Richard J. Connolly

Plasma facilitated delivery of DNA to skin

Non‐viral delivery of cell‐impermeant drugs and DNA in vivo has traditionally relied upon either chemical or physical stress applied directly to target tissues. Physical methods typically use contact between an applicator, or electrode, and the target tissue and may involve patient discomfort. To overcome contact‐dependent limitations of such delivery methodologies, an atmospheric helium plasma source was developed to deposit plasma products onto localized treatment sites. Experiments performed in murine skin showed that samples injected with plasmid DNA encoding luciferase and treated with plasma demonstrated increased levels of expression relative to skin samples that received injections of DNA alone. Increased response relative to injection alone was observed when either positive or negative voltage was used to generate the helium plasma. Quantitative results over a 26‐day follow‐up period showed that luciferase levels as high as 19‐fold greater than the levels obtained by DNA injection alone could be achieved. These findings indicate that plasmas may compete with other physical delivery methodologies when skin is the target tissue. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 1034–1040.

Characterization of plasma mediated molecular delivery to cells in vitro

Ion-based strategies have recently emerged as a method to facilitate molecular delivery. These methods are attractive as they separate the applicator from the treatment site avoiding some issues encountered with other electrically driven methods. Current literature on plasma delivery has shown utility in vitro and in vivo for both drugs and genes. To advance this technology more information must become available on the mechanism responsible for delivery and the effects of ion exposure on eukaryotic cells. This in vitro investigation found that molecular delivery facilitated by a DC-based plasma follows a dose-response behavior, with optimum uptake of Sytox Green occurring in two cell lines after 600 s of exposure. In both cell lines exposure to the discharge caused no adverse effects in viability for exposure times up to 600 s. It was also found that membranes treated with ions remained permeabilized for several minutes following plasma treatment and that membrane resealing exhibited first order kinetics.

Enhancement of antigen specific humoral immune responses after delivery of a DNA plasmid based vaccine through a contact-independent helium plasma

Non-viral in vivo delivery of DNA, encoding for specific proteins, has traditionally relied on chemical or physical forces applied directly to tissues. Physical methods typically involve contact between an applicator/electrode and tissue and often results in transient subject discomfort. To overcome these limitations of contact-dependent delivery, a helium plasma source was utilized to deposit ionized gasses to treatment/vaccination sites without direct contact between the applicator and the tissues. The study reported here evaluated the efficacy of this strategy as an effective method to administer DNA vaccines. Balb/C mice were vaccinated with a DNA plasmid expressing an HIVgp120 envelope glycoprotein either with or without co-administration of helium plasma or electroporation. The results indicated, for the first time, the potential efficacy of helium plasma delivery for the induction and enhancement of antigen specific immune responses following DNA vaccination.

Non-contact helium-based plasma for delivery of DNA vaccines: Enhancement of humoral and cellular immune responses

Non-viral in vivo administration of plasmid DNA for vaccines and immunotherapeutics has been hampered by inefficient delivery. Methods to enhance delivery such as in vivo electroporation (EP) have demonstrated effectiveness in circumventing this difficulty. However, the contact-dependent nature of EP has resulting side effects in animals and humans. Noncontact delivery methods should, in principle, overcome some of these obstacles. This report describes a helium plasma–based delivery system that enhanced humoral and cellular antigen-specific immune responses in mice against an intradermally administered HIV gp120-expressing plasmid vaccine (pJRFLgp120). The most efficient plasma delivery parameters investigated resulted in the generation of geometric mean antibody-binding titers that were 19-fold higher than plasmid delivery alone. Plasma mediated delivery of pJRFLgp120 also resulted in a 17-fold increase in the number of interferon-gamma spot-forming cells, a measure of CD8+ cytotoxic T cells, compared with non-facilitated plasmid delivery. This is the first report demonstrating the ability of this contact-independent delivery method to enhance antigen-specific immune responses against a protein generated by a DNA vaccine.

Optimization of a plasma facilitated DNA delivery method

Plasma-based methods have recently emerged as a technique for augmenting plasmid DNA delivery to skin. This delivery modality relies on the deposition of ionized gas molecules on to targeted cells or tissue to establish an electric field. It is hypothesized that this electric field results in the dielectric breakdown of cell membranes, making cells permeable to exogenous molecules. This in vivo investigation sought to optimize the intradermal delivery of a luciferase expressing plasmid DNA by modulating the total exposure to the plasma source and the plasmid DNA dose. Varying the plasma exposure time from 2, 5, 10, and 20 min allowed the conditions resulting in the highest expression of luciferase to be found. These conditions correlated to the 10 minute exposure time for a plasma derived from either +8 kV or -8 kV, when the generator was operated 3 cm from the epidermal tissue surface with a helium flow rate of 15 L/min. Exposing the injected flank skin for 10 min resulted in a rise of 37.3-fold for a plasma created with +8 kV and 27.1-fold for a plasma created with -8 kV. When using this treatment time with 50, 100, or 200 μg of a luciferase expressing plasmid, it was found that 100 μg resulted in the highest peak luminescence.

Electrostrictive forces on vesicles with compartmentalized permittivity and conductivity conditions

Electrostrictive forces on the plasma membrane of a lipid bilayer vesicle that result as a consequence of an applied electric field and differential dielectric material properties can be calculated via the Maxwell stress tensor. In this situation, the plasma membrane is proposed as a barrier that separates compartments of a system with different conductivity and relative permittivity values. A numerical model of this case is presented. Model force calculations compare with analytical equation results and were used to validate published experimental work. The model also was used to study electrostatic forces in a simple vesicle system contrasting such forces to frequency dependent deformations. Model results for vesicles in variable conductivity and relative permittivity environments are analyzed to build a framework with the potential to become a tool to study more complex problems with multiple compartments such as cells and tissues. Impedance spectroscopy is also explored as a potential experimental method to predict cell and tissue system behavior in the presence of electric fields.

Electrogenetherapy of B16.F10 murine melanoma tumors with an interleukin-28 expressing DNA plasmid

Augmented delivery of cytokine-expressing DNA plasmids to subcutaneous tumors has been demonstrated to result in a level of enhanced anti-tumor activity. One delivery enhancement method which has been evaluated is in vivo electroporation (EP), a contact-dependent delivery technique where electric pulses are hypothesized to augment the transfer of DNA into cells and tissues through the induction of temporary cell membrane pores. Previous work by members of our group, as well as others, has demonstrated the anti-tumor effects of DNA plasmids expressing the cytokines IL-12 and IL-15. In this report the potential anti-tumor activity of a relatively newly-described cytokine, IL-28, was measured when administered intratumorally as a DNA expression plasmid (designated pIL28) to established murine (B16.F10) melanoma tumors. The administration of the IL-28 expressing plasmid was performed through enhanced delivery methods. One method was EP and the other a non-contact dependent technique using a helium plasma stream. IL-28 is a member of the type III interferon family of cytokines that has been characterized as possessing potent anti-viral activity. This cytokine has been demonstrated to function as an adjuvant in small animal model vaccination protocols and stimulates CD8+ CTL responses. In addition, stimulation of anti-tumor activity has been demonstrated in several studies using IL-28. Based on these activities, it was hypothesized that this cytokine could, when delivered through a DNA expression plasmid, mediate anti-tumor activity. The results of this study indicated that enhanced delivery of pIL-28 resulted in attenuation of tumor growth, compared with non-enhanced delivery. Of note, this is the first proof-of-concept experiment, of our knowledge, documenting the ability of a non-contact dependent helium plasma-based delivery method to mediate the enhancement of an anti-tumor effect by a cytokine-expressing DNA plasmid. This suggests the use of the helium plasma delivery method as an alternative or adjunctive method to EP for the effective delivery of agents that possess potential anti-tumor activity.

Effectiveness of non-penetrating electroporation applicators to function as impedance spectroscopy electrodes

Electroporation is commonly performed to deliver drugs and genes to cells comprising tissues. A possible way to control and confirm delivery is through the use of impedance spectroscopy. Ideally, this tool should not interfere with delivery and should incorporate the use of electrodes, applicators, used for delivery. This work examines impedance spectra obtained with non-penetrating surface applicators commonly used for skin electroporation. After collecting and processing over 9,000 spectra from three animal models it was determined that the electrode systems tested would have no significant effect on the obtained spectra. Therefore, electroporation applicators currently in use could be used concurrently for the collection of impedance spectra.

Development of an adaptive electroporation system for intratumoral plasmid DNA delivery

Intratumoral electroporation of plasmid DNA encoding the proinflammatory cytokine interleukin 12 promotes innate and adaptive immune responses correlating with anti-tumor effects. Clinical electroporation conditions are fixed parameters optimized in preclinical tumors, which consist of cells implanted into skin. These conditions have little translatability to clinically relevant tumors, as implanted models cannot capture the heterogeneity encountered in genetically engineered mouse models or clinical tumors. Variables affecting treatment outcome include tumor size, degree of vascularization, fibrosis, and necrosis, which can result in suboptimal gene transfer and variable therapeutic outcomes. To address this, a feedback controlled electroporation generator was developed, which is capable of assessing the electrochemical properties of tissue in real time. Determination of these properties is accomplished by impedance spectroscopy and equivalent circuit model parameter estimation. Model parameters that estimate electrical properties of cell membranes are used to adjust electroporation parameters for each applied pulse. Studies performed in syngeneic colon carcinoma tumors (MC38) and spontaneous mammary tumors (MMTV-PyVT) demonstrated feedback-based electroporation is capable of achieving maximum expression of reporter genes with significantly less variability and applied energy. These findings represent an advancement to the practice of gene electro-transfer, as reducing variability and retaining transfected cell viability is paramount to treatment success.

Impedance spectroscopy as an indicator for successful in vivo electric field mediated gene delivery in a murine model

In vivo gene electro transfer technology has been very successful both in animal models and in clinical trials over the past 20years. However, variable transfection efficiencies can produce inconsistent outcomes. This can be due to differences in tissue architecture and/or chemical composition which may effectively create unique biological environments from subject to subject that may respond differently to the identical electric pulses. This study investigates the integration of impedance spectroscopy into the gene electro transfer process to measure murine skin impedance spectra before, during (after pulse delivery), and after gene electro transfer pulse application to determine if changes in impedance correlate with reporter gene expression. Both post-treatment impedance spectra and gene expression were dependent upon the applied electric field strength. These results indicate that alterations in tissue impedance produced by the applied electric field represent an excellent parameter to predict degrees of transfection and gene expression. These results could ultimately be used to alter pulsing parameters in order to optimize delivery/expression.