R. W. Blamey

A prognostic index in primary breast cancer

From a multiple-regression analysis of prognostic factors and survival in a series of 387 patients with primary breast cancer, a prognostic index has been constructed, based on lymph-node stage, tumour size and pathological grade. This index is more discriminating than lymph-node stage alone, and enables a larger group of patients to be identified with a very poor prognosis.

Epidermal growth factor receptor expression in breast cancer: association with response to endocrine therapy.

Summary106 previously untreated breast cancer patients have been immunohistochemically analysed for EGF-R, ER, Ki67, and c-erbB-2 product. All patients received assessable endocrine therapy following disease progression. Significant associations were observed between EGF-R and ER (inverse) and Ki67 (direct). No association was observed between EGF-R and the c-erbB-2 product. EGF-R expression was significantly associated with the loss of endocrine sensitivity in breast cancer. This was observed in both ER positive and negative disease. In ER positive breast cancers, EGF-R expression had no significant influence on the quality of tumour remissions. Further sub-classification of the ER/EGF-R data by Ki67 immunostaining showed that in ER+/EGF-R- disease, increasing proportions of Ki67 positive cells were associated with a decline in the numbers of women experiencing good quality tumour remissions. A similar trend was also observed in ER+/EGF-R+ tumours. The presence of c-erbB-2 protein product did not influence endocrine sensitivity in any of the ER/EGF-R sub-groups.

p53 protein expression in mammary ductal carcinoma in situ: Relationship to immunohistochemical expression of estrogen receptor and c-erbB-2 protein

The immunohistochemical expression of the p53 gene protein was examined in a consecutive series of 143 cases of pure ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) of the breast. Expression of wild-type and/or mutant p53 protein was detected in 36 (25.2%) of the cases examined, as evidenced by positive nuclear staining with the monoclonal antibody DO 7. Thirty-four (35.8%) of the large cell cases showed p53 protein expression compared with two (4.1%) of the small cell cases (chi 2 = 15.3 [df = 1], P < .001). p53 Protein expression also was associated with an increased histologic degree of necrosis, with a nearly significant association of negative tumor estrogen receptor status and p53 protein expression. No significant association of p53 protein expression and c-erbB-2 protein expression was seen. Immunohistochemical expression of p53 protein is present in approximately 25% of DCIS cases and is confined almost exclusively to large cell DCIS, a morphologic subtype of in situ breast carcinoma thought to be more biologically aggressive. Expression of p53 protein may be important in the neoplastic progression of DCIS, reflecting the acquisition of p53 gene mutations in large cell DCIS cases. Therefore, p53 may be implicated in mammary tumor evolution from in situ to invasive disease.

Assessment of angiogenesis in breast carcinoma: An important factor in prognosis?

Recent evidence suggests that angiogenesis, as assessed by vascular density, may be an independent prognostic factor in breast carcinoma. The authors chose to examine this hypothesis further using two different methods, both using an immunohistochemical technique to assess vascularity. In the first, tissue sections from 93 patients with human breast carcinoma were immunostained for the endothelial antigen CD 34. Fields were selected at random in sections stained with the monoclonal antibody QBEnd/10, and both the number of blood vessels and percentage of endothelial cells per unit area measured using an interactive image analysis system (SEESCAN). In the second, an additional 72 patients were added and the 165 sections immunostained for CD31 (PECAM 1) using the monoclonal antibody JC 709. The area of highest vascular density was then identified and measured. A statistically significant correlation was found between percentage endothelial area and tumor type (P < .03) using the first method, and, for lymph node-negative patients only, between vascular density and tumor type (P < .02) using the second method. There was no correlation with lymph node status, recurrence, distant metastases, or overall survival using either method (minimum follow-up 12 years). The authors conclude that the evaluation of tumor angiogenesis using these methods does not provide additional prognostic information in this group of patients.

A randomized comparison of tamoxifen with surgical oophorectomy in premenopausal patients with advanced breast cancer.

We randomized 122 premenopausal women to receive tamoxifen or to undergo a surgical oophorectomy. Of 54 evaluable women treated with tamoxifen, 24% had an objective response, as compared with 21% of 53 women having an oophorectomy. The median duration of response for tamoxifen (20 months) was longer than that for surgical oophorectomy (7 months), but this did not achieve statistical significance (P = .056). Overall median survival was 15 months for 58 patients receiving tamoxifen and 25 months for 53 patients undergoing oophorectomy (P = .18). Toxicity was greater in those undergoing oophorectomy, though both treatments were well tolerated. In those premenopausal women for whom hormonal therapy is indicated, tamoxifen is a suitable alternative to surgical oophorectomy.

Mastectomy or tamoxifen as initial therapy for operable breast cancer in elderly patients: 5-year follow-up☆

135 consecutive patients aged over 70 years with operable primary breast cancer (clinically maximum diameter 5 cm) were randomised to either wedge mastectomy or tamoxifen 20 mg twice daily as initial therapy. The mean time from randomisation is now 65 months. There was no difference between the two groups in terms of overall survival or cause of death. Likewise, the groups were similar for site of initial metastatic disease and the probability of developing metastatic disease. However, failure of locoregional control was significantly greater in the tamoxifen group. The optimum treatment for elderly patients with operable breast cancer includes mastectomy.

c-erbB3 and c-erbB4 expression is a feature of the endocrine responsive phenotype in clinical breast cancer.

We examined c-erbB3 and c-erbB4 mRNA expression in 47 primary breast cancer samples by simultaneous RT–PCR and have investigated correlations between these parameters and the expression of both ER and EGFR mRNA and protein as measured by RT–PCR and ICA and with Ki67 immunostaining. A direct association was found between c-erbB3 and c-erbB4 mRNA and ER marker status measured by either RT–PCR (c-erbB3 P=0.0003; c-erbB4 P=0.02) or ICA (c-erbB-3 P=0.002; c-erbB4 P=0.01). Inverse associations were seen between c-erbB3 and c-erbB4 mRNA marker status and EGFR membrane protein (c-erbB3: P=0.003; c-erbB4: P=0.003) and mRNA (c-erbB4: P=0.009) status. These associations were reinforced by Spearman Rank Correlation Tests. A significant relationship was seen between Ki67 and c-erbB4 mRNA status and level. Measurements of c-erbB3 protein levels in tumour samples removed from a further 89 patients of known response to endocrine therapy: (i) confirmed the relationship between c-erbB3 and ER and (ii) identified that patients whose ER positive tumours expressed high levels of c-erbB3 were most likely to benefit from endocrine measures. A non-significant trend was recorded between c-erbB3 levels and Ki67 immunostaining. These results clearly demonstrate that increased c-erbB3 and c-erbB4 expression appears to be associated with the prognostically-favourable ER phenotype.

Relationship between oestrogen-receptor content and histological grade in human primary breast tumours

A series of 300 patients presenting consecutively with primary operable breast cancer has been studied. A significant correlation was found between oestrogen-receptor (ER) content and histological grade: the better-differentiated tumours rarely lacked receptor. This correlation was significant only in women defined as post-menopausal. Data on early recurrence of disease indicate a worse prognosis for women in whom primary tumours are ER-.

Comparison of mastectomy with tamoxifen for treating elderly patients with operable breast cancer.

STUDY OBJECTIVE--Comparison of tamoxifen and mastectomy in treatment of breast cancer in elderly patients. DESIGN--Randomised trial of treatment of operable breast cancer by wedge mastectomy or tamoxifen, with median follow up 24 and 25 months respectively (range 1-63). SETTING--University hospital; most patients from primary catchment area. PATIENTS--135 consecutive patients with breast cancer aged over 70 with operable tumours (less than 5 cm maximum diameter); 68 were allocated to tamoxifen group and 67 to mastectomy group. Histological diagnosis by biopsy. Two incorrect randomisations in each group. Patient characteristics similar in the two groups and all under care of one surgical team. INTERVENTIONS--Mastectomy group received wedge mastectomy plus excision of symptomatic axillary lymph nodes. Tamoxifen group received continuous treatment with tamoxifen 20 mg twice daily. Patients in tamoxifen group received wedge mastectomy if there was sign of local progression. Those in mastectomy group received further excision or radiotherapy for locoregional recurrence and when local treatments had been exhausted or metastatic disease diagnosed they received tamoxifen. END POINT--Treatment efficacy was assessed by local control of disease and by survival. MAIN RESULTS--Mortality from metastatic cancer in tamoxifen group was 7 (10.6%) and in mastectomy group 10 (15.3%) (NS). There was no difference in survival between the two groups. In mastectomy group 70% remained alive and free of local recurrence at 24 months; in tamoxifen group only 47% remained alive and free of local progression. In mastectomy group locoregional recurrence occurred in 16 patients and metastatic disease in 13; in tamoxifen group locoregional progression occurred in 29 patients and metastatic disease in seven. CONCLUSIONS--As a high proportion of patients treated with tamoxifen eventually required surgery treatment of elderly patients with breast cancer should include mastectomy. Optimum treatment may include both mastectomy and tamoxifen.

Relationship between primary breast tumor receptor status and patient survival.

For a minimum of 30 months, 250 women who underwent mastectomy for primary breast cancer have been followed up. ER status has had a pronounced effect upon disease‐free interval and survival: in patients with node involvement ER‐positive (ER+) tumors carry a better prognosis.