R. Marsh

The clinical spectrum of anxiety in Parkinson's disease

Anxiety is common in Parkinsons disease (PD), and contributes to increased disability and poorer quality of life. In spite of its significant impact, the symptomatology, chronology, and neurobiology of anxiety in PD are all poorly understood, and this hinders accurate diagnosis and development of effective treatment strategies. This review investigates and updates literature related to the clinical spectrum of anxiety in PD. The reported prevalence of anxiety in PD varies considerably, with emerging interest in the frequency of the DSM‐IV residual category of “Anxiety disorder, not otherwise specified” (Anxiety disorder NOS), which is observed in up to 25% of PD patients. By design, there are no standardized diagnostic criteria for Anxiety disorder NOS, because this is the category applied to individuals who do not meet diagnostic criteria for any other current anxiety disorder. Anxiety rating scales incompletely capture anxiety symptoms that relate specifically to PD symptoms and the complications arising from PD therapy. Consequently, these scales have been deemed inappropriate for use in PD, and there remains a need for the development of a new PD‐specific anxiety scale. Research establishing accurate symptom profiles of anxiety in PD is sparse, although characterizing such symptomatology would likely improve clinical diagnosis and facilitate targeted treatment strategies. Research into the neurobiological and psychological underpinnings of anxiety in PD remains inconclusive. Anxiety can precede the onset of PD motor symptoms or can develop after a diagnosis of PD. Further investigations focused on the chronology of anxiety and its relationship to PD diagnosis are required.

Clinical issues in the treatment of anxiety and depression in older adults with Parkinson’s disease

A significant proportion of persons affected by Parkinsons disease (PD) are over age 65 years. Mental health issues are often less a focus of treatment in this population than physical manifestations of the illness. Anxiety or depression alone, as well as comorbid depression and anxiety, are underrecognized in patients with PD and are associated with deleterious effects on physical and interpersonal functioning, negatively impacting quality of life and well‐being. We offer a brief overview of salient clinical points with respect to assessment and treatment approaches to enhance efficacy of the treatment of mental health symptoms in older adults with PD. Cognitive behavior therapy involves the patient learning to overcome behavioral avoidance associated with anxiety and challenge unhelpful negative cognitions. It is suggested that cognitive behavior therapy is an effective approach to treatment of anxiety and depression in PD and should be offered as a treatment to patients.

Validity and reliability of the Geriatric Anxiety Inventory in Parkinson's disease

Aim:  To examine the psychometric properties of a novel anxiety rating scale, the Geriatric Anxiety Inventory (GAI) in Parkinsons disease (PD).

Validity of Hamilton Depression Inventory in Parkinson's Disease

Studies investigating the assessment of depression in Parkinsons disease (PD) are limited. We examined the concurrent validity and the internal consistency of the Hamilton Depression Inventory (HDI) and compared it to the Hamilton and Geriatric Depression Scales. PD patients (n = 79) were recruited from neurology clinics. Diagnosis of depressive disorder was made according to DSM‐IV criteria. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to calculate sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values. The HDI exhibited an optimal cutoff for discriminating between depressed and nondepressed PD patients of 13.5/14.0 and is a valid instrument to use in the setting of PD.

Disease-specific anxiety symptomatology in Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND Symptoms of anxiety relating to Parkinsons disease (PD) occur commonly and include symptomatology associated with motor disability and complications arising from PD medication. However, there have been relatively few attempts to profile such disease-specific anxiety symptoms in PD. Consequently, anxiety in PD is underdiagnosed and undertreated. The present study characterizes PD-related anxiety symptoms to assist with the more accurate assessment and treatment of anxiety in PD. METHODS Ninety non-demented PD patients underwent a semi-structured diagnostic assessment targeting anxiety symptoms using relevant sections of the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI-plus). In addition, they were assessed for the presence of 30 PD-related anxiety symptoms derived from the literature, the clinical experience of an expert panel and the PD Anxiety-Motor Complications Questionnaire (PDAMCQ). The onset of anxiety in relation to the diagnosis of PD was determined. RESULTS Frequent (>25%) PD-specific anxiety symptoms included distress, worry, fear, agitation, embarrassment, and social withdrawal due to motor symptoms and PD medication complications, and were experienced more commonly in patients meeting DSM-IV criteria for an anxiety disorder. The onset of common anxiety disorders was observed equally before and after a diagnosis of PD. Patients in a residual group of Anxiety Not Otherwise Specified had an onset of anxiety after a diagnosis of PD. CONCLUSION Careful characterization of PD-specific anxiety symptomatology provides a basis for conceptualizing anxiety and assists with the development of a new PD-specific measure to accurately assess anxiety in PD.

The Psychiatric and Neuropsychiatric Symptoms After Subthalamic Stimulation for Parkinson’s Disease

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) is an established treatment for the motor symptoms of Parkinsons disease (PD). Nonmotor features of PD, however, may not improve with STN DBS, and a specific constellation of neuropsychiatric symptoms may emerge in the postoperative period. Mania, impulsivity, depression, and apathy may curtail the potential gains from surgery. In this paper, the authors discuss surgical candidacy, postoperative management of neuropsychiatric issues, and clinical dilemmas for the psychiatrist at the DBS center. A paradigm that considers stimulation effects and dopamine replacement therapy to be key drivers of postoperative neuropsychiatric problems is presented.

Cognitive behavior therapy for anxiety in Parkinson’s disease: outcomes for patients and caregivers

ABSTRACT Objective: Anxiety negatively impacts the quality of life of Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients and caregivers. Despite high prevalence, there is a paucity of trials investigating effective treatments for anxiety in PD. This uncontrolled study investigated the use of a manualized and tailored Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) for anxiety in PD. Methods: Participants completed 6 weekly CBT sessions. Pre-, post- and follow-up (3 and 6 months) assessments were made. Change in outcomes were analysed using t-tests and Reliability Change Index. Of 17 PD patients who agreed to CBT, 12 completed the intervention. Results: This study showed a significant reduction in Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale scores in PD immediately post CBT (t(11) = 3.59, p < .01), maintained at 3-month (t(8) = 2.83, p = .02) and 6-month (t(7) = 2.07, p = .04) follow-up. A reduction in caregiver burden (t(11) = 2.68, p = .03) was observed post intervention. Improvements in motor disability (t(11) = 2.41, p = .04) and cognitive scores (t(11) = −2.92, p = .01) were also observed post intervention and at follow-up. Conclusions: Tailored CBT can be used to treat anxiety in PD. Clinical Implications: This study provides preliminary evidence suggesting that tailored CBT reduces anxiety in PD with persisting benefits, and lowers caregiver burden.

Characteristics and Treatment of Anxiety Disorders in Parkinson's Disease

Background: Anxiety disorders are common in Parkinsons disease (PD) and are undertreated. The current study investigates demographic and PD‐specific factors associated with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM‐IV) anxiety disorders and subsyndromal anxiety in PD. It also examines the use of pharmacological and nonpharmacological treatments for anxiety in PD. Methods: Ninety nondemented PD patients completed a semistructured interview. Logistic regression models were constructed examining associations between several demographic, disease‐specific, and treatment factors, as well as both current syndromal, DSM‐IV anxiety disorders, and subsyndromal anxiety. Results: Associations were found between current DSM‐IV anxiety disorder, as well as female gender, younger age, more severe stages of PD, and poor activities of daily living. Subsyndromal anxiety was related to a younger onset age of PD. Relationships were also found between both anxiety groups and more complications of PD therapy, as well as higher depression scores. There were no associations between anxiety and levodopa equivalent daily dosage, motor disability, and cognition. In our sample, 57% of patients with current DSM‐IV anxiety disorders or subsyndromal anxiety were not currently treated with pharmacotherapy. Of those who currently received such treatment, 83% still experienced current anxiety disorders. Results suggest that anxiety is poorly recognized and treated in PD. Conclusions: Clinical trials investigating the efficacy of pharmacotherapy, tailored psychotherapy, and combination therapy primarily focusing on anxiety are much needed, with the aim of establishing novel targeted treatment protocols for the management of subtypes of anxiety disorders in PD.

Deep brain stimulation for depression: Scientific issues and future directions

Objective: Deep brain stimulation is an experimental intervention for treatment-resistant depression. Open trials have shown a sustained response to chronic stimulation in many subjects. However, two recent randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials failed to replicate these results. This article is a conceptual paper examining potential explanations for these discrepant findings. Method: We conducted a systematic review of the published studies obtained from PubMed and PsycINFO. Studies were selected if they directly examined the impact of deep brain stimulation on depressive symptoms. We excluded case reports and papers re-describing the same cohort of patients. We compared them with data from the placebo-controlled trials, available from Clinicaltrials.gov and abstracts of the American Society for Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery. We supplemented our investigation by reviewing additional publications by the major groups undertaking deep brain stimulation for mood disorders. Results: We selected 10 open studies reporting on eight cohorts of patients using four different operative targets. All published studies reported positive results. This was not replicated in data available from the randomised, placebo-controlled trials. Many studies reported suicide or suicide attempts in the postoperative period. Conclusion: We consider the placebo effect, the pattern of network activation, surgical candidacy and design of a blinded trial including the length of a crossover period. We suggest a greater focus on selecting patients with melancholia. We anticipate that methodological refinements may facilitate further investigation of this technology for intractable depression. We conclude by noting the psychiatric adverse events that have been reported in the literature to date, as these will also influence the design of future trials of deep brain stimulation for depression.

Validity of a Self-Rated Method to Identify a Lifetime History of Depression in Parkinson's Disease

Defining depression in Parkinsons disease (PD) is challenging, given the overlap of symptoms between parkinsonism and depression. We recently reported on the validity of two self‐rated depression rating scales in PD.1 These rating scales are useful to identify current depressive status in PD patients, but by themselves, do not identify a lifetime history of depression. We have recently extended our original work, and here we report and validate a self‐rated method to dichotomise PD patients according to their lifetime history of depression. This method can be used in risk factor studies to obtain two extreme groups of ‘ever’ and ‘never’ depressed; as illustrated in our recent genetic study.2