Rebecca Li

Delivering on the promise of bone morphogenetic proteins.

The advent of bone growth factors has been widely anticipated since their successful production using recombinant DNA technology. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) are an important class of bone growth factors and will be the focus of this article. In the near future these therapeutics might revolutionize how clinicians treat such diverse orthopedic applications as the healing of broken bones, increasing bone density lost through aging, and strengthening the spine. These potent proteins require application directly at the site of repair via a delivery system. The choice of delivery system has a profound effect on the clinical outcome. In the past decade, researchers have focused on developing efficient delivery systems and advancing these factors from the bench to the clinic.

Bone morphogenetic protein delivery systems.

Study Design. A review was conducted. Objectives. To review the rationale for the use of carrier systems to deliver bone morphogenetic proteins to sites of orthopedic repair, and to discuss commonly used carriers. Summary of Background Data. Carriers for bone morphogenetic protein in spine fusion are used to increase the retention of these osteogenic factors at the treatment site, and to serve as an osteoconductive matrix for bone forming cells while maintaining a space or volume in which bone formation can occur. Methods. The literature is reviewed and discussed. Results. Although bone morphogenetic proteins can induce bone formation when delivered in formulation buffer in small animal models, carriers often are used in larger animal models and human clinical trials to maintain the concentration of osteogenic factors at the treatment site for a sufficient period to allow bone-forming cells to migrate to the area of injury and to proliferate and differentiate. For spine fusion, carriers also are required to serve as an osteoconductive matrix for bone-forming cells while maintaining a space or volume in which bone formation can occur. Four major categories of carrier materials are used for osteogenic factor delivery: inorganic materials, synthetic polymers, natural polymers, and composites of the first three materials. In addition, allograft bone has been used to deliver osteogenic factors to the site of orthopedic repairs. The efficacy of osteogenic carrier combinations often is site specific and species specific. The requirement for supraphysiologic concentrations of osteogenic factors may be related to the ability of the delivery system to increase the retention time at the treatment site and overcome tight regulation of these factors by their inhibitors. Dose escalation in large animal models also may be related to a decrease in the number of responding cells and a slower rate of bone formation. New delivery systems being evaluated include depot delivery systems, viral vector systems, conjugated osteogenic factor delivery systems, and oral small molecule targets. Conclusions. Delivery systems play an important role in the use of osteogenic factors to augment spine fusions and other orthopedic repairs.

Recombinant Human Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 Delivered in an Injectable Calcium Phosphate Paste Accelerates Osteotomy-Site Healing in a Nonhuman Primate Model

BACKGROUND In recent clinical trials demonstrating the efficacy of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) for the acceleration of bone-healing, investigators used carriers requiring open surgery for administration. In this study, we used a nonhuman primate fibular osteotomy model to evaluate injectable rhBMP-2/carrier formulations that can be administered in closed fractures. METHODS The fibular osteotomy model was first characterized by evaluating surgically harvested fibular segments containing untreated osteotomy sites (controls) from seventy adult male Cynomolgus monkeys at eight weeks (twenty-four monkeys), ten weeks (thirty-four), twelve weeks (six), and fourteen weeks (six). Fibular segments, from twenty-four animals, in which an osteotomy had not been performed served as normal controls (intact). The contralateral limb of twenty-four of the animals was then used to evaluate the effect of rhBMP-2 administered, three hours after the osteotomy, in eight carrier formulations (buffer, calcium phosphate paste, and hyaluronan gel, hyaluronan paste, and gelatin foam formulated with and without tricalcium phosphate granules). Each carrier was used in three monkeys. At ten weeks, the fibulae with the treated osteotomy sites were harvested and were compared with the contralateral, untreated osteotomized fibulae (paired control). The most promising carrier, calcium phosphate paste (alpha bone substitute material, or alpha-BSM), was then evaluated in eleven additional animals. The outcomes included the findings on radiographs made weekly until the time of fibular harvest, the callus area, the biomechanical properties, and the histologic findings. RESULTS Radiographic and histologic studies confirmed complete bridging of the control osteotomy sites in most animals by fourteen weeks. The mean torsional stiffness and maximum torque of the control osteotomy sites were 42.7% and 53.7%, 55.2% and 60.4%, 66.7% and 66.4% of the mean torsional stiffness and maximum torque of the intact fibulae at eight, ten, and twelve weeks, respectively, but they were not substantially different from the mean torsional stiffness and maximum torque of the intact fibulae at fourteen weeks (82.3% and 79.8%). In the carrier screening study, outcome measures of healing were more consistently enhanced in the rhBMP-2/alpha-BSM-treated osteotomy sites. In the confirmatory study, the mean callus area, torsional stiffness, and maximum torque were 86%, 72%, and 68% greater in the rhBMP-2/alpha-BSM-treated osteotomy sites than in the paired-control osteotomy sites at ten weeks (p < 0.001). The torsional stiffness and maximum torque in the rhBMP-2/alpha-BSM-treated osteotomy sites were equal to those in the intact fibulae, whereas those parameters in the paired-control osteotomy sites were only 55% and 58%, respectively, of the torsional stiffness and maximum torque of the intact fibulae. Histologic analysis confirmed complete osseous bridging of the rhBMP-2/alpha-BSM-treated osteotomy sites but incomplete bridging of the paired-control osteotomy sites at ten weeks. CONCLUSIONS A single percutaneous injection of rhBMP-2/alpha-BSM accelerates the healing of fibular osteotomy sites in nonhuman primates by approximately 40% compared with the healing of untreated osteotomy sites.

A Review of Preclinical Program Development for Evaluating Injectable Carriers for Osteogenic Factors

Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) delivered with an absorbable collagen sponge (ACS) has been used to both accelerate and ensure healing of open tibial fractures in human patients 1,2. Recombinant human osteogenic protein-1 (rhOP-1, rhBMP-7) delivered with type-1 bovine bone-derived collagen has also been used to treat tibial nonunions in patients 3. A major limitation of both of these biomaterials is the requirement for open surgical placement, which prevents treatment of patients with a closed fracture managed by closed reduction. This represents a substantial patient population, since closed fractures constitute the vast majority of the 6.3 million fractures seen annually in the United States 4. Development of an injectable carrier for osteogenic factors would allow treatment of closed fractures and would also overcome several other limitations of current implantable carriers. Placement of implantable products during the repair of open long-bone fractures is generally limited to areas of exposed bone caused by the injury, which often are not ideal environments for healing. For example, the anteromedial surface of the bone is typically exposed in open tibial fractures, and there is minimal soft tissue for interaction with osteogenic factors placed in this location. Elevation of normal muscle attachments to create a space for more optimal placement of implantable osteogenic factors is often not done because of the risk of further compromising the already damaged blood supply to the fractured bone. In contrast, injectable formulations could be delivered to these more advantageous sites with no additional soft-tissue exposure. Implantable products are also difficult to place into the sites of metaphyseal fractures, as access to these sites is sometimes limited. The increased use of minimally invasive surgical techniques further limits the utility of implantable osteogenic factor formulations. As a result, considerable clinical benefit would be derived from the …

rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix accelerates osteotomy-site healing in a nonhuman primate model at multiple treatment times and concentrations.

BACKGROUND While recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) administered in a calcium phosphate cement accelerates osteotomy-site healing in animal models when administered three hours after surgery, definitive fracture treatment is often delayed. The present study evaluated the ability of rhBMP-2, administered in a new particulating calcium phosphate matrix, to accelerate nonhuman primate fibular osteotomy-site healing following treatment at multiple treatment times and concentrations. METHODS The ability of 1.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix to accelerate osteotomy-site healing when administered three hours, one day, one week, or two weeks after surgery was first evaluated with use of bilateral proximal and distal fibular osteotomy sites in adult male monkeys. In a second study, the healing of osteotomy sites that had been treated with the administration of calcium phosphate matrix alone and with different concentrations of rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix (0.5 mg/mL, 1.5 mg/mL, or 4.5 mg/mL) seven days after surgery was compared with that of contralateral, untreated osteotomy sites. In a third study, the histologic progression of osteotomy-site healing following treatment with 1.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix or calcium phosphate matrix alone, administered three hours or one week after surgery to the osteotomy site, was assessed at multiple time points for as long as twenty-four months after surgery. RESULTS Radiographs demonstrated increased callus area and more rapid healing in response to 1.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix administered over the range of treatment times after surgery as compared with the findings of previous reports on untreated osteotomy sites. Bone formation appeared at the osteotomy sites sooner following treatment at one and two weeks as compared with the findings at the earlier time-points. Scintigraphic imaging at one day and one week after surgery showed prolonged retention of rhBMP-2 at the osteotomy site following an initial burst release. In the second study, radiographic, peripheral quantitative computed tomographic, biomechanical, and microscopic evaluation demonstrated that administration of 1.5 and 4.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix one week after surgery accelerated osteotomy-site healing by 40% to 50% compared with the findings in untreated controls. The magnitude of acceleration was less in response to 0.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix, and calcium phosphate matrix alone did not accelerate osteotomy-site healing. Histological evaluation indicated that an increased cellular infiltrate and increased direct bone formation contributed to the accelerated osteotomy-site healing following administration of rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix at one week compared with three hours after surgery. CONCLUSIONS A single percutaneous injection of rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix accelerated healing in nonhuman primate fibular osteotomy sites over a wide range of treatment times. Efficacy was optimized in association with the administration of 1.5-mg/mL rhBMP-2/calcium phosphate matrix. Delaying treatment for one week further accelerated healing because of an increase in the number of responding cells and an increase in direct bone formation.

Evaluation of SMN Protein, Transcript, and Copy Number in the Biomarkers for Spinal Muscular Atrophy (BforSMA) Clinical Study

Background The universal presence of a gene (SMN2) nearly identical to the mutated SMN1 gene responsible for Spinal Muscular Atrophy (SMA) has proved an enticing incentive to therapeutics development. Early disappointments from putative SMN-enhancing agent clinical trials have increased interest in improving the assessment of SMN expression in blood as an early “biomarker” of treatment effect. Methods A cross-sectional, single visit, multi-center design assessed SMN transcript and protein in 108 SMA and 22 age and gender-matched healthy control subjects, while motor function was assessed by the Modified Hammersmith Functional Motor Scale (MHFMS). Enrollment selectively targeted a broad range of SMA subjects that would permit maximum power to distinguish the relative influence of SMN2 copy number, SMA type, present motor function, and age. Results SMN2 copy number and levels of full-length SMN2 transcripts correlated with SMA type, and like SMN protein levels, were lower in SMA subjects compared to controls. No measure of SMN expression correlated strongly with MHFMS. A key finding is that SMN2 copy number, levels of transcript and protein showed no correlation with each other. Conclusion This is a prospective study that uses the most advanced techniques of SMN transcript and protein measurement in a large selectively-recruited cohort of individuals with SMA. There is a relationship between measures of SMN expression in blood and SMA type, but not a strong correlation to motor function as measured by the MHFMS. Low SMN transcript and protein levels in the SMA subjects relative to controls suggest that these measures of SMN in accessible tissues may be amenable to an “early look” for target engagement in clinical trials of putative SMN-enhancing agents. Full length SMN transcript abundance may provide insight into the molecular mechanism of phenotypic variation as a function of SMN2 copy number. Trial Registry Clinicaltrials.gov NCT00756821

A Global, Neutral Platform for Sharing Trial Data

Brigham and Womens Hospital–Harvard Universitys Multi-Regional Clinical Trials Center, along with partners, is designing a platform to link existing data-sharing platforms and communities and host data from investigators who want to share data but lack the resources to do so.

Candidate Proteins, Metabolites and Transcripts in the Biomarkers for Spinal Muscular Atrophy (BforSMA) Clinical Study

Background Spinal Muscular Atrophy (SMA) is a neurodegenerative motor neuron disorder resulting from a homozygous mutation of the survival of motor neuron 1 (SMN1) gene. The gene product, SMN protein, functions in RNA biosynthesis in all tissues. In humans, a nearly identical gene, SMN2, rescues an otherwise lethal phenotype by producing a small amount of full-length SMN protein. SMN2 copy number inversely correlates with disease severity. Identifying other novel biomarkers could inform clinical trial design and identify novel therapeutic targets. Objective: To identify novel candidate biomarkers associated with disease severity in SMA using unbiased proteomic, metabolomic and transcriptomic approaches. Materials and Methods: A cross-sectional single evaluation was performed in 108 children with genetically confirmed SMA, aged 2–12 years, manifesting a broad range of disease severity and selected to distinguish factors associated with SMA type and present functional ability independent of age. Blood and urine specimens from these and 22 age-matched healthy controls were interrogated using proteomic, metabolomic and transcriptomic discovery platforms. Analyte associations were evaluated against a primary measure of disease severity, the Modified Hammersmith Functional Motor Scale (MHFMS) and to a number of secondary clinical measures. Results A total of 200 candidate biomarkers correlate with MHFMS scores: 97 plasma proteins, 59 plasma metabolites (9 amino acids, 10 free fatty acids, 12 lipids and 28 GC/MS metabolites) and 44 urine metabolites. No transcripts correlated with MHFMS. Discussion In this cross-sectional study, “BforSMA” (Biomarkers for SMA), candidate protein and metabolite markers were identified. No transcript biomarker candidates were identified. Additional mining of this rich dataset may yield important insights into relevant SMA-related pathophysiology and biological network associations. Additional prospective studies are needed to confirm these findings, demonstrate sensitivity to change with disease progression, and assess potential impact on clinical trial design. Trial Registry Clinicaltrials.gov NCT00756821.

SMA-MAP: a plasma protein panel for spinal muscular atrophy.

Objectives Spinal Muscular Atrophy (SMA) presents challenges in (i) monitoring disease activity and predicting progression, (ii) designing trials that allow rapid assessment of candidate therapies, and (iii) understanding molecular causes and consequences of the disease. Validated biomarkers of SMA motor and non-motor function would offer utility in addressing these challenges. Our objectives were (i) to discover additional markers from the Biomarkers for SMA (BforSMA) study using an immunoassay platform, and (ii) to validate the putative biomarkers in an independent cohort of SMA patients collected from a multi-site natural history study (NHS). Methods BforSMA study plasma samples (N = 129) were analyzed by immunoassay to identify new analytes correlating to SMA motor function. These immunoassays included the strongest candidate biomarkers identified previously by chromatography. We selected 35 biomarkers to validate in an independent cohort SMA type 1, 2, and 3 samples (N = 158) from an SMA NHS. The putative biomarkers were tested for association to multiple motor scales and to pulmonary function, neurophysiology, strength, and quality of life measures. We implemented a Tobit model to predict SMA motor function scores. Results 12 of the 35 putative SMA biomarkers were significantly associated (p<0.05) with motor function, with a 13th analyte being nearly significant. Several other analytes associated with non-motor SMA outcome measures. From these 35 biomarkers, 27 analytes were selected for inclusion in a commercial panel (SMA-MAP) for association with motor and other functional measures. Conclusions Discovery and validation using independent cohorts yielded a set of SMA biomarkers significantly associated with motor function and other measures of SMA disease activity. A commercial SMA-MAP biomarker panel was generated for further testing in other SMA collections and interventional trials. Future work includes evaluating the panel in other neuromuscular diseases, for pharmacodynamic responsiveness to experimental SMA therapies, and for predicting functional changes over time in SMA patients.

Engineering what comes naturally

Tissue engineers have developed a synthetic matrix that interacts with host cells to deliver bone-inductive proteins for bone regeneration.