Philip L. Cohen

The lpr and gld genes in systemic autoimmunity: life and death in the Fas lane

The single gene lpr and gld models of spontaneous systemic autoimmunity have attracted much attention in recent years. Here, Philip Cohen and Robert Eisenberg describe the fascinating recent findings that the lpr and gld [corrected] phenotypes result from defects in the Fas gene and, perhaps, in the ligand for fas, respectively.

Stochastic control of anti-Sm autoantibodies in MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr mice.

MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr autoimmune mice consistently show an approximately 25% incidence of the systemic lupus erythematosus marker autoantibody anti-Sm. In the present report, we show that the failure to find anti-Sm antibodies in three-quarters of 5-mo-old MRL/lpr mice was not an artifact of an insensitive assay, but rather that the mice fell into two populations as regards their anti-Sm positivity. Based on an extensive analysis of the incidence of anti-Sm positivity in 5-mo-old mice according to their cage of residence, we found no evidence for genetic, environmental, or parental influences on the propensity of an individual animal to become anti-Sm positive. Also, the gender of the mouse, its Sm antigen level, or its length of survival were not related to anti-Sm antibody, nor was the anti-Sm antibody status of either parent. Some animals became anti-Sm positive after 5 mo of age, but this was less likely than becoming positive before 5 mo of age. Finally, a survey of 205 autoimmune C57BL/6-lpr/lpr mice confirmed the uniqueness of the MRL background for this autoantibody response. These results together indicate that the possibility of making anti-Sm antibodies is under genetic control, but that the expression of this capability in an individual animal is governed by stochastic events. We hypothesize further that such random processes may involve the expression of particular immunoglobulin variable-region genes combined with mechanisms of extensive somatic mutation or positive feedback amplification, which would transmute an initial monoclonal response into an eventual polyclonal one.

Fas ligand (gld)‐ and Fas (lpr)‐deficient mice do not show alterations in the extravasation or apoptosis of inflammatory neutrophils

Apoptosis of neutrophils plays a critical role in the resolution of acute inflammation. Neutrophils from human peripheral blood express Fas (CD95) and are sensitive to Fas ligand (FasL)/Fas‐mediated apoptosis. Mice carrying spontaneous mutations in the genes for fas ligand (B6/gld) or fas (B6/lpr) were used to assess the role of FasL/Fas in the kinetics and magnitude of neutrophil extravasation to the thioglycolate (TG)‐inflamed peritoneum and in the spontaneous apoptosis of TG‐elicited neutrophils. The results showed that TG‐elicited neutrophils (defined by flow cytometry as GR‐1/Ly‐6Ghi cells) from normal (B6) and B6/gld mice, but not from the Fas‐deficient B6/lpr mice, express high levels of Fas. The TG‐elicited neutrophil response began at 2 h, peaked at 4 h, and subsided by 24–48 h after TG administration in all three strains. However, the response was more prolonged in B6 mice, such that B6/gld and B6/lpr mice had fewer neutrophils at 6 h after TG administration than did B6 mice. Further studies showed that 4 h TG‐elicited neutrophils from B6, B6/gld and B6/lpr mice undergo apoptosis in vitro at similar rates (as assessed through flow cytometry by the decrease in forward angle light‐scatter and externalization of phosphatidylserine (PS; as detected by Annexin V‐FITC) that occur as neutrophils undergo apoptosis). Fas expression was down‐regulated on apoptotic neutrophils in conjunction with maximal PS externalization and decreased forward angle light‐scatter. Collectively, these findings suggest that FasL/Fas‐mediated apoptosis is not essential in regulating the lifespan of neutrophils during an acute inflammatory response. The abbreviated inflammatory response observed in FasL/Fas‐deficient mice is likely to be a secondary effect of the gld/lpr autoimmune/lymphoproliferative syndrome, and not a direct effect of FasL/Fas on the ability of inflammatory neutrophils to undergo apoptosis. J. Leukoc. Biol. 64: 373–383; 1998.

Experimental induction of systemic lupus erythematosus by recognition of foreign Ia.

A chronic GVH reaction induced in normal mice results in a syndrome that closely resembles SLE. In this study, we compared the autoimmune GVH syndrome induced in parent (C57BL/6Kh [B6] and B6.C-H-2bm12 [bm12]) and F1 [( B6 x bm12]F1) mice by transfer of parental spleen cells. A majority of the mice in all groups developed autoantibodies to chromatin and erythrocytes, and some of the mice also produced anti-dsDNA antibodies. The predominant isotype of the anti-chromatin autoantibodies was found to be IgG2a, although high levels of IgG2b antibodies were also present. Autoantibody production was in general more intense and more prevalent in parent----F1 hybrid combinations, compared to parent----parent infusions. No influence of host or graft gender was observed. These studies show that a chronic GVH reaction can be induced by both parent----parent and parent----hybrid combinations.

Quantitation and IgG subclass distribution of antichromatin autoantibodies in SLE mice.

Antibodies to a native chromatin preparation were found in most mice suffering from spontaneous SLE. All MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr (MRL/lpr) sera tested (more than 500) contained antibodies to chromatin and antichromatin levels increased with age. Approximately 50% of the IgG antichromatin antibody in the MRL/lpr sera was of the IgG2a subclass, 30% IgG2b, 10% IgG1, and 10% IgG3. Interestingly, the relative restriction of antichromatin autoantibodies to the IgG2a subclass was apparent in MRL/lpr mice as young as 1 month, well before the onset of lymphadenopathy. Antichromatin autoantibodies were also detectable in sera from MRL/Mp- +/+ (MRL/+), NZB, (NZB x NZW)F1 (B x W), and BXSB mice, but were not found in sera from normal mice. A similar subclass distribution skewed toward IgG2a was seen for MRL/+, B x W, and NZB mice. These results indicate that the spontaneous autoantibody directed against chromatin is a good marker for murine SLE, and is predominantly of the IgG2a subclass.

Class II major histocompatibility antigens and the etiology of systemic lupus erythematosus

It is hypothesized that the underlying immunoregulatory dysfunction in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is altered recognition by T cells of self class II major histocompatibility antigens (Ia). The resultant cellular autoreactivity would directly cause certain of the immunopathological manifestations of SLE. The perception by T cells of self non-MHC antigens in the context of altered Ia on antigen presenting cells would also stimulate specific help for autoantibody production. Autoimmunity induced by the graft-versus-host reaction is an experimental model that illustrates this potential mechanism (A. G. Rolink, S. T. Pals, and E. Gleichmann, J. Exp. Med. 157, 755, 1983; R. A. Eisenberg, S. Y. Craven, and P. L. Cohen, Arth. Rheum. 26, S19, 1983).

Regulation of the anti-Sm autoantibody response in systemic lupus erythematosus mice by monoclonal anti-Sm antibodies.

The administration of certain monoclonal anti-Sm antibodies (2G7, 7.13) induced most MRL/lpr mice to become anti-Sm positive by 5 mo of age, although other anti-Sm monoclonals (Y2, Y12) suppressed the spontaneous response. Positive anti-Sm antibody enhancement occurred efficiently only in MRL/lpr mice and not in other systemic lupus erythematosus mice that have little spontaneous anti-Sm production. The enhancement by anti-Sm antibodies was specific for the anti-Sm response. The mechanism of the passive antibody enhancement was apparently not isotype- or idiotype-related. The fine specificity of the anti-Sm monoclonal antibody may be essential to its enhancing or suppressing effects, since both enhancing monoclonals recognized only the D Sm polypeptide, whereas both suppressing monoclonals saw the D and the B polypeptides. Furthermore, analysis of serial bleeds from unmanipulated MRL mice that developed anti-Sm positivity showed that the D specificity almost always appeared first. We hypothesize, therefore, that those animals in which an anti-Sm response is initiated by D-specific B-cell clones can become serologically positive with the aid of a positive feedback loop. In contrast, animals in which the initial specificity is for both B and D peptides would be prevented from developing a full anti-Sm response.

Tyrosine phosphorylation of a c-Src-like protein is increased in membranes of CD4- CD8- T lymphocytes from lpr/lpr mice.

Mice homozygous for the autosomal recessive lpr gene have a disorder that results in autoimmunity and massive accumulation of T lymphocytes lacking CD4 and CD8 surface markers. These abnormal T cells exhibit constitutive tyrosine phosphorylation of a component of the CD3-T-cell receptor complex. We compared membrane tyrosine phosphorylation in lpr/lpr CD4- CD8- T cells and control T cells, lpr membranes exhibited a 7.3-fold increase (n = 16) in tyrosine phosphorylation of a 60-kilodalton protein. The increase was correlated with the Lpr but not the CD4- CD8- phenotype in that p60 phosphorylation was not increased in membranes from normal CD4- CD8- thymocytes. To identify the p60 in lpr cells, we examined the activity of several T-cell tyrosine-specific protein kinases. p56lck phosphorylation was only slightly increased in lpr membranes (2.2-fold; n = 16). Phorbol ester treatment of intact T cells before membrane isolation caused p56lck to migrate as pp60lck; however, pp60lck could be clearly distinguished from the pp60 in lpr cells by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The pp60 from lpr cells exhibited several isoforms at pH approximately 6.3 to 6.5. Although on two-dimensional gels pp60c-src had a pI (6.4 to 6.8) within a similar region, p60c-src mRNA, protein, and kinase activities were not increased in lpr cells. In addition, staphylococcal V8 proteolytic cleavage of the lpr pp60 isolated on two-dimensional gels yielded two major fragments, a pattern distinct from that of pp60c-src. However, by using an antiserum against the C-terminal sequence of c-Src and other related kinases, including p59fyn, the pp60 could be immunoprecipitated in greater amounts from lpr than from control T cells. When pp59(fyn) was selectively immunoprecipitated from T-cell membranes with specific antisera, its molecular weight, proteolytic cleavage pattern, and behavior on two-dimensional gels were identical to those of the pp60 from lpr cells. We conclude that p59(fyn) phosphorylation is increased in membranes from lpr/lpr CD4(-) CD8(-) T cells and that the increase is correlated with constitutive tyrosine phosphorylation and perhaps with the expansion of this unusual T-cell population.

The polypeptide structure of the Sm and RNP nuclear antigens

Sm and nuclear ribonucleoprotein are ubiquitous nuclear antigens towards which important autoantibodies are directed in systemic lupus erythematosus and other human autoimmune syndromes. Using physicochemical techniques and affinity adsorptions, we have purified the polypeptide components of these antigens. The Sm antigen contained polypeptide chains of 15,000 and 17,000 mol. wt. The RNP antigen, which is known by immunochemical techniques to contain the Sm antigen, had the same two polypeptides as well as a larger one of 85,000 mol. wt. This larger peptide was quite labile and apparently broke down into smaller components with manipulation. In addition, the process of affinity purification of the Sm polypeptides gave a product which had increased positive charge. Amino acid analysis of the Sm polypeptides confirmed the presence of relatively large numbers of basic residues. The purified Sm antigen provided an effective reagent for the investigation of autoreactivity to Sm. The differences in structure from our results and those published by others are probably accounted for by the lability of the constituent polypeptides.

Characterization of functional T-cell lines derived from MRL mice

In an effort to characterize further the role of T cells in the autoimmune disease of MRL/Mp-lpr/lpr (lpr) mice, continuous cell lines were established from spleen and lymph nodes using EL-4 lymphoma supernatants as a source of T-cell growth factor(s). Five lines were derived from lpr spleen and lymph nodes, and an equal number from MRL/Mp- +/+ (+/+). All of the lines lost their alloreactivity after a short time in culture. Surprisingly, every line manifested marked proliferation in response to autologous irradiated spleen cells. This response was restricted to I-Ak, as it was blocked with monoclonal anti-I-Ak antibodies, and as B10.A(4R) accessory cells were stimulatory while B10.A(3R) were not. There was no difference in the degree of stimulation from lpr accessory cells compared to that in those from +/+ or other H-2k mice. The T-cell lines bore Thy-1, Ly-1, L3T4, and 7D4 (interleukin 2 (IL-2) receptor), but lacked Ly-2 and surface Ig. They proliferated in response to both conventional and recombinant DNA-derived IL-2. When cocultured with Ia-identical B cells, the T-cell lines provoked B-cell division and antibody production. The cells also caused intense proliferation when cultured with freshly isolated lpr (but not +/+) lymph node cells. The results indicate that lpr lymphoid tissue contains functional T cells reactive to autologous Ia molecules and capable of inducing both B-cell activation and the proliferation of lpr lymphocytes. Such cells may be of importance in inducing hypergammaglobulinemia, autoantibody production, and lymphoproliferation in these SLE mice.