Rachna Ujwal

The crystal structure of mouse VDAC1 at 2.3 Å resolution reveals mechanistic insights into metabolite gating

The voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) constitutes the major pathway for the entry and exit of metabolites across the outer membrane of the mitochondria and can serve as a scaffold for molecules that modulate the organelle. We report the crystal structure of a β-barrel eukaryotic membrane protein, the murine VDAC1 (mVDAC1) at 2.3 Å resolution, revealing a high-resolution image of its architecture formed by 19 β-strands. Unlike the recent NMR structure of human VDAC1, the position of the voltage-sensing N-terminal segment is clearly resolved. The α-helix of the N-terminal segment is oriented against the interior wall, causing a partial narrowing at the center of the pore. This segment is ideally positioned to regulate the conductance of ions and metabolites passing through the VDAC pore.

Crystallizing membrane proteins using lipidic bicelles.

Crystallization of membrane proteins remains a significant challenge. For proteins resistant to the traditional approach of directly crystallizing from detergents, lipidic phase crystallization can be a powerful tool. Bicelles are an excellent medium for crystallizing membrane proteins in a lipidic environment. They can be described as bilayer discs formed by the mixture of a long-chain phospholipid and an amphiphile in an aqueous medium. Membrane proteins can be readily reconstituted into bicelles, where they are maintained in a native-like bilayer environment. Importantly, membrane proteins have been shown to be fully functional in bicelles under physiological conditions. Protein-bicelle mixtures can be manipulated with almost the same ease as detergent-solubilized membrane proteins, making bicelles compatible with standard equipment including high-throughput crystallization robots. A number of membrane proteins have now been successfully crystallized using the bicelle method, including bacteriorhodopsin, β2 adrenergic receptor, voltage-dependent anion channel, xanthorhodopsin and rhomboid protease. Because of the success with a variety of membrane proteins and the ease of implementation, bicelles should be a part of every membrane protein crystallographers arsenal.

Post-translational Modifications of Integral Membrane Proteins Resolved by Top-down Fourier Transform Mass Spectrometry with Collisionally Activated Dissociation

Integral membrane proteins remain a challenge to proteomics because they contain domains with physicochemical properties poorly suited to todays bottom-up protocols. These transmembrane regions may potentially contain post-translational modifications of functional significance, and thus development of protocols for improved coverage in these domains is important. One way to achieve this goal is by using top-down mass spectrometry whereby the intact protein is subjected to mass spectrometry and dissociation. Here we describe top-down high resolution Fourier transform mass spectrometry with collisionally activated dissociation to study post-translationally modified integral membrane proteins with polyhelix bundle and transmembrane porin motifs and molecular masses up to 35 kDa. On-line LC-MS analysis of the bacteriorhodopsin holoprotein yielded b- and y-ions that covered the full sequence of the protein and cleaved 79 of 247 peptide bonds (32%). The experiment proved that the mature sequence consists of residues 14–261, confirming N-terminal propeptide cleavage and conversion of N-terminal Gln-14 to pyrrolidone carboxylic acid (−17.02 Da) and C-terminal removal of Asp-262. Collisionally activated dissociation fragments localized the N6-(retinylidene) modification (266.20 Da) between residues 225–248 at Lys-229, the sole available amine in this stretch. Off-line nanospray of all eight subunits of the cytochrome b6f complex from the cyanobacterium Nostoc PCC 7120 defined various post-translational modifications, including covalently attached c-hemes (615.17 Da) on cytochromes f and b. Analysis of murine mitochondrial voltage-dependent anion channel established the amenability of the transmembrane β-barrel to top-down MS and localized a modification site of the inhibitor Ro 68-3400 at Cys-232. Where neutral loss of the modification is a factor, only product ions that carry the modification should be used to assign its position. Although bond cleavage in some transmembrane α-helical domains was efficient, other regions were refractory such that their primary structure could only be inferred from the coincidence of genomic translation with precursor and product ions that spanned them.

The Electrostatics of VDAC: Implications for Selectivity and Gating

The voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) is the major pathway mediating the transfer of metabolites and ions across the mitochondrial outer membrane. Two hallmarks of the channel in the open state are high metabolite flux and anion selectivity, while the partially closed state blocks metabolites and is cation selective. Here we report the results from electrostatics calculations carried out on the recently determined high-resolution structure of murine VDAC1 (mVDAC1). Poisson-Boltzmann calculations show that the ion transfer free energy through the channel is favorable for anions, suggesting that mVDAC1 represents the open state. This claim is buttressed by Poisson-Nernst-Planck calculations that predict a high single-channel conductance indicative of the open state and an anion selectivity of 1.75--nearly a twofold selectivity for anions over cations. These calculations were repeated on mutant channels and gave selectivity changes in accord with experimental observations. We were then able to engineer an in silico mutant channel with three point mutations that converted mVDAC1 into a channel with a preference for cations. Finally, we investigated two proposals for how the channel gates between the open and the closed state. Both models involve the movement of the N-terminal helix, but neither motion produced the observed voltage sensitivity, nor did either model result in a cation-selective channel, which is observed experimentally. Thus, we were able to rule out certain models for channel gating, but the true motion has yet to be determined.

Affixing N-terminal α-helix to the wall of the voltage-dependent anion channel does not prevent its voltage gating.

Background: There is ongoing controversy concerning the location and mobility of the N-terminal α-helix in VDAC1 during voltage gating. Results: mVDAC1 with the N-terminal α-helix cross-linked to β-strand 11 forms typical voltage-gated channels. Conclusion: The N-terminal domain of VDAC1 does not move independently during voltage gating. Significance: This study dramatically alters the current view of voltage gating dynamic in VDAC1. The voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC) governs the free exchange of ions and metabolites between the mitochondria and the rest of the cell. The three-dimensional structure of VDAC1 reveals a channel formed by 19 β-strands and an N-terminal α-helix located near the midpoint of the pore. The position of this α-helix causes a narrowing of the cavity, but ample space for metabolite passage remains. The participation of the N-terminus of VDAC1 in the voltage-gating process has been well established, but the molecular mechanism continues to be debated; however, the majority of models entail large conformational changes of this N-terminal segment. Here we report that the pore-lining N-terminal α-helix does not undergo independent structural rearrangements during channel gating. We engineered a double Cys mutant in murine VDAC1 that cross-links the α-helix to the wall of the β-barrel pore and reconstituted the modified protein into planar lipid bilayers. The modified murine VDAC1 exhibited typical voltage gating. These results suggest that the N-terminal α-helix is located inside the pore of VDAC in the open state and remains associated with β-strand 11 of the pore wall during voltage gating.

Crystal packing analysis of murine VDAC1 crystals in a lipidic environment reveals novel insights on oligomerization and orientation.

All eukaryotic cells require efficient trafficking of metabolites between the mitochondria and the rest of the cell. This exchange is carried out by the dominant protein in the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM), the Voltage Dependent Anion Channel (VDAC), which serves as the primary pathway for the exchange of ions and metabolites between the cytoplasm and the intermembrane space of the mitochondria. Additionally, VDAC provides a scaffold for the binding of modulator proteins to the mitochondria and has been implicated in mitochondriadependent cell death. We recently determined the structure of the murine VDAC1 (mVDAC1) at 2.3Å resolution crystallized in a native-like bilayer environment. The high-resolution structure provided concise structural details about the voltage-sensing N-terminal domain and catalyzed new hypotheses regarding the gating mechanisms for metabolites and ions that transit the OMM. In this study, the crystal packing of mVDAC1 is analyzed revealing a strong antiparallel dimer that further assemble as hexamers mimicking the native oligomeric packing observed in EM and AFM images of the OMM. Oligomerization has been shown to be important for VDAC regulation and function, and mVDAC1 crystal packing in a lipidic medium reveals insights on how oligomerization is accomplished using protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions. Furthermore, orientation of VDAC in the OMM remains uncertain due to inconsistencies in antibody labeling studies. The physiological implications of a novel antiparallel arrangement are addressed that may clarify these conflicting biochemical data.

High-throughput crystallization of membrane proteins using the lipidic bicelle method.

Membrane proteins (MPs) play a critical role in many physiological processes such as pumping specific molecules across the otherwise impermeable membrane bilayer that surrounds all cells and organelles. Alterations in the function of MPs result in many human diseases and disorders; thus, an intricate understanding of their structures remains a critical objective for biological research. However, structure determination of MPs remains a significant challenge often stemming from their hydrophobicity. MPs have substantial hydrophobic regions embedded within the bilayer. Detergents are frequently used to solubilize these proteins from the bilayer generating a protein-detergent micelle that can then be manipulated in a similar manner as soluble proteins. Traditionally, crystallization trials proceed using a protein-detergent mixture, but they often resist crystallization or produce crystals of poor quality. These problems arise due to the detergents inability to adequately mimic the bilayer resulting in poor stability and heterogeneity. In addition, the detergent shields the hydrophobic surface of the MP reducing the surface area available for crystal contacts. To circumvent these drawbacks MPs can be crystallized in lipidic media, which more closely simulates their endogenous environment, and has recently become a de novo technique for MP crystallization. Lipidic cubic phase (LCP) is a three-dimensional lipid bilayer penetrated by an interconnected system of aqueous channels. Although monoolein is the lipid of choice, related lipids such as monopalmitolein and monovaccenin have also been used to make LCP. MPs are incorporated into the LCP where they diffuse in three dimensions and feed crystal nuclei. A great advantage of the LCP is that the protein remains in a more native environment, but the method has a number of technical disadvantages including high viscosity (requiring specialized apparatuses) and difficulties in crystal visualization and manipulation. Because of these technical difficulties, we utilized another lipidic medium for crystallization-bicelles (Figure 1). Bicelles are lipid/amphiphile mixtures formed by blending a phosphatidylcholine lipid (DMPC) with an amphiphile (CHAPSO) or a short-chain lipid (DHPC). Within each bicelle disc, the lipid molecules generate a bilayer while the amphiphile molecules line the apolar edges providing beneficial properties of both bilayers and detergents. Importantly, below their transition temperature, protein-bicelle mixtures have a reduced viscosity and are manipulated in a similar manner as detergent-solubilized MPs, making bicelles compatible with crystallization robots. Bicelles have been successfully used to crystallize several membrane proteins (Table 1). This growing collection of proteins demonstrates the versatility of bicelles for crystallizing both alpha helical and beta sheet MPs from prokaryotic and eukaryotic sources. Because of these successes and the simplicity of high-throughput implementation, bicelles should be part of every membrane protein crystallographers arsenal. In this video, we describe the bicelle methodology and provide a step-by-step protocol for setting up high-throughput crystallization trials of purified MPs using standard robotics.

Fluorescence Detection of Heavy Atom Labeling (FD-HAL): A rapid method for identifying covalently modified cysteine residues by phasing atoms

Membrane protein crystallography frequently stalls at the phase determination stage due to poor crystal diffraction and the inability to identify heavy atom derivatization prior to data collection. Thus, a majority of time, effort and resources are invested preparing potential derivatized crystals for synchrotron data collection and analysis without knowledge of heavy atom labeling. To remove this uncertainty, we introduce Fluorescence Detection of Heavy Atom Labeling (FD-HAL) using tetramethylrhodamine-5-maleimide (a fluorescent maleimide compound) to monitor in-gel cysteine residue accessibility and ascertain covalent modification by mercury, platinum and gold compounds. We have tested this technique on three integral membrane proteins (LacY, vSGLT and mVDAC1) and can quickly assess the optimal concentrations, time and heavy atom compound to derivatize free cysteine residues in order to facilitate crystal phasing. This, in conjunction with cysteine scanning for incorporating heavy atoms at strategic positions, is a useful tool that will considerably assist in phasing membrane protein structures.

Chapter 5 Practical Aspects of Membrane Proteins Crystallization in Bicelles

Publisher Summary The structure determination of membrane proteins is a significant challenge. One of the important bottlenecks is growing high quality crystals. The crystallization of membrane proteins directly from detergents is by far the most popular approach; although, lipidic cubic phase crystallization is attracting increasing use. This chapter introduces the use of bicelles as an alternative method for the crystallization of membrane proteins. Bicelles are a mixture of a detergent and a lipid and can be described as a compromise between the two media with beneficial aspects from both. Membrane proteins reconstituted in bicelles are maintained in a native like bilayer environment and can be manipulated with almost the same ease as detergent solublized membrane proteins, making it compatible with standard high-throughput screening. An increasing number of recent bicelle crystallization successes support the expanded use of this method, including β 2-adrenergic receptor, the voltage-dependent anion channel, and xanthorhodopsin. This chapter describes the bicelle method, its properties, advantages and disadvantages and considers how to achieve future progress with the bicelle method.

The Electrostatics of VDAC: Implications in Selectivity and Gating

Voltage-dependant anion channels (VDAC) are transmembrane proteins found in high abundance in the outer mitochondrial membrane of sacchromyces cerevisiae and all higher eukaryotes. VDAC is gated, or opened and closed, by changes in voltage across the membrane as well as pH, and it is thought to mediate the transfer of metabolites such as ATP, ADP, and NADH between the cytoplasm and intermembrane space. Apoptotic regulating proteins interact directly with VDAC to modulate the mitochondrial membrane potential and control the release of cytochrome c during apoptosis. Additionally, altered VDAC permeability has been associated with cancer and cardiovascular disease. Recently the x-ray crystal structure of VDAC from mouse (mVDAC1) was solved at 2.3 A resolution making it possible to study the molecular workings of this channel in unprecedented detail. Our lab is using computational methods to explore the biophysical properties of the channel. I will discuss the results from continuum electrostatics calculations that show that the channel is selective for anions, which suggests that the x-ray structure is in the open state. This claim is buttressed by Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) calculations that predict a high single channel conductance indicative of the open state. Furthermore, we performed in silico mutagenesis on residues shown to be involved in selectivity, and the changes in the calculated free energy profiles are consistent with experimental changes in selectivity. I will end by discussing how we used membrane potential calculations to rule out a proposed gating mechanism of the channel.