Philip E. Bernatz

Thymoma. A clinicopathologic review

The clinical and pathologic features of 283 patients with thymoma treated at the Mayo Clinic (147 female and 136 male; ages 16 years to 90 years; mean, 52 years) were examined. Forty‐six percent of the patients had myasthenia gravis and 10% had other paraneoplastic phenomena. The tumors were locally invasive at operation in 32%, including 6% with metastasis to lung or pleura. Intrathoracic recurrence was noted postoperatively in 15% of those who had total excision and distant metastasis developed in 3% of patients. Thirteen percent died of their thymomas and 16% died of myathenia. Overall 5‐year survival was 67% and 10‐year survival was 53%. Poor prognostic factors included presence of tumor‐related symptoms, large tumor size, local invasion or metastasis in initial operation, and predominantly epithelial histologic features. Although true thymomas are composed of cytologically benign elements, they show a propensity for local invasion and intrathoracic recurrence. They rarely metastasize outside the thorax.

Postsurgical Stage I Bronchogenic Carcinoma: Morbid Implications of Recurrent Disease

Three hundred forty-six patients with post-surgical non-small cell Stage I bronchogenic carcinoma were followed from 5.0 to 10.8 years (median, 7.0 years). Recurrent cancer developed in 135 patients (39%). Seventy-five recurrences were nonregional metastases (55.6%); 35 (25.9%), a subsequent primary lung cancer; and 25 (18.5%), local recurrence only. The rate of recurrent lung cancer decreased from 15.0 patients per 100 patient-years the first postoperative year to 2.3 the seventh and subsequent years. The rate of recurrence varied among the three different types of recurrent cancer. Five years after pulmonary resection, 70.0% of patients with T1 N0 neoplasms had no evidence of recurrence compared with 58.2% of patients with T2 N0 tumors (p = 0.012) and only 31.8% of patients with T1 N1 neoplasms (p less than 0.001). There was no significant difference in overall rate of recurrence among the various cell types. Currently, 174 patients are alive. Lung cancer survival (Kaplan-Meier) was 69.1% at 5 years and 61.9% at 9 years. At 2 years following detection of subsequent lung cancer, 51.8% of patients with subsequent primary lung cancer had survived lung cancer compared with 23.4% for those with local recurrence and only 8.9% for those with nonregional metastases.

Screening for lung cancer. A critique of the Mayo Lung Project.

The National Cancer Institute of the United States recently sponsored three large‐scale, randomized controlled trials of screening for early lung cancer. The trials were conducted at the Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, the Memorial Sloan‐Kettering Cancer Center, and the Mayo Clinic. Participants were middle‐aged and older men who were chronic heavy cigarette smokers and thus at high risk of developing lung cancer. Screening procedures were chest radiography and sputum cytology, the only screening tests of established value for detecting early stage, asymptomatic lung cancer. In the Hopkins and Memorial trials the study population was offered yearly chest radiography plus sputum cytology every 4 months. The control population was offered yearly chest radiography only. In these trials the addition of sputum cytology appeared to confer no lung cancer mortality rate advantage. The Mayo Clinic trial compared offering chest radiography and sputum cytology every 4 months to offering advice that the two tests be obtained once a year. This trial demonstrated significantly increased lung cancer detection, resectability, and survivorship in the group offered screening every 4 months compared with the control group. However, there was no significant difference in lung cancer mortality rate between the two groups. The statistical power of these trials was somewhat limited. Nevertheless, results do not justify recommending large‐scale radiologic or cytologic screening for early lung cancer at this time.

The Treatment of Renal Cell Carcinoma with Solitary Metastasis

Between 1950 and 1970, 44 patients (2.5 per cent) with renal cell carcinoma and a solitary metastatic lesion were treated at our clinic. Generally, treatment was aggressive, involving nephrectomy and excision of the metastatic lesion when possible. Patients presenting with the primary and metastatic lesion at the same time did not do as well as patients who presented with metastasis after nephrectomy. An operation for the metastatic lesion seemed to offer the best results in patients who presented with the solitary metastatic lesion after nephrectomy. The prognosis was uniformly poor in patients presenting with the primary and secondary lesion together, regardless of the mode of therapy. However, an operation seemed to be better marginally and did produce an occasional long-term survival.

Primary thymic carcinomas.

Within a 75-year period, 20 patients with primary nonteratomatous carcinomas of the thymus were seen at the Mayo Clinic. Fourteen were males and six were females, with a mean age of 48 years. Thirteen of the lesions were classified as poorly differentiated or spindling squamous cell carcinomas. One neoplasm was a sacromatoid carcinoma, and two showed both squamous cell and neuroendocrine ultrastructural features. The remaining four tumors had both light- and electron-microscopic features of neuroendocrine carcinomas. In all 20 patients, careful clinical and pathologic examinations, including autopsy in fatal cases, excluded malignant lymphomas and metastasis to the thymus from epithelial tumors in other anatomic sites. Thirteen patients underwent surgery, with or without postoperative radiotherapy; of these, one was alive and apparently disease-free 43 months after diagnosis. There were two operative deaths. The remaining patients received primary radiotherapy or chemotherapy, or both. The mean survival of the 16 patients who died (excluding operative deaths) was 18.7 months for the 14 patients with tumors of squamous cell differentiation and 36.0 months for the two patients with pure neuroendocrine carcinomas. Among patients with squamous cell carcinoma, 11 developed metastases to lungs, liver, bones, adrenal glands, or extrathoracic lymph nodes; nine of these died of massive local growth within the mediastinum. Among patients with neuroendocrine carcinomas, two of four patients died of local growth within the mediastinum; one of these also had metastases to the liver and adrenal glands. One patient with oat cell carcinoma was alive with residual thoracic tumor and cervical lymph node metastasis 18 months after diagnosis.

Inflammatory abdominal aortic aneurysms: A thirty-year review

The operative records of 2816 patients undergoing repair for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) from 1955 to 1985 were reviewed. Inflammatory aortic or iliac aneurysms were present in 127 patients (4.5%), 123 men and four women. Most patients were heavy smokers (92.1%). Clinical evidence of peripheral arterial occlusive disease and coronary artery disease was found in 26.6% and 39.4%, respectively. Additional aneurysms occurred in half of the patients; iliac aneurysms were the most common (55 patients), followed by thoracic or thoracoabdominal (17 patients), femoral (16 patients), and popliteal aneurysms (10 patients). Ultrasound and computed tomography suggested the diagnosis in 13.5% and 50%, respectively; angiography was not helpful. Excretory urographic findings of medial ureteral displacement or obstruction suggested the diagnosis in 31.4%. The aneurysm was repaired in 126 patients. Only one patient experienced acute aneurysm rupture, but eight patients had chronic contained leakage. When compared with patients who have ordinary atherosclerotic aneurysms, patients with inflammatory aneurysms are significantly more likely to have an elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR, 73% vs. 33%, p less than 0.0001); weight loss (20.5% vs. 10%, p less than 0.05); symptoms (66% vs. 20%, p less than 0.0001); and an increased operative mortality rate (7.9% vs. 2.4%, p less than 0.002). The triad of chronic abdominal pain, weight loss, and elevated ESR in a patient with an abdominal aortic aneurysm is highly suggestive of an inflammatory aneurysm and may be beneficial in the preoperative preparation of the patient for aneurysm repair.

Esophagomyotomy versus Forceful Dilation for Achalasia of the Esophagus: Results in 899 Patients

Between 1949 and 1976, 899 patients underwent treatment for achalasia of the esophagus at the Mayo Clinic, 431 by forceful hydrostatic or pneumatic dilation and 468 by a standardized transthoracic esophagomyotomy. Esophageal leak and mediastinal sepsis was an uncommon but major complication of both types of therapy, occurring four times more often with dilation (4%) than with myotomy (1%), although no deaths resulted from this in either group. The 30-day mortality was 0.2% after myotomy and 0.5% after forceful dilation. Although there was minimal morbidity and mortality with either modality, the late results were significantly superior after myotomy. Excellent to good results were obtained by 85% of the group treated with myotomy but only by 65% of those treated with hydrostatic dilation. Late poor results were encountered three times more frequently after dilation (19%) than after myotomy (6%). Analysis of poor results after myotomy indicates that late serious complications of gastroesophageal reflux developed in only 3% of patients operated on.

Bronchogenic Carcinoma with Chest Wall Invasion: Factors Affecting Survival Following en Bloc Resection

Sixty-six patients (54 men and 12 women) with primary bronchogenic carcinoma and documented chest wall invasion underwent en bloc chest wall and pulmonary resection at the Mayo Clinic between January 1, 1960, and January 1, 1980. Ages ranged from 36 to 85 years, with a mean of 62.2. Forty-eight lobectomies, 16 pneumonectomies, and 2 wedge excisions were performed. After operation, 31 patients were classified as T3 N0 M0, 7 as T3 N1 M0, and 12 as T3 N2 M0. In 16 patients, the N classification could not be determined (T3 Nx M0). Operative mortality was 15.2%. Actuarial five-year survival (Kaplan-Meier method) of the 56 patients surviving operation was 32.9%. Five-year survival for patients with T3 N0 M0 neoplasms was 53.7%; five-year survival for patients with N1 and N2 neoplasms was only 7.4% (p = 0.001). The effect of various factors on survival, both singularly and in combination, was assessed by Coxs proportional hazards model. Only age had a significant association with survival. Among patients with T3 N0 M0 neoplasms, five-year survival was 84.6% for those 60 years of age or less and 27.7% for patients who were older than 60 years (p = 0.009). We conclude that en bloc resection for primary bronchogenic carcinoma with chest wall invasion, while associated with a significant mortality, can be performed with a strong likelihood of long-term survival if regional lymph nodes are not metastatically involved and there is no evidence of distant metastasis.

Primary Chest Wall Tumors: Factors Affecting Survival

Between 1955 and 1975, chest wall resection was done in 90 patients for primary chest wall tumors. Ages ranged from 8 to 96 years (mean, 44.3 years). A painful mass was the most common sign and symptom. Eighty-two tumors (91.1%) were located in the lateral chest wall and eight, in the anterior thorax. The tumor was malignant in 71 patients (78.9%) and benign in 19. All patients with benign tumors had complete excision and are currently free from disease. Malignant fibrous histiocytoma, chondrosarcoma, and rhabdomyosarcoma constituted 62% of the malignant neoplasms. Most malignancies were treated by wide resection. There were no thirty-day operative deaths. Overall 1-, 5-, and 10-year survival was 89%, 57%, and 49%, respectively. Recurrent tumor developed in 37 patients (52%); 5-year survival, however, was only 17% after recurrence. Cell type and extent of invasion significantly influenced survival. Both chondrosarcoma and rhabdomyosarcoma had a better prognosis than malignant fibrous histiocytoma (p less than 0.05). We conclude that early resection is the treatment of choice for primary malignant chest wall tumors and that development of recurrent disease is an ominous event.

Carcinoid Tumors of the Lung

Resection of typical bronchial carcinoid was carried out in 203 patients. The average age was 48 years, and the sex distribution was approximately equal. Bronchoscopy was the most definitive diagnostic procedure, even though 15% of the tumors were located in the segmental bronchus or beyond. Conservative resection including local removal of the lesion was the treatment of choice, but distal suppuration and location of the tumor necessitated pneumonectomy in 54 (27%) of the patients. The incidence of metastasis was 5% (11 patients), and the overall hospital mortality was 3%. Of patients who qualified for follow-up, 94% survived 5 years, and of those who were asymptomatic preoperatively, 98% survived 5 years. The 10- and 25-year survival rates for the group as a whole were 87 and 66%, respectively.