R. F. Sturrock

Immunity after treatment of human schistosomiasis mansoni. II. Identification of resistant individuals, and analysis of their immune responses.

Intensities of re-infection were monitored at three-monthly intervals after treatment of Schistosoma mansoni infections in a group of 119 Kenyan schoolchildren, whose levels of water contact were also observed. 22 children showed high reinfection intensities (greater than 100 eggs per gram of faeces) by 12 months after treatment, and were considered to be susceptible. Out of 70 children who showed low reinfection intensities during the same period (less than 30 eggs per gram), 35 showed high levels both of total water contact and of contact with sites containing infected snails. In these children, the relative lack of reinfection could not be attributed to a lack of exposure, and they were classified as resistant to reinfection. Comparison of the two groups, resistant and susceptible, revealed no difference in pretreatment intensities of infection. However, there was a marked difference in age, the mean age of the resistant group being two years greater than that of the susceptible group, within a restricted starting age range. These findings indicated that resistance was an acquired and age-dependent phenomenon, not obviously related to previous egg-induced pathology. Studies of immune responses revealed no clearcut correlate of resistance, but there were interesting differences between the two groups. Whereas anti-egg antigen responses declined after treatment to a greater extent in the resistant than in the susceptible group, antibodies mediating eosinophil-dependent killing of schistosomula rose markedly in both groups, strongly suggesting that the resistant children were being exposed to cercariae. Anti-adult worm antibodies rose sharply in both groups immediately after treatment, and thereafter declined to pretreatment levels. Although some individual children showed high levels of IgE anti-schistosomulum antibodies, there were no significant differences between the two groups. Since all children showed detectable levels of antibodies mediating eosinophil-dependent killing of schistosomula, the possibility was considered that such antibodies might be a necessary, but not a limiting, factor in immunity. Instead, the functional state of the effector cells mediating antibody-dependent killing might be limiting. Eosinophil levels, measured as an indirect estimate of eosinophil functional activity, did not differ between the two groups. There were, however, marked differences between different individuals in their capacity to produce eosinophil-stimulating monocyte mediators, and although this cannot yet be related to resistance, this aspect is worth further study.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Immunity after treatment of human schistosomiasis mansoni. I. Study design, pretreatment observations and the results of treatment

This paper describes the design of a study on immunity to reinfection after treatment of children with Schistosoma mansoni infections, the initial observations on transmission that led to the selection of the study population, the effects of treatment, and the results of immunological tests carried out before and at five weeks after treatment. Iietune village in Machakos District, Kenya, was selected on the basis of high prevalence and intensities of infection in a small preliminary survey, a stable population living in a small area amenable to detailed study, and a lack of previous intervention in the area. Subsequent observations over a pretreatment period of one year confirmed that prevalence and intensities of infection among children attending the local primary school were high. This was associated with extensive contact of members of the community with water-bodies shown to contain large numbers of infected snails. Analysis of pretreatment intensities of infection and water contact patterns in the schoolchildren allowed the selection of 129 children showing a broad scatter between: (a) high intensity, low water contact, and predicted to be non-immune, and (b) low intensity, high water contact, and predicted to be immune. These children were treated with oxamniquine, 30 mg/kg in divided doses. Five weeks after treatment, 70% of children showed apparent complete cure, and the over-all reduction in geometric mean egg output was 98.9%. Since these children represented only a small proportion of the whole community, there was no obvious reduction in transmission, as reflected by snail infection rates, during the following five-month period. Thus, we are in a position to determine whether successfully treated children do or do not become reinfected in a high transmission environment in which it will be possible to make direct estimates of exposure. Immunological tests carried out immediately before treatment were consistent with a pattern of high exposure leading to the early expression of immune responses in most infected children. Eosinophil levels were elevated in 61% of the children, all of whom showed detectable levels of antibodies against adult worm and egg antigens, as measured by ELISA. In addition, all patients showed antibodies capable of mediating eosinophil-dependent killing of schistosomula. At five weeks after treatment, eosinophil counts and anti-adult worm antibody levels had risen, whereas anti-egg antibodies remained grossly unchanged. The wide variation in the levels of responses shown by different individuals will allow us to test whether such responses are associated with resistance to reinfection during the follow-up period.

Efficacy and side effects of praziquantel treatment in a highly endemic Schistosoma mansoni focus at Lake Albert, Uganda

The aim of the study was to assess the efficacy and side effects following single and repeated (6 weeks apart) praziquantel treatment (40 mg/kg) in a Schistosoma mansoni-endemic focus with long-standing transmission at Lake Albert in Uganda between December 1996 and January 1997. The results were based on 482 individuals, randomly representing all age and both gender groups. The cure rate following the first and second treatments was 41.9% and 69.1%, respectively. The cure rate was higher in adults than in children, irrespective of intensity of infection. In addition, the cure rate declined markedly with increasing intensity of infection. The reduction in intensity of infection was marked, being 97.7% and 99.6% after the first and second treatments, respectively. A pre- and post-treatment symptom questionnaire revealed a broad range of side effects, including abdominal pain and diarrhoea. However, no serious or long-lasting complications affecting compliance were observed. The marked reductions in faecal egg excretion and the acceptable level of side effects point to a single praziquantel treatment (40mg/kg) as the strategy of choice in such a highly endemic S. mansoni focus.

A statistical approach to schistosome population dynamics and estimation of the life-span of Schistosoma mansoni in man

Dynamic models which predict changes in the intensity of schistosome infection with host age are fitted to pre-intervention Schistosoma mansoni data from Kenya. Age-specific post-treatment-reinfection data are used to estimate the force of infection, thus enabling investigation of the rate of worm death. An empirical and statistical approach is taken to the model fitting: where possible, distributional properties and function relationships are obtained from the data rather than assumed from theory. Attempts are made to remove known sources of bias. Maximum likelihood techniques, employed to allow for error in both the pre-intervention and reinfection data, yield confidence intervals for the worm life-span (CI95% = 5.7-10.5 years) and demonstrate that the worm death rate is unlikely to vary with host age. The possibilities and limitations of fitting dynamic models to data are discussed. We conclude that a detailed, quantitative approach will be necessary if progress is to be made with the interpretation of epidemiological data and the models intended to describe them.

Comparison of different chemotherapy strategies against Schistosoma mansoni in Machakos District, Kenya : effects on human infection and morbidity

A comparison was made of the long-term impact of different methods of administration of chemotherapy (oxamniquine, 30 mg/kg in divided doses; or praziquantel, 40 mg/kg) on prevalence and intensity of Schistosoma mansoni infection in four areas in Kangundo Location, Machakos District, Kenya. In Area A, treatment was offered in October 1983 and again in April 1985 to all infected individuals. In Area H, treatment was offered in April 1985 to individuals excreting greater than or equal to 100 eggs per gram (epg) of faeces. In Area S, treatment was offered in April 1985 to all infected school children, within the framework of the primary schools. In the witness area, Area W, treatment was given in April 1985, for ethical reasons, to a small number of individuals excreting greater than or equal to 800 epg. Prevalence and intensities of infection were subsequently monitored at yearly intervals for three complete post-treatment years. In the Area S schools, clinical examination was also carried out at yearly intervals. Treatment of all infected individuals on two occasions (Area A) was the most effective and long-lasting way of reducing prevalence and intensity of infection. In this area, however, some earlier interventions had been carried out and pre-treatment intensities were lower than in the other areas. Treatment only of infected schoolchildren (Area S) also had a marked and prolonged effect, comparable to or better than treatment of individuals with heavy infections (Area H). Treatment of infected schoolchildren also caused a persistent reduction in the prevalence of hepatomegaly, and there was suggestive evidence from intensities of infection in community stool surveys (but not from incidence rates) of an effect on transmission. In all study areas, reinfection was most rapid and most intense among children. These findings are discussed in the light of theoretical considerations and of results from other studies, both on schistosomiasis and on intestinal helminths. We conclude that, in areas of low morbidity such as Kangundo, chemotherapy of schoolchildren only, at intervals of up to 3 years, is a satisfactory way of producing a long-term reduction in both intensity of infection and morbidity.

On the use of age-intensity data to detect immunity to parasitic infections, with special reference to Schistosoma mansoni in Kenya

We consider two phenomena, related to the host age-intensity profiles of parasitic infections, which have been suggested to be indicative of acquired immunity: (i) a lower age of peak intensity among more intensely infected hosts; and (ii) a decline with age in the dispersion of the distribution of parasites between hosts. We demonstrate that these phenomena occur among Kenyan schoolchildren infected with Schistosoma mansoni, although the magnitude of both is small. We also examine the mathematical models underlying these predictions and conclude that both phenomena are possible in the absence of acquired immunity or, indeed, in the absence of any density-dependent effect. In our opinion, insufficient attention has been focused upon mathematical models, describing the null hypothesis, i.e. density-independent models. In particular, we regard the usual assumptions made for the two stochastic components of these models, describing the heterogeneity between hosts and the probabilistic nature of infection and death of parasites, as too rigid and unrealistic. We demonstrate that deviation from these assumptions undermines the qualitative distinctions between models which describe acquired immunity or density dependence and those which are density-independent.

Schistosomiasis epidemiology and control: how did we get here and where should we go?

Although a disease of great antiquity, scientific studies of schistosomiasis began only 150 years ago. The complete life-cycle was not described until just before the First World War, making it possible at last to plan proper community control programmes. Inadequate tools prevented their effective implementation until well after the Second World War when new tools became available, thanks to the newly formed World Health Organization. Molluscicides spearheaded control programmes until the late 1970s but were then replaced by the newly developed, safe drugs still used today. Whatever the method used, the initial goal of eradication was, in the light of experience and cost, gradually replaced by less ambitious targets; first to stop transmission and then to reduce morbidity. The most successful programmes combined several methods to minimise reinfection after chemotherapy. Comparisons between different programmes are difficult without using appropriate, standardised diagnostic techniques and the correct epidemiological measurements. Some examples will be presented, mainly from our studies on Schistosoma mansoni in Kenya. Drug resistance on a scale comparable with malaria has not occurred in schistosomiasis but the likely withdrawal of all drugs except praziquantel leaves its control extremely vulnerable to this potential problem. An effective, affordable vaccine for use in endemic countries is unlikely to be ready for at least 5 years, and developing strategies for its use could take a further decade or more, judging from experience with drugs and molluscicides. In the interim, by analogy with malaria, the most cost-effective approach would the use of drugs combined with other methods to stop transmission, including molluscicides. The cost of molluscicides needs to be reduced and fears allayed about their supposedly adverse ecological effects.

Seroepidemiology and serodiagnosis of schistosomiasis in Kenya using crude and purified egg antigens of Schistosoma mansoni in ELISA

The performance of antibody detection for the diagnosis of schistosomiasis has been evaluated in Kenya. Approximately 1500 blood samples from 3 areas with endemic schistosomiasis (Schistosoma mansoni only, S. haematobium only, and a mixed infection area), and from a non-endemic control area, were tested for their antibody reactivity in an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The results were compared with infection status determined by parasitological examination. Two test antigens were used: unfractionated S. mansoni egg homogenate (SEA), and CEF6, a previously described, partially purified fraction of SEA containing 2 cationic antigens. The antigens prepared from eggs of Kenya and Puerto Rico S. mansoni isolates gave very similar results. Bloods from patients with S. haematobium infection cross-reacted significantly with the two S. mansoni antigen preparations, but reactivity against CEF6 appeared more specifically indicative of S. mansoni infection. Of 254 blood samples from schoolchildren in the non-endemic area, 100% gave ELISA optical density readings at 492 nm (OD492) < 0.20 against SEA, and 98% were < 0.20 against CEF6. With 887 blood samples from subjects of all ages in the area endemic for S. mansoni alone, using an ELISA OD492 cut-off point of 0.20, SEA and CEF6 had sensitivities of 94% and 97% respectively, and specificities of 64% and 59% respectively. Increasing the OD492 cut-off value reduced the sensitivity and increased the specificity of both test antigens. Specificity of both antigens was poor with samples from 234 children in an area endemic for both S. mansoni and S. haematobium (< 20% for both antigens at an OD492 cut-off value of 0.20).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Spatial patterns of human water contact and Schistosoma mansoni transmission and infection in four rural areas in Machakos district Kenya.

This paper presents the results of microgeographical studies of human water contact behavior and Schistosoma mansoni transmission levels and intensity of infection in four rural areas in Machakos District, Kenya. The relationship between intensity of infection (geometric mean egg counts) in 3502 persons aggregated in 120 household clusters and eight independent variables was investigated using straight and stepwise linear regression and mapping techniques. Results indicate that the two water contact variables, mean frequency per person and mean duration per person, as well as mean number of sites used per person, a transmission index and mean distance to the most frequently used site were the strongest predictors of geometric mean egg counts. All three distance variables were usually negatively associated with infection although intensity of infection and water contact declined relatively slowly with distance from the streams. This pattern appears to be owing to a combination of the relatively short distances, a general lack of safe alternative water sources and the use of more distant water contact sites both inside and outside the study area during periods of drought. The study of snail-to-man transmission identified number of infected snails as the major transmission variable and number of contacts as the major predictor variable. Mapping of total egg counts at the household cluster level and total number of infected snails revealed spatial association with transmission sites. All results varied considerably between study areas, owing to differences in exposure levels, transmission patterns and environmental factors. Findings are discussed in relation to the epidemiology and control of schistosomiasis and suggestions are made for further spatial studies.

The isolation of a 22 kDa band after SDS-PAGE of Schistosoma mansoni adult worms and its use to demonstrate that IgE responses against the antigen(s) it contains are associated with human resistance to reinfection

In schistosomiasis endemic areas, intensities of reinfection after treatment are greater amongst young children than amongst adults, and high levels of parasite‐specific IgE are associated with resistance to reinfection in an age‐dependent manner. Previously we have reported that, in Western blots, a 22 kDa band was recognized by human IgE and that the incidence and intensity of S. mansoni reinfection were significantly lower amongst individuals who had IgE against this band, compared with those who did not (Dunne et al. 1992). Here we report the isolation of a 22 kDa SDS‐PAGE band, its incorporation into ELISA and the demonstration that levels of human anti‐22 kDa IgE had a significant negative correlation with intensities of subsequent reinfection. Rabbit anti‐22 kDa band serum recognized the outer tegument, gut tegument, and the collecting ducts and flame cells of adult worms. The 22 kDa band antigen(s) was also present in ‘lung’‐ and ‘post‐lung’ schistosomula stages of S. mansoni, and in S. haematobium, S. bovis and S. japonicum adult worms. Metabolic labelling of schistosomula and worms demonstrated the in vitro synthesis and release of 22 kDa antigens.