Richard Wrobel

Field Comparison of 37-mm Closed-Face Cassettes and IOM Samplers

On examining the published results of comparisons of sampling with Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) (Edinburgh, U.K.) samplers and 37-mm closed-face cassettes it was observed that they usually do not take into account the dust deposited on the walls of the cassettes. As the method used by the Institut National de Recherche et de Sécurité, France (INRS), to analyze metals includes the analysis of these deposits, it was decided to evaluate the differences obtained between these samplers when using this method. The essays were conducted in three different plants, and repetitive static samplings were carried out to compare 2 L/min, IOM cassettes and 1 or 2 L/min 37-mm closed-face cassettes. The airborne particles were also sampled simultaneously for granulometric analysis. Gravimetric determinations of sampled aerosol were obtained by weighing 37-mm filters and IOM cassettes, and the aerosol collected on the filters and the particles deposited on the walls were analyzed separately for both types of samplers by atomic spectrometry for metals content. The intra-sampler variability and inter-sampler ratios were then determined. Although results obtained for gravimetric analysis are comparable to those published elsewhere (ratio IOM/37-mm much higher than 1), the metal analysis revealed a close agreement between the results obtained with the three sampling methods tested when the wall deposits were taken into account. As published previously, the ratio of wall deposits to filter collected aerosol for 37-mm cassettes is variable, and it would appear to be very difficult to find an appropriate correction factor applicable when only the filter is analyzed. Were these results to be confirmed by further experiments, sampling with 37-mm closed-faced at 1 or 2 L/min or with an IOM sampler would be equivalent for all pollutants for which the analytical method allows the recovery of walls deposit.

Study of fifteen respirable aerosol samplers used in occupational hygiene

European and international standards lay down criteria for the size-selective aerosol sampling in occupational hygiene. Aerosol samplers are supposed to match these target sampling criteria. This study focused on 15 aerosol samplers used to sample the conventional respirable fraction. An aerodynamic particle sizer (APS) method was used to measure the sampling efficiency of the samplers in a low-velocity wind tunnel. Polydisperse coal dust was generated as the test aerosol. The data were fitted by an appropriate mathematical model. For some instruments the results show serious deviations from the conventional target curve, whereas other devices meet the convention quite well. The flow rate of certain cyclone-separator-based instruments was optimized to adjust their sampling efficiency. The mass concentration bias and accuracy of the samplers were calculated for a number of ranges of particle size distributions of aerosols commonly found in industrial workplaces. Finally, the performance of each sampler was evaluated using bias and accuracy maps. Most of these samplers are suitable for sampling the CEN-ISO-ACGIH respirable fraction of aerosols, but several require modification of the flow rate. For real industrial situations, the rough knowledge of the aerosol size distribution can guide the choice of an appropriate sampling technique.

Physical and Biochemical Properties of Airborne Flour Particles Involved in Occupational Asthma

Aerosol particles which deeply penetrate the human airways and which trigger bakers asthma manifestations are known to represent only a part of flour and of airborne particles found in bakeries. They were a major focus of this study. To this end, aerosols were produced from different wheat and rye flours, using an automatic generator designed for bronchial challenge. Particles were characterized for their size distribution, their ability to be deposited in the airways, their protein content, their histological composition and their reactivity with immunoglobulin E (IgE) present in sera from asthmatic bakers. Like dust particles collected in the bakery, the aerosols produced showed increased protein content but decreased IgE reactive protein content when compared to the corresponding bulk flours. The sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis analysis of these particles showed a predominance of endosperm gluten proteins. Under scanning electron microscopy, flour particles displayed various tissue fragments with entrapped large A-starch and small B- or C-starch granules, whereas aerosol particles appeared primarily as a mixture of the endosperm intracellular interstitial protein matrix and small B- or C-starch granules free or still associated. These observations showed that aerosols supposed to penetrate deeply the airways, mainly correspond to intracellular fragments of endosperm cells enriched in gluten proteins but with lower amount of allergens belonging to albumins or globulins.