Rob W. Briddon

Geminivirus strain demarcation and nomenclature

Geminivirus taxonomy and nomenclature is growing in complexity with the number of genomic sequences deposited in sequence databases. Taxonomic and nomenclatural updates are published at regular intervals (Fauquet et al. in Arch Virol 145:1743–1761, 2000, Arch Virol 148:405–421, 2003). A system to standardize virus names, and corresponding guidelines, has been proposed (Fauquet et al. in Arch Virol 145:1743–1761, 2000). This system is now followed by a large number of geminivirologists in the world, making geminivirus nomenclature more transparent and useful. In 2003, due to difficulties inherent in species identification, the ICTV Geminiviridae Study Group proposed new species demarcation criteria, the most important of which being an 89% nucleotide (nt) identity threshold between full-length DNA-A component nucleotide sequences for begomovirus species. This threshold has been utilised since with general satisfaction. More recently, an article has been published to clarify the terminology used to describe virus entities below the species level [5]. The present publication is proposing demarcation criteria and guidelines to classify and name geminiviruses below the species level. Using the Clustal V algorithm (DNAStar MegAlign software), the distribution of pairwise sequence comparisons, for pairs of sequences below the species taxonomic level, identified two peaks: one at 85–94% nt identity that is proposed to correspond to “strain” comparisons and one at 92–100% identity that corresponds to “variant” comparisons. Guidelines for descriptors for each of these levels are proposed to standardize nomenclature under the species level. In this publication we review the status of geminivirus species and strain demarcation as well as providing updated isolate descriptors for a total of 672 begomovirus isolates. As a consequence, we have revised the status of some virus isolates to classify them as “strains”, whereas several others previously classified as “strains” have been upgraded to “species”. In all other respects, the classification system has remained robust, and we therefore propose to continue using it. An updated list of all geminivirus isolates and a phylogenetic tree with one representative isolate per species are provided.

Revision of taxonomic criteria for species demarcation in the family Geminiviridae, and an updated list of begomovirus species.

Members of the family Geminiviridae characteristically have circular single-stranded DNAgenomes packaged within twinned (so-called geminate) particles. Geminiviruses are currentlydivided into four genera on the basis of their genome organizations and biological properties[2,20].Thosethathaveamonopartitegenomeandaretransmittedbyleafhoppervectors,primarilyto monocotyledonous plants, are included in the genus Mastrevirus, of which Maize streak virus isthe type species. Viruses that have monopartite genomes distinct from those of the mastrevirusesand that are transmitted by leafhopper vectors to dicotyledonous plants are included in thegenus Curtovirus, with Beet curly top virus as the type species. The genus Topocuvirus, recentlyrecognized by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV) [18], has only onemember (also the type species), Tomato pseudo-curly top virus, which has a monopartite genomeandistransmittedbyatreehoppervectortodicotyledonousplants.ThegenusBegomoviruscontainsviruses that are transmitted by the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) to dicotyledonous plants,with Bean golden yellow mosaic virus (originally Bean golden mosaic virus – Puerto Rico)asthetype species. Many begomoviruses have bipartite genomes (DNA A and DNA B components),although numerous begomoviruses with a monopartite genome occur in the Old World, and thereare some for which a single component is not infectious yet no DNA B component has been found.Geminiviruses cause significant yield losses to many crop plants throughout the world [5, 7].Because of their economic importance and the relative ease with which their DNA genomescan be cloned, many geminiviruses have been isolated and characterized. Guidelines for naming

Diversity of DNA β, a satellite molecule associated with some monopartite begomoviruses

DNA beta molecules are symptom-modulating, single-stranded DNA satellites associated with monopartite begomoviruses (family Geminiviridae). Such molecules have thus far been shown to be associated with Ageratum yellow vein virus from Singapore and Cotton leaf curl Multan virus from Pakistan. Here, 26 additional DNA beta molecules, associated with diverse plant species obtained from different geographical locations, were cloned and sequenced. These molecules were shown to be widespread in the Old World, where monopartite begomoviruses are known to occur. Analysis of the sequences revealed a highly conserved organization for DNA beta molecules consisting of a single conserved open reading frame, an adenine-rich region, and a region of high sequence conservation [the satellite conserved region (SCR)]. The SCR contains a potential hairpin structure with the loop sequence TAA/GTATTAC; similar to the origins of replication of geminiviruses and nanoviruses. Two major groups of DNA beta satellites were resolved by phylogenetic analyses. One group originated from hosts within the Malvaceae and the second from a more diverse group of plants within the Solanaceae and Compositae. Within the two clusters, DNA beta molecules showed relatedness based both on host and geographic origin. These findings strongly support coadaptation of DNA beta molecules with their respective helper begomoviruses.

Universal primers for the PCR-mediated amplification of DNA β

DNA β is an approx 1350 nucleotide, single-stranded DNA molecule which has been shown to be associated with some monopartite geminiviruses of the genus Begomovirus. This component requires the helper begomovirus for replication in the cells of host plants and for insect transmission, possibly by trans-encapsidation. Sequence comparisons of the two available DNA β sequences has identified a highly conserved region upstream of a predicted hairpin structure. Abutting primers designed to this conserved region allows PCR-mediated amplification of the full-length DNA β component from total nucleic acid extracts isolated from infected plants originating from a variety of geographically distinct sources and host plants.

Geminivirus disease complexes: an emerging threat

Small circular single-stranded DNA satellites have recently been isolated from plants infected with whitefly-transmitted monopartite begomoviruses. The satellites, named DNA beta, depend on the helper viruses for their proliferation and, in turn, are required for helper virus accumulation and symptom expression. They are highly diverse yet retain an overall conserved structure with respect to potential coding regions and regulatory elements. The begomovirus-satellite disease complexes are associated with economically important diseases, and have been isolated from vegetable and fibre crops, ornamental plants and weeds throughout Africa and Asia. Their widespread distribution and diversity, coupled to the global movement of plant material and the dissemination of the whitefly vector, suggests that these disease complexes pose a serious threat to tropical and sub-tropical agro-ecosystems worldwide.

Geminivirus coat protein gene replacement alters insect specificity

Chimeric clones have been constructed in which the coat protein encoded by DNA A of the bipartite genome of the geminivirus African cassava mosaic virus (ACMV) has been replaced by that of beet curly top virus (BCTV). Constructs containing the coding region inserted in either orientation were infectious when co-inoculated with ACMV DNA B onto Nicotiana benthamiana, producing symptoms typical of ACMV infection. The onset of symptom production was delayed relative to plants inoculated with parental ACMV clones and remission of symptoms was observed. When inserted in the correct orientation for expression from the ACMV coat protein promoter, the BCTV gene was expressed in plants and the coat protein synthesized encapsidated ssDNA of both ACMV genomic components. The BCTV leafhopper vector, Circulifer tenellus (Baker), transmitted both BCTV and the chimeric virus but not ACMV when injected with virus preparations and transferred to N. benthamiana seedlings. The results show that the specificity of leafhopper transmission from insect to plant resides with the coat protein.

Recommendations for the classification and nomenclature of the DNA-β satellites of begomoviruses

The symptom-modulating, single-stranded DNA satellites (known as DNA-β) associated with begomoviruses (family Geminiviridae) have proven to be widespread and important components of a large number of plant diseases across the Old World. Since they were first identified in 2000, over 260 full-length sequences (∼1,360 nucleotides) have been deposited with databases, and this number increases daily. This has highlighted the need for a standardised, concise and unambiguous nomenclature for these components, as well as a meaningful and robust classification system. Pairwise comparisons of all available full-length DNA-β sequences indicate that the minimum numbers of pairs occur at a sequence identity of 78%, which we propose as the species demarcation threshold for a distinct DNA-β. This threshold value divides the presently known DNA-β sequences into 51 distinct satellite species. In addition, we propose a naming convention for the satellites that is based upon the system already in use for geminiviruses. This maintains, whenever possible, the association with the helper begomovirus, the disease symptoms and the host plant and provides a logical and consistent system for referring to already recognised and newly identified satellites.

Cotton leaf curl disease is associated with multiple monopartite begomoviruses supported by single DNA β

Summary For bipartite begomoviruses (family Geminiviridae) trans-replication of the DNA B component by the DNA A-encoded replication-associated protein (Rep) is achieved by virtue of a shared sequence, the “common region”, which contains repeated motifs (iterons) which are sequence-specific Rep binding sites and form part of the origin of replication. Recently cotton leaf curl disease (CLCuD), a major constraint to cotton production on the Indian subcontinent, has been shown to be caused by a monopartite begomovirus (Cotton leaf curl Multan virus [CLCuMV]) and a novel single-stranded DNA satellite molecule termed CLCuD DNA β. The satellite molecule is trans-replicated by CLCuMV but does not possess the iteron sequences of this virus. We have investigated the ability of CLCuD DNA β to interact with three further clones of monopartite begomoviruses, isolated from cotton, that have distinct Rep binding specificities. All three cloned viruses were capable of trans-replicating the satellite molecule and inducing CLCuD symptoms in cotton, indicating that the interaction between begomovirus and DNA β is relaxed in comparison to the interaction between DNA A and DNA B components. Field surveys across all the cotton growing regions of Pakistan indicate that dual and multiple infections are the norm for CLCuD with no evidence of synergism. Despite the diversity of begomoviruses associated with CLCuD, only a single class of DNA β has been detected, suggesting that this satellite has the capacity to be recruited by unrelated begomoviruses.

Cotton leaf curl virus disease

Cotton is one of the most important crops of Pakistan, accounting for over 60% of foreign exchange earnings. The present epidemic of cotton leaf curl disease (CLCuD) originated in the Punjab region near the city of Multan and was first reported in 1985, although it was noted in this region as early as 1967. By the early 1990s, CLCuD had become the major limitation to cotton production in Pakistan and it has now spread into India and, more recently, south and west into other provinces of Pakistan. The very characteristic symptoms include leaf curling, darkened veins, vein swelling and enations that frequently develop into cup-shaped, leaf-like structures on the undersides of leaves. Identification of the vector of CLCuD as the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Genn.) quickly led to the suggestion that the causative agent of the disease is a geminivirus. Researchers soon confirmed the presence of such a virus that is currently ascribed to the genus Begomovirus of the family Geminiviridae, However, in 1999, the aetiology of the disease was shown to be more complex than was originally assumed. Despite the identification of both a begomovirus and a so-called nanovirus-like component, the precise causal agent of CLCuD remains uncertain.

The coat protein of beet curly top virus is essential for infectivity

We have applied the procedure of Agrobacterium-mediated inoculation to develop a simple, efficient, and reproducible assay for the infectivity of the leafhopper-transmitted geminivirus, beet curly top virus (BCTV). This assay system was used to show that a coat protein mutant of BCTV is not infectious, but could be complemented by coagroinoculation with a second mutant bearing a lethal mutation in the complementary-sense open reading frame, C1. Furthermore, the coat protein mutant retained the ability to replicate and to produce both ssDNA and dsDNA when electroporated into Nicotiana tabacum protoplasts. We conclude that the coat protein of BCTV is essential for spread of the virus. The results are discussed in the light of results with coat protein mutants of other geminiviruses.