Robert D. Fraser

Magnetic resonance imaging assessment of disc degeneration 10 years after anterior lumbar interbody fusion.

Study Design One-hundred-eight patients from a consecutive series of 125 anterior lumbar interbody fusions were invited to participate in a radiographic and magnetic resonance imaging assessment more than 10 years after the original surgery. Objective The aim of this study was to determine the long-term incidence of disc degeneration adjacent to an anterior interbody fusion and to determine whether this was influenced by the length of the fusion. Summary of Background Data Biomechanical studies in human cadaver spines support the view that fusion in the lumbar spine is likely to be associated with an increased incidence of degeneration at adjacent levels, but there is little reliable information on the incidence of juxtafusion degeneration from the few long-term studies of lumbar spine fusion reported in the literature. Methods Eighty-seven patients agreed to take part in the study, but in six cases the magnetic resonance imaging procedure had to be abandoned. Of the 81 patients who underwent both radiographic assessment and magnetic resonance imaging scanning, preoperative discography had demonstrated a normal disc above the level of the fusion in 52. This group of patients formed the basis of this report. Each sequence of magnetic resonance imaging films was examined by one radiologist. The signal strength was assessed on T2-weighted images in the sagittal plane and disc morphology was assessed on T1- and T2-weighted sagittal and T1-weighted axial images. Fusion status was assessed on the plain films and magnetic resonance imaging. Results The incidence of a normal adjacent intervertebral disc in cases of solid fusions to the sacrum was 68%. This was not influenced by the length of the fusion. Conclusion The findings of this study suggest that degeneration after an anterior lumbar interbody fusion is determined more by individual characteristics than by the fusion itself.

A Randomized, Double-Blind, Controlled Trial : Intradiscal Electrothermal Therapy Versus Placebo for the Treatment of Chronic Discogenic Low Back Pain

Study Design. A prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of intradiscal electrothermal therapy (IDET) for the treatment of chronic discogenic low back pain (CDLBP). Objectives. To test the safety and efficacy of IDET compared with a sham treatment (placebo). Summary of Background Data. In North America alone, more than 40,000 intradiscal catheters have been used to treat CDLBP. The evidence for efficacy of IDET is weak coming from retrospective and prospective cohort studies providing only Class II and Class III evidence. There is one study published with Class I evidence. This demonstrates statistically significant improvements following IDET; however, the clinical significance of these improvements is questionable. Methods. Patients with CDLBP who failed to improve following conservative therapy were considered for this study. Inclusion criteria included the presence of one- or two-level symptomatic disc degeneration with posterior or posterolateral anular tears as determined by provocative computed tomography (CT) discography. Patients were excluded if there was greater than 50% loss of disc height or previous spinal surgery. Fifty-seven patients were randomized with a 2:1 ratio: 38 to IDET and 19 to sham procedure (placebo). In all cases, the IDET catheter was positioned to cover at least 75% of the annular tear as defined by the CT discography. An independent technician connected the catheter to the generator and then either delivered electrothermal energy (active group) or did not (sham group). Surgeon, patient, and independent outcome assessor were all blinded to the treatment. All patients followed a standard postprocedural rehabilitation program. Independent statistical analysis was performed. Outcome Measures. Low Back Outcome Score (LBOS), Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), Short Form 36 questionnaire (SF-36), Zung Depression Index (ZDI), and Modified Somatic Perceptions Questionnaire (MSPQ) were measured at baseline and 6 months. Successful outcome was defined as: no neurologic deficit, improvement in LBOS of greater then 7 points, and improvement in SF-36 subsets (physical function and bodily pain) of greater than 1 standard deviation. Results. Baseline demographic data, initial LBOS, ODI, SF-36, ZDI, and MSPQ were similar for both groups. No neurologic deficits occurred. No subject in either arm showed improvement of greater than 7 points in LBOS or greater than 1 standard deviation in the specified domains of the SF-36. Mean ODI was 41.42 at baseline and 39.77 at 6 months for the IDET group, compared with 40.74 at baseline and 41.58 at 6 months for the placebo group. There was no significant change in ZDI or MSPQ scores for either group. Conclusions. The IDET procedure appeared safe with no permanent complications. No subject in either arm met criteria for successful outcome. Further detailed analyses showed no significant change in outcome measures in either group at 6 months. This study demonstrates no significant benefit from IDET over placebo.

Discitis after discography

Infection after intradiscal injections has been recognised as a distinct entity, but discitis after discography has often been attributed to an aseptic process or a chemical reaction to the contrast material. We examined the hypothesis that discitis after discography is always due to infection, and report a clinical review and an experimental study. Part I. We reviewed the case records and radiographs of 432 patients who had undergone lumbar discography. When an 18-gauge needle without a stilette had been used, discitis was diagnosed in 2.7% of 222 patients but stiletted needles and a two-needle technique at each level reduced the incidence to 0.7%. Seven patients with discitis after discography had undergone anterior discectomy and fusion; in them the histopathological findings were of a chronic inflammatory response. Bacteria were isolated from the discs of three of the four patients who had open biopsy less than six weeks from the time of discography. These findings suggest that bacteria were initiators rather than promoters of the response. Part II. Multiple level lumbar discography was carried out in mature sheep, injecting contrast material with or without various concentrations of bacteria. Radiographs were taken and the discs and end-plates were examined histologically and cultured for bacteria at intervals after injection. None of the controls showed any evidence of discitis but all sheep injected with bacteria had typical radiological and histopathological changes by six weeks, though cultures were almost all negative. However, at one and two weeks after injection, but usually not after three weeks, bacteria could be isolated. We suggest that all cases of discitis after discography are initiated by infection, and that a very strict aseptic technique should be used for all injections into intervertebral discs.

Symposium : A Critical Discrepancy-A Criteria of Successful Arthrodesis Following Interbody Spinal Fusions

Question: What should the radiographic criteria be for a successful arthrodesis for lumbar interbody fusion cages? The definition of successful arthrodesis following anterior lumbar fusion is controversial. The comparison of different surgical arthrodesis techniques, interbody prostheses, and bone g

Discitis after discography. The role of prophylactic antibiotics

Discitis after discography is due to bacterial penetration into the intervertebral disc by a contaminated needle and has an incidence of 1% to 4%. We have examined the prophylactic role of cephazolin administered at the time of discography. An experimental study in sheep using radiographic contrast containing Staphylococcus epidermidis showed that either adding the antibiotic to the intradiscal suspension or giving it intravenously 30 minutes before intradiscal inoculation of bacteria prevented any radiographic, macroscopic or histological signs of discitis; all the intervertebral disc cultures were negative. In a prospective clinical study of 127 consecutive patients having lumbar discography, the injected contrast contained cephazolin 1 mg per ml. None of the patients developed clinical or radiographic signs of discitis. We recommend the use of a suitable broad spectrum antibiotic in a single prophylactic dose whenever the intervertebral disc is entered.

FORAMINAL INJECTION FOR LATERAL LUMBAR DISC HERNIATION

Between 1986 and 1995, we treated with foraminal injection of local anaesthetic and steroids 30 patients with severe lumbar radiculopathy secondary to foraminal and extraforaminal disc herniation which had not resolved with rest and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents. They were assessed prospectively using standardised forms as well as the Low Back Outcome Score, and were reviewed at an average of 3.4 years (1 to 10) after injection by an independent observer (BKW). Relief of symptoms was obtained in 27 immediately after injection. Three subsequently relapsed, requiring operation, and two were lost to long-term follow-up. Thus 22 of the 28 patients available for long-term follow-up had considerable and sustained relief from their symptoms. Before the onset of symptoms 17 were in employment and, after injection, 13 resumed work, all but two in the same job. The average score before injection was 25 out of a possible 75 points. At follow-up, the overall average score was 54, and in those who had obtained relief of symptoms it had improved to a mean of 61. Based on these findings we recommend foraminal injection of local anaesthetic and steroids as the primary treatment for patients with severe radiculopathy secondary to foraminal or extraforaminal herniation of a lumbar disc.

The origin and fate of herniated lumbar intervertebral disc tissue.

Study Design In a clinicopathologic study, disc tissue collected from surgery and from cadaveric spines was examined to test an hypothesis about the pathogenesis of herniation. Objectives To determine the origin and fate of herniated lumbar intervertebral disc tissue. Summary of Background Data Previous studies have ascribed herniated disc tissue to the nucleus, anulus, or endplate, or combinations of the three. One study describes it as newly synthesized fibrocartilage. Regardless of its origin, peripheral neovascularization of disc fragments has been described and may be related to pain symptoms. Methods Disc tissue was collected after extrusion and was examined histologically to determine its origin and fate. To test the hypothesis that sequestration results from migration of isolated, degenerate fragments of nucleus pulposus through preexisting tears in the anulus fibrosus, cadaveric lumbar discs were examined in detail. Results Ninety‐eight percent of sequestrations contained some nuclear material indicating that nucleus pulposus is the principal substance extruded from the disc. None contained anulus alone. Although vascular repair was present in 89% of specimens, it did not correlate with several clinical parameters. Conclusions The autopsy study confirmed the model of nuclear fragmentation, migration, and extrusion along radiating anular clefts. Neovascularization of extruded fragments bore no relationship with duration of sciatic pain symptoms or clinical outcome.

A cadaveric study comparing discography, magnetic resonance imaging, histology, and mechanical behavior of the human lumbar disc.

The aims of this study were 1) to compare discography and magnetic resonance imaging scanning on cadaver specimens and to correlate these imaging procedures by examining all the discs histologically; and 2) to study the extent to which the amplitude of rotational movement in the neutral and flexed position at a certain level correlates with the morphologic appearance of that disc. Twenty-four human lumbar spines were harvested from cadavers between the ages of 19 and 75 years. Each specimen underwent standard radiography, magnetic resonance imaging scanning, discography, histologic examination, and measurement of axial rotation in a torsion apparatus. For practical reasons, all specimens did not undergo all of the examinations. Not all peripheral anular lesions were detected by discography. Histology showed rim lesions of the anterior anulus in 18% of discs with normal discography. The overall incidence of anterior and posterior anular tears was greater in discs where larger amplitudes of rotation were observed. To which extent the one is a consequence of the other or vice versa is not clear. Magnetic resonance imaging was found to be less specific than discography. However, it must be emphasized that no axial magnetic resonance imaging scans were taken in this study. Discs with significantly decreased amounts of nuclear material (observed at histology) can still produce normal magnetic resonance imaging images. Infolding of the inner layers of the anulus fibrosus (33% anterior, 4% posterior) was a frequently observed feature.

The natural history of age-related disc degeneration: The pathology and sequelae of tears

Study Design. A quasi 3-dimensional pathologic survey of tears in the L4–L5 disc. Objective. To seek accurate information on the pathogenesis and outcomes of tears to facilitate correlation with radiologic imaging and biomechanical testing; and to improve laboratory models for testing hypotheses of disc function and failure. Summary of Background Data. Tears are evidence of structural failure involving the anulus. There are substantial differences in the structure and function of the anterior and posterior anulus and the nonlamellar “nucleus” is much smaller than generally conceptualized and modeled. Method. Microscopy of sections prepared from 5-mm-thick parallel sagittal slices of 70 L4–L5 discs was used to construct maps of tears in each slice and record other features of interest. A template was used to classify data for analysis. Results. Multiple-level analysis detected 20% more tears than in a single disc section. Concentric, perinuclear, and radiating tears often appeared first in the posterior disc and were numerous throughout life. However, rim lesions, transdiscal tears, endplate separations, and Schmorls nodes were infrequent in young discs. Rim lesions and transdiscal tears markedly increased in the older discs while the other tears showed modest growth. In elderly discs, many tears acquired blood vessels accompanied by nerves capable of transmitting pain. Apart from about 15% of rim lesions, healing of tears by scar tissue was absent. Links between various types of tears result in complex discographic images from older discs and the cavitation of transdiscal tears lead to segmental instability. Conclusion. Tears in the L4–L5 disc show different patterns of incidence with aging, which can be explained by current biomechanical concepts. Tears may not only perturb disc function and cause segmental instability, but the frequency of neovascularization accompanied by neoinnervation indicates that pain originating within the degenerate disc should not be dismissed as the frequent evidence of bleeding into the tear lumen indicates the susceptibility of the vessels to trauma.

Short segment fixation of thoracolumbar burst fractures without fusion.

Abstract There continues to be controversy surrounding the management of thoracolumbar burst fractures. Numerous methods of fixation have been described for this injury, but to our knowledge, spinal fusion has always been part of the stabilising procedure, whether this involves an anterior or a posterior approach. Apart from an earlier publication from this centre, there have been no reports on the use of internal fixation without fusion for this type of fracture. The aim of the study was to determine the outcome of patients with thoracolumbar burst fractures who were treated with short segment pedicle screw fixation without fusion. This is a retrospective review of 28 consecutive patients who had short segment pedicle screw fixation of thoracolumbar burst fractures without fusion performed between 1990 and 1993. All patients underwent a clinical and radiological assessment by an independent observer. Outcome was measured using the Low Back Outcome Score. The minimum follow-up period was 2 years (mean 3.1 years). Fifty percent of patients achieved an excellent result with the Low Back Outcome Score, while 12% were assessed as good, 20% fair and 16% obtained a poor result. The only significant factor affecting outcome was the influence of a compensation claim (P < 0.05). The implant failure rate (14% of patients) and the clinical outcome was similar to that from series where fusion had been performed in addition to pedicle screw fixation. The results of this study support the view that posterolateral bone grafting is not necessary when managing patients with thoracolumbar burst fractures by short segment pedicle screw fixation.