Pilar Nozal

Autoantibodies to complement components in C3 glomerulopathy and atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome

The alternative pathway of complement is implicated in the pathogenesis of several renal diseases, such as atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome, dense deposit disease and other forms of C3 glomerulopathy. The underlying complement defects include genetic and/or acquired factors, the latter in the form of autoantibodies. Because the autoimmune forms require a specific treatment, in part different from that of the genetic forms, it is important to detect the autoantibodies as soon as possible and understand their characteristics. In this overview, we summarize the types of anti-complement autoantibodies detected in such diseases, i.e. autoantibodies to factor H, factor I, C3b, factor B and those against the C3 convertases (C3 nephritic factor and C4 nephritic factor). We draw attention to newly described autoantibodies and their characteristics, and highlight similarities and differences in the autoimmune forms of these diseases.

Complement factor I deficiency: a not so rare immune defect. Characterization of new mutations and the first large gene deletion

BackgroundComplement Factor I (CFI) is a serine protease with an important role in complement alternative pathway regulation. Complete factor I deficiency is strongly associated with severe infections. Approximately 30 families with this deficiency have been described worldwide.Patients and methodsWe have studied five new Spanish families suffering from CFI deficiency. From 19 screened people, 7 homozygous, 10 heterozygous and 2 healthy subjects were identified. Clinical, biochemical and genetic descriptions are included.ResultsMolecular studies demonstrated 4 novel mutations in the screened individuals; amongst them, we describe here the first great gene deletion reported in the CFI locus, which includes full exon 2 and part of the large intron 1.ConclusionCFI deficiency is possibly an underestimated defect and the eventual existence of this deficiency should be tested in those patients exhibiting low C3 and recurrent bacterial infections. We propose a simple diagnostic flowchart to help clinicians in the identification and correct diagnosis of such patients.BACKGROUND Dystrophin is a large essential protein of skeletal and heart muscle. It is a filamentous scaffolding protein with numerous binding domains. Mutations in the DMD gene, which encodes dystrophin, mostly result in the deletion of one or several exons and cause Duchenne (DMD) and Becker (BMD) muscular dystrophies. The most common DMD mutations are frameshift mutations resulting in an absence of dystrophin from tissues. In-frame DMD mutations are less frequent and result in a protein with partial wild-type dystrophin function. The aim of this study was to highlight structural and functional modifications of dystrophin caused by in-frame mutations. METHODS AND RESULTS We developed a dedicated database for dystrophin, the eDystrophin database. It contains 209 different non frame-shifting mutations found in 945 patients from a French cohort and previous studies. Bioinformatics tools provide models of the three-dimensional structure of the protein at deletion sites, making it possible to determine whether the mutated protein retains the typical filamentous structure of dystrophin. An analysis of the structure of mutated dystrophin molecules showed that hybrid repeats were reconstituted at the deletion site in some cases. These hybrid repeats harbored the typical triple coiled-coil structure of native repeats, which may be correlated with better function in muscle cells. CONCLUSION This new database focuses on the dystrophin protein and its modification due to in-frame deletions in BMD patients. The observation of hybrid repeat reconstitution in some cases provides insight into phenotype-genotype correlations in dystrophin diseases and possible strategies for gene therapy. The eDystrophin database is freely available: http://edystrophin.genouest.org/.

Anti-factor H antibody affecting factor H cofactor activity in a patient with dense deposit disease

Complement alternative pathway dysregulation seems to be the pathophysiological basis of Dense Deposit Disease (DDD). Here, we describe a monoclonal anti-factor H (FH) autoantibody in a woman diagnosed with DDD with a monoclonal gammapathy. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays evidenced the presence of anti-FH antibodies in the patients serum and showed that they were associated with the monoclonal IgG-λ fraction. These autoantibodies recognize the N-terminal region of FH and interfere with its regulatory function. In summary, in the DDD patient described here, the activation of complement alternative pathway was favoured by the presence of anti-FH autoantibodies that recognize the regulatory region of this protein and impede its function and which could ultimately cause the glomerulopathy.

Heterogeneity but individual constancy of epitopes, isotypes and avidity of factor H autoantibodies in atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome

Factor H (FH) autoantibodies are present in 6-10% of atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) patients, most of whom have homozygous deficiency of the FH-related protein FHR-1. Although the pathogenic role of the autoantibodies is established, little is known about their molecular characteristics and changes over time. Here, we describe the specificity and other immunological features of anti-FH autoantibodies in the Spanish and Hungarian aHUS cohorts. A total of 19 patients were included and serial samples of 14 of them were available. FH autoantibodies from FHR-1 deficient patients (n=13) mainly recognized FH, its SCR19-20 fragment and FHR-1, but autoantibody specificity in patients who are homo- or heterozygous for the CFHR1 gene (n=6) was heterogeneous. No significant changes apart from total antibody titer were observed during follow-up in each patient. Fine epitope mapping with recombinant FH SCR19-20 containing single amino acid mutations showed significantly reduced binding in 6 out of 14 patients. In most cases, autoantibody binding to residues 1183-1189 and 1210-1215 was impaired, revealing a major common autoantibody epitope. Avidities showed variations between patients, but in most cases the avidity index did not change upon time. Most autoantibodies were IgG3, and all but three presented only with kappa or with lambda light chains. Although the pathogenic role of anti-FH autoantibodies in aHUS is well established, this study shows autoantibody heterogeneity among patients, but no significant variation in their characteristics over time in each patient. The presence of a single light chain in 16 out of 19 patients and the limited number of recognized epitopes suggest a restricted autoantibody response in most patients.

An ELISA assay with two monoclonal antibodies allows the estimation of free factor H and identifies patients with acquired deficiency of this complement regulator

Complement factor H (FH) serum levels can be affected by the presence of immune complexes of FH with autoantibodies like in autoimmune forms of atypical haemolytic uraemic syndrome (aHUS) or with C3b in homozygous factor I (FI) deficiency. These complexes reduce the amount of free functional circulating FH. In this study we aimed to determine whether FH levels measurement is disturbed in some pathological conditions and to establish a method for quantifying free and total FH in serum. For that purpose, FH levels were measured in serum samples from aHUS patients having anti-FH autoantibodies or mutations in FH gene, in patients with homozygous FI deficiency, and in healthy controls. Two anti-FH monoclonal antibodies, OX24 and A229, recognizing different functional regions in FH, were used as capture antibodies in an ELISA assay. In the control group and in the group of patients with FH mutations, the FH levels obtained with the two monoclonal antibodies were similar. In patients with anti-FH autoantibodies or with homozygous FI deficiency, however, FH levels measured with both antibodies were significantly different. As these patients had complexes of FH with autoantibodies or C3b, we interpreted that OX24 was detecting total FH and A229 was recognising free FH. Therefore, quantification of FH in plasma using these two monoclonal antibodies provides not only total FH level but also gives an estimation of how much FH circulates free and is thus available to properly control complement activation.

Testing the Activity of Complement Convertases in Serum/Plasma for Diagnosis of C4NeF-Mediated C3 Glomerulonephritis.

Autoantibodies termed C3-nephritic factor (C3NeF), which stabilize convertases of the alternative complement pathway, often stimulate autoinflammatory diseases. However, knowledge about analogous autoantibodies acting on the classical pathway (C4NeF) is limited to a few reports, which indicate association with kidney dysfunction, systemic lupus erythematous, and infections. C4NeF may appear independently from C3NeF, but the lack of a routine diagnostic method predisposes C4NeF for being an underestimated player in autoinflammatory episodes. We tested the activity of classical convertases directly in serum/plasma to screen samples from 13 patients with C3 glomerulopathies and identified one patient showing significantly prolonged half-life of these enzymes. Observed effect was reproduced by immunoglobulins purified from patient’s plasma and additionally confirmed on classical convertase built from purified components. Isolated immunoglobulins protected classical convertases from both spontaneous and inhibitor-driven decay but not from C4b proteolysis. The patient had a decreased serum level of C3, elevated sC5b-9, and normal concentrations of factor B and C4. Neither C3NeF nor other autoantibodies directed against alternative pathway proteins (factor H, factor B, factor I, C3, and properdin) were found. Genetic analysis showed no mutations in C3, CFB, CFH, CFI, MCP, THBD, and DGKE genes. Renal biopsy revealed a membranoproliferative pattern with intense C3 deposits. Our results underline the importance of C4NeF as an independent pathogenic factor and a need for the implementation of routine examination of classical convertase activity. Proposed method may enable robust inspection of such atypical cases.

Complement as a diagnostic tool in immunopathology

The complement system is a complex and autoregulated multistep cascade at the interface of innate and adaptive immunity. It is activated by immune complexes or apoptotic cells (classical pathway), pathogen-associated glycoproteins (lectin pathway) or a variety of molecular and cellular surfaces (alternative pathway). Upon activation, complement triggers the generation of proteolytic fragments that allow the elimination of the activating surface by enhancing inflammation, opsonization, phagocytosis, and cellular lysis. Moreover, complement efficiently discriminates self from non-self surfaces by means of soluble and membrane-bound complement regulators which are critical for innate self-tolerance. Complement deficiency or dysfunction disturb complement homeostasis and give rise to diseases as diverse as bacterial infections, autoimmunity, or renal and neurological disorders. Research on complement-targeted therapies is an expanding field that has already improved the prognosis of severe diseases such as atypical Haemolytic Uremic syndrome or Paroxysmal Nocturnal Haemoglobinuria. Therefore, complement analysis and monitoring provides valuable information with deep implications for diagnosis and therapy. In addition to its important role as an extracellular defense system, it has now become evident that complement is also present intracellularly, and its activation has profound implications for leukocyte survival and function. In this review, we summarize the essential, up-to-date information on the use of complement as a diagnostic and therapeutic tool in the clinics.