source differs for each: the retinal pigmented epithelium in amphibians and embryonic birds, Müller glia in posthatch birds and intrinsic stem cells in fish. The molecular events surrounding injury-induced neuronal regeneration are beginning to be identified.

Antibodies against pax6 immunostain amacrine and ganglion cells and neuronal progenitors, but not rod precursors, in the normal and regenerating retina of the goldfish

Pax6 is a developmental regulatory gene that plays a key role in the development of the embryonic brain, eye, and retina. This gene is also expressed in discrete groups of neurons within the adult brain. In this study, antibodies raised against a fusion protein from a zebra fish pax6 cDNA were used to investigate the expression of the pax6 gene in the mature, growing, and regenerating retina of the goldfish. On western blots of retinal proteins, the pax6 antibodies recognize a single band at the approximate size of the zebra fish pax6 protein. In retinal sections, the antibodies label the nuclei of mature amacrine and some ganglion cells. At the retinal margin, where neurogenesis and cellular differentiation continually occur in goldfish, the antibodies label neuronal progenitors and the newly postmitotic neurons. Following injury and during neuronal regeneration, the antibodies label mitotically active progenitors of regenerating neurons. Rod precursors, proliferating cells that normally give rise solely to rod photoreceptors and are the presumed antecedents of the injury-stimulated neuronal progenitors, are not immunostained by antibodies to the pax6 protein. The results of this study document the identity of pax6-expressing cells in the mature retina and demonstrate that in the goldfish pax6 is expressed in neuronal progenitors during both retinal growth and regeneration.

How the Neural Retina Regenerates

The rules that govern cellular behavior during development and regeneration of tissues are complex and enigmatic, but substantial progress is being made toward understanding the molecular basis of proliferation and differentiation. Although most of the recent mechanistic insights have been gained from studies of embryonic development, the capacity of differentiated tissues and organs to regenerate is also an intriguing and important question (Lewis 1991; Brockes 1997; Ferrari et al. 1998). The greatest challenge to understanding how damaged tissues are repaired is to identify the stem cells and to understand the molecular factors that regulate their proliferation and differentiation.

The teleost retina as a model for developmental and regeneration biology.

Retinal development in teleosts can broadly be divided into three epochs. The first is the specification of cellular domains in the larval forebrain that give rise to the retinal primordia and undergo early morphogenetic movements. The second is the neurogenic events within the retina proper-proliferation, cell fate determination, and pattern formation-that establish neuronal identities and form retinal laminae and cellular mosaics. The third, which is unique to teleosts and occurs in the functioning eye, is stretching of the retina and persistent neurogenesis that allows the growth of the retina to keep pace with the growth of the eye and other tissues. The first two events are rapid, complete by about 3 days postfertilization in the zebrafish embryo. The third is life-long and accounts for the bulk of retinal growth and the vast majority of adult retinal neurons. In addition, but clearly related to the retinas developmental history, lesions that kill retinal neurons elicit robust neuronal regeneration that originates from cells intrinsic to the retina. This paper reviews recent studies of retinal development in teleosts, focusing on those that shed light on the genetic and molecular regulation of retinal specification and morphogenesis in the embryo, retinal neurogenesis in larvae and adults, and injury-induced neuronal regeneration.

Persistent neurogenesis in the teleost retina: evidence for regulation by the growth-hormone/insulin-like growth factor-I axis

Based on results from previous studies (J. Comp. Neurol. 394 (1998) 386, 395), it was hypothesized that the persistent neurogenesis in the retina of teleost fish is modulated by insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I), which, in turn, is regulated by growth hormone (GH). Two approaches were undertaken to test this hypothesis. First, a variety of techniques were used to determine if IGF-I and the IGF-I receptor (IGF-IR) are expressed in the retina. Second, GH was injected into animals to stimulate IGF-I synthesis in target tissues, and IGF-I expression and cell proliferation in the retina was quantitatively assayed. Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction, screening a retinal cDNA library and Northern analysis showed that genes encoding IGF-I and IGF-IR are expressed in the retina of goldfish. In situ hybridization showed that IGF-IR is expressed by retinal progenitors and all differentiated retinal neurons. Intraperitoneal injections of GH elevate IGF-I mRNA levels in the liver, brain and retina and produce a dose-dependent change in the proliferation of stem cells and progenitors in the retina. These data indicate that the principal components of the IGF-I signaling cascade are present in the retinas of teleosts, and we suggest these elements mediate the persistent, growth-associated neurogenesis in this tissue.

Insulin-related growth factors stimulate proliferation of retinal progenitors in the goldfish.

The retina of the adult goldfish grows throughout the life of the animal, in part, by the continual addition of new neurons. Further, destruction of extant neurons in this tissue stimulates neuronal regeneration. In an attempt to identify growth factors that regulate both normal and injury‐stimulated neurogenesis, we used organ culture techniques and tested nine peptide growth factors for their ability to modulate cell proliferation in both normal retinas and retinas with lesions. Of the growth factors tested, only the insulin‐related peptides (insulin and insulin‐like growth factors I and II) consistently stimulated proliferation, and this was restricted to the retinal progenitors within the circumferential germinal zone. None of the growth factors tested stimulated proliferation of rod precursors (cells in the mature retina whose progeny are exclusively rod photoreceptors) or the injury‐stimulated retinal progenitors. Although the negative data are subject to multiple interpretations, these data suggest that in the retina of the adult goldfish, insulin‐related peptides regulate proliferation of retinal progenitors within the circumferential germinal zone, but molecules that modulate the proliferation of the rod precursors or injury‐induced retinal progenitors in the retina of the adult goldfish have yet to be identified. J. Comp. Neurol. 394:386–394, 1998.

VSX-1 AND VSX-2: TWO CHX10-LIKE HOMEOBOX GENES EXPRESSED IN OVERLAPPING DOMAINS IN THE ADULT GOLDFISH RETINA

The genetic linkages of the murine ocular retardation mutation with the Chx10 gene and the murine small eye mutation with the Pax‐6 gene has demonstrated the importance of Paired class homeobox genes in the development of the mammalian retina. Previously, we identified a Paired‐class homeobox gene, Vsx‐1, whose expression in the adult goldfish retina is restricted to the inner nuclear layer (INL) and to postmitotic, differentiating progenitor cells in the growth zone at the retinal peripheral margin, where neurogenesis continues throughout life. Here, we report the molecular cloning and expression pattern of a new Paired class homeobox gene, Vsx‐2, in the adult goldfish retina. Like Vsx‐1, Vsx‐2 expression is highly restricted to the retina in the adult goldfish and overlaps with Vsx‐1 expression in the mature INL. At the peripheral margin, Vsx‐2 is expressed in mitotically active neuronal progenitors and is downregulated as these cells become postmitotic and begin to differentiate. Comparison of the amino acid sequences of Vsx‐2, Vsx‐1, Chx10, and C. elegans ceh‐10 reveal a conserved homeodomain and a unique domain termed the CVC domain. The similarities of the Vsx‐2, Vsx‐1, and Chx10 expression patterns suggest that genes containing the CVC domain have conserved functions during retinal development in vertebrates. J. Comp. Neurol. 387:439–448, 1997.

NeuroD regulates proliferation of photoreceptor progenitors in the retina of the zebrafish

neuroD is a member of the family of proneural genes, which function to regulate the cell cycle, cell fate determination and cellular differentiation. In the retinas of larval and adult teleosts, neuroD is expressed in two populations of post-mitotic cells, a subset of amacrine cells and nascent cone photoreceptors, and proliferating cells in the lineages that give rise exclusively to rod and cone photoreceptors. Based on previous studies of NeuroD function in vitro and the cellular pattern of neuroD expression in the zebrafish retina, we hypothesized that within the mitotic photoreceptor lineages NeuroD selectively regulates aspects of the cell cycle. To test this hypothesis, gain and loss-of-function approaches were employed, relying on the inducible expression of a NeuroD(EGFP) fusion protein and morpholino oligonucleotides to inhibit protein translation, respectively. Conditional expression of neuroD causes cells to withdraw from the cell cycle, upregulate the expression of the cell cycle inhibitors, p27 and p57, and downregulate the cell cycle progression factors, Cyclin B1, Cyclin D1, and Cyclin E2. In the absence of NeuroD, cells specific for the rod and cone photoreceptor lineage fail to exit the cell cycle, and the number of cells expressing Cyclin D1 is increased. When expression is ectopically induced in multipotent progenitors, neuroD promotes the genesis of rod photoreceptors and inhibits the genesis of Müller glia. These data show that in the teleost retina NeuroD plays a fundamental role in photoreceptor genesis by regulating mechanisms that promote rod and cone progenitors to withdraw from the cell cycle. This is the first in vivo demonstration in the retina of cell cycle regulation by NeuroD.

Human retinopathy-associated ciliary protein retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator mediates cilia-dependent vertebrate development

Dysfunction of primary cilia is associated with tissue-specific or syndromic disorders. RPGR is a ciliary protein, mutations in which can lead to retinitis pigmentosa (RP), cone-rod degeneration, respiratory infections and hearing disorders. Though RPGR is implicated in ciliary transport, the pathogenicity of RPGR mutations and the mechanism of underlying phenotypic heterogeneity are still unclear. Here we have utilized genetic rescue studies in zebrafish to elucidate the effect of human disease-associated mutations on its function. We show that rpgr is expressed predominantly in the retina, brain and gut of zebrafish. In the retina, RPGR primarily localizes to the sensory cilium of photoreceptors. Antisense morpholino (MO)-mediated knockdown of rpgr function in zebrafish results in reduced length of Kupffers vesicle (KV) cilia and is associated with ciliary anomalies including shortened body-axis, kinked tail, hydrocephaly and edema but does not affect retinal development. These phenotypes can be rescued by wild-type (WT) human RPGR. Several of the RPGR mutants can also reverse the MO-induced phenotype, suggesting their potential hypomorphic function. Notably, selected RPGR mutations observed in XLRP (T99N, E589X) or syndromic RP (T124fs, K190fs and L280fs) do not completely rescue the rpgr-MO phenotype, indicating a more deleterious effect of the mutation on the function of RPGR. We propose that RPGR is involved in cilia-dependent cascades during development in zebrafish. Our studies provide evidence for a heterogenic effect of the disease-causing mutations on the function of RPGR.