Ric Swindell

Systemic treatment of early breast cancer by hormonal, cytotoxic, or immune therapy. 133 randomised trials involving 31,000 recurrences and 24,000 deaths among 75,000 women. Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group.

In a worldwide collaboration, information was sought and centrally checked on mortality and recurrence for each woman in any randomised trial that began before 1985 of any aspect of systemic adjuvant therapy for early breast cancer. Checked data were available for 75,000 women (about 90% of those ever randomised), of whom 32% had died and another 10% had experienced recurrence. The parts now reviewed include 30,000 women in tamoxifen trials, 3000 in ovarian ablation trials, 11,000 in polychemotherapy trials, 15,000 in other chemotherapy comparisons, and 6000 in immunotherapy trials. Highly significant reductions in the annual rates both of recurrence and of death are produced by tamoxifen (25% SD 2 recurrence and 17% SD 2 mortality: 2p less than 0.00001), by ablation below age 50 (26% SD 6 recurrence and 25% SD 7 mortality: 2p = 0.0004), and by polychemotherapy (28% SD 3 recurrence and 16% SD 3 mortality: 2p less than 0.00001), but not by ablation at older ages or by immunotherapy. (Tamoxifen also reduced the risk of development of contralateral breast cancer by 39% SD 9: 1p less than 0.00001). For tamoxifen and for polychemotherapy the avoidance of recurrence is chiefly during years 0-4 (this difference being maintained but not increased afterwards), but the avoidance of mortality is highly significant both during and after years 0-4, so the cumulative differences in survival produced by these relatively brief treatments (median: 2 years tamoxifen, 1 year polychemotherapy) are larger at 10 than at 5 years. There is little information beyond year 10 (except for ovarian ablation, which produces separately significant mortality reductions both during and after years 0-9). Both direct and indirect randomised comparisons show long-term polychemotherapy (eg, 12 months) to be no better than shorter (eg, 6 months) regimens, but do show polychemotherapy to be significantly better than single-agent chemotherapy. Indirect randomised comparisons do not reveal significant differences between different forms of polychemotherapy, or differences between different tamoxifen doses, but do show that long-term tamoxifen (eg, 2 years, or even 5 years) is significantly more effective than shorter tamoxifen regimens. In old age (70+) tamoxifen is of demonstrated efficacy, but chemotherapy has not been evaluated. Between ages 50 and 69 direct comparisons show that chemotherapy plus tamoxifen is better (1p less than 0.00001) than chemotherapy alone both for recurrence and for mortality, and better (1p less than 0.00001) than tamoxifen alone for recurrence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The christie hospital breast conservation trial: An update at 8 years from inception

In 1990, we published the results of a clinical trial involving 708 patients with breast carcinoma of 4 cm or less in diameter, who, following lumpectomy, were randomized to have radiotherapy to the tumour bed only (limited field, LF group) or to the whole breast and regional nodes (wide field, WF group). No adjuvant systemic therapy was prescribed. At the time the median follow-up was 37 months. We present the updated results after an extended median follow-up of 65 months. The overall survival is 72.7% and 71.2% for the LF and WF groups respectively. The actuarial breast recurrence rate (first event) is 15% (LF) versus 11% (WF) for infiltrating ductal carcinoma, whereas, for infiltrating lobular carcinoma, the recurrence rate was 34% (LF) versus 8% (WF). A high actual recurrence rate of 21% (LF) and 14% (WF) was also found for extensive ductal carcinoma in situ. It was extremely rare for medullary, mucoid or tubular carcinomas to recur. Salvage surgery was possible in 86% (LF) and 90% (WF) respectively. The recurrence rate in the breast following lumpectomy and wide field irradiation is comparable with others reported in the literature. This trial also shows the lumpectomy with limited field irradiation is feasible, albeit with a higher breast recurrence rate; the latter could be reduced by improved selection and refinement of the technique.

Effect of spinal irradiation on growth.

Standing height, sitting height, and leg length were measured in 79 patients (aged 16-30 years), who had been given craniospinal irradiation (n = 37) or cranial irradiation (n = 42) in childhood for a brain tumour and had completed their growth. Their measurements were compared with established standards for sitting height and leg length in British children (aged 16-18 years). To examine the effects of spinal irradiation on spinal growth independent of growth hormone deficiency we analysed the leg length (LL) minus sitting height (SH) standard deviation score (SDS) and used the cranial group as controls. There was an overall significant difference between the median craniospinal LL-SH SDS (1.98) and the median cranial LL-SH SDS (0.545). Within the craniospinal group there was a significant correlation with age at treatment, but there was no such correlation for the cranial group. After splitting age at treatment into three groups (0 less than 5, 5 less than 10, and 10-15 years) there was a significant difference between the LL-SH SDS of the craniospinal and cranial groups for each of the age ranges. In conclusion, spinal irradiation has a profound effect on spinal growth and the younger the child is when given irradiation the greater the subsequent skeletal disproportion. Our most conservative figures indicate that the eventual loss in height is 9 cm when irradiation is given at 1 year, 7 cm when given at 5 years, and 5.5 cm when given at 10 years.

Adjuvant tamoxifen for male breast cancer (MBC).

A study was started in 1976 whereby patients with Stage II and operable Stage III MBC were given adjuvant Tamoxifen for 1 year, increasing to 2 years from 1988. All patients had axillary nodal involvement. Primary treatment consisted of a radical mastectomy or simple mastectomy with radiotherapy. The rarity of the disease precluded a randomised trial. Thirty-nine patients are available for analysis at a median follow-up of 49 months. The actuarial survival of the Tamoxifen treated patients is 61% (range 42-80%) at 5 years compared to 44% (range 35-53%) for historical controls (P = 0.006). Disease-free survival was 56% (37-75%) vs 28% (17-33%) at 5 years (P = 0.005). There were no serious side-effects recorded. The conclusion from this, the first reported series on adjuvant Tamoxifen therapy for MBC, is that significant improvement in disease-free survival can be achieved with minimal upset to the patients. Recruitment to the study continues.

Gemcitabine alone or in combination with cisplatin in patients with advanced or metastatic cholangiocarcinomas or other biliary tract tumours: a multicentre randomised phase II study - The UK ABC-01 Study.

Background:We assessed the activity of gemcitabine (G) and cisplatin/gemcitabine (C/G) in patients with locally advanced (LA) or metastatic (M) (advanced) biliary cancers (ABC) for whom there is no standard chemotherapy.Methods:Patients, aged ⩾18 years, with pathologically confirmed ABC, Karnofsky performance (KP) ⩾60, and adequate haematological, hepatic and renal function were randomised to G 1000 mg m−2 on D1, 8, 15 q28d (Arm A) or C 25 mg m−2 followed by G 1000 mg m−2 D1, 8 q21d (Arm B) for up to 6 months or disease progression.Results:In total, 86 patients (A/B, n=44/42) were randomised between February 2002 and May 2004. Median age (64/62.5 years), KP, primary tumour site, earlier surgery, indwelling biliary stent and disease stage (LA: 25/38%) are comparable between treatment arms. Grade 3–4 toxicity included (A/B, % patients) anaemia (4.5/2.4), leukopenia (6.8/4.8), neutropenia (13.6/14.3), thrombocytopenia (9.1/11.9), lethargy (9.1/28.6), nausea/vomiting (0/7.1) and anorexia (2.3/4.8). Responses (WHO criteria, % of evaluable patients: A n=31 vs B n=36): no CRs; PR 22.6 vs 27.8%; SD 35.5 vs 47.1% for a tumour control rate (CR+PR+SD) of 58.0 vs 75.0%. The median TTP and 6-month progression-free survival (PFS) (the primary end point) were greater in the C/G arm (4.0 vs 8.0 months and 45.5 vs 57.1% in arms A and B, respectively).Conclusion:Both regimens seem active in ABC. C/G is associated with an improved tumour control rate, TTP and 6-month PFS. The study has been extended (ABC-02 study) and powered to determine the effect on overall survival and the quality of life.

Steroid-hormone receptors and survival after first relapse in breast cancer

Oestrogen receptors were measured in the primary breast tumours of 508 patients and progesterone receptors in those of 486 patients. Survival from mastectomy was significantly longer in patients with receptor-positive tumours. There was no significant difference between patients with receptor-positive and receptor-negative tumours in the relapse-free interval, but survival from first relapse was longer in patients with receptor-positive tumours. Axillary node status and tumour size indicated the probability of relapse but did not influence the length of survival after relapse. Response to tamoxifen or ovarian ablation was known in 65 of the 137 patients who relapsed. Survival from first relapse was significantly longer in patients who both responded to hormone therapy and had receptor-positive tumours. Patients who did not respond to hormone therapy and had receptor-positive tumours had the same survival characteristics as those with receptor-negative tumours who did not respond.

Prognostic factors for breast recurrence after conservative breast surgery and radiotherapy: results from a randomised trial

Prognostic factors predicting for breast recurrence following breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy have been identified in a prospective randomised trial comparing two different radiotherapy techniques. The first used megavoltage radiation to encompass the whole breast and regional nodes (WF group). The second used an electron field directed to the tumour bed only (LF group). With a median follow up of 8 years survival in both groups was the same (72%). There was an increased rate of breast recurrence in the LF group: 25%, compared to the WF group: 13% (P = 0.00008), expressed in actuarial terms at 8 years. In a multivariate analysis of factors predicting for breast recurrence, once the difference in treatment technique is allowed for, only two factors were found to be significant: histological grade (P = 0.013) and lymphovascular invasion in the histological specimen (P = 0.037).

Gonadal function following chemotherapy for Hodgkin's disease: a comparative study of MVPP and a seven-drug hybrid regimen.

PURPOSE AND METHODS Gonadal function was assessed in 89 patients after chemotherapy for Hodgkins disease (HD). Thirty-seven patients had received mechlorethamine, vinblastine, prednisolone, and procarbazine (MVPP) and 52 patients, a hybrid combination of chlorambucil, vinblastine, prednisolone, procarbazine, doxorubicin, vincristine, and etoposide (ChIVPP/EVA). Fifty men (MVPP, n = 21; ChIVPP/EVA, n = 29) with a median age of 26 years (range, 16 to 54) and 39 women (MVPP, n = 16; ChIVPP/EVA, n = 23) with a median age of 30 years (range, 15 to 47) were studied at a median of 30 months (range, 4 to 83) following chemotherapy. RESULTS Semen analysis showed azoospermia in 35 of 37 men, and increased serum follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) levels in this group confirmed severe germinal epithelial damage. Analysis of pretreatment semen in 28 men showed azoospermia in one, oligospermia in four (sperm count < 20 x 10(6)/mL), and a normal sperm count in the remaining 23. In the women, 26 of 34 (76%) with a regular menstrual cycle before commencing chemotherapy became amenorrheic following treatment. Menses returned in 10 women, who had a median age of 25 years (range, 21 to 34), and there were two pregnancies in this group. In the other 16, with a median age of 36 years (range, 27 to 47), amenorrhea persisted and premature ovarian failure was confirmed by increased serum gonadotrophins and reduced estradiol (E2) concentrations. Of the original eight women in whom menses were maintained following treatment, two subsequently developed amenorrhea and the clinical and biochemical features of an early menopause. In total, 18 of 34 women (53%) required hormone replacement therapy for chemotherapy-induced ovarian failure. CONCLUSION There was no statistically significant difference in the frequency or severity of gonadal dysfunction between MVPP- and ChIVPP/EVA-treated patients. We conclude that both of these chemotherapy schedules cause substantial damage to gonadal function in both sexes.

Conservation of the Breast Using Two Different Radiotherapy Techniques: Interim Report of a Clinical Trial

Patients with a clinically palpable breast carcinoma, 4 cm or less in diameter, and with no palpable nodes in the axilla were prospectively entered into a randomized clinical trial. A total of 713 patients were registered between November 1982 and December 1987, of whom 708 are evaluable at a median follow-up of 37 months. Following excision of the primary tumour, patients were randomly allocated either to have radiotherapy to the affected quadrant only (LF group) or to the whole breast and regional lymph node areas (WF group). No adjuvant hormone or chemotherapy was prescribed. The primary tumour was reported as completely excised histologically in 80% of cases, incompletely excised in 10%, and no estimate was possible in 10%. At six years from first randomization, 96% of the WF group and 92% of the LF group have remained free of breast recurrence (94% and 87% actuarial breast recurrence-free survival at 5 years). Part of the difference may be explained by the 20% recurrence rate in the breast for lobular carcinomas treated within the LF group. Of the WF group 14 patients (4%) developed recurrent disease in the axilla, compared to 50 patients (14%) in the LF group (95% and 86% actuarial axillary recurrent-free survival at 5 years). Patients with primary tumours histologically 1 cm or less in diameter had a 98% actuarial 5-year survival compared with 74% for those with tumours measuring 2 cm or more in diameter (P = 0.003). Continued follow-up of these patients will provide further information on the factors governing local/regional recurrence.

Malignant pleural mesothelioma and epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-R). Relationship of EGF-R with histology and survival using fixed paraffin embedded tissue and the F4, monoclonal antibody

The expression of epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-R) in 34 formalin fixed paraffin embedded specimens of malignant mesothelioma was examined using the F4 antibody. Eight samples of reactive pleura showed homogenous cytoplasmic staining with the antibody. EGF-R positive cells (greater than or equal to 5%) were found in 68% of the mesotheliomas examined. EGF-R positivity was more commonly seen in the epithelial histological subtype than in the sarcomatous or mixed subtypes. Patients with less than 5% of mesothelioma cells staining positive for EGF-R had a significantly shorter survival (median 299 days) compared with patients whose tumours had a greater number of cells positive for EGF-R (median 446 days) (P = 0.04). However, when the histological subgroup was also taken into consideration (epithelial type had a significantly longer survival than the sarcomatous or mixed) the survival difference in relation to EGF-R positivity was no longer significant (P = 0.08). EGF-R could not be used to distinguish between malignant and benign mesothelial tissue and was not an independent prognostic factor for survival.