Robert H. Gilkey

Sound localization in noise: The effect of signal‐to‐noise ratio

The sound localization ability of human observers has been frequently examined in quiet environments, but there have been relatively few studies that have considered the effect of noise on sound localization. In this study, three subjects judged the perceived direction of broadband click-train signal in the quiet and in the presence of a broadband noise at nine signal-to-noise ratios, which varied over a 23 dB range. The signal could originate from any of 239 spatial locations that completely surrounded the subjects in azimuth 360 degrees) and ranged from -45 degrees to (+)90 degrees in elevation; the masker (when present) was always located directly in front of the subjects at 0 degrees azimuth and 0 degree elevation. The subjects indicated the perceived direction of the signal by pointing at a 20-cm-diam spherical model of auditory space. As the signal-to-noise ratio was lowered, the accuracy of localization judgments decreased nearly monotonically. However, the accuracy of judgments relative to the median plane (i.e., the left/right dimension) was less strongly influenced by the presence of noise than was the accuracy of judgments relative to the horizontal plane (i.e., the up/down dimension). The accuracy of judgments relative to the frontal plane (i.e., the front/back dimension) was most strongly influenced by noise.

Effects of masker waveform and signal‐to‐masker phase relation on diotic and dichotic masking by reproducible noise

The proportions of hits and false alarms were estimated for the detection of a 500-Hz sinusoidal signal in each of 25, reproducible samples of wideband, white, Gaussian noise. The effects of signal phase were investigated under diotic (MoSo) and dichotic (MoS pi) conditions and compared to the predictions of two major models of binaural hearing. Averaging the data over samples obscured important across-sample and across-subject differences in performance. The proportions of hits and false alarms for individual noise samples presented under the MoSo condition were highly correlated with those for the same noise samples under the dichotic MoS pi condition, suggesting that the cues determining performance under these conditions are related. Signal-to-masker phase had a large effect on the proportion of hits under the MoSo condition, but only a small effect under the MoS pi condition. The Vector model predicts a large effect of signal phase under the MoS pi condition, and is, therefore, imcompatible with this aspect of the data. The expected value of the decision variable of the EC model is independent of signal phase. However, when the variance of the decision variable is also considered, the EC model does predict changes in the proportion of hits with the phase of the signal, comparable to those observed here. Further, it was shown that, if minor changes in the form of the EC models decision variable or in the distribution of the internal noise parameters are assumed, the expected value of the decision variable also changes with the phase of the signal.

The sense of presence for the suddenly deafened adult: Implications for virtual environments

Reports from adventitiously deafened individuals of a sense of unconnectedness with their surroundings, of a sense that the world seems dead, offer a compelling rationale for the argument that auditory cues are a crucial determinant of the sense of presence. Moreover, the crucial element of auditory stimulation for creating a sense of presence may be the auditory background, comprising the incidental sounds made by objects in the environment, rather than the communication and warning signals that typically capture our attention. Although designers of virtual environments have most often tried to maximize the sense of presence in the user by attempting to improve the fidelity of visual displays, the arguments presented here suggest that background auditory stimulation may be useful or even critical for achieving a full sense of presence.

Models of auditory masking: a molecular psychophysical approach.

Gilkey et al. [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 78, 1207-1219 (1985)] measured hit proportions and false alarm proportions for detecting a 500-Hz tone at each of four starting phase angles in each of 25 reproducible noise samples. In the present paper, their results are modeled by fitting the general form of the electrical analog model of Jeffress [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 48, 480-488 (1967)] to the diotic data. The best-fitting configurations of this model do not correspond to energy detectors or to envelope detectors. A detector composed of a 50-Hz-wide single-tuned filter, followed by a half-wave rectifier and an integrator with an integration time of 100 to 200 ms fits the data of all four subjects relatively well. Linear combinations of the outputs of several detectors that differ in center frequency or integration window provide even better fits to the data. These linear combinations assign negative weights to some frequencies or to some time intervals, suggesting that a subjects decision is based on a comparison of information in different spectral or temporal portions of the stimulus.

Effects of frequency on free-field masking.

As three-dimensional auditory displays become more prevalent, there will be an increasing need to understand the interactions that can be expected among spatially separated sounds. A two-alternative, forced-choice, adaptive staircase procedure was used to measure the detectability of a 165-ms click-train signal masked by a continuous Gaussian noise, as a function of the spatial separation between the signal and the masker in the free field. Horizontal separations within the horizontal plane and vertical separations within the median plane were examined for low-, mid-, and high-frequency stimuli. Masking was reduced by as much as 18 dB when the signal and masker were separated horizontally. Sizable reductions in masking (6-9 dB) were also observed for vertical separation. The largest reductions in masking were observed for the high-frequency stimuli. The data are compared with the results of headphone-based studies of binaural masking. Implications for the design of auditory displays are considered.

Binaural detection with narrowband and wideband reproducible noise maskers: I. Results for human

This study investigated binaural detection of tonal targets (500 Hz) using sets of individual masker waveforms with two different bandwidths. Previous studies of binaural detection with wideband noise maskers show that responses to individual noise waveforms are correlated between diotic (N0S0) and dichotic (N0S(pi)) conditions [Gilkey et al., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 78, 1207-1219 (1985)]; however, results for narrowband maskers are not correlated across interaural configurations [Isabelle and Colburn, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 89, 352-359 (1991)]. This study was designed to allow direct comparison, in detail, of responses across bandwidths and interaural configurations. Subjects were tested on a binaural detection task using both narrowband (100-Hz bandwidth) and wideband (100 Hz to 3 kHz) noise maskers that had identical spectral components in the 100-Hz frequency band surrounding the tone frequency. The results of this study were consistent with the previous studies: N0S0 and N0S(pi) responses were more strongly correlated for wideband maskers than for narrowband maskers. Differences in the results for these two bandwidths suggest that binaural detection is not determined solely by the masker spectrum within the critical band centered on the target frequency, but rather that remote frequencies must be included in the analysis and modeling of binaural detection with wideband maskers. Results across the set of individual noises obtained with the fixed-level testing were comparable to those obtained with a tracking procedure which was similar to the procedure used in a companion study of rabbit subjects [Zheng et al., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 111, 346-356 (2002)].

A pointing technique for rapidly collecting localization responses in auditory research

A technique is described for rapidly collecting responses in auditory-localization experiments. Subjects indicate the perceived direction of the sound by pointing at a 20-cm-diam spherical model. In Experiment 1, the subjects judged the direction of a broadband signal, which could originate from any of 239 directions ranging through 360° of azimuth and between −45° and +90° of elevation. Using this technique, the subjects responded 2–8 times more rapidly than previous subjects who used either a verbal-reporting technique or a head-pointing technique. Localization judgments were as accurate as they had been with verbal reports, but were not as accurate as judgments collected using the head-pointing technique. In Experiment 2, the signal was turned off and the experimenter read the spherical coordinates of the signal location to the subjects. The subjects pointed to these coordinates more accurately than they had judged the direction of the sounds in Experiment 1, suggesting that the response technique had not been the limiting factor in that experiment. Circumstances relevant to the choice of response techniques for auditory-localization experiments are discussed.

3D Audio Cueing for Target Identification in a Simulated Flight Task

Modern Traffic Advisory Systems (TAS) can increase flight safety by providing pilots with real-time information about the locations of nearby aircraft. However, most current collision avoidance systems rely on non-intuitive visual and audio displays that may not allow pilots to take full advantage of this information. In this experiment, we compared the response times required for subjects participating in a fully-immersive simulated flight task to visually acquire and identify nearby targets under four different simulated TAS display conditions: 1) no display; 2) a visual display combined with a non-spatialized warning sound; 3) a visual display combined with a clock-coordinate speech signal; and 4) a visual display combined with a spatialized auditory warning sound. The results show that response times varied in an orderly fashion as a function of display condition, with the slowest times occurring in the no display condition and the fastest times occurring in the 3D audio display condition, where they were roughly 25% faster than those without the 3D audio cues.

Visual Search Performance With 3-D Auditory Cues: Effects of Motion, Target Location, and Practice

Objectives: We evaluate visual search performance in both static (nonmoving) and dynamic (moving) search environments with and without spatial (3-D) auditory cues to target location. Additionally, the effects of target trajectory, target location, and practice are assessed. Background: Previous research on aurally aided visual search has shown a significant reduction in response times when 3-D auditory cues are displayed, relative to unaided search. However, the vast majority of this research has examined only searches for static targets in static visual environments. The present experiment was conducted to examine the effect of dynamic stimuli upon aurally aided visual search performance. Method: The 8 participants conducted repeated searches for a single visual target hidden among 15 distracting stimuli. The four main conditions of the experiment consisted of the four possible combinations of 3-D auditory cues (present or absent) and search environment (static or dynamic). Results: The auditory cues were comparably effective at reducing search times in dynamic environments (—25%) as in static environments (—22%). Audio cues helped all participants. The cues were most beneficial when the target appeared at large eccentricities and on the horizontal plane. After a brief initial exposure to 3-D audio, no training or practice effects with 3-D audio were found. Conclusion: We conclude that 3-D audio is as beneficial in environments comprising moving stimuli as in those comprising static stimuli. Application: Operators in dynamic environments, such as aircraft cockpits, ground vehicles, and command-and-control centers, could benefit greatly from 3-D auditory technology when searching their environments for visual targets or other time-critical information.

Diotic and dichotic detection with reproducible chimeric stimuli

Subject responses were measured for individual narrow-band reproducible stimuli in a low-frequency tone-in-noise detection task. Both N0S0 and N0Spi conditions were examined. The goal of the experiment was to determine the relative importance of envelope and fine-structure cues. Therefore, chimeric stimuli were generated by recombining envelopes and fine structures from different reproducible stimuli. Detection judgments for noise-alone or tone-plus-noise stimuli that had common envelopes but different fine structures or common fine structures but different envelopes were compared. The results showed similar patterns of responses to stimuli that shared envelopes, indicating the importance of envelope cues; however, fine-structure cues were also shown to be important. The relative weight assigned to envelope and fine-structure cues varied across subjects and across interaural conditions. The results also indicated that envelope and fine-structure information are not processed independently. Implications for monaural and binaural models of masking are discussed.