Ray Brettle

HIV and harm reduction for injection drug users.

This review seeks to examine not the evidence for and against harm reduction with regard to the treatment of drug dependency, but whether harm reduction can have a substantial impact on the spread of HIV

Changes in use of antiretroviral therapy in regions of Europe over time

Objectives:To analyse use of antiretroviral therapy within Europe between 1994 and 1997. Design:From September 1994, the EuroSIDA study (cohorts I-III) has prospectively followed unselected HIV-infected patients from 50 clinical centres in 17 European countries (total, 7230). Methods:Patients under follow-up at half-year intervals from September 1994 (n = 2871) to September 1997 (n = 3682) were classified according to number of drugs currently used (none, one, two, three, four or more). Use of antiretroviral therapy was stratified by CD4 cell count (< 200 versus ≥ 200 × 106/1) and by region of Europe (south, central, or north). Frequency data were compared by χ2 test and logistic regression modelling. Results:The proportion of patients on antiretroviral monotherapy diminished over time (1994, 42%; 1997, 3%), as did the proportion of patients without therapy (from 37 to 9%). Over time, the proportion of patients on triple (from 2 to 55%) and quadruple (from 0 to 9%) therapy increased, whereas use of dual therapy peaked in 1996 and subsequently fell. In the three regions of Europe, changes in use of antiretroviral therapy differed substantially, However, as of September 1997, only minor differences persisted. The proportion of patients on dual, triple, and quadruple therapy were as follow: south, 33, 52 and 5%, respectively; central, 23, 55 and 14%, respectively; north, 16, 59 and 10%, respectively. In September 1997, odds for use of three or more drugs including at least one protease inhibitor did not differ significantly between regions. Conclusions:Use of antiretroviral therapy in Europe has changed dramatically towards combination treatment in the last few years. Regional differences in use of antiretroviral therapy have decreased, and by September 1997 only minor differences remained. Antiretroviral therapy with three or more drugs and use of protease inhibitors has become more common in all regions of Europe.

Transmission of HIV to heterosexual partners of infected men and women.

Future heterosexual spread of HIV will in part depend on the efficiency of transmission from men to women and from women to men. We studied seventy-eight female sexual partners of men infected with HIV and 18 male sexual partners of infected women. Participants were interviewed concerning sexual practices, use of contraception and other risk factors for HIV infection. Fifteen out of 78 (19.2%) female partners and one out of eighteen (5.5%) male partners were seropositive for HIV antibody. All couples had practised vaginal intercourse. Seropositive female partners did not differ significantly from seronegative partners with regard to length of relationship, number of acts of vaginal intercourse, other sexual practices, stage of clinical disease in the index case, or numbers of other sexual partners in the last five years. In two women, seroconversion was documented after one act of unprotected sexual intercourse. The majority of infected female partners (eight out of 15) had sexual relationships with men who were asymptomatic and did not practice anal intercourse. Biological factors such as variability in infectivity of the index case and susceptibility of the contact, as well as behavioural variables may be important in determining transmission.

Progression of HIV : follow-up of Edinburgh injecting drug users with narrow seroconversion intervals in 1983-1985

ObjectiveTo describe progression and survival of individuals infected with HIV by injecting drug use in Edinburgh. Design and methodsFrom 313 HIV-infected patients with retrospectively estimated narrow seroconversion intervals, 260 infected via injecting drug use in the years 1983–1985 were selected for the study group. Main outcome measuresThe effects of gender, age, human leukocyte antigen (HLA) type and zidovudine (ZDV) treatment on progression and survival from seroconversion; Weibull estimates of the AIDS incubation distribution and the overall survival distribution; slopes of absolute CD4 lymphocyte loss (on the square root scale) and loss of CD4 percentage. ResultsThe cumulative progression rates at 10 years were 68% to CDC stage IV and 31% to AIDS with a mortality rate of 25%. Three-year survival rates for AIDS and CDC stage IV cases were 25 and 72%, respectively. Gender and age effects on progression or overall survival were not found, although those aged over 30 years experienced poorer survival from AIDS. A strong HLA (A1,B8,DR3) association with faster progression and poorer survival was found. Median survival was estimated by Weibull distribution to be 12.6 years; median AIDS-free time was estimated to be 11.6 years. CD4 cell loss was approximately linear when transformed to the square root scale as was the decline in CD4 percentage. Only HLA effects on slopes were found: A1,B8,DR3 was significantly associated with faster loss of both absolute CD4 cells and CD4 percentage (P < 0.001) and B27 was significantly associated with slower loss of CD4 percentage (P = 0.01). ConclusionsEdinburgh IDU do not seem to progress more rapidly than other cohorts with predominantly different risk activities. Older age was associated with poorer survival from AIDS but no gender effect was found for progression or overall survival. The clearest significant association with AIDS progression, mortality and loss of CD4 cells was the phenotype HLA A1,B8,DR3. In contrast HLA B27 was associated with slower loss of CD4 cells.

HIV and drug misuse in the Edinburgh cohort

Summary: The Edinburgh cohort of intravenous drug users (IVDUs) became infected with HIV between 1983 and 1984. Before the era of effective therapy, many of these infected IVDUs displayed cognitive impairments on progressing to AIDS and were found to have HIV encephalitis (HIVE). Full autopsies were conducted on these patients, providing an opportunity to study the intersecting pathology of pure HIVE and drug use. High proviral load in the brain correlated well with the presence of giant cells and HIV p24 positivity. In presymptomatic HIV infection, IVDUs were found to have a lymphocytic infiltrate in the central nervous system (CNS). Apart from the expected microglial activation in the presence of HIV infection of the CNS, drug use in its own right was found to be associated with microglial activation. Examination of HIV‐negative IVDUs revealed a number of neuropathologic features, including microglial activation, which may underpin HIV‐related pathology in the CNS. HIV isolated from different regions of the brain was exclusively of R5‐tropic type throughout the course of infection. Detailed studies of p17gag and V3 sequences suggest that viral sequestration occurs in the CNS before the onset of AIDS and that increasing diversity of HIV variants within the brain is associated with increasing severity of HIVE. Because brain isolates have proved to be different from those in lymphoid tissue (and blood), it is likely that selective neuroadaptive pressures operate before HIVE supervenes. Drug abuse may be synergistic in this process through activation of microglia, breakdown of the blood‐brain barrier, and direct neurotoxicity. Collections of clinically well‐characterized HIV‐infected tissues such as those in the Edinburgh Brain Bank are a vital resource to support ongoing studies of viral pathogenesis in the CNS and interactions with drug abuse.

Mismatched human leukocyte antigen alleles protect against heterosexual HIV transmission

Summary: Genetic variation at the human leukocyte antigen (HLA) loci has been shown to be an important risk factor for progression to HIV disease, but its significance in infection is less well understood. We have investigated its role in HIV transmission in a cohort of individuals at risk for heterosexual infection. Analysis of over 80 individuals revealed that that the degree of concordance at HLA A, B, and DR loci differs significantly between transmitting and nontransmitting couples at risk for heterosexual HIV transmission (p < .02), suggesting that allogeneic immune responses may confer a degree of protection against HIV infection. Analysis of the frequencies of specific alleles at the A, B, and DR loci revealed a significantly higher frequency of HLA DR5 among exposed uninfected individuals, relative to population controls.

Does drug abuse influence the microglial response in AIDS and HIV encephalitis

Objectives: To investigate the pathological evidence for a possible interaction between drugs of abuse and HIV infection in terms of microglial responses in early and late HIV/AIDS, and to discuss the possible long-term consequences of microglial activation in chronic HIV infection. Design: This brain pathology study compared age and sex-matched control patients with HIV-negative intravenous drug users, and with HIV-positive drug users both in the presymptomatic stage and with AIDS. A further group of non-drug-using AIDS patients was included. All the AIDS patients had HIV encephalitis (HIVE) but no other significant HIV-associated brain pathology. Methods: Microglia/macrophages were identified in the grey and white matter of the frontal and temporal lobes and the thalamus, using antibodies to CD68 and MHCII. Objective quantitation was used to compare subjects in the different groups. Results: AIDS patients showed a significant increase in activated microglia/macrophages in both the grey and white matter of all areas compared with non-AIDS patients. Drug users with HIVE tended to have more activated microglia than non-drug-using comparison groups, but this difference was not found in all brain areas studied. Conclusion: Drug misuse appears to enhance the microglial activation resulting from HIV infection in some individuals. Other factors such as the severity of HIVE, or systemic immune factors, are also likely to affect the degree of microglial activation. The implications for drug-using patients who survive long term with HIV/AIDS are discussed, particularly in relation to premature neurodegeneration.

Combination therapy for HIV: the effect on inpatient activity, morbidity and mortality of a cohort of patients

Summary: We set out to quantify the changes in HIV-related morbidity and mortality associated with the clinical use of antiretroviral therapy via prospectively collected patient-related events (admissions, bed days, deaths, WHO stage 3 and 4 events and drug costs) on all HIV patients known to the Regional Infectious Disease Unit (RIDU) from 1 January 1987 to 31 December 1996. The introduction of zidovudine monotherapy in 1987 for those with AIDS was associated with a subsequent decline of inpatient activity for 2 years: in 1989 there was a 23% reduction in bed days but only a 6% reduction in admissions. A further dramatic decline of patient-related events in those with AIDS was noted during 1996 following the introduction of combination therapy, a 39% reduction in admissions, 44% reduction in bed days, 54% reduction in stage 4 events, 33% reduction in WHO stage 3 events and 40% reduction in the death rate. Reductions were also observed for patients without AIDS including a 42% reduction in the rate of patients developing AIDS. Similar reductions were noted when the patients were classified by immunological instead of clinical status although data for 1997 suggest an increase in patient-related activity for those with CD4 counts 200 cells/ul possibly as a result of low levels of anti-HIV therapy. The introduction of combination therapy for HIV has to date led to a minimum saving of one inpatient bed per 100 patient years which helped defray the cost of combination therapy. Although we cannot imply causality from an observational study, dramatic reductions in patientrelated activity were associated with the introduction of combination therapy into clinical practice. The ultimate extent and duration of this effect cannot as yet be predicted and caution is required since similar reductions were noted with zidovudine therapy which were unfortunately time limited.

Survival following HIV infection of a cohort followed up from seroconversion in the UK.

Objectives: To estimate changes over calendar time in survival following HIV seroconversion in the era of HAART and to provide updated survival estimates. Methods: Using data from a UK cohort of persons with well estimated dates of HIV seroconversion, we analysed time from seroconversion to death from any cause using Cox models, adjusted for prognostic factors. Kaplan–Meier methods were then used to determine the expected survival in each calendar period. Results: 2275 seroconverters were included with 18 695 person-years of follow up. A total of 444 (20%) died. The relative risk of death, compared with pre-1996, decreased over time to 0.63 [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.48–0.81], 0.24 (0.17–0.34), 0.14 (0.10–0.21), 0.08 (0.05–0.13) and 0.03 (0.02–0.06) in 1996–1997, 1998–1999, 2000–2001, 2002–2003 and 2004–2006, respectively. An elevated risk of death was associated with older age at seroconversion [hazard ratio (HR), 1.49; 95% CI, 1.34–1.66 per 10-year increase] and HIV infection through injecting drug use (HR, 1.53; 95% CI, 1.17–2.00). In 2000–2006, the proportion of individuals expected to survive 5, 10 and 15 years following seroconversion was 99%, 94% and 89%, respectively. Conclusions: Survival following HIV seroconversion has continued to improve over calendar time in our cohort, even in the more recent years of HAART availability. HIV seroconverters, by definition identified early in their infection, are likely to have the greatest opportunity for intervention; if similar high survival expectations are to be seen in the wider HIV-infected population, early diagnosis is likely to be crucial.

Rising population cost for treating people living with HIV in the UK, 1997-2013.

Background The number of people living with HIV (PLHIV) is increasing in the UK. This study estimated the annual population cost of providing HIV services in the UK, 1997–2006 and projected them 2007–2013. Methods Annual cost of HIV treatment for PLHIV by stage of HIV infection and type of ART was calculated (UK pounds, 2006 prices). Population costs were derived by multiplying the number of PLHIV by their annual cost for 1997–2006 and projected 2007–2013. Results Average annual treatment costs across all stages of HIV infection ranged from £17,034 in 1997 to £18,087 in 2006 for PLHIV on mono-therapy and from £27,649 in 1997 to £32,322 in 2006 for those on quadruple-or-more ART. The number of PLHIV using NHS services rose from 16,075 to 52,083 in 2006 and was projected to increase to 78,370 by 2013. Annual population cost rose from £104 million in 1997 to £483 million in 2006, with a projected annual cost between £721 and £758 million by 2013. When including community care costs, costs increased from £164 million in 1997, to £683 million in 2006 and between £1,019 and £1,065 million in 2013. Conclusions Increased number of PLHIV using NHS services resulted in rising UK population costs. Population costs are expected to continue to increase, partly due to PLHIVs longer survival on ART and the relative lack of success of HIV preventing programs. Where possible, the cost of HIV treatment and care needs to be reduced without reducing the quality of services, and prevention programs need to become more effective. While high income countries are struggling to meet these increasing costs, middle- and lower-income countries with larger epidemics are likely to find it even more difficult to meet these increasing demands, given that they have fewer resources.